Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K.S.Sasidharan v. Union of India Ministry of Finance

Central Administrative Tribunal
Mar 16, 2012

HON'BLE Dr K.B.S.RAJAN, JUDICIAL MEMBER The legal issues involved in this case are as under:- (a) When for a particular nature of misconduct, respondents have decided to initiate proceedings under Rule 16 of the CCS(CC&A) Rules, 1965, whether they could be permitted to initiate proceedings under Rule 14 for identical nature of misconduct in respect of the self same sets of facts or otherwise. (b) Whether the respondents could keep the Rule 16 proceedings pending till the superannuation of the applicant and have the same deemed to have been closed without arriving at a logical conclusion on the basis of the records and defence offered by the applicant. (c) Whether the proceedings under Rule 14 could be permissible at the fag end of the service career of the applicant in the facts and circumstance of the case. (d) Whether Judicial Review could be permitted at the threshold stage of the disciplinary proceedings and quash the very charge sheet. Brief facts of the case with terse sufficiency are as under:-

2. The applicant is aggrieved by memorandum dated 25.2.2011 by which he has been proceeded against under Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965. OA 799 /11

3. Briefly stated, the applicant while functioning as Assistant Commissioner and holding charge of Air Cargo Complex, Karipur during the period 11/2005 to 2/2006, countersigned certain bill of entry which according to the respondents, was without following the prescribed procedure. For this reason, initially a memorandum dated 31.8.2010 under Rule 16 was issued to him. This charge memo contained details of three bills of entry No.1099 dated 8.12.2005, 1111 dated 12.12.2005 and 211 dated 30.1.2006 in respect of clearance of certain excise items imported by M/s Prompt Exports and Imports, Calicut. The applicant had furnished his response to the same by Annexure A-2 letter dated 17.9.2010. While this case was pending, Annexure A-3 memo was issued which contained 2 articles of charge, one relating to 63 bills of entry and another 17. The applicant requested for the copies of relied upon documents by Annexure letter dated 10.3.2011 followed by Annexure A-5 reminder dated 8.6.2011 as well as 25.8.2011. While the Annexure A-2 memo as well as Annexure A-1 memo were pending, the applicant superannuated on 30.4.2011. Since no minor penalty proceedings could continue beyond superannuation( as no minor penalty can be imposed after his retirement). By Annexure A-7 order dated 23.5.2011, the respondents had decided to close the minor penalty proceedings initiated against the applicant vide Annexure A-1 charge memo dated 31.8.2010. Thus, what survived thereafter is only the Annexure A-3 charge sheet. The grievance of the applicant is on account of the reason that according to him, the

2 charge memos being the same nature of alleged misconduct (countersigning the bill of entry without following prescribed procedure as per certain order dated 15.3.2004) cannot be proceeded under two different rules, Rule 16 in respect of one and Rule 14 in respect of the other. In addition, the ground of challenge includes that issue of Rule 14 charge memo at the fag end of the career is also illegal. Other grounds have also been specified in the O.A. The applicant, has, OA 799 /11 therefore sought for the following reliefs:

(i) To declare that the disciplinary authority has no power, authority or jurisdiction to initiate proceedings under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 during the pendency of the proceedings already initiated under Rule 16 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, in respect of the same set of facts and allegations and self same charges and hence Annexure A-3 memorandum of Charges are illegal, ultra vires and one issued without authority of law;

(ii)To call for the records leading to Annexure A-3 memorandum dated 25.2.2011 and to set aside the same;

(iii)To issue appropriate direction or order directing the respondents to disburse the retiral benefits legally due to the applicant forthwith without regard to Annexure A-3 which is legally indefensible.

(iv)To issue appropriate direction or order interdicting the respondents from taking further steps pursuant to Annexure A-3 memorandum of Articles of charge;

(v)To grant such other reliefs which this Hon'ble Tribunal deems fit, just and proper in the circumstances of the case.

