- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Roopa Devi M. v. Cpio & Assistant Commissioner
1. The complainant vide her RTI application sought information on 12 points seeking details in respect of Mr. Devappa Naik (Supt. of Customs - Airport, Bangalore); regarding details of his present posting, official income, declared assets and liabilities, pending investigation, present residential address, present EMIs made towards discharge of liabilities, departmental action taken against him and related issues.
2. The CPIO vide its letter dated 05.02.2016, denied information under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, 2005. Dissatisfied by the reply of the CPIO, the complainant approached the Commission.
Hearing:
Facts emerging during the hearing:
3. The following were present:
Complainant: Ms. Roopadevi M. (M:9743072044) alongwith Mr. Kriplani (M: 9845024807) through VC;
Respondent: Mr. D. Anil, Additional Commissioner of Customs (M: 9900063930) through VC;
4. The complainant reiterated the contents of her RTI application and stated that due to denial of information by the CPIO, they filed a complaint before the Commission. On being queried as to why they did not file first appeal, it was alleged that even the FAA is conniving with other officials and due to lack of trust in the institution of FAA, a complaint was filed before the Commission. The respondent explained that the information sought by the complainant related to personal information which had no relationship to any public activity or interest and would cause unwarranted invasion of the privacy of the individual, hence it was denied under Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act, 2005. The complainant also submitted that they had filed a complaint with the CVC as the officer involved in this case had demanded bribe from the complainant directly which was video recorded. The recording had also been shared with the CVC. During hearing, the Commission was informed that CVC had sought additional details from the complainant to substantiate their claim and therefore, they had resorted to RTI. The respondent further alleged that the video recording of seeking bribe from the complainant is a photoshopped version and contested its authenticity.
5. The respondent further referred to the judgment pronounced by Hon'ble Supreme Court in Girish Ramchandra Deshpande v. Central Information Commission reported as (2013) 1 SCC 212 which held as under:—
“13. We are in agreement with the CIC and the courts below that the details called for by the Petitioner i.e copies of all memos issued to the third Respondent, show cause notices and orders of censure/punishment etc. are qualified to be personal information as defined in Clause (j) of Section 8(1) of the RTI Act. The performance of an employee/officer in an organization is primarily a matter between the employee and the employer and normally those aspects are governed by the service rules which fall under the expression “personal information”, the disclosure of which has no relationship to any public activity or public interest. On the other hand, the disclosure of which would cause unwarranted invasion of privacy of that individual. Of course, in a given case, if the Central Public Information Officer or the State Public Information Officer of the Appellate Authority is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies the disclosure of such information, appropriate orders could be passed but the Petitioner cannot claim those details as a matter of right.”
6. Further, the Commission referred to judgments quoted below:
7. The Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the case of Union Public Service Commission v. Dr. Mahesh Mangalat (Date of Decision: 17 March, 2015) (W.P(C) No. 7431/2011) had held:—
“18. Prior to the enactment of the RTI Act, access to any information pertaining to public authorities was correlated to the locus standi of the requestor. In other words, it was necessary for the information-seeker to show why he/she wanted the information before a decision could be made to give or not to give the information sought by him. With the enactment of the RTI Act this requirement has been changed drastically. The present Act abolishes the concept of locus standi as under section 6(2) of the RTI Act no reasons need to be given for seeking information. However, this restriction on disclosure of reasons cannot be misconstrued to mean that any information pertaining to a public authority or its employees is public information.
19. It is a settled law that for seeking personal information regarding any employee of the public authority the applicant must disclose a ‘sustainable public interest’. Even Section 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act was enacted to ensure that all information furnished to public authorities including personal information is not given free access to. As per this Section unless the CPIO or the State PIO or the appellate authority, as the case may be, is satisfied that the larger public interest justifies, the disclosure of any such information that invades the privacy of an individual is not permissible.”
8. The complainant contested it on the ground that the details were required to substantiate their allegations before the investigating agency. However, no larger public interest could be justified or established which outweighs the harm to the protected interests. The respondent consistently argued that as the matter is being investigated by the CVC, all the allegations made by the complainant can be verified by the investigating agency as per law.
DECISION
9. In the light of the facts of the case and the submissions made by both the parties, it is evident that the CPIO had given a response in the matter. As stated by the complainant the matter is already under investigation with the CVC, therefore keeping in view the aforesaid judgment cited above, no intervention of the Commission is warranted in the matter. The personal information and other details can be sought by the investigating agency directly, if so required.
10. The complaint stands disposed accordingly.
Alert