Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

1.B.Nambirajan v. 1.The District Collector,

Madras High Court
Apr 18, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion: W.P. (MD) No.2353 of 2018 (Madurai Bench of Madras High Court, 18.04.2018)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition was filed by 24 petitioners under Article 226 of the Constitution of India seeking a writ of mandamus to restrain the respondents from forcibly taking possession of or demolishing petitioners' houses situated along a newly aligned stretch of National Highway NH-47 without following the procedure established under Section 3E (and related provisions) of the National Highways Act, 1956 (the Act).

The petitioners alleged that the National Highways Authority (NHAI) changed the alignment of the NH-47 four‑laning project (originally proposed to pass through Kaliyakkavizhai, Marthandam and Thukkalay) because of encroachments by "influential persons" and that the NHAI should have widened the existing road instead of realigning it. The first petitioner claimed ownership of 24 cents of land and said he had received a notice under Section 3A, submitted objections which were rejected by an order dated 06.08.2010, and thereafter an award was passed allegedly without enquiry or further notices. The petitioners also contended that compensation should be determined under the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (Act 30 of 2013) in light of Section 105(3) of that Act, and that possession cannot be taken without depositing compensation in terms of Section 3E read with Section 3H of the National Highways Act.

The respondents (including the District Collector, Revenue Officer (Land Acquisition National Highways) & Competent Authority, Tahsildars, Superintendent of Police, Project Director of NHAI and the Union of India through the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways) contested maintainability and asserted that acquisition proceedings and statutory procedures required under the Act had been followed, notifications and publications made under the Act, awards passed and compensation deposited (with some disbursed to entitled owners).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondents can be restrained by a writ of mandamus from dispossessing or demolishing petitioners' houses situated along the new alignment of NH-47 without following the procedure under Section 3E (and related provisions) of the National Highways Act, 1956.
  2. Whether the acquisition proceedings and related notifications/awards for four‑laning of NH-47 are vitiated on the ground that the new alignment is a "new road" not declared to be a National Highway (and therefore the Act is inapplicable unless a declaration is made under Section 2(1) or Section 3 of the Act).
  3. Whether the petitioners' challenge amounts to an impermissible indirect challenge to the acquisition proceedings already completed (i.e., whether the Writ Petition is maintainable when acquisition proceedings are not directly contested).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners sought an order preventing forcible dispossession/demolition without compliance with Section 3E of the National Highways Act.
  • They contended the project alignment was a new road (not a declared National Highway) and that the Act would apply only if a declaration is made under Section 2(1) (and/or Section 3) — therefore acquisition proceedings were vitiated.
  • The petitioners alleged the alignment change benefited influential encroachers and that objections submitted under Section 3A were not properly considered; they also complained that awards were made without proper notice or enquiry and that compensation issues should be governed by the 2013 Act.
  • They asserted compensation had not been deposited as required and therefore possession could not be taken.

Respondents' (NHAI and Government) Arguments

  • The writ was said to be not maintainable because the petitioners did not directly challenge acquisition proceedings and could not indirectly attack completed acquisition proceedings through this petition.
  • The respondents maintained that statutory procedure under the Act was scrupulously followed: specific notifications and enquiries under Sections 3A(1), 3C(2), 3D(1), 3G(3) were issued/conducted and awards passed; environmental and other statutory approvals had been obtained.
  • The award dates and deposit of compensation were furnished; awards for the villages were passed between 11.08.2014 and 07.10.2014 (with specific award numbers and later dates also recorded), and compensation was deposited in a joint account for the project with part disbursed to those who proved title.
  • The respondents indicated that some petitioners who proved title were paid; a meeting for disbursal had been held on 17.11.2017; and that the project was being stalled on account of pendency of the writ, so the interim protection should be vacated.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P. No.1109 of 2014, dated 21.02.2014 (Jayaraman & Ors. vs. State of Tamilnadu & Ors.) Rejected the submission that the relevant Act (a highways enactment) cannot be read to permit acquisition for construction/widening unless the road has already been declared a highway under the statute; the statute empowers acquisition for construction, maintenance or development of a highway. The court relied on this decision to reject petitioners' argument that the National Highways Act was inapplicable because the alignment was a "new road" not previously declared as a National Highway; held that acquisition for four‑laning/widening falls within the Act's scope.
Girials Investment (P) Ltd. vs. State of Karnataka, 2008 (7) SCC 53 Affirmed that land acquisition for public benefit should not be interdicted by courts except for extraordinary reasons; public purpose and public benefit weigh against injuncting acquisition. The court cited this Supreme Court authority to emphasize that acquisition for public benefit (four‑laning NH‑47) should not be restrained by the court in the absence of extraordinary reasons; used it to support dismissal of the petition.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed the matter as a petition seeking protection of possession rather than a direct challenge to acquisition proceedings. It held that an attempt to indirectly challenge completed acquisition proceedings in this writ petition cannot be entertained.