4. Respondents have contested the O.A. contenting that on account of two cases filed by the CBI correspondingly, two charge memos were issued to the applicant. They are independent of each other as the bills of entry and the importers were different in both the cases. They have also stated that the extent of loss to the Government revenue amounts to Rs.1.60 crores in respect of Article I and Rs.31.94 lakhs in respect of the Article II.

5. The applicant has filed rejoinder in which he has annexed Annexure A-8 and A-9 which are two FIRs referred to by the respondents in their reply. He has OA 799 /11 stated in the rejoinder that finalising the minor penalty proceedings by way of abandoning midway without bringing it to its logical ends is illegal. He has also submitted that the gravamen of the articles of charge relating to Rule 16 proceedings and Rule 14 proceedings is identical in essence, import and content. Without there being any distinguishable features to bring under a different category of misconduct, institution of two proceedings, one under minor penalty proceedings and the other under major penalty proceeding is against the rules.

6. Senior Counsel for the applicant, succinctly referred to the facts of the case and elaborately dealt with the aforesaid legal issues. His contentions in nutshell are as under:- (a) The two Charge Sheets vide Annexure A-3 and A-1 are based on identical sets of facts. Respondents in their counter have not denied the same. (b) Though in respect of Annexure A-3, the number of bills of entry is more, they also include the bills of entry referred to in Annexure A-1 charge sheet which itself vitiates the proceedings. (c) In any event, the nature of misconduct in the said two charges is one and the same, i.e. alleged negligence and alleged violation of the Board circular dated 15-03-2004. (d) When a charge sheet is ex facie illegal, the same is liable to be quashed.

7. Counsel for the applicant also relied upon the following decisions:- (a) 2007)11) SCC 517 OA 799 /11 (b) 1994(28) ATC 306 of Calcutta Bench of the Tribunal.

8. The applicant has at this stage filed a copy of the reply furnished by him to the Disciplinary authority in response to the Rule 14 Charge Sheet, denying the charges and defending his case.

9. Counsel for the respondents invited the attention of the Tribunal to para 3 of the counter in which it has been indicated that the two sets of charges are different and are based on two different F.I.Rs. (Though the name of the applicant is not figuring in the said F.I.Rs, the counsel stated that the list of accused contains the word, "and others" to include the applicant as well). Counsel further argued that the nature of misconduct though may be identical in both the charges, the gravity of charges vide Annexure A-3 is such that the loss resulted due to the negligence of the applicant is a stupendous Rs. 1.60 crores. Due opportunity shall be given to the applicant to defend this case and exculpate.

10. Arguments were heard and documents perused. First as to the question whether the two sets of charges are identical so as to warrant only one procedure adopted, i.e. Rule 16 which was invoked first vide Annexure A-1.

11. Annexure A-1 charge sheet reflects that the applicant while holding charge of Assistant Commissioner of Customs at Air Cargo Complex, Calicut, had countersigned Bills of Entry No. 1099 (dated 08-12-2005), 1111 (dated 12- 12-2005) and 211 (dated 30-=01-2006). It was alleged that the applicant while so countersigning the above Bills of Entry, the set procedure as contained in CBEC Circular No. 450/105/2003 Cus IV dated 15-03-2004 and Notification No.

29 (RE2004)/2002-2007 dated 28-01-2004 had not been followed, inasmuch as OA 799 /11 when the consignments are not accompanied by pre-shipment certificate from the notified agencies, the consignments can be cleared only after testing the same from the notified agency for the presence of hazardous dyes and that for this purpose, where samples are required, the same art to be sent for testing hazardous dyes.

12. Annexure A-3 charge sheet contains Article I, relating to as many as 63 Bills of Entry, in respect of consignments, each having assessable value exceeding Rupees one lakh, which the applicant had countersigned, in token of acceptance of examination and assessment of the same made by Inspector and Superintendent of Air Cargo Complex, wherein the importers declared insufficient description and claimed inappropriate classification in respect of imported readymade garments attracting lower duty. It has also been alleged that the applicant failed to ascertain the nature and composition of the materials through test by competent authorities, and though samples were drawn and tested for hazardous dyes as per Notification dated 28-01-2004, no sample was drawn for testing the nature and composition of the fabrics in terms of CBEC circular No. 23/24 Cus dated 15-03-2004 for arriving at the appropriate classification and rate of duty in respect of the garments under issue. The estimated loss to the Revenue was indicated as Rs. 1.60 Crores due to the lapse on the part of the applicant in respect of charge under Article I.

