Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K.L Bhardwaj v. State Of J&K And Others

Jammu and Kashmir High Court
Mar 22, 2018
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion — Tashi Rabstan, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an office communication (PO/Cell/03-04/28193-95 dated 12.02.2004 issued by respondent No.3) to the extent it denied him the benefit of SRO 19 of 1998 and sought a direction to calculate his pension in terms of the Revised Pension Rules (SRO 19 of 1998) along with interest as directed by this Court vide judgment dated 31.05.2001.

The petitioner had been a government employee in the respondent department and had sought grant of the grade of the post of Principal with retrospective effect from 30.03.1981. When that relief was not granted, he filed Writ Petition SWP No. 707/93, which this Court disposed of by judgment dated 31.05.2001 holding the petitioner entitled to the grade from 1981 and directing the respondents to calculate and release the benefit within two months of service of the order.

Allegedly in default of that direction, the petitioner instituted a contempt proceeding (COA(SW) No. 51-C/2002 titled K.L. Bhardwaj v. Vijay Bakaya). That contempt petition was disposed of by an order dated 13.10.2005 which, among other things, stated that because the petitioner had retired on 31.12.1995 he was entitled only to emoluments payable to him on that date and could not claim pensionary benefits by reference to emoluments that became payable after retirement (i.e., on or after 01.01.1996).

The petitioner challenged that finding before the Division Bench by filing an LPA, which was ultimately withdrawn with liberty to pursue appropriate remedies; the Division Bench observed that anything said by the Contempt Court would have no bearing on the remedy that the petitioner might pursue.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a government servant who retired on 31.12.1995 is entitled to the benefits under SRO 19 of 1998 (which, in the opinion, applies to those retired on or after 01.01.1996), on the basis that his effective retirement should be treated as 01.01.1996.
  2. Whether emoluments or benefits that became payable after the date of retirement (including increments, revised pensions or commutation rights effective from or after 01.01.1996) can be used as the basis for calculating retiral benefits for a person who ceased to discharge duties on 31.12.1995.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner contended that although he attained the age of superannuation on 31.12.1995 and relinquished charge on that day (AN), he continued to enjoy the status of a government servant until midnight of 31.12.1995 and therefore must be deemed to have retired with effect from 01.01.1996.
  • Relying on that premise, the petitioner argued he was a retiree w.e.f. 01.01.1996 and thus entitled to the benefits flowing from the Revised Pension Rules issued by SRO 19 of 1998.
  • The petitioner also challenged the contempt court's finding (in the 13.10.2005 order) that addressed entitlement under SRO 19 of 1998, arguing that such a finding was not appropriate in contempt proceedings and sought liberty to pursue appropriate remedies after withdrawing the LPA.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents relied on Rule 226 of the J&K Civil Service Regulations, Vol. I (incorporated by SRO 157 dated 24.03.1976) to contend that retirement of a government employee takes effect from the afternoon of the last day of the month in which the employee attains the age of superannuation; thus the effective date of the petitioner's retirement is 31.12.1995, not 01.01.1996.
  • They pointed out that on the date of retirement (31.12.1995) the petitioner was drawing basic pay of Rs. 6,500/- in the scale 4,500-7,300 and his pension had been fixed/authorized as Rs. 3,230/- based on average emoluments payable on 31.12.1995 in accordance with pension rules operative on that date.
  • The respondents explained that rationalization of pension structure for pre-01.01.1996 pensioners took place by Government Order No. 46-F of 1998 dated 19.01.1998 read with SRO 19 of 1998, and that subsequent fixation/revision and commutation in the petitioner's case had been carried out on the basis of the pension as fixed on 31.12.1995 (e.g., revision to Rs. 8,225/- and commutation as authorized by later orders and office communication dated 01.03.2004).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Principal Accountant General, A.P v. C. Subba Rao (Full Bench, reported as 2005 LAB I.C 1224) Principle that a government servant is entitled only to pay and allowances attachable to the post while discharging duties; increments or other emoluments falling due after cessation of duty (i.e., after retirement) cannot be claimed. Analysis based on Fundamental Rules (F.R. 17, F.R. 24, F.R. 26 and F.R.9(21)(a)). The Court relied on the Full Bench reasoning to support the conclusion that benefits or emoluments that become payable after the date of retirement (even if the next day is the first day of pension) cannot form the basis for grant of retiral benefits; hence the petitioner cannot claim benefits at par with those who retired on or after 01.01.1996.
Order dated 13.10.2005 passed in COA(SW) No. 51-C/2002 (contempt petition) Judicial determination in the contempt proceedings that the petitioner, having retired on 31.12.1995, was entitled only to salary and emoluments payable on that date and could not claim pensionary benefits on the basis of emoluments payable after retirement. The Court treated that earlier order as having already dealt with the issue in detail and noted that its operative observations were consistent with the conclusion reached in the present petition; the present petition was dismissed in line with the reasoning recorded earlier.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by first identifying the statutory framework and administrative orders relied upon:

  • SRO 19 of 1998 amended the Civil Pension (Commutation Rules-Schedule) by inserting Rule 5(bbb), which provides that a government servant who is retired from service on or after 01.01.1996 shall be entitled to commute 40% of his pension payable to him.
  • Government Order No. 46-F of 1998 (dated 19.01.1998) rationalized the pension structure for pre-01.01.1996 pensioners and defined "existing pensioner" and "existing pension" as those drawing or entitled to pension on 31.12.1995 and the basic pension inclusive of commuted pension, respectively.

Applying those instruments to the facts, the Court observed:

  • The petitioner was not an "existing pensioner" on 31.12.1995 because on that date he remained an employee in active government service; the status of "pensioner" arose only on 01.01.1996.
  • Nonetheless, entitlement to pensionary benefits for retiral purposes is governed by the emoluments and rules operative on the date when the employee ceased to discharge duties. The respondents' position—relying on Rule 226 of the J&K CSR Vol. I (incorporated by SRO 157 dated 24.03.1976)—was that retirement takes effect from the afternoon of the last day of the month in which the employee attains the age of superannuation, i.e., 31.12.1995 in this case.
  • The Court accepted the principle articulated by the Full Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Principal Accountant General, A.P v. C. Subba Rao (2005 LAB I.C 1224): Fundamental Rules indicate that a government servant is entitled to pay and allowances only while discharging duties and is not entitled to increments or other emoluments that become payable after he ceases to discharge those duties. Consequently, benefits whose effective date is after the date of retirement cannot be used as the basis for calculating retiral benefits.
  • Given those principles, the Court concluded that the petitioner, having retired on 31.12.1995, was entitled only to salary and pensionary emoluments as were payable on that date; he could not claim the benefits specifically designed for persons retiring on or after 01.01.1996 (i.e., the enhanced commutation entitlement under SRO 19 of 1998) by asserting an effective retirement date of 01.01.1996.
  • The Court also noted that this precise issue had been dealt with earlier in the petitioner’s contempt proceeding by the order dated 13.10.2005, which reached a consistent conclusion and directed that if any amount remained payable on the basis of emoluments as on 31.12.1995 it should be paid within two months; otherwise no further amount would be payable.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition is dismissed as devoid of merit and is dismissed along with connected miscellaneous petitions.

Implications:

  • The direct practical consequence of the holding is that the petitioner is not entitled to have his pensionary benefits recalculated by reference to emoluments or rules that became effective on or after 01.01.1996 (i.e., the benefits under SRO 19 of 1998 available to those retired on or after 01.01.1996), because his effective cessation of duty is recorded as 31.12.1995.
  • The Court reaffirmed that the basis for calculation of retiral benefits is the emoluments and pension rules applicable on the date the employee ceases to discharge duties; benefits that accrue only after retirement cannot be claimed retroactively as the basis for calculating retiral entitlements.
  • No new legal principle or departure from existing law was announced; the Court applied existing administrative orders and the precedent cited (the Andhra Pradesh Full Bench decision) to the facts and disposed of the petition accordingly.
Show all summary ...

Tashi Rabstan, J.:— Through the medium of instant petition, petitioner is seeking quashment of PO/Cell/03-04/28193-95 dated 12.02.2004 issued by respondent No. 3 to the extent it denies the benefit of SRO 19 of 1998 to the petitioner and also a direction to the respondents to calculate the pension of the petitioner in terms of Revised Pension Rules issued vide SRO 19 of 1998 dated 01.12.1998 and accord all the benefits to the petitioner flowing therefrom along with interest @ 12% per annum as directed by this Court vide judgment dated 31.05.2001

2. The case of the petitioner is that he was serving in respondent Department. For grant of benefit of grade of the post of Principal w.e.f 30.03.1981 at par with similarly situated persons, he approached the respondents. However, when respondents did not grant him the benefit of the grade at par with similarly situated persons, he filed a writ petition, bearing SWP No. 707/93, which was disposed of vide judgment dated 31.05.2001, whereby this Court held the petitioner entitled to the grant of benefit of the grade of the post of Principal w.e.f 1981 when his juniors were given the grade and a direction was issued to calculate the said benefit and release the same within a period of two months from the date a copy of the said order passed by this Court was served upon the respondents.

3. When nothing was done, petitioner filed a contempt, petition bearing COA(SW) No. 51-C/2002 titled K.L Bhardwaj v. Vijay Bakaya, seeking a direction to the respondents to comply with the judgment dated 31.05.2001 passed in SWP No. 707/93. The said contempt petition came to be disposed of vide order dated 13.10.2005 The operative part of the order dated 13.10.2005 reads as under:—

“In the present case, petitioner retired on 31.12.1995 and was entitled to the salary and other service emoluments as were payable to him on the said date though he become pensioner w.e.f 01.01.1996 Any emoluments which became payable after the date of retirement or when he ceases to be a government servant, cannot be made the basis for grant of retiral benefit even if the said day follows the date of retirement or be the first day of his retirement. Therefore, by no stretch of imagination, petitioner can be said to be entitled to seek the pensionary benefits at par with those who retired on 1.1.1996 or thereafter.

In view of the above, this contempt petition is disposed of with the direction that if the petitioner has been paid all pensionary benefits by treating his emoluments as were payable to him on 31.12.1995, he is not entitled to any other amount. However, if anything remains payable on that basis, the same may be paid and released in his favour within a period of two months.”

4. Learned counsel for the petitioner contends that while disposing of the contempt petition, this Court had returned a finding about the entitlement of the petitioner to claim the retiral and other service emoluments in terms of SRO 19, which was not permissible under contempt jurisdiction, as such, being aggrieved of the said finding, the petitioner had approached the Division Bench of this Court with an LPA, which was finally withdrawn by the petitioner with a liberty to take recourse to an appropriate remedy available to him under the law to get adjudicated the issue with regard to the entitlement of the petitioner to seek pensionary benefits w.e.f 01.01.1996 The Division Bench of this Court has further observed that anything said by the Contempt Court shall have no bearing on any remedy to be taken by the petitioner herein, which would otherwise proceed uninfluenced by any observation or finding returned in order dated 13.10.2005

5. Learned counsel for the petitioner further contends that the petitioner, who admittedly attained the superannuation on 31.12.1995, continued to enjoy the status of a government servant till midnight of 31.12.1995 and as such, the date of retirement in case of the petitioner, in any case, is to be taken as 01.01.1996 and not as 31.12.1995 The petitioner, having completed the age of superannuation on 31.12.1995 and relinquished the charge of his office on 31.12.1995 (AN), shall be deemed to have effectively retired from service w.e.f 01.01.1996 and as such, being a retiree w.e.f 01.01.1996, he is entitled to the benefit as accrued from the Revised Rules issued vide SRO 19 of 1998.

6. Respondents have filed the objections, contending therein that as per Rule 226 of the J&K CSR Vol-I, incorporated vide Finance Department's Notification issued under SRO 157 dated 24.03.1976, the retirement of the government employee in service on 01.01.1976 or appointed on or after that date, shall take effect from afternoon of last day of month, in which the employee concerned attains the age of superannuation and hence the contention of the petitioner that his retirement commenced from 01.01.1996 is not correct. It is further contended that at the time of retirement, i.e 31.12.1995, the petitioner was drawing and disbursing the basic pay of Rs. 6500/- in the scale of 4500-7300 and his pension was, accordingly, fixed/authorised as Rs. 3230/- on the basis of average emoluments drawn for the last ten months as per the Pension Rules in force on 31.12.1995 The rationalization of pension structure for pre 01.01.1996 pensioners took place and as per Govt. Order No. 46-F of 1998 dated 19.01.1998 read with SRO-19 dated 19.01.1998, the basic pension of the petitioner was revised from 3230/- to 8225/-. Besides, the commuted value of the pension (one third of basic pension) was also authorised in favour of petitioner on the basis of pension fixed, i.e Rs. 3230/- as on 31.12.1995, as per Pension Rules authorised in terms of Govt. Order No. 90-F/89-F of 2001 dated 28.03.2001 and SRO 122 dated 28.03.2001 vide office letter No. PPO Cell/2003-04/28193-95 dated 01.03.2004

7. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

8. In terms of SRO 19 of 1998 dated 19.01.1998, the provisions of the J&K Civil Service Regulations, 1956 were amended. The following was inserted as Rule 5(bbb) in Civil Pension (Commutation Rules-Schedule):

“5(bbb) a Govt. servant who is retired from service on or after 01.01.1996 shall be entitled to commute 40% of his pension payable to him.”

9. By another Govt. Order No. 46-F of 1998 dated 19.01.1998, the Government ordered the rationalization of pension structure for the pre 01.01.1996 pensioner/family pensioners wherein the definition of existing pensioners as well as existing pension was also given. It provided in the following manner:

“2. In these orders:—

a) “Existing pensioner “and, existing family pensioners will mean a pensioner who was drawing/entitled to pension/family pension on 31.12.1995

b) “existing pension” will mean the basic pension inclusive of commuted pension of pension, if any, due on 31.12.1995”

10. From the above Govt. Order, it is evident that the petitioner, in no case, falls under the category of pre 01.01.1996 pensioner as his status as on 31.12.1995 was not that of the pensioner but, as contended by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the petitioner was an employee under active Government service till 31.12.1995 (AN) and on 31.12.1995, he was discharging his duties and thus, he became pensioner only on 01.01.1996 In that view of matter, by no stretch of imagination, it can be presumed that the petitioner was an existing pensioner as on 31.12.1995 as described under Govt. Order No. 46-F of 1998 dated 19.01.1998 It is also contended that the petitioner being a retiree on 01.01.1996, he is entitled to the benefit flowing from SRO 19 of 1998 and, as such, entitled to pensionary benefits, accordingly. But the contention of learned counsel for the respondents is that petitioner is not entitled to any benefit of emoluments as were payable to the Government servants, who retired on 01.01.1996, as the effective date of his retirement continues to be 31.12.1995 It is admitted by petitioner that he retired on 31.12.1995, but it is argued that he continued to be in service upto mid-night of 31.12.1995 and thus he is deemed to have retired w.e.f 01.01.1996 and thus the emoluments as were payable to Government servants on 01.01.1996 should be made the basis for calculation of his post-retiral benefits.

11. A Full Bench of the Andhra Pradesh High Court in Principal Accountant General, A.P v. C. Subba Rao reported as 2005 LAB I.C 1224, while considering the similar question, whether a Government servant who retired on the last day of the month is entitled to the benefit of annual increment, which falls on the 1st of the next month, held as under:

“As per F.R 17, extracted hereinabove, a Government servant shall begin to draw the pay and allowances attached to his post with effect from the date when he assumes the duties of that post until he ceases to discharge those duties. “Pay” as defined in F.R.9(21)(a) means, the amount drawn monthly by a Government servant which also includes the increment given at an anterior date. Therefore, after retirement, a person will not be entitled to any pay including the increment that may be due from the posterior date. F.R.22 regulates the initial pay of a Government servant who is appointed to a post in time-scale and F.R.24 and F.R.26 regulate the sanction of increment to a Government servant, who is on duty. A reading of various Fundamental Rules extracted hereinabove would show that a person appointed as a Government servant is entitled to pay in time-scale of pay. He is also entitled to draw the increment as per time-scale of pay as a matter of course as long as such Government servant discharges duties of the post and such Government servant shall not be entitled to draw the pay and allowances attached to the post as soon as he ceases to discharge those duties. In other words, as per F.R 17 read with F.Rs.24 and 26 annual increment is given to a Government servant to enable him to discharge duty and draw pay and allowances attached to the post. If such Government servant ceases to discharge duties by any reason say, by reason of attainment of age of superannuation, such Government servant will not be entitled to draw pay and allowances. As a necessary corollary, such employee would not be entitled to any increment if it falls due after the date of retirement, be it on the next day of retirement or sometime thereafter.

12. The petitioner, in the present case, had retired on 31.12.1995 and was entitled to the salary and other service emoluments as were payable to him on the said date, though he become pensioner w.e.f 01.01.1996 Any benefits which became payable after the date of retirement or when he ceases to be a government servant, cannot be made the basis for grant of retiral benefit even if the said day follows the date of retirement or be the first day of his retirement. Therefore, by no stretch of imagination, the petitioner can be said to be entitled to seek the pensionary benefits at par with those who retired on 01.01.1996 or thereafter. In this regard, this Court vide Order dated 13.10.2005 passed in COA (SW) No. 51-A/2002 filed by the petitioner has already elaborately dealt with the issue.

13. That being the situation and in view of the above discussion, I do not find any merit in the petition and the same is accordingly, dismissed along with connected MP(s).