On the contention that the alignment was a "new road" and therefore the National Highways Act was inapplicable unless the road had been declared a National Highway, the court found the submission devoid of merit. The court considered the project to be the four‑laning (which includes widening) of NH‑47 and concluded that such works fall within the Act's scope. The court noted that a road need not be formed and dedicated to public use before the statute applies; the statutory notifications and related procedures may precede formation.

The court examined the procedural history as furnished by the respondents and found compliance with the Act's provisions: - Notification under Section 3A(1) was approved by the Central Government and published in village gazettes and local dailies between March and June 2010 (with objections invited under Section 3A(3)). - Petitions were inquired under Section 3C(1) and orders made under Section 3C(2). - Notification under Section 3D(1) was approved by the Central Government and published between February and September 2011. - Publication in the local newspaper under Section 3G(3) was made inviting claims for superstructure, crops, trees, etc. - Awards were passed (specific award numbers and dates are recorded), and in terms of the Act the lands vested in the Central Government free of encumbrances after Section 3D notifications.

The court further noted the deposit and disbursal status of compensation: Awards were passed (Award No.6 of 2014 dated 16.09.2014; Award No.6 of 2015 dated 29.02.2015; Award No.7 of 2015 dated 07.10.2015 are recorded in the opinion), a sum of Rs. 2,21,44,362/- had been disbursed to claimants who proved title, and Rs. 6,72,28,777/- remained in joint deposit. The court observed that landowners who wished to receive compensation must produce their title documents and prove entitlement to receive the amounts deposited.

The court treated allegations of mala fides (that the alignment was changed to benefit certain influential persons and that those persons were encroachers) as bald and unsubstantiated; the respondents specifically denied encroachment and the petitioners did not file a reply to that denial. Consequently the court rejected the mala fide contention.

Applying the principles in the precedents it cited (including the Tamil Nadu Highways Act decision and Girials Investment), the court held that land acquisition for a project of public benefit like four‑laning cannot be restrained except for extraordinary reasons, which were absent here. The court therefore concluded there was no merit in the petition.

Holding and Implications

Final Ruling: The Writ Petition was dismissed and the interim order granted in the Writ Petition was vacated. The court ordered no costs.

Implications (Direct Effects)

  • The petitioners' request to be protected from dispossession/demolition without compliance with Section 3E and related provisions was rejected.
  • The acquisition proceedings for four‑laning/widening of NH‑47 were held not to be vitiated on the ground that the alignment was a "new road" not previously declared a National Highway; the statutory notifications and processes recorded in the opinion were treated as compliant with the Act.
  • Compensation has been determined and deposited (with specified amounts disbursed and specified sums lying in joint deposit); landowners who claim entitlement must approach the authorities with title documents to obtain payment.
  • The vacatur of the interim order removes the interlocutory restraint that had been affecting the project (the opinion records that the project was time bound and had been stalled on account of the writ).

The court relied on existing case law to support its conclusions; the opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal principle beyond application of those authorities to the facts at hand.

Show all summary ...

1

BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT

Dated : 18.04.2018

Coram

The Hon'ble Mr.Justice T.S.Sivagnanam &

The Hon'ble Mrs.Justice R.Tharani

Orders reserved on Orders pronounced on

15.03.2018 18.04.2018

W.P (MD) No.2353 of 2018

1.B.Nambirajan 2.P.Gurusamy 3.P.Mohanaraj 4.V.Dhasappan 5.M.Joseph Legoi 6.J.Maria Chanam 7.K.Jaisey

8.M.Maria Thangam 9.P.Rajamani 10.J.Siluvai Rajan 11.V.Maria Nesam 12.M.Maria Thangam 13.C.Sarojini 14.C.E.George 15.R.Irin

16.S.Kurusu Micheal 17.A.Augustine Selvaraj 18.S.Francis

19.J.Maria Samidas 20.S.Sahayaraj

21.J.Maria Selvi 22.A.Sadasivan

23.S.Loius

24.C.Lilly Gladis ...Petitioners Vs.

