Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/S. Lifelong Mediatech Pvt. Ltd. v. M/S. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.

Delhi High Court
May 3, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — High Court of Delhi (Coram: G.S. Sistani & Sangita Dhingra Sehgal, JJ.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an application (CM No. 10452/2018) by the appellant, M/s Lifelong Mediatech Pvt Ltd, seeking condonation of 65 days' delay in filing an appeal (FAO (OS) (COMM) No. 50/2018) under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. The appeal was filed against an order dated 22.11.2017 of a learned Single Judge which had dismissed objections to an arbitral award. The appellant sought relief from this Court to condone the delay so that the appeal could be heard on merits. The respondent is M/s United India Insurance Co Ltd.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant has furnished sufficient and acceptable grounds to justify condonation of a 65-day delay in filing the appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
  2. Whether the explanations advanced (corporate decision-making delays, obtaining opinions from counsel and internal approvals) amount to bona fide reasons rather than negligence or deliberate inaction, such that the court should take a lenient approach consistent with the Supreme Court's approach to condonation of delay.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The delay of 65 days was unintentional and due to bonafide corporate processes: the matter had to pass through the company's legal department and higher management before a decision to file the appeal could be taken.
  • The appellant obtained opinions from "some counsels" and conducted internal self-analysis before placing the matter before higher management; these steps consumed time.
  • The appellant relied on the decision in Ummer vs Pottengal Subida & Ors (2018 Vol. 3 JT 154), particularly paragraph 18, for the proposition that a litigant is not required to explain each day's delay.
  • The appellant contended it has a strong case on merits and urged the Court to take a lenient view so as to avoid injustice arising from strict technicality.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent opposed the application, submitting that no reasonable or acceptable grounds had been shown to justify condonation of the delay.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ummer vs Pottengal Subida & Ors, 2018 Vol. 3 JT 154 The proposition (referred to in paragraph 18) that the earlier requirement to explain the delay of each day has been diluted and that a litigant need not explain each day's delay. The appellant relied on this decision to contend that it need not explain every day of the 65-day delay. The Court noted the reliance but examined the sufficiency of the appellant's overall explanation and ultimately found it inadequate.
Office of the Chief Postmaster General & Ors. v. Living Media India Ltd. & Anr., AIR 2012 SC 1506 Sets out the Supreme Court's analysis on condonation of delay, emphasizing that while courts may adopt a liberal approach to advance substantial justice, parties (including government bodies) must give plausible and acceptable explanations for delay; mechanical condonation is inappropriate where there is inaction or lack of diligence. The Court reproduced paras 11–13 of this judgment and used its principles to evaluate the present application: noting the obligation of entities possessing legal knowledge to act with diligence and that mere assertions of procedural delay (or seeking counsel opinions) without particulars are insufficient to justify condonation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner:

  1. Contextual framing: The Court began by emphasising the statutory objective behind the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 — speedy disposal of commercial disputes and improvement of the justice delivery system's image.
  2. Principled starting point: The Court acknowledged the Supreme Court's consistent guidance that applications under Section 5 of the Limitation Act (and generally condonation applications) should be approached liberally to advance substantial justice, but only where there is no gross negligence, deliberate inaction or lack of bonafides attributable to the applicant.
  3. Examination of the application: The Court carefully reviewed the appellant's condonation application and concluded that it was "highly casual in nature," lacked material particulars, and did not disclose sufficient cause for the delay. The Court reproduced the application verbatim and highlighted that it contained bald assertions rather than detailed or dated explanations (for example, it failed to state when the certified copy of the impugned judgment was received).
  4. Evaluation of the asserted reasons: The appellant's account that delay arose from seeking opinions of counsel and obtaining higher management approval was treated as conclusory. The Court found that mere statements that time was spent obtaining counsel opinions and internal clearance, without particulars or dates, cannot be treated as satisfactory reasons for condoning delay — particularly given the appellant was a corporate entity with its own legal department.
  5. Reliance on precedent: By citing and reproducing the Supreme Court's reasoning in Office of the Chief Postmaster General v. Living Media, the Court underscored that even government departments (and a fortiori entities with legal departments) cannot rely on impersonal procedural red-tape or vague assertions to justify inordinate delay. The Court applied that line of authority to the present facts to require a plausible and cogent explanation.
  6. Conclusion from facts to law: Because the application failed to provide specific, acceptable explanations (dates, steps taken, why certified copy was not obtained / when it was obtained, particulars of counsel opinions sought), and because the appellant is a company with internal legal capacity, the Court found that the appellant had not discharged the onus to demonstrate bona fide reasons devoid of negligence or inaction.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The application for condonation of delay is dismissed. Accordingly, the appeal (FAO (OS) (COMM) No. 50/2018) is dismissed as barred by limitation.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The appellant's appeal will not be heard on merits because the Court dismissed the condonation application and held the appeal to be barred by limitation. The respondent's position, as to finality of the challenged order (which had dismissed objections to the award), is thereby reinforced.
  • Broader legal implications: The Court applied established Supreme Court guidance requiring plausible and cogent reasons for condonation; it did not indicate the setting of any new precedent. The judgment reiterates that entities possessing legal expertise (including companies with legal departments) bear responsibility to act with diligence when limitation runs and cannot rely on vague assertions of internal processes or counsel consultations to excuse delay.

