- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Hindustan Lever Ltd., Bombay v. Collector Of Central Excise, Calcutta
[Order per : H.R. Syiem, Member]. - A revision petition dated 18th February, 1981 was filed by M/s. Hindustan Lever Ltd., Bombay against order-in-appeal No. 474/Cal-1979, dated 29-10-1979 passed by the Appellate Collector of Central Excise, Calcutta, This order is said to have been received by the petitioner on 10-9-1980, a fantastic time to take, by any standards.
2. The Appellate Collector held that spent earth which comes in the course of soap manufacture was assessable to duty under item 68 of the central excise tariff. This spent earth is obtained when activated bleaching earth has gone through processes of soap manufacture in which it plays the role of removing the colour etc. from the oil to render it colourless. After a number of processes, the activated earth can no longer bleach or remove colour from the oil. This is when it loses its activity and is called spent earth. The Appellate Collector said that spent earth had a distinctive name, had different uses and was saleable. He found that spent earth was sold to manufacturers of cheap washing soap.
3. This order of the Appellate Collector follows upon the Order No. 2(0) of 1979, dated 26-2-1979 passed by the Assistant Collector of Central Excise, Calcutta III Division saying the same thing. The Assistant Collector held that the factory M/s. Hindustan Lever Limited suppressed the fact about spent earth while submitting the application for L-4 Licence and concealed the name of the said product and did not incorporate it in their B-2 bond. Therefore, he said that the time limit for demand would be 5 years. He accordingly rejected the factory’s contention that the demand was time-barred.
4. The learned counsel for M/s. Hindustan Lever Ltd., Mr. Gupta, Senior Legal Manager argued that the spent earth was not manufactured by them. It was obtained as a waste product from activated earth which is used in the manufacture of soap. They do not set out to manufacture spent earth; it is generated during the manufacture when the activated earth becomes inactive through use in the process. It is the same activated earth which comes out as spent earth, and not a new product or commodity that they planned to manufacturer, and on which they lavished time and energy in order to process and obtain. As a product it is useless to them. It may be true that it fetches some money, because when it goes through the process of soap production, after it has decoloured and bleached the oil, it absorbs and acquires a little of the oil which it comes into contact. This is inevitable in such a process. The oil in the spent earth is taken in the use of cheap washing soaps. This is true of many waste products and not just spent earth.
5. He argued that the demand was time-barred since it was issued after the time limit. They had made no misdeclaration or suppression of any kind.
6. The learned counsel for the department Mr. Khanna said that the spent earth had a distinct use. This was a by-product and by failing to mention it by declaring it to the central excise the factory was guilty of suppression. The central excise did not know anything about the spent earth. He referred to the tariff advice of the Central Board of Excise and Customs which said that spent earth which is used in the manufacture of soap is classifiable under tariff item 68 of the central excise tariff. He said that this product, spent earth, was a by-product which was sold and which had uses in the manufacture of soap. It is a distinct product with a distinct use.
7. The learned counsel for the appellants replied that there was no manufacture of spent earth : only recovery of a substance that had outlived its utility. He quoted the famous judgment of the Supreme Court in Delhi Cloth Mill and South Bihar Sugar Mill. He quoted 1984 ECR 2253 Collector of Central Excise v. Sarang Engineering in which the Tribunal held that reshelling of roller shafts does not amount to manufacture. He also quoted = 1984 ECR. 1999 Jay Electric Wire Corporation v. Collector of Central Excise, Mysore in which the Tribunal held that process scrap cannot be treated as manufactured product and hence was not liable to duty under item 68. The scraps were sold as wire scrap and filament scrap. The Tribunal held that there was difficulty in equating the scrap with the end-product. Next he quoted 1980 E.L.T. 146 in which the High Court of Bombay said that dross and skimmings were neither goods nor any products. They cannot be said to be the result of treatment, labour or manipulation whereby a new and different article emerges with a distinctive name, character or use which can ordinarily come to the market to be bought and sold. Merely because such goods may fetch some price in the market does not justify it, being called a by-product, much less an end-product or a finished product.