2

1.The District Collector, Kanyakumari District at Nagercoil 2.The Revenue Officer,

(Land Acquisition National Highways) and Competent Authority, Tirunelveli 3.The Tahsildar,

Kalkulam Taluk,

Kanyakumari District.

4.The Superintendent of Police, Kanyakumari District,

Kanyakumari

5.The Project Director cum DGM (Tech) No.314E, K.P.Road, Near Ayappan Kovil, Parvathipuram, Nagercoil - 629 003 Kanyakumari District.

6.The Union of India,

Rep., by its Secretary,

Ministry of Road Transport and Highways Transport Bhawan,

No.1, Parliament Street, New Delhi. 7.The Tahsildar,

Villavan Kodu Taluk, Kanyakumari District. ...Respondents Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, to issue a Writ of Mandamus, to forbear the respondents from forcibly taking possession or demolishing the houses of the petitioners situated along with new aligned NH47 without following the procedure established under Section 3E of the National Highways Act 1956 and pass such further or other orders.

3

For Petitioner : Mr.G.Prabhu Rajadurai For Respondents : Mr. S.Dhayalan G.A., for R1 to R4 & R7

Mr.Su.Srinivasan for R5

Mr.P.Paul Pandi for R6

O R D E R

T.S.Sivagnanam, J.,

The petitioners, 24 in number, have filed this Writ Petition to forbear the respondents from forcibly taking possession or demolishing the houses of the petitioners situated along the new aligned NH-47 without following the procedure under Section 3E of the National Highways Act 1956 (hereinafter referred to as "The Act").

2. The petitioners' case is that for several years there has been a proposal for converting the existing National Highway NH-47 between Kanyakumari to Trivandrum as a four way road and ultimately, when the proposal was drawn, the four way road had to pass through Kaliyakkavizhai, Marthandam and Thukkalay town. However, the National Highway Authority have changed the alignment of the Highway on account of the encroachments made by several influential persons along side the road in those three towns. The petitioners'

4

further case is that the National Highways Authority ought to have removed the encroachments and widened the existing NH-47 and should not have realigned the road. The first Writ Petitioner would state that he owns lands measuring an extent of 24 cents and has constructed a house and after receiving notice under Section 3A of the Act, he submitted his objections before the second respondent and other similarly placed landowners also filed their objections, which were not considered and an order was passed by the second respondent dated 06.08.2010, rejecting the representation on the ground that the lands are required for the National Highways. Thereafter, without even issuing any notice to any of the landowners and without conducting enquiry, an award was passed. Thus, it is submitted that the petitioners and other similarly placed persons are not aware as to what is the extent of property of their property which is to be acquired for the formation of NH-47. The details of the landholdings of the other 23 petitioners have also been set out in paragraph 8 of the affidavit filed in support of the Writ Petition. Further, it is submitted that the compensation payable to the petitioners has to be determined in accordance with Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Settlement Act, 2013 in the light of the Section 105(3) of the said Act.

5

Further, it is submitted that without depositing the compensation in terms of Section 3E read with Section 3H of the Act, the possession of the acquired land cannot be taken over.

3. Mr.G.Prabhu Rajadurai, learned counsel for the petitioners, while reiterating the submissions made in the Writ Petition, contended that the land acquisition proceedings itself is vitiated as the provisions of the Act are inapplicable, since the road, which is proposed to be formed is a new road and not a declared National Highway and the National Highways Act will be applicable only if a declaration is made in accordance with Section 2 of the Act. Therefore, it is submitted that the entire proceedings stand vitiated. Further, it is submitted that compensation has not been deposited and therefore, the possession of the lands owned by the petitioners cannot be disturbed.

4. Mr.Su.Srinivasan, learned Standing counsel appearing for the National Highways Authority submitted that the Writ Petition is not maintainable and none of the petitioners have challenged the acquisition proceedings and therefore, they are not entitled for any relief in this Writ Petition. Further, it is submitted that the procedure required to be followed under the National Highways Act, have been scrupulously followed and there has been no error. The learned

6

counsel furnished the dates on which the respective notification/enquiry was issued/conducted namely under Section 3A(1), 3C(2), 3D(1), 3G(3), and award and date of deposit of the compensation amount. Further, the details as to which of the petitioners, who had attended the 3G(3) enquiry and what is the outcome of such enquiry were also furnished in a tabulated form. Further, it is submitted that the award in respect of all the four villages were passed between 11.08.2014 and 07.10.2014 and the compensation amount has been deposited in a joint account for all the four villages and some of the landowners who appeared and produced their documents of title and extent of holding, were paid the compensation and they have received the same. Further, the Sub- Collector of Padmanabapuram had conducted a meeting on 17.11.2017 on directions issued by the District Collector for disbursal of the amount of compensation. Further, all statutory approvals have been obtained including the environmental clearance. Further, it is submitted that the prayer in the Writ Petition itself is not to dispossess the petitioners without following due procedure of issuance of notice and when such a prayer has been made, the petitioners cannot indirectly challenge the acquisition proceedings, which has already been completed.

