- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Siddharth Agarwal & Ors. v. State Bank Of India & Ors.
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion addresses a writ petition filed against a communication dated 19th November 2014 issued by a respondent bank to a Company. The Company, represented by the petitioners as directors and guarantors, had obtained financial assistance from the bank and acknowledged its liability. The Company was advised to repay the loan by 10th December 2014 but failed to do so and instead initiated proceedings before the Debts Recovery Tribunal and this Court. The petitioners sought a writ of mandamus and prohibition restraining the bank from acting on the impugned communication.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the bank can publish photographs of borrowers and sureties for non-repayment of loans without violating any legal rights or provisions.
- Whether the impugned communication dated 19th November 2014 amounts to a show-cause notice and if the Court should interfere with it.
- Whether the petitioners, as directors and guarantors, can be held liable for the alleged default of the Company.
- Whether the Company has wilfully defaulted within the meaning of RBI guidelines, thereby justifying coercive measures such as publication of photographs.
Arguments of the Parties
Respondent Bank's Arguments
- The bank relied on a 2016 Madras High Court decision holding no violation in publishing photographs of defaulters.
- Earlier Madras High Court judgments, including K.J. Doraiswamy Vs. The Assistant General Manager State Bank of India, support the bank's right to caution the public against defaulting borrowers.
- The Division Bench Judgment of the Bombay High Court in Exim (India) Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. vs. State Bank of India & Ors. affirmed no legal impediment to publishing defaulter photographs.
- Supreme Court precedents (Trade Tax Officer, Saharanpur Vs Royal Trading Co. and Union Of India And Another Vs. Vicco Laboratories) establish judicial reluctance to interfere in matters involving show-cause notices.
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners submitted that the Madras High Court Division Bench decision supporting the bank is under challenge before the Supreme Court, but could not provide details.
- The petitioners contended that the Company has not been declared a wilful defaulter under RBI Master Circular, which is relevant to restraining the bank's action.
- They argued that the impugned communication does not constitute a show-cause notice, and the petitioners as directors and guarantors cannot be held liable for the Company's conduct.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| 2016 SCC OnLine Madras 32928 | Permissibility of publishing photographs of borrowers and sureties for loan default. | Supported the bank's right to caution public against defaulters; considered relevant but not binding due to pending Supreme Court challenge. |
| K.J. Doraiswamy Vs. The Assistant General Manager State Bank of India (Madras High Court) | Support for lender bank's measures to caution public about defaulting borrowers. | Considered in the 2016 Madras High Court decision; reinforced bank's position. |
| Exim (India) Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. vs. State Bank of India & Ors (Bombay High Court) | No legal impediment to publishing photographs of defaulters. | Supported bank's position; court noted reliance by counsel for the bank. |
| Trade Tax Officer, Saharanpur Vs Royal Trading Co., (2005) 11 SCC 518 | Judicial reluctance to interfere in issuance of show-cause notices. | Cited to argue limited scope of court interference; found inapplicable as impugned letter not a show-cause notice. |
| Union Of India And Another Vs. Vicco Laboratories, (2007) 13 SCC 270 | Reluctance of courts to interfere with show-cause notices. | Referenced similarly to above; impugned communication distinguished from a show-cause notice. |
| State Bank of India & Ors. Vs. Ujjal Kumar Das & Anr (Madras High Court) | Caution against publishing photographs of wilful defaulters respecting Article 21 of the Constitution. | Binding on this Court; established a "window" for coercive measures only in special circumstances of wilful default with mala fide intent, not applicable here. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the admitted liability of the Company and noted the absence of any dispute on this point in response to the SARFAESI notice. The Court observed that the Company had not repaid the loan by the stipulated date and had initiated litigation to delay repayment. However, the Court emphasized that the Company had not been declared a wilful defaulter under the RBI Master Circular, a key factor in assessing the permissibility of publishing photographs of defaulters.
The Court acknowledged the persuasive precedents favoring the bank's right to publish defaulter photographs but held itself bound by the Division Bench judgment in State Bank of India & Ors. Vs. Ujjal Kumar Das & Anr, which cautions against such publication unless there is wilful default with mala fide intention. The Court found no material on record to establish wilful default or mala fide intent by the Company or the petitioners.
Further, the Court distinguished the impugned letter dated 19th November 2014 from a show-cause notice, rendering the cited Supreme Court precedents on judicial reluctance to interfere with show-cause notices inapplicable.
Accordingly, the Court confirmed its interim order restraining the bank from acting on the impugned communication.
Holding and Implications
The Court CONFIRMED THE INTERIM ORDER dated 20th January 2015 restraining the respondent bank from acting on the impugned communication dated 19th November 2014.
The writ petition (WP No. 9 of 2015) is disposed of on this basis.
The order is without prejudice to the bank's right to pursue remedies against the Company under the SARFAESI Act, RBI guidelines, or any other law currently in force.
No new precedent was established; the decision is fact-specific and limited to the absence of wilful default and mala fide intention in this case.
Honble Madras High Court reported in 2016 SCC On Line Madras 32928 which had considered a similar case and had held that there is no violation of any right or legal provision in publishing photographs of borrowers and the surety for non repayment of the loan. Earlier judgements of the Honble Madras High Court namely K.J. Doraiswamy Vs. The Assistant General Manager State Bank of India, were considered in the said judgment and a strong case made out in favour of the lender bank for resorting to appropriate measures to caution the public at large against the defaulting borrowers.
Counsel also relies on a Division Bench Judgment of the Honble Bombay High Court D.J. Exim (India) Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. vs. State Bank of India & Ors. which held that there is no legal impediment prohibiting a bank from publishing photographs of a defaulter. He relies upon two other judgements reported in (2005) 11 Supreme Court Cases 518; Trade Tax Officer, Saharanpur Vs Royal Trading Co. and (2007) 13 Supreme Court Cases 270; Union Of India And Another Vs. Vicco Laboratories for the proposition that a 5Court should be reluctant to interfere in matters involving issuance of a show- cause notice.
Counsel for the petitioner submits that the decision of the Division Bench of the Honble Madras High Court has been challenged before the Honble Supreme Court of India, but is unable to give further details as to the status of the Special Leave Petition.
I have considered the submissions of Counsel appearing for the parties. From the documents annexed to the writ petition there is no doubt that the Company of which the petitioners are directors and guarantors (for the financial assistance availed of by the Company), have acknowledged and admitted their liability in respect of the credit facilities obtained from the respondent bank. The response of the Company to the notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI does not dispute this liability. It is also clear from the impugned letter dated 19th November 2014, which is under challenge in this proceeding, that the Company had been advised to repay the loan amount by 10th December 2014 and that admittedly no steps have been taken by the Company thereafter to honour its financial obligations to the respondent bank. The company has instead filed a suit and an application before the Debts Recovery Tribunal in an attempt to push back their obligations to the bank.
In the present Writ Petition this Court has been invited to only consider the case made out by the petitioners for the relief claimed namely, for a writ of mandamus and prohibition restraining the respondent/bank from acting in terms of the impugned communication dated 19th November, 2014. In 6considering whether such relief can be granted, the fact that the Company has not yet been declared a wilful defaulter under the RBI Master Circular is relevant.
It is also relevant that proceedings filed by the Company before this Court as well as the Debts Recovery Tribunal are pending as on date and will consider the merits of the cross-claims at the time of adjudication.
Although the reasons stated in the decisions of the Division Bench of the Madras High Court, supported by the Bombay High Court in favour of the banks are compelling, this Court is bound by the Division Bench Judgement rendered in State Bank of India & Ors. Vs. Ujjal Kumar Das & Anr. where a note of caution has clearly been given against publishing of photographs of wilful defaulters in the backdrop of Article 21 of the Constitution of India. It should be noted, however, that the judgement of this Court provides a window of Special Circumstances when the bank can proceed with such coercive measures against borrowers who have committed deliberate default of the RBI Guidelines with mala-fide intention. This window cannot, however, be applied in the present case since, it cannot be from the material on record said that the Company has wilfully defaulted in its financial obligation to the respondents Bank or that the petitioner as Directors and Guarantors of the Company can be held liable for the conduct complained of on the part of the Company. The decisions relied on by the Bank with regard to the limited sphere of interference of a Court in relation to show-cause notices are not applicable since the impugned letter dated 19th November, 2014 cannot be construed as a show-cause notice per-se.
7In the facts and circumstances as stated above, the interim order passed by this Court on 20th January, 2015 is confirmed.
Let there be an order in terms of prayer f of the Writ Petition. WP No. 9 of 2015 is disposed of on that basis.
The order passed is without prejudice to the right of the respondent No. 1 bank to pursue its remedies against the Company under the Sarfaesi Act and the Rules thereunder or the RBI Guidelines or under any law other law presently in force.
(MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA, J) GH/RS
Alert