8. He then quoted 1977 E.L.T. J 34 to say that it would be a case of charging double duty because the activated earth is a duty paid product, which have suffered duty under item 68.
9. The counsel also said that the show-cause notice did not say that there was clandestine removal. Therefore, this argument cannot be used in the order when no such charge was brought against them in the show-cause notice. He quoted in support 1983 E.L.T. 1199 Pyrites Phosphates and Chemicals case.
10. It is a fact that the activated earth is duty paid under item 68. There are gate passes in evidence and, indeed, we cannot see how the activated earth could have reached market without paying duty and item 68 is the only item under which duty can be paid because there is no item in the whole central excise tariff for activated earth .
11. The question to be determined is whether the spent earth is a result of manufacture. In our opinion, it is not, because no one produces anything by degrading it, or by subtracting from its properties. The activated earth is a substance used in decolouring and is used to bleach the oil in soap manufacture. After it has been used in the soap manufacture, the activated earth loses its ability to decolour. In other words, it can no longer decolour and bleach an oil at that stage; it has lost its ability to attract and absorb the colouring matter and pigments in the oil and has to be discarded as activated earth. It is still an earth, but no longer activated and no longer able to serve the purpose that it had once served.
12. By manufacture, we understand a manipulation, a subjection to a process, a working or a handling to improve a material or an article or a substance so that it becomes something it was not or to acquire a character or a property or a use that it never had. The manufactured product or the end-product is a product superior to the beginning or starting product the superiority being imparted to it in the process of manufacture as a deliberate and conscious plan in the mind of the manipulator, processor, handler, manufacturer etc. Often, the end-product is a culmination and sum total of one or more properties that such end-product is desired to have. Sometimes the manipulation or process is a good one; the processor manipulator is a skilful one; because of all these factors, the end-product is better than another similar end-product produced by a less skilful manufacturer or from inferior material. But in no case is the end-product a baser commodity than the material from which it is made; it is always better, more valuable, more finished.
13. In this case, we see the reverse of the above. The spent earth is a baser material than the activated earth which it was at the beginning of the soap manufacturing process. This is because it had lost the virtues it had as an activated earth. It can no longer remove colour from an oil. It is to be sold off only as a waste product, undesired and unwanted in the place it originated as a spent earth. It is a base material, baser than the substance, activated earth, from which it came. It would not do, we think, to call this a manufacture and to say that spent earth had been manufactured from activated earth. It is more reasonable to say that it was not manufactured from activated earth. Nor can we visualize any factory spending time, money, energy on manufacturing spent earth from activated earth. That it fetches some money is not much of an argument: many waste matter can fetch money if the right customer appears. And waste matter can be put to a lot of uses, like city waste sewage for example.
14. There is one serious difficulty in the way of the department’s charging duty on the spent earth. The activated earth, from which it is obtained, had already paid duty under item 68. If central excise want to charge the same duty over again on the same material after it has degraded to a baser material, it must show more justification than it has done, and until it does, we would have to prohibit it from doing so.
15. It is, of course, true that the spent earth was sold and was used in order to manufacture cheap washing soap. We cannot say that this is a reason for accessability of the spent earth. After all, much waste material can be sold and can be used to produce a good many things. But that will not make them manufactured articles liable to excise duty.
16. We have also seen the various rulings quoted by M/s. Hindustan Lever. We are in agreement with them, and furthermore think that the spent earth here should not be subjected to the same duty a second time. The fact that the central excise proposal will result in taking the same duty twice on an article which had not undergone any manufacture is, in our opinion, the stronger reason for holding the duty demanded by central excise to be not payable.
17. The Collector of Central Excise and his subordinates shall take note and act in accordance with these orders.
Alert