7

5. Heard the learned counsels for the parties and perused the materials placed on record.

6. The petitioners have sought for issuance of a Writ of Mandamus to forbear the respondents from dispossessing them from the lands in question without following the procedure under the provisions of National Highways Act. Thus, there is no challenge to the acquisition proceedings initiated by the National Highways Authority and the petitioners seek to protect their possession and claim that they shall not be evicted without notice. In the background of these facts, any indirect challenge to the acquisition proceedings cannot be entertained and such contentions are to be outrightly rejected.

7. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the present alignment which has been fixed by the authorities, is totally a new alignment, a new road, not declared as a National Highway and that unless a declaration is made to the said effect in terms of Section 2(1) of the Act, the question of terming it as a National Highway does not arise.

8

8. In our considered view, this submission is totally devoid of merits, as the acquisition proceedings is for four laning of NH-47, which includes widening of the existing road. Therefore, to state that it is totally a new road, not declared as a National Highway, is an incorrect submission. Nextly, unless the road is formed before dedicating to public use, it is to be declared as a National Highway and not prior to that. In the instant case, the notification under Section 3A(1) was approved by the Central Government and has been published in the village gazettes as well as in the local daily between March 2010 and June 2010, as mandated under Section 3A(3), objections have been called for within 21 days from the date of publication and the petitions which were received have been shown to have been enquired in terms of Section 3C(1) of the Act and orders have been passed under Section 3C(2) of the Act. It is thereafter notification under Section 3D(1) of the Act was approved by the Central Government and it has been published in the village gazettes as well as in the local daily between February and September 2011.

9. The substance of the notification has been published in the local newspaper as required under Section 3G(3) of the Act inviting claims from persons interested and for obtaining the correct value of

9

the superstructure, standing crops, trees etc. After following such procedure, awards have been passed in Award No.6 of 2014, dated 16.09.2014, Award No.6 of 2015, dated 29.02.2015 and Award No.7 of 2015, dated 07.10.2015. Thus, in terms of the scheme of the Act, after a notification is issued under Section 3D(1)&(2) of the Act, the lands shall absolutely vest with the Central Government free from all encumbrances and such notification was published on 11.02.2011, 16.05.2011 and 08.04.2011 in respect of Thiruvithamcode village, Eraniel village and Kalkulam village respectively. The respondent NHAI has denied the allegations that there is encroachment in the three villages alongside NH-47 and it is stated that there is no encroachment into the road, but the area is congested and will not be sufficient for free flow of traffic from Kanyakumari to Trivandrum and therefore, a new alignment was proposed. Thus, it can be seen that the project is four laning of existing NH-47, and as per technical exigencies, alignments have been altered, so that the road serves its purpose. It is further submitted that sofar as the compensation payable in respect of the landowners in Kalkulam village, since the award was passed prior to 31.12.2014, it was not paid in terms of the Act 30 of 2013, but in respect of the other two villages namely, Thiruvithamcode and Eraniel, compensation has been paid in terms of

10

Act 30 of 2013. The respondents have clearly stated that there is no forcible action taken by them against the landowners and the work done by the National Highways has been proceeded strictly in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Further, it is submitted that on account of the pendency of the Writ Petition, the entire project is being stalled and it being a time bound project, unless the entire stretch is available, it would be difficult for the respondents to move the machinery from one place to another and therefore, the interim order has to be vacated.

10. As mentioned earlier, the petitioners have not questioned the acquisition proceedings and from the data furnished by NHAI, it is seen that the notifications have been published in accordance with the provisions of the Act and there is no violation of time lines prescribed under the Act and the award amount has also been deposited in a joint account of the Project Director of NHAI and the competent authority. Further, from the information furnished by the NHAI, it is seen that some of the landowners have received the compensation after proving their title and extent over their respective properties. In this manner, a sum of Rs.2,21,44,362/- has been disbursed as compensation and the amount lying in joint deposit is Rs. 6,72,28,777/-. Thus, if the

11

petitioners/land owners are interested in receiving the compensation, they are required to approach the authorities by producing their documents of title, prove their entitlement and receive the same. Thus, this Court cannot entertain an indirect challenge to the acquisition proceedings in the manner done by the petitioners.

