- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ramesh Chandra Gupta v. Union Of India
Tribunal Opinion Summary: Ramesh Chandra Gupta v. Union of India & Ors. (Order by Administrative Member Anil Kumar)
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant, Ramesh Chandra Gupta, retired on 31.01.2008. Prior to retirement he had been served with a charge-sheet dated 07.09.2006. That charge-sheet was quashed and set aside by this Bench of the Tribunal by order dated 20.05.2009 in O.A. No. 304/2007. Despite quashing, the applicant's terminal benefits were not paid immediately; they were paid only in August 2011. The applicant alleged a delay exceeding three years in payment of his retiral dues and filed the present Original Application seeking, inter alia:
- quashing of the order annexure A-1;
- direction to respondents to pay interest @ 12% on delayed payment of an asserted total of Rs. 2,460,898/- until actual payment;
- other consequential reliefs and costs.
The applicant submitted a chart (Annexure A/3; representation dated 02.09.2011) setting out amounts claimed, due dates, actual payment dates and a calculation of interest (total interest claimed: Rs. 791,877 as per the chart). The respondents filed a reply and defended the refusal to pay interest on certain heads of retirement dues.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the applicant is entitled to interest on delayed payment of retirement dues other than gratuity (i.e., on commutation of pension, leave encashment, pay/salary arrears) in view of the quashing of the charge-sheet.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The charge-sheet that prevented timely payment was quashed by the Tribunal on 20.05.2009, yet terminal benefits were paid only in August 2011, constituting substantial delay.
- The applicant submitted a chart (Annexure A/3) detailing amounts, due dates (with a 3-month margin), actual payment dates, delay in months and interest calculation totaling Rs. 791,877.
- The applicant relied on precedent (Bal Swarup Agarwal; Vijay L. Mehrotra; O.P. Gupta; Smt. Raman Munjal) to support entitlement to interest on delayed payments.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents admitted the charge-sheet was quashed but contended the applicant is not entitled to interest on delayed payment of leave encashment and commutation of pension.
- For gratuity, respondents relied on Rule 68 of the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules, 1972 and the Department of Pension & Pensioners' Welfare OM dated 29.04.2002, which permit allowance of the prevalent GPF interest rate where delay is due to judicial/departmental proceedings.
- For leave encashment, respondents relied on OM dated 05.10.1999 (Annexure R/2) stating there is no provision under CCS (Leave) Rules for payment of interest on delayed payment.
- For commutation, respondents cited Rule 4 of the Central Civil Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981 (which restricts commutation where departmental/judicial proceedings, as per Rule 9 of the Pension Rules, are pending) to justify non-payment while proceedings were pending.
- The respondents also stated that the applicant's representation had been decided and communicated, and therefore urged dismissal of the Original Application with costs.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bal Swarup Agarwal v. Union of India & Ors. (OA No. 208/1999) — C.A.T., Jaipur Bench, order dated 23.05.2001 | Held that applicant is entitled to interest on delayed payment of commuted value of pension at the rate of 12% p.a., subject to adjustments as per rules (para 18 of the cited order). | The Tribunal relied on this decision to support the proposition that interest is payable on delayed commuted pension and adopted the 12% rate for non-gratuity delayed payments. |
| Vijay L. Mehrotra v. State of U.P. & Ors. [JT 2000 (5) SC 171] | Supreme Court emphasised that retiral benefits should be paid on retirement or soon thereafter and in that case directed payment of simple interest at 18% from date of retirement until date of payment (paras 3–4). | The Tribunal cited the case as authority recognising entitlement to interest on delayed retiral dues (including leave encashment, commuted pension, arrears), supporting payment of interest for delays. |
| O.P. Gupta v. Union of India & Ors. [AIR 1987 SC 2257] | Supreme Court noted the settled practice of directing payment of interest at 12% on delayed payment of pension (para 23). | The Tribunal treated this decision as endorsing 12% as a settled practice and used it to justify granting interest at 12% for non-gratuity delayed payments. |
| Smt. Raman Munjal v. Govt. of NCT (OA No. 1014/2011) — C.A.T., Principal Bench, order dated 19.07.2011 | Followed the law in Vijay L. Mehrotra and allowed interest on delayed payment of leave encashment. | The Tribunal cited this CAT Principal Bench decision as precedential support for awarding interest on delayed leave encashment. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Tribunal proceeded through the following steps of analysis, as recorded in the opinion:
- Admitted facts: the applicant retired on 31.01.2008 and had been served a charge-sheet dated 07.09.2006 which prevented immediate payment of certain retiral benefits; that charge-sheet was quashed on 20.05.2009 by this Bench (OA No. 304/2007).
- Identified the narrow controversy before it as whether the applicant is entitled to interest on delayed payment of retirement dues other than gratuity (para 13).
- Examined the jurisprudence cited by the applicant:
- Bal Swarup Agarwal: held entitlement to interest (12%) on delayed commuted pension (para 14).
- Vijay L. Mehrotra: Supreme Court emphasised expectation of timely payment of retiral benefits and in that case directed interest (18%) for extended delay (paras 15).
- O.P. Gupta: Supreme Court recognised settled practice of awarding interest at 12% on delayed pension (para 16).
- Smt. Raman Munjal: CAT Principal Bench followed Mehrotra and allowed interest for delayed leave encashment (para 17).
- Evaluated respondents' submissions regarding applicable rules and OMs:
- Respondents relied on Rule 68, CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and the DoP&PW OM dated 29.04.2002 for gratuity (allowing GPF rate where delay is due to judicial/departmental proceedings).
- Respondents relied on OM dated 05.10.1999 that CCS (Leave) Rules contain no provision for interest on delayed leave encashment.
- For commutation, respondents invoked Rule 4 of Central Civil Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981, which restricts commutation during the pendency of departmental or judicial proceedings (thus explaining non-payment while proceedings were pending).
- Found that the charge-sheet preventing payment had been quashed and that the respondents had not rebutted the applicant's chart (Annexure A/3) setting out due dates, payment dates and interest calculations (para 18–19).
- Concluded, on the basis of the cited precedents and the absence of rebuttal to the chart, that the applicant was entitled to interest on delayed payments. The Tribunal applied a two-fold approach to rates:
- Gratuity: interest to be paid at the prevalent interest rate of GPF (consistent with Rule 68 and Departmental OM rationale).
- All other delayed payments: simple interest at 12% per annum (drawing on Bal Swarup Agarwal, O.P. Gupta and related authorities endorsing 12% as settled practice).
- Directed that interest be calculated by the respondents from the dates provided by the applicant in his chart, since those dates were neither contradicted in respondents' written reply nor during arguments (para 19).
- Finally, the Tribunal ordered payment of the interest within three months from receipt of a copy of the order (para 20) and disposed of the Original Application with no order as to costs (para 21).
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Original Application is disposed of with directions that the respondents shall pay interest on delayed retiral payments as specified.
Direct consequences ordered by the Tribunal:
- Respondents are directed to pay interest on delayed gratuity at the prevalent interest rate of GPF.
- Respondents are directed to pay simple interest at the rate of 12% per annum on all other delayed retirement payments (commutation, leave encashment, pay/salary on selection grade, etc.).
- The interest must be calculated from the dates supplied by the applicant in his chart (Annexure A/3), because those dates were not rebutted by respondents.
- The respondents must make the interest payments within three months from receipt of a copy of the order.
- The Original Application is disposed of with no order as to costs.
Implications beyond the parties: The Tribunal relied on existing Supreme Court and CAT precedents to apply established practice (noting 12% as a settled practice for pension-related delays and recognising other authorities). The order applies settled principles to the facts but does not purport to create a new legal precedent; its effect is the directed payment to the applicant in this case.
CORAM HONBLE MR. ANIL KUMAR, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER Ramesh Chandra Gupta S/o Shri Buddha Lal Gupta, aged around 64 years, R/o Flat No. 401, E-2 Kackar Golden Enclave, Kanti Chandra Road, Banipark, Jaipur (Rajasthan). Applicant Mr. Amit Mathur, counsel for applicant. VERSUS
1. The Union of India through its Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, North Block, New Delhi.
2. Central Board of Direct Taxes, North Block, New Delhi through its Chairman.
3. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Revenue Building, Jan Path, Jaipur. Respondents Mr. Gaurav Jain, counsel for respondents. ORDER (ORAL) The applicant has filed the present Original Application claiming for the following reliefs: - (I). The order annexure A-1 may kindly be quashed and set aside.
(II). The respondents may be directed to make the payment of interest @ 12% on the delayed payment of amount of Rs. 24,60,898/-. The applicant is entitled for the aforesaid payment of interest till the actual payment has been made by the respondents.
(III). Any other order or direction which deem fit and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case may also be passed in favour of the applicant.
(IV). Cost of this original application also may be awarded in favour of the applicant.
2. Brief facts of the case, as stated by the learned counsel for the applicant, are that the applicant retired on 31.01.2008. At the time of retirement, a charge-sheet was pending against the applicant; which was quashed and set aside by this Bench of the Tribunal vide order dated 20th May, 2009 in O.A. No. 304/2007 - Ramesh Chandra Gupta vs. Union of India & Anr.- (Annexure A/2). Despite the quashing of the charge-sheet, the applicant was not paid terminal benefits. He was paid his terminal benefits only in the month of August, 2011. Thus, there was a delay of more than three years on the part of the respondents in making payments, but the applicant was disallowed the payment of interest over the delayed payments. The applicant has filed a chart indicating the delayed payments and calculation of interest along with his representation dated 02.09.2011 (Annexure A/3) submitted to the Chairman, Central Board of Direct Taxes, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, North Block, New Delhi. This chart is reproduced as below: - Sr. No. Item Amount (In Rs.) Due date of payment even after margin of 3 months Date on which paid Delay in months Interest @ 12% p.a. (In Rs.)
1. Gratuity (a) As per old scale 350000 30.04.08 15.07.11 38 133000 (b) Additional amount on account of 6th pay commission 554035 30.11.08 29.08.11 33 182831
2. Commutation of Pension (a) As per old scale 534685 30.04.08 15.07.11 38 203180 (b) Additional amount on account of 6th pay commission 515436 30.11.08 29.08.11 33 170094
3 Leave encashment 142460 30.11.08 28.08.10 21 29916
4 Pay and salary on granting of selection grade (promotion as Additional Commissioner) 364282 30.11.08 04.08.10 20 72856 Total 2460898 791877
3. Therefore, learned counsel for the applicant submitted that the respondents may be directed to make the payment of interest @ 12% on the delayed payment till the actual payment is made by the respondents.
4. In support of his averments, learned counsel for the applicant referred to the following case law: -
(i). Bal Swarup Agarwal vs. Union of India & Ors. (OA No. 208/1999) date of order 23.05.2001 C.A.T., Jaipur Bench.
(ii). Vijay L. Mehrotra vs. State of U.P. & Ors. [reported in JT 2000 (5) SC 171].
(iii). O.P. Gupta vs. Union of India and others [reported in AIR 1987 Supreme Court 2257].
(iv). Smt. Raman Munjal vs. Govt. of NCT (OA No. 1014/2011) - date of order 19th July, 2011 C.A.T., Principal Bench, New Delhi.
5. On the contrary, learned counsel for the respondents admitted that vide order dated 20th May, 2009 passed by this Bench of the Tribunal in OA No. 304/2007 - Ramesh Chandra Gupta vs. Union of India & Anr. (supra), the charge-sheet dated 07.09.2006 has been quashed and set aside but the applicant is not entitled for interest on delayed payment of leave encashment and amount of commutation.
6. Learned counsel for the respondents further submitted that the delayed payment of gratuity is covered by Rule 68 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 according to which prevalent interest rate of GPF can be allowed, if delay is on account of judicial / departmental proceedings as mentioned in the Department of Pension and Pensioners Welfare OM dated 29.04.2002 (Annexure R/1).
7. Learned counsel for the respondents also submitted that according to OM dated 05.10.1999 (Annexure R/2), there is no provision under CCS (Leave) Rules for payment of interest on the delayed payment of leave encashment.
8. With regard to delay in payment of commutation of pension, learned counsel for the respondents referred to Rule 4 of Central Civil Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981, which is reproduced as under: - 4. Restriction on commutation of pension - No Government servant against whom departmental or judicial proceedings, as referred to in Rule 9 of the Pension Rules, have been instituted before the date of his retirement, or the pensioner against whom such proceedings are instituted after the date of his retirement, shall be eligible to commute a fraction of his provisional pension authorised under Rule 69 of the Pension Rules or the pension, as the case may be, during the pendency of such proceedings. In view of Rule 4 of Central Civil Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981, since the criminal proceedings were pending against the applicant, the payment was not made.
9. Learned counsel for the respondents further stated that the representation submitted by the applicant was decided and the decision was communicated to the applicant by the respondents. Therefore, he submitted that the Original Application has no merit and it should be dismissed with costs.
10. Heard learned counsel for the parties, perused the documents available on record and the case law referred to by the learned counsel for the applicant.
11. It is admitted between the parties that the applicant retired on 31.01.2008. The applicant was served a charged sheet dated 07.09.2006 prior to his retirement. Therefore, immediately after the retirement, gratuity could not be paid. Similarly, the orders for commutation of pension and leave encashment were not passed by the respondents. However, the charge-sheet dated 07.09.2006 issued by the respondents was quashed and set aside by this Bench of the Tribunal vide its order dated 20th May, 2009 passed in OA No. 304/2007 (Annexure A/2).
12. The respondents in para 5 of their written reply have stated that in the present matter, criminal proceedings were pending against the applicant, therefore, in view of Rule 4 of Central Civil Services (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981, the payment was not made. Learned counsel for the applicant submitted that there was no criminal proceedings pending against the applicant, it was only departmental proceedings initiated after a criminal case registered against the applicant was dropped by the CBI.
13. The short controversy involved in the present Original Application is whether the applicant is entitled for interest on the delayed payment of retirement dues other than gratuity as it is admitted fact that an employee is entitled for interest in case of delayed payment of gratuity.
14. I have gone through the order dated 23.05.2001 passed by this Bench of the Tribunal in the case of Bal Swarup Agarwal vs. Union of India & Ors. (supra), wherein in para 18, this Bench of the Tribunal has held that the applicant shall also be entitled to interest on delayed payment of commuted value of pension at the rate of 12% per annum, subject to adjustment as per rules.
15. In the case of Vijay L. Mehrotra vs. State of U.P. & Ors. (supra), the Honble Supreme Court in para 3 and 4 has as under: - 3. In case of an employee retiring after having rendered service, it is expected that all the payment of the retiral benefits should be paid on the date of retirement or soon thereafter if for some unforeseen circumstances the payments could not be made on the date of retirement.
4. In this case, there is absolutely no reason or justification for not making the payments for months together. We, therefore, direct the respondent to pay to the appellant within 12 weeks from today simple interest at the rate of 18 per cent with effect from the date of her retirement, i.e., 31st August, 1997 till the date of payments. In the case of Vijay L. Mehrotra (supra), the question of payment of interest on account of delayed payment of encashment of leave, arrears of pay, gratuity, commuted pension, detained amount, G.P.F. and G.I.S. was involved.
16. The Honble Supreme Court in the case of O.P. Gupta vs. Union of India and others (supra) in para 23 has held as under: - 23. Normally, this Court, as a settled practice, has been making direction for payment of interest at 12% on delayed payment of pension. There is no reason for us to depart from that practice in the facts of the present case.
17. The Central Administrative Tribunal, Principal Bench, New Delhi in the case of Smt. Raman Munjal vs. Govt. of NCT (supra) following the law laid down by the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Vijay L. Mehrotra (supra) also allowed for granting interest to the applicant on the delayed payment of leave encashment.
18. Thus, in view of the settled law, the applicant is also entitled for interest on the delayed payment. The respondents have not rebutted the chart enclosed by the applicant along with his representation dated 02.09.2011 (Annexure A/3) addressed to the Chairman, Central Board of Direct Taxes, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, New Delhi, with regard to the amount to be paid, due date of payment even after margin of 3 months, date on which payment made, delay in months and the calculation of interest. Therefore, the respondents are directed to make the payment of interest to the applicant on the delayed payment at the following rate: - (i). On delayed payment of Gratuity - at the prevalent interest rate of GPF, and
(ii). On all other delayed payments at simple interest rate of 12% per annum.
19. The payment of interest shall be calculated by the respondents from the date(s) which is given by the applicant in the chart, as quoted in para 2 of this order, since these dates have neither been rebutted by the respondents in their written reply nor during the arguments.
20. The respondents are directed to make the payment of interest to the applicant within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
21. With these observations and directions, the Original Application is disposed of with no order as to costs. (ANIL KUMAR) ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER kumawat
Alert