Order delivered: May 3, 2018 — G.S. Sistani, J. & Sangita Dhingra Sehgal, J.

Show all summary ...

$~4 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

Date of Decision: 3rd May, 2018 + FAO(OS) (COMM) 50/2018 M/S LIFELONG MEDIATECH PVT LTD ..... Appellant Through: Mr.Sameer Nandwani, Advocate. versus

M/S UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO LTD ..... Respondent Through: Mr. A. K. De, Advocate.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G.S.SISTANI HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE SANGITA DHINGRA SEHGAL

G.S.SISTANI, J. (ORAL)

CM No.10452/2018 (Delay)

1. The appellant has filed the present appeal under Section 37 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 against the order dated 22.11.2017 passed by the learned Single Judge of this Court, by which the objections to the award have been dismissed. The appellant seeks condonation of 65 days delay in filing the present appeal.

2. Learned counsel appearing for the applicant submits that the delay has been caused on account of bona-fide reasons and not on account of inaction or carelessness. Learned counsel for the applicant submits that the appellant is a corporate body with a legal department and any decision to file the appeal has to go through the legal department as well as by the higher management. The appellant had preferred to take an opinion from "some counsels" and also gave some self-analysis of the case. Thereafter, the facts were placed before the higher

1

management of the company and thus, this process took some time and resulted in delay, which is contended to be unintentional.

3. Learned counsel for the applicant has relied upon a decision rendered in the case of 'Ummer vs Pottengal Subida & Ors.' reported in 2018 Vol. 3 JT 154, more particularly, paragraph 18 which reads as under:

"18. One cannot now dispute the legal proposition that the earlier view of this Court that the appellant was required to explain the delay of each day till the date of filing the appeal has since been diluted by the later decisions of this Court and is, therefore, held as no longer good law".

4. This application is opposed by the learned counsel for the respondent, who submits that no reasonable grounds have been raised by the appellant seeking condonation of delay in filing the present appeal.

5. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties. Before the rival submissions of the parties can be considered, we deem it appropriate to highlight the main objective of the Commercial Courts, Commercial Division and Commercial Appellate Division of High Courts Act, 2015 is to provide speedy disposal of commercial disputes, to create a positive image and to improve the international image of the Indian Justice Delivery System.

6. Learned counsel for the appellant has relied upon the judgment rendered in the case of Ummer Vs Pottengal Subida & Ors. (Supra) in support of his submission that each days delay is not required to be explained. It has also been submitted before us that the appellant has a strong case on merits and this Court must take a lenient view in the matter to avoid any injustice to the appellant.

2

7. No doubt, The Supreme Court of India has taken a consistent view that while deciding an application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, the Courts must take a liberal view so as to advance substantial justice. However, the Supreme Court has also observed that a liberal approach must be taken, provided there is no gross negligence, deliberate inaction or lack of bonafides imputable to the parties seeking condonation of delay.

8. We have carefully examined the application filed by the appellant seeking condonation of delay. A careful reading of the application would show that the application is highly casual in nature, it lacks material particulars and does not disclose sufficient cause for condoning the delay.

9. Since, the application is very short, we deem it appropriate to reproduce the same:

"1. That the above said appeal has been filed today which is most likely to succeed as many questions of fact and law are involved. The grounds of objections may please be read as part of this application as the same are not being repeated for sake of brevity.

2. That the appellant is a body corporate and has got its own legal department, any decision to file appeal has to go through the legal department as well as higher management.

3. That the objections were decided against the appellant, the appellant preferred to take opinion from some counsels and also did self-analysis of the case and thereafter placed the facts before the higher management of the company.

4. That after the higher management gave consent to file the appeal the present appeal is

3

being preferred on various grounds as advised to the appellant.

5. That all this process took some time and a delay of 65 days has occurred in the process, which is purely unintentional.

6. That it is settled law that in case a party has got a good case, technicalities should not stand in the way of justice.

7. That the appellant/applicant has got a good case on merits and is most likely to succeed.

8. That for the mercy shown to the Appellant, the Appellant shall ever pray to this Hon'ble Court with folded hands.

PRAYER

It is, therefore, respectfully prayed that this Hon'ble Court may please be kind enough to condone delay of 65 days in filing the accompanying appeal keeping in view the aforesaid facts and circumstances as also in the interest of justice.

Any other relief which this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper may also pass in favour of the appellants and against the respondent."

10. In the case of Office of the Chief Postmaster General & Ors. Vs. Living Media India Limited and Anr., reported at AIR 2012 SC 1506, the Supreme Court of India has analysed the entire law on the subject. It would be relevant to reproduce paras 11 to 13, which is reproduced below:

"11) We have already extracted the reasons as mentioned in the "better affidavit" sworn by Mr. Aparajeet Pattanayak, SSRM, Air Mail Sorting Division, New Delhi. It is relevant to note that in

4

the said affidavit, the Department has itself mentioned and is aware of the date of the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court in LPA Nos. 418 and 1006 of 2007 as 11.09.2009. Even according to the deponent, their counsel had applied for the certified copy of the said judgment only on 08.01.2010 and the same was received by the Department on the very same day. There is no explanation for not applying for certified copy of the impugned judgment on 11.09.2009 or at least within a reasonable time. The fact remains that the certified copy was applied only on 08.01.2010, i.e. after a period of nearly four months. In spite of affording another opportunity to file better affidavit by placing adequate material, neither the Department nor the person in-charge has filed any explanation for not applying the certified copy within the prescribed period. The other dates mentioned in the affidavit which we have already extracted, clearly show that there was delay at every stage and except mentioning the dates of receipt of the file and the decision taken, there is no explanation as to why such delay had occasioned. Though it was stated by the Department that the delay was due to unavoidable circumstances and genuine difficulties, the fact remains that from day one the Department or the person/persons concerned have not evinced diligence in

5

prosecuting the matter to this Court by taking appropriate steps.

12) It is not in dispute that the person(s) concerned were well aware or conversant with the issues involved including the prescribed period of limitation for taking up the matter by way of filing a special leave petition in this Court. They cannot claim that they have a separate period of limitation when the Department was possessed with competent persons familiar with court proceedings. In the absence of plausible and acceptable explanation, we are posing a question why the delay is to be condoned mechanically merely because the Government or a wing of the Government is a party before us. Though we are conscious of the fact that in a matter of condonation of delay when there was no gross negligence or deliberate inaction or lack of bonafide, a liberal concession has to be adopted to advance substantial justice, we are of the view that in the facts and circumstances, the Department cannot take advantage of various earlier decisions. The claim on account of impersonal machinery and inherited bureaucratic methodology of making several notes cannot be accepted in view of the modern technologies being used and available. The law of limitation undoubtedly binds everybody including the Government.

13) In our view, it is the right time to inform all the government bodies, their agencies and

instrumentalities that unless they have reasonable and acceptable explanation for the delay and there

6

was bonafide effort, there is no need to accept the usual explanation that the file was kept pending for several months/years due to considerable degree of procedural red-tape in the process. The government departments are under a special obligation to ensure that they perform their duties with diligence and commitment. Condonation of delay is an exception and should not be used as an anticipated benefit for government departments. The law shelters everyone under the same light and should not be swirled for the benefit of a few. Considering the fact that there was no proper explanation offered by the Department for the delay except mentioning of various dates, according to us, the Department has miserably failed to give any acceptable and cogent reasons sufficient to condone such a huge delay. Accordingly, the appeals are liable to be dismissed on the ground of delay."

11. In the case of Office of the Chief Postmaster General & Ors. (Supra), the Supreme Court was considering an application seeking condonation of delay filed by a Government Department. The present case pertains to a Private Limited Company which admittedly has a legal department. The first question which arises for our consideration is whether the application discloses sufficient grounds for condonation of delay.

12. While considering the application seeking condonation of delay, the period of delay is not the criteria. A short delay may not be condoned in the absence of an acceptable explanation while a large delay may be condoned if the explanation is satisfactory. Courts cannot lose track of

7

the fact that normally after the expiry of the period, the right to sue extinguishes and the other side acquires a right which should not be usually disturbed as it would cause injustice to the opposite party.

13. We find that in this case, the application seeking condonation of delay is completely silent as to when the certified copy of the impugned judgment was received and the causes for the delay in filing the present appeal. Reading of the application would show that delay was caused on account of times spent in seeking opinion from some counsel. This in our view cannot be treated as sufficient grounds as no details have been provided and only a bald statement has been made. In the absence of any satisfactory explanation, it cannot be said that the delay was caused due to bonafide reasons and not on account of negligence or inaction. The Court cannot lose track of the fact that the appellant is not an illiterate litigant but a company which admittedly has its own legal department which is evident from reading para 2 of the application.

14. Accordingly, we find no merit in the application. The same, is therefore, dismissed.

FAO (OS) (COMM) No. 50/2018

15. In view of the order passed in the application, the present appeal is dismissed being barred by limitation.

G. S. SISTANI, J

SANGITA DHINGRA SEHGAL, J

MAY 03, 2018

afa

8