13. The said Annexure A-3 also contains another article of charge relating to

17 Bills of entry and the said charge alleges the same lapse as stated above and the estimated loss of revenue was indicated as Rs 31.94 lakhs.

14. A comparison of the two Charge Sheets (Annexure A-3 and A-1) would go to show that these are based on different set of facts. Respondents are not OA 799 /11 wrong when they have contended in para 3 of their counter that "the Bills of Entry and the importers were different in both the cases." Of course, the applicant, in his reply to the charge sheet at Annexure A-3 has stated that the 63 Bills of Entry also includes the three entries relating to Annexure A-1 charge sheet, which was issued under the provisions of Rule 16 of the CCS(CC&A) Rules, 1965. If that be so, the same by itself cannot be fatal to the conducting of the proceedings under Rule 14.

15. The main thrust of the arguments by the Senior Counsel for the applicant is that both the Charge Sheets were based upon the same alleged lapse of not following the provisions contained in order dated 15-03-2004 and thus, when for one, respondents have proceeded with minor penalty proceedings, they are not justified in proceeding with major penalty proceedings. This contention of the Senior Counsel for the applicant ill merits acceptance. For, in the earlier Charge Sheet, the number of Bills of Entry counter signed was only three whereas, in the other, it is as many as 63 in respect of Article I and 17 in respect of II totaling 80 (or at least 77, if the first article includes also those bills of Entry which were subject matter of the Annexure A-1 Charge Memo). The cumulative impact of the alleged lapse on the part of the applicant is stated to have resulted in a revenue loss of nearly two crores of rupees. Perhaps, in the first charge sheet, if there be only one Bill of Entry which had been countersigned without due scrutiny the same may not constitute even such a misconduct against which the respondents could proceed under Rule 16 of the Rules. In the case of Union of India vs J. Ahmed (1979) 2 SCC 286, the Apex Court has inter alia held as under:- "A single act of omission or error of judgment would ordinarily not constitute misconduct though if such error or omission results in serious or atrocious consequences the same may amount to misconduct as was held by this Court in P.H. Kalyani v. Air France, Calcutta wherein it was found that the two mistakes OA 799 /11 committed by the employee while checking the load-sheets and balance charts would involve possible accident to the aircraft and possible loss of human life and, therefore, the negligence in work in the context of serious consequences was treated as misconduct."

16. Thus, if there are plural acts of omission, the same would constitute misconduct and depending upon the gravity of the misconduct (which takes into account the extent of revenue loss sustained by the Respondents), the charge sheet could either be under Rule 16 as in Annexure A-1 or under Rule 14, vide Annexure A-3 order. Thus, the applicant cannot take any advantage of the two sets of charge sheet reflecting the same omission(to follow the circular dated 15- 03-2004) to contend that only minor penalty should be imposed. Thus, the first question raised vide para 1 of the order is answered.

17. As regards the second issue, i.e. Whether the respondents could keep the Rule 16 proceedings pending till the superannuation of the applicant and have the same deemed to have been closed without arriving at a logical conclusion on the basis of the records and defence offered by the applicant, answer to this question is not far to seek. The authorities have the discretion to close the case and in case for any reason whatsoever, if the case could not be brought to a logical end, and the delinquent by that time superannuates, he is given the benefit of closure of the proceedings. This is what precisely has taken place in the instant case. Assuming that there has been a full fledged exoneration from the A-1 Charge Memorandum, then again, the same cannot absolve the applicant from facing the second charge sheet, which, as per the above finding of this Tribunal is not based on identical sets of facts.

18. Senior counsel for the applicant also argued that the respