Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

SHOIB PASHA @ SEYBU v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court
Aug 30, 2018

Accused no.1 and 2 in Crime No.23/18 registered by the respondent police for the offences punishable under Sections 393, 397 and 307 of IPC have sought for bail under Section 439 Cr.P.C.

2. Heard the petitioners counsel and the High Court Government Pleader.

3. The allegations found against the petitioners are that on 17.01.2018 at about 7.45 p.m. when the complainant Rajanna was alighting from BMTC bus near Kalyan Motors, Nayandanahalli circle, two persons tried to snatch his mobile phone. As the mobile phone fell down, and the complainant bent forward to pick it, one of them inflicted injury with a knife on his stomach. As the complainant shouted loudly they both went away. With the help of an autorickshaw driver the complainant contacted his friend and then went to a nearby clinic to take treatment.

4. The petitioners counsel argues that no mobile was recovered by the police from the petitioners and that test identification parade was also not held. The investigation is over and charge sheet is filed. There are no prima facie materials and therefore bail can be granted. But the High Court Government Pleader opposes grant of bail by submitting that both the petitioners are involved in many cases. There are about 16 cases pending against them. They are habitual offenders.

5. The learned counsel for the petitioners submits that there are only 6 cases and in all the cases bail has been granted.

6. If the entire papers are perused it can be said clearly that bail cannot be granted. Even according to the petitioners counsel there are six cases against the petitioners. Pendency of these six cases shows that they are habitual offenders. Just because bail has been granted, it cannot be said that bail should be granted in this case also. Bail protects personal liberty of the accused; but at the same time he cannot misuse the benefit of bail by committing crime again. Though sometimes a condition prohibiting the accused from involving in any crime in future is not imposed at the time of granting bail, but such a condition is implicit. Bail is not a license to commit crime. In this case, the complainant has sustained injury on his stomach as a result of infliction of injury on him by the petitioners. It is clearly stated in the complaint itself that the petitioners could not snatch the mobile phone as it fell down and by that time the complainant shouted loudly. This could be reason why the police could not recover the mobile phone from the petitioners. Merely because investigation is completed, it cannot be said that bail can be granted. Prima facie materials are very much forth coming. Petition is dismissed. Sd/- JUDGE