- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Commissioner Of Central Excise, Coimbatore v. Indicarb Ltd.
[Order per : V.P. Gulati, Vice President]. - The issue in the appeal relates to the grant of refund under Rule 173L of Central Excise Rules, 1944 in respect of the goods which were after clearance on payment of duty received back and thereafter after re-processing etc. were cleared again on payment of duty. The goods in question are `Tungstin Carbide Powder’.
2. The learned Lower Appellate Authority has entered a finding of fact that Tungstin Carbide Powder of a particular grade which was returned back was converted into different grades of Tungstin Carbide Powder. He has held that the appellants had complied with all the requirements of Rule 173L and therefore thereafter entitled to the refund based on the claim made within six months of the return of the goods in the factory, reckoning the relevant date in terms of Section 11B(5)(B)(c). In the grounds of appeal, it has been urged that the learned Collector has not taken note of all the points which were made out in the learned original authority’s order for the rejection of the refund. It has been pleaded that the Tungstin Carbide Powder which was returned was manufactured into different products inasmuch as the goods on return were subjected to the process amounting to manufacture and therefore the refund was not maintainable in terms of Rule 173L, since the requirements of Rule 173L had not been fully complied with. It has been urged that the claim would also be barred by limitation and the relevant date in terms of Section 11B(5)(B)(b) will not be relevant. The respondents are absent and have sought for adjournment for the reason that the Consultant is not well. Since the issue falls in a short compass declining the request for adjournment, the appeal is taken up for disposal. The plea has also been taken that the assessee’s accounts required to be produced in terms of Rule 173L(3)(i) had not been rendered.
3. The learned JDR has reiterated the grounds of appeal. He has pleaded that the Rule 173L stipulates various conditions for the purpose of grant of refund and all these conditions are required to be satisfied. The learned lower authority, he has pleaded, has not entered any findings that all these conditions had been satisfied. The learned original authority he pleaded has not clearly brought out as to how these conditions had not been satisfied. He has therefore prayed for setting aside the order of the learned lower authority.
5. I have considered the pleas made by learned JDR, Shri S. Murugandy and perused the grounds of appeal wherein the plea is that the requirements of Rule 173L have not been complied with. These requirements relate to as seen from Rule 173L, the procedure to be followed at the time of receipt of the returned goods and thereafter the storage thereof and the records to be maintained evidencing the re-processing done and the return of the goods. So far as the procedure to be followed at the time of receipt of goods is concerned, no fault has been found in that regard with the respondents. The plea of the revenue pertains to only two aspects namely that the goods could not have been taken to have been received for the purpose set out under Rule 173L as the returned goods had been manufactured into different products at the appell-ant’s factory. It has been urged that this is not envisaged under Rule 173L. I observe that there is a clear finding by the learned lower appellate authority that the Tungstin Carbide Powder of a particular grade was re-processed into Tungstin Carbide Powder of various other grades. This activity of re-processing in my view falls within the parameters set out under Rule 173L. There is nothing in the rule to say that the returned goods as such should be defective for the purposes of Rule 173L or that on re-processing of the goods in question, goods of different grades answering to the same description would tantamount to the violation of the conditions of Rule 173L. This plea of the revenue, therefore has to be rejected and the finding of the learned lower authority in this regard is upheld.
6. In regard to condition 173L sub-para 3, there is a stipulation that the goods are required to be shown to have been re-processed etc. and an account has to be rendered to the Collector within six months of the return of the goods in the factory. It is observed that there are no findings of the learned lower authority in this regard. This particular aspect therefore will have to be gone into and for this limited purpose, therefore the matter is required to be remanded to the learned lower appellate authority. If the appellants are able to satisfy the said authority regarding the requirements of Rule 173L(3) the appellants shall be allowed the refund subject to the provisions of Section 11B if applicable. So far as the limitation aspect is concerned, in the present case, limitation has to be reckoned in terms of Rule 11B(5)(B)(b) and the learned lower authority has rightly held that the claim was within time. The appeal is decided in the above terms.
Alert