11. The learned counsel for the petitioner stressed that the change of alignment was to benefit certain influential persons. However, such an allegation remains unsubstantiated and it is a bald averment and no material has been placed by the petitioners before this Court to prove the said submission. The other allegation made by the petitioners is that the influential persons are encroachers. This has been specifically denied by the second respondent in their counter affidavit stating that there is no encroachment. The petitioners have not denied the said stand taken in the counter affidavit, as no reply affidavit has been filed. Thus, the faint plea of malafide exercise of power is liable to be outrightly rejected.

12. As mentioned earlier, the contention of the petitioners that since there is no declaration under Section 2(1) of the Act, for declaring the newly aligned road, as a National Highway, the provisions

12

of the Act would not apply, is an incorrect submission. Such an argument was considered in a case arising under the Tamil Nadu Highways Act, a State enactment [refer decision in W.P.No.1109 of 2014, dated 21.02.2014(Jayaraman & Ors., vs. State of Tamilnadu & Ors.,]. The submission made by the said Writ Petitioners was also identical to that of the submissions made before us. While rejecting the said submission, it was held that the Act cannot be read and interpreted to mean that it does not empower the Government or the competent authority to acquire lands, for construction of a highways or for widening of any road, unless and until, a road has been declared as Highways, under Section 3 of the Act. The Act manifestly states that for the purpose of construction, maintenance or development of any highway lands can be acquired. The Act provides for construction of a highway. It provides for maintenance. An existing road can also be declared as State Highways, and developed. For the purpose of construction of a highway, maintenance, development, and in sum and substance, for the purpose of giving effect to the Act, all acts can be done by the competent authorities, which includes acquisition of lands also.

13

13. Thus, for the above reasons, we find that the acquisition proceedings initiated for widening of NH-47 cannot be faulted and the contentions advanced by the petitioners to continue to remain in the property in question, which is vested with the Central Government free from all encumbrances, is devoid of merits. As pointed out by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Girials Investment (P) Ltd vs. State of Karnataka [2008 (7) SCC 53], the acquisition is for the benefit of the public at large and therefore, the Court should not interdict such proceedings and in doing so, extraordinary reasons must exist. We find that there are no extraordinary reasons to entertain the petitioners' prayer. Furthermore, the compensation amount has been determined and lying in deposit, which the landowners can receive on establishing their entitlement. In respect of two of the villages, the compensation is stated to have been given in accordance with Act 30 of 2013. The adequacy and inadequacy of the compensation is to be adjudicated before a different forum. The typed set of documents filed by the respondent NHAI, shows that adequate publication has been given in the locality including Press statement and local publication by way of announcement in the villages etc., and the Collector has also conducted special camp to sensitize the public of the area. Thus, all persons, whose lands have been acquired are fully conversant with the

14

factual position and therefore, the present attempt of the 24 petitioners is to somehow stall the road widening project which has commenced and is in the advanced stage of implementation. It is not for the petitioner to dictate as to which part of the road is first required, what is the type of work which has to be done at the first instance. These are all issues to be decided by the authorities and not for the Court in a Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution, especially when there is no malafide exercise of power.

14. For the above reasons, there is no merit in the Writ Petition and the same is dismissed and the interim order granted in the Writ Petition is vacated. No costs.

(T.S.S.J.,) & (R.T.J.,)

18.04.2018

pbn Index : yes/no Speaking Order/Non speaking Order

15

To 1.The District Collector, Kanyakumari District at Nagercoil 2.The Revenue Officer,

(Land Acquisition National Highways) and Competent Authority, Tirunelveli 3.The Tahsildar,

Kalkulam Taluk,

Kanyakumari District.

4.The Superintendent of Police, Kanyakumari District,

Kanyakumari

5.The Project Director cum DGM (Tech) No.314E, K.P.Road, Near Ayappan Kovil, Parvathipuram, Nagercoil - 629 003 Kanyakumari District.

6.The Union of India,

Rep., by its Secretary,

Ministry of Road Transport and Highways Transport Bhawan,

No.1, Parliament Street, New Delhi. 7.The Tahsildar,

Villavan Kodu Taluk, Kanyakumari District.

16

T.S.Sivagnanam,J., and

R.Tharani.J.,

pbn

W.P (MD) No.2353 of 2018

18.04.2018