- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sur Hennings v. Commissioner Of Customs & C. Ex., Bangalore
[Order per : V.P. Gulati, Vice President]. - The issue in the appeal relates to the classification of item Cable Conduit.
2. The ld. Advocate for the appellants has pleaded that the appellants have sought for classification under T.H. 8466.93 while the Revenue has assessed it under T.H. 83.07. He has pleaded that under the HSN, the flexible tubing made into form of machinery or vehicle parts, for example by assembly with other materials gets excluded from Tariff Heading 83.07. He has pleaded since this flexible tubing imported by them is to provide protective covering to the cables which are fixed on to the machine tool, this should be deemed to have been correlated as the part of the machine tool and therefore same stands excluded from the purview of 83.07. He, on a query from the Bench, could not refer to any parts catalogue to indicate as to what is the part number that the tubing bears. He has pleaded that inasmuch as the end use is for fixing on to the machine tool, it should be treated as part of the machine.
3. Heard the ld. JDR for the department.
4. We have considered the pleas made. We observe that T.H. 83.07 is specific for flexible tubing of base metal. There is no dispute that this answers to this description. The plea of the appellant is that since this is for use on the machine tool to provide protective covering to the cable, it should be deemed to be a part of the machine tool.
5. The ld. JDR has pointed out that the goods imported are in length and have to be cut to length and shape for being used on the machine.
6. We observe that the exclusion as pointed out by the ld. Advocate in the HSN is only in respect of such of those flexible tubings which have been made formed as part of machinery by assembly with other materials i.e. item gets to be identified as forming part of the machinery. These become functional parts and are identified so in the parts catalogue of the machine. It cannot be a length which later gets to be cut and shaped for use on the machine. The fact remains that the item as imported is in length and not formed into shape in which it is required to be used in the machine.
7. In the facts and circumstances of the case therefore we hold that there is no merits in the appellant’s plea and we therefore dismiss the appeal.
Alert