Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Babji v. State Of Andhra Pradesh .

Supreme Court Of India
Aug 9, 2018
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

PW 4 Sumeet Asthana lodged a written complaint (Exhibit P-1) with the Vigilance Officer of Indian Airlines, Hyderabad. He alleged that when he sought a confirmed ticket on Flight IC 948 for travel to Madras on 21-6-1995, an unidentified Indian Airlines employee directed him to Babji (A-1) of M/s Varun Movies, Srinagar Colony, Hyderabad. On 1-6-1995 A-1 purportedly agreed to secure a confirmed seat in exchange for ₹2,100, although the actual fare was ₹1,646. Acting on the complaint, PW 1 (Manager, Vigilance, Indian Airlines) forwarded a report (Exhibit P-2) to the Superintendent of Police, CBI, alleging that A-1 and the present appellant (A-2) were cheating the public.

Based principally on the testimony of PW 4 and PW 2, the trial court convicted the appellant under Section 8 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (“PC Act”). The High Court, in Criminal Appeal No. 421 of 2000, affirmed the conviction. The appellant, on bail, has now challenged those concurrent findings before the Supreme Court.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution proved all essential ingredients of Section 8 of the Prevention of Corruption Act—namely, that the appellant solicited or received gratification as a motive or reward for inducing a public servant to perform an official act.
  2. Whether the evidence sufficiently established for whom and for what purpose the alleged gratification was demanded, and whether any linkage to a public servant existed.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court articulated the statutory requisites for an offence under Section 8 of the PC Act: (i) solicitation or receipt of gratification; (ii) for oneself or another; (iii) as a motive or reward; (iv) to induce a public servant to perform or refrain from an official act or show favour. It further clarified that three core elements must co-exist: solicitation/receipt, the quid pro quo of inducing a public servant, and a clear link between the gratification and the public servant’s anticipated action.

Evaluating the record, the Court found the prosecution evidence “vague” on two pivotal aspects:

  • Identification of the person on whose behalf the appellant allegedly demanded money.
  • Proof that such person was in fact a public servant capable of securing confirmation of an airline seat.

The Court acknowledged that an intermediary who receives money need not himself be a public servant; nevertheless, the prosecution must adduce “convincing evidence” that the payment was intended to induce a public servant. Here, the evidence did not show that the appellant demanded or received money to influence any identifiable public servant. In the absence of such linkage, a key statutory ingredient failed, rendering the conviction unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

HELD: The appeal is allowed; the appellant is acquitted of the charge under Section 8 of the Prevention of Corruption Act.

Immediate Consequences: The appellant’s conviction and sentence are set aside, and his bail bonds stand discharged. No broader legal principle was formulated beyond the case-specific reaffirmation that all statutory elements of Section 8 must be strictly proved to sustain a conviction.

Show all summary ...

R. Banumathi, J.— Being aggrieved by the conviction under Section 8 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, the appellant has preferred this appeal.

2. The case of the prosecution is that PW 4 Sumeet Asthana gave Ext. P-1 complaint to Vigilance Officer, Indian Airlines, Hyderabad, stating that he had approached the Indian Airlines Office on 20-6-1995 for reservation of a seat in Flight IC No. 948 for his travel to Madras on 21-6-1995 but there was a long waiting list and that an employee of the Indian Airlines, whom he does not know, had told him to contact Babji (A-1) of M/s Varun Movies at Srinagar Colony, Hyderabad. PW 4 had approached A-1 on 1-6-1995 and A-1 told him that there was long waiting list but he can arrange a confirmed ticket and demanded Rs 2100 as against the actual fair of Rs 1646. On receipt of the said complaint PW 1, the Manager, Vigilance, Indian Airlines, Hyderabad, gave report, Ext. P-2 to the Superintendent of Police, CBI Hyderabad stating that A-1 and A-2 are cheating the public.

3. Based on the evidence of PW 4 and PW 2 who accompanied PW 4, the trial court has convicted the appellant under Section 8 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (for short “the Act”) which was confirmed Criminal Appeal No. 421 of 2000 by the High Court.

4. We have heard Mr P. Venkat Reddy, learned counsel appearing for the appellant as well as Mr P.K. Dey, learned counsel appearing for CBI.

5. In order to establish the offence under Section 8 of the Prevention of Corruption Act it must be proved:

(i) That the accused accepted or obtained, or agreed to accept, or attempted to obtain, from someone;
(ii) For himself or for some other person;
(iii) Any gratification whatever;
(iv) As a motive or reward for inducing by corrupt or illegal means any “public servant” to do or forbear to do any official act or to show favour or render any service to any of the persons specified in the section.

6. In order to constitute an offence under Section 8 of the Act, three things are essential. In the first place there must have been the solicitation or receipt of the gratification. Secondly, such gratification must have been asked for or paid as a motive or reward for inducing a public servant to do an act or do a favour or render some service as stated under Section 8 of the Act. In the present case, the evidence adduced by the prosecution is vague for whom the appellant had demanded the money and whether the person for whom the appellant demanded and received the money is a public servant. Though the receiver of the money, like in the present case may not be a public servant, the prosecution has to establish by convincing evidence that the amount must have been received for inducing a public servant for doing something by that public servant in his official capacity. So far as confirmation of the seat in the Indian Airlines, there may be persons in the middle who may be a public servant or a travel agency or others. In the absence of convincing evidence to show that the appellant had received the money from PW 4, to induce a public servant to get the confirmation of the ticket, the conviction of the appellant under Section 8 of the PC Act cannot be sustained. In the result, the appeal is allowed and the appellant is acquitted.

7. The appellant is on bail. His bail bonds shall stand discharged.