Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shri Ganesh Kumar Petitioner v. Union Of India & Ors. S

Meghalaya High Court
Feb 1, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion (Dinesh Maheshwari, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was enrolled as a Rifleman in Assam Rifles on 31.10.1977. He applied for promotion to Assistant Commandant in 1995 and was selected by the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) in August 1996; training completed on 20.11.1996. A piping ceremony was conducted for seven of the selected candidates, but the petitioner was excluded due to an allegation regarding a TA/DA claim without an attached movement order.

The petitioner challenged the denial of promotion in WP (C) No. 209 (SH) 2001 before the Shillong Bench of the Gauhati High Court. A Single Judge allowed that petition on 07.04.2003, directing re-examination in light of an Apex Court decision (State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bani Singh).

Following that order the petitioner was promoted effective 01.08.2006. He then filed WP (C) No. 312 (SH) 2006 seeking promotion effective 22.01.1997 (the date on which seven batch-mates were promoted); a Single Judge allowed that petition and directed notional promotion and seniority from the batch-mates' promotion date, and directed consideration for subsequent promotions on that basis.

The respondents appealed (WA No. 20 (SH) 2010) and the Division Bench dismissed the appeal, upholding the Single Judge's directions.

After these orders the respondents re-fixed the petitioner's seniority in the Assistant Commandant cadre to 22.01.1997, but did not extend notional fixation of pay. The petitioner was notionally promoted to Deputy Commandant w.e.f. 01.04.2004 and to 2IC w.e.f. 01.04.2008, again without notional fixation of pay. The petitioner made representations; the respondents maintained they had complied and made certain payments, including an order dated 31.10.2013 and an arrear payment of Rs. 6,32,051 credited on 29.09.2014. The petitioner contested that the compliance was inadequate, leading to the present writ petition which the Court has allowed.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner was entitled to notional promotion to Assistant Commandant with effect from 22.01.1997 (the date of promotion of his batch-mates) and consequent seniority and progression.
  2. Whether the petitioner was entitled to notional fixation of pay in the relevant scale for the Assistant Commandant post w.e.f. 22.01.1997 and consequential re-fixation of pay in subsequent cadres of progression (Deputy Commandant and 2IC).
  3. Whether the respondents have adequately complied with prior judicial directions (including orders dated 23.03.2010 and earlier) and, if not, what corrective steps should be directed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The respondents have not adequately complied with the court's earlier orders because the petitioner was wrongly denied the benefit of notional fixation of pay in the cadre of Assistant Commandant w.e.f. 22.01.1997.
  • Consequential re-fixation of pay in the cadre of Deputy Commandant and 2IC has also not been effected despite notional promotions/seniority being granted.
  • The petitioner relied on a Division Bench decision in WA No. 6 of 2014: Union of India v. Shri Ram Sukhpal Singh as covering his case.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents initially contended that they had complied with the court's orders and that necessary payments had been made.
  • In an additional affidavit dated 21.10.2016 the respondents stated that: (a) seniority was refixed as Assistant Commandant w.e.f. 22.01.1997 by Order No. A/Offr/Pay & Allce/2013/567 dated 31.10.2013; (b) the petitioner was notionally promoted to Deputy Commandant w.e.f. 01.04.2004 and to 2IC w.e.f. 01.04.2008 without effecting pay and allowances as per HQ DGAR sig No. A1792 dated 21.02.2011; (c) the petitioner's pay was refixed in certain scales and an amount of Rs. 6,32,051 was paid as arrears credited on 29.09.2014; and (d) a fresh IPS was prepared and verified, asserting that grievances were addressed by the 31.10.2013 order.
  • During oral submissions, counsel for the respondents accepted the earlier findings that the petitioner was denied promotion through no fault of his own and that the court had directed notional promotion and seniority.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bani Singh Referenced in the Single Judge's earlier order directing re-examination where proceedings had been initiated but no final decision had been made. The Single Judge in WP (C) No. 209 (SH) 2001 relied on this decision to direct the respondents to re-examine the petitioner's case and pass appropriate orders for promotion; the present Court records that reliance in the background.
Union of India v. K.V. Jankiraman — (1991) 4 SCC 109 Principle that "no work no pay" is not applicable where an employee is willing to work but kept away by the authorities for no fault of his; when exonerated, an employee may be entitled to salary of the higher post, subject to authority's discretion in certain circumstances and requirement to record reasons if arrears are denied. The Court (by reference in Ram Sukhpal Singh and applied here) relied on this ratio to support the conclusion that notional promotion and seniority inherently carry the requirement of notional fixation of pay from the retrospective date, subject to the exceptions and recording of reasons contemplated in Jankiraman.
State of Haryana v. O.P. Gupta — (1996) 7 SCC 533 Referred to in conjunction with other precedents; the opinion cites this case as part of the jurisprudential background discussed in the Division Bench decision in Ram Sukhpal Singh. The Court referred to this decision as one of the authorities considered in Ram Sukhpal Singh which influenced the Court's view on entitlement to notional benefits in cases where denial of promotion was not the employee's fault.
Union of India v. Shri Ram Sukhpal Singh — WA No. 6 of 2014 (Division Bench decision) The Division Bench referred to the ratio in K.V. Jankiraman and O.P. Gupta and applied those principles to a factual situation where a writ petitioner was not allowed to work in a higher post through no fault and considerations on entitlement to arrears/benefits were discussed. The petitioner relied on this Division Bench decision and the present Court treated it as covering the legal position, applying the reasoning to conclude that notional promotion and seniority carried with them requirement of notional pay fixation and consequential re-fixation across cadres.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by reviewing the factual matrix and the orders passed in earlier rounds of litigation. It noted that:

  1. The earlier Single Judge had found that the petitioner's promotion was withheld only because proceedings had been initiated against him and that no final decision had been taken to deny promotion. That led to a direction to re-examine and ultimately to notional promotion and seniority from the date applicable to his batch-mates.
  2. The Division Bench dismissed the respondents' appeal, observing that absent any rules or norms that a severe reprimand would strip promotional benefits, the Single Judge's order was justified.
  3. Post-judgment, the respondents refixed seniority w.e.f. 22.01.1997 but did not grant notional fixation of pay; later notional promotions to subsequent cadres were recorded without notional pay.
  4. The respondents asserted compliance, citing the order dated 31.10.2013 and payment of arrears (Rs. 6,32,051 credited on 29.09.2014). The petitioner challenged that this did not fully implement reliefs, particularly the notional fixation of pay in the Assistant Commandant scale w.e.f. 22.01.1997 and consequential refixation in later cadres.
  5. The Court relied on the Division Bench decision in Ram Sukhpal Singh which in turn applied the ratio in Union of India v. K.V. Jankiraman and other authorities. The Jankiraman principle—stated in the opinion—permits salary and benefits of the higher post to be awarded where an employee, kept away through no fault, is exonerated; it also recognizes limited circumstances where arrears may be withheld but requires recorded reasons for denial.
  6. Given the concluded findings that the petitioner was denied promotion through no fault, the Court found that the direction for notional promotion and fixing of seniority "carried inherently the requirement of fixation of scale pay" from 22.01.1997 and that further notional fixation of pay in subsequent cadres should follow, applying the legal principles from the cited authorities.

The Court limited its reasoning to the facts and authorities discussed in the opinion: it held that the factual conclusions from earlier rounds and the applicable precedents justified notional pay fixation and consequential corrections.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed in terms of the reliefs prayed for.

Direct consequences and directions:

  • The respondents are directed to carry out the corresponding modifications and take all necessary corrective steps to give effect to the reliefs (including notional fixation of pay w.e.f. 22.01.1997 and consequential re-fixation across cadres) at the earliest, preferably within 60 days from the date of the order.
  • No costs were awarded by the Court ("No costs.").

Implications beyond the parties: The opinion does not assert the creation of a new legal precedent beyond application of existing authorities (K.V. Jankiraman, State of Haryana v. O.P. Gupta and the Division Bench decision in Ram Sukhpal Singh) to the facts of this case. The practical effect is to require the respondents to implement notional pay fixation and consequential corrections for this petitioner as ordered.

Show all summary ...

Dinesh Maheshwari, C.J:— The petitioner, at present said to be working as Commandant, H.Q 27 Sector, Manipur with the respondent-Assam Rifles is in third round of litigation by way of this writ petition on his claim for promotion and consequential benefits; and has prayed for the following reliefs in this petition:—

“In the premises aforesaid, it is therefore prayed that Your Lordship's may be pleased to consider this application, admit the same, call for the records of the case and Issue Rule nisi upon the respondents as to why a writ of like nature should not issue directing and/or commanding the respondents;

(i) to re-fix the pay of the petitioner at least on notional basis taking his scale of pay to the cadre of Asst. Commandant Rs. 8000-275-13500 as on 22.01.1997 and corresponding re-fixation of his scale of pay to the cadre of Deputy Commandant as on 01.04.2004 and to the cadre of 2IC as on 01.04.2008 in the light of the judgment and order dated 23.03.2010, passed in W.P (C) No. 312 (SH) 2006.

(ii) to modify the impugned statement of fixation of pay as on 01.08.2006 (Annexure-8) after fixation of pay of the petitioner w.e.f 22.01.1997 in the cadre of Assistant Commandant;

(iii) to modify the impugned Part-II order No. ARTC&S/22/2011 dated 04.06.2011 (Annexure-9) as well as impugned Part II order No. ARTC&S/21/2011 dated 26.05.2011 communicated vide impugned letter No. I.36011.A-37.II/1868 dated 07.06.2011 in the light of prayer No.(i).

Cause or causes being shown and upon hearing the parties be pleased to make the Rule absolute and/or pass such other or further order(s) as Your Lordships may deem fit and proper.

Pending hearing of the Rule, be pleased to observe that pendency of this case shall not debar the respondents from considering prayer of the petitioner.

And for this act of kindness, the petitioner is duty bound shall ever pray.”

2. The background aspects, so far relevant for the present purpose are that the petitioner was enrolled as Rifleman in Assam Rifles on 31.10.1977 In the year 1995, he applied for promotion to the post of Assistant Commandant and was selected for the Departmental Promotion Committee [‘DPC’]. In the DPC held in the month of August 1996, total 9 (nine) candidates including the petitioner were selected for the post of Assistant Commandant and they were sent for training which was completed on 20.11.1996 However, later on, Piping Ceremony was held only for 7 (seven) of the selected candidates and the petitioner was left out. It further appears from the record that the petitioner was not promoted because of an allegation against him of having made a claim for TA/DA without attaching the movement order. The petitioner approached the Shillong Bench of Gauhati High Court, then exercising jurisdiction in the matter, by way of a writ petition, being WP (C) No. 209 (SH) 2001, stating the grievance against denial of promotion. The said writ petition was considered and allowed by a Single Judge on 07.04.2003 with the following findings and observations:—

“8. In the instant case the petitioner's promotion was not granted only on the ground that the proceedings against him have been initiated. No final decision has been made so as to deprive the petitioner of his promotion for which he has already been selected.

9. For the aforesaid reasons and in view of the decision rendered by the Apex Court in the case of State of Madhya Pradesh v. Bani Singh (supra), I disposed of this writ petition with a direction that the respondents authority namely respondent No. 2 shall re-examine the case of the petitioner in the light of the above observations and the decision of the Apex Court, and, on proper consideration of the matter shall pass appropriate orders for granting of promotion to the petitioner on the basis of his selection by the DPC. This shall be done within a period of two months from the date a copy of this order is served on the respondent No. 2.”

3. After passing of the said order, the petitioner was granted promotion to the post of Assistant Commandant w.e.f 01.08.2006 by an order of the even date. The petitioner again approached the jurisdictional High Court by way of WP (C) No. 312 (SH) 2006 seeking the relief of grant of promotion to the post of Assistant Commandant w.e.f 22.01.1997, the date of promotion of his 7 (seven) batch-mates. The said writ petition was also allowed by a Single Judge of the High Court with the following observations, findings and directions:—

“17. The respondents now want to say that the petitioner is entitled to have the benefit of promotion only prospectively w.e.f 1.8.2006 and he cannot be considered for retrospective promotion. But when the basis for appointment/promotion of the petitioner is the common recommendation made in August 1996 to the petitioner and others in his batch (who were promoted in January 1997), it is difficult to accept the respondents' contention that the petitioner is entitled to promotion/appointment only prospectively from 1.8.2006 No legal reason could be cited by the respondents to deny retrospective appointment benefit to the petitioner and this is found to be an unfair denial by the respondents.

18. In view of the above discussion and conclusion, I am of the considered opinion that the petitioner is entitled to retrospective benefit of appointment to the cadre of Assistant Commandant from the time when his batch mates who were appointed as Assistant Commandants in pursuant to the common recommendation made by the DPC in August 1996. But at this stage only a notional exercise is possible.

19. Accordingly the respondents are directed to give notional promotion to the petitioner from the date of the promotion of his batch mates and grant him benefit of seniority on the basis of such retrospective notional promotion. Further promotion to the cadre of Deputy Commandant be also considered on the basis of retrospective appointment to the cadre of Assistant Commandant, in accordance with the norms in force, by convening, if necessary, a review DPC for the said purpose. Obviously the suitability and the other criteria for promotion to the Deputy Commandant may kept in mind, at the time of considering promotion to the cadre of Deputy Commandant. It is ordered accordingly.”

4. The present respondents preferred an intra-court appeal, being WA No. 20 (SH) 2010, that was also considered and dismissed by a Division Bench of the jurisdictional High Court with the following observations and findings:—

“In our considered opinion, in absence of any rules, norms, guidelines which provide that punishment of severe reprimand would denude an incumbent from getting the benefits of promotion, it would not be possible for the High Court to hold that the appellants could justify its action in granting the promotion to the petitioner with effect from 1.8.2006

After hearing the learned counsel for the parties, we are of the considered opinion that the learned Single Judge was absolutely justified in allowing the petition and granting the relief in favour of the petitioner. As on the merits, we do not find any scope for interference in the matter, condonation of delay or grant of stay or any such other temporary relief in favour of the appellants, would be of no use, the interim applications are rejected and the appeal is also dismissed.”

5. After passing of the orders aforesaid, the respondents re-fixed the seniority of petitioner in the cadre of Assistant Commandant w.e.f 22.01.1997 in place of 01.08.2006 but the benefit of notional fixation of pay was not extended to him. Thereafter, on 21.02.2011, the petitioner was granted notional promotion to the rank of Deputy Commandant w.e.f 01.04.2004 and to the rank of 2IC w.e.f 01.04.2008 but again without the benefit of notional fixation of pay in the relevant and appropriate scale in the respective cadres. The petitioner made representations but the respondents took the stand that he had already been re-fixed as Assistant Commandant w.e.f 22.01.1997 and that he was not entitled to any arrears of pay and allowances. Hence, the present petition.

6. The respondents have taken the stand in their counter affidavit that necessary compliance of the orders passed by the Court has been carried out and necessary payments have also been made to the petitioner. It is, inter alia, stated in the additional affidavit dated 21.10.2016 filed on behalf of the respondents as under:—

“3. That in compliance of the Judgment and Order dated 23.03.2010 passed by the Hon'ble High Court in WP (C) No. 312 (SH) of 2006 by the Hon'ble Single Judge of the Gauhati High Court, Shillong Bench, the Col (A) on behalf of Directorate General of Assam Rifles with the approval of Ministry of Home Affairs vide Order No. A/Offr/Pay & Allce/2013/567 dated 31.10.2013 had refixed the seniority of the petitioner as Assistant Commandant with effect from 22.01.1997 instant of 01.08.2006 in pre-revised pay scale of Rs. 8000-275-13750/- per month. Further, the officer has been notionally promoted to the rank of Deputy Commandant with effect from 01.04.2004 in the pre-revised scale of pay Rs. 10000-325-15200/- per month and to the rank of 2IC with effect from 01.04.2008 in the revised scale of pay Rs. 15600-39100 with Grade Pay Rs. 7600/- alongwith his batch mates as per his seniority without effecting pay and allowances vide HQ DGAR sig No. A1792 dated 21.02.2011

(Copy of the order dated 31.10.2013 is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure 1).

4. That it is stated that the Petitioners pay has been refixed in the pre-revised scale of Rs. 10,000-325-15,200/- per month with effect from 01.08.2006 for the rank of Deputy Commandant and in revised scale pay of Rs. 15600-39100 with Grade Pay Rs. 7600/- per month with effect from 22.01.2011 for the rank of 2IC and a sum of Rs. 6,32,051 (Rupees Six Lakhs Thirty Two Thousand and Fifty One) only has been paid to the Petitioner as arrears from the date of assumption of his rank i.e w.e.f 01.01.2006 to 31.03.2013 for the Deputy Commandant. The amount has already credited into the Petitioners salary account on 29.09.2014

Further, it is stated that a fresh IPS was prepared from 31.10.2013 which was also verified by the Assistant Accounts officer of Pay & Account (Assam Rifles), MHA Shillong. As such the Petitioners grievances also have been addressed by the Order dated 31.10.2013 and the cause of action no longer survives in the instant case.

(Copy of the Letter dated 29.09.2014 is annexed herewith and marked as Annexure 2)

5. That this affidavit is filed for the purpose of declaring that the directions passed by the Hon'ble Court in WP (C) No. 312 (SH)/2006 has been duly complied with by the Respondents Assam Rifles as well as Union of India and the fact that on passing of the Order dated 31.10.2013, the grievances of the Petitioner in the instant writ petition has been duly addressed to by the Respondent authority.”

7. Learned counsel for the petitioner has strenuously argued that the respondents have not carried out adequate compliance of the orders passed by the Court inasmuch as, the petitioner has wrongly been denied the benefits of notional fixation of pay in the cadre of Assistant Commandant w.e.f 22.01.1997 and consequential re-fixation of pay in other cadres of progression. Learned counsel has, inter alia, referred to a Division Bench decision of this Court in WA No. 6 of 2014: Union of India v. Shri Ram Sukhpal Singh and has submitted that the matter stands covered with the said decision.

8. Learned counsel Shri K Paul appearing for the respondents though has initially attempted to submit that necessary compliance of the orders passed by the Court has been carried out but could not deny the fact that as per the findings and observations of the Court in the earlier rounds of litigation, it is but evident that earlier the petitioner was denied promotion for none of his fault and the Court did not approve of granting him benefit of promotion only w.e.f 01.08.2006 but directed his notional promotion from the date of promotion of his batch-mates and for granting him benefit of seniority and other promotions.

9. In the said case of Ram Sukhpal Singh (supra), this Court referred to the ratio of decisions in the case of Union of India v. K.V Jankiraman: (1991) 4 SCC 109 as also in the case of State of Haryana v. O.P Gupta: (1996) 7 SCC 533 and, inter alia, observed as under:—

“….. Therefore, it is a clear case that the respondent/writ petitioner for his no fault was not allowed to work in the higher post of Commandant from 29.09.2007 till the date of his actual promotion i.e 08.07.2009 The Apex Court in Union of India v. K.V Jankiraman: (1991) 4 SCC 109 held that:

“25. We are not much impressed by the contentions advanced on behalf of the authorities. The normal rule of “no work no pay” is not applicable to cases such as the present one where the employee although he is willing to work is kept away from work by the authorities for no fault of his. This is not a case where the employee remains away from work for his own reasons, although the work is offered to him. It is for this reason that F.R.17(1) will also be inapplicable to such cases.

26. We are, therefore, broadly in agreement with the finding of the Tribunal that when an employee is completely exonerated meaning thereby that he is not found blameworthy in the least and is not visited with the penalty even of censure, he has to be given the benefit of the salary of the higher post along with the other benefits from the date on which he would have normally been promoted but for the disciplinary/criminal proceedings. However, there may be cases where the proceedings, whether disciplinary or criminal, are, for example, delayed at the instance of the employee or the clearance in the disciplinary proceedings or acquittal in the criminal proceedings is with benefit of doubt or on account of non-availability of evidence due to the acts attributable to the employee etc. In such circumstances, the concerned authorities must be vested with the power to decide whether the employee at all deserves any salary for the intervening period and if he does, the extent to which he deserves it. Life being complex, it is not possible to anticipate and enumerate exhaustively all the circumstances under which such consideration may become necessary. To ignore, however, such circumstances when they exist and lay down an inflexible rule that in every case when an employee is exonerated in disciplinary/criminal proceedings he should be entitled to all salary for the intervening period is to undermine discipline in the administration and jeopardize public interests. We are, therefore, unable to agree with the Tribunal that to deny the salary to an employee would in all circumstances be illegal. While, therefore, we do not approve of the said last sentence in the first sub-paragraph after clause (iii) of paragraph 3 of the said Memorandum, viz, “but no arrears of pay shall be payable to him for the period of notional promotion preceding the date of actual promotion”, we direct that in place of the said sentence the following sentence be read in the Memorandum:

“However, whether the officer concerned will be entitled to any arrears of pay for the period of notional promotion preceding the date of actual promotion, and if so to what extent, will be decided by the concerned authority by taking into consideration all the facts and circumstances of the disciplinary proceeding/criminal prosecution. Where the authority denies arrears of salary or part of it, it will record its reasons for doing so.”

10. Faced with the decisions aforesaid as also the concluded findings in the petitioner's case in the earlier rounds of litigation, learned counsel for the respondents frankly submitted that the respondents shall be advised appropriately. This Court is clearly of the view that in the given set of facts and circumstances and particularly in view of the concluded findings in the case of the petitioner, the requirement of notional promotion and fixing of seniority carried inherently the requirement of fixation of scale pay of the petitioner w.e.f 22.01.1997 and for further fixation of pay on notional basis after placement in appropriate scale as applicable at the relevant point of time in all the cadres of progression.

11. For what has been discussed hereinabove, this writ petition is allowed in terms of the reliefs prayed for. The respondents shall carry out the corresponding modifications and take all necessary corrective steps at the earliest, preferably within 60 days from today.

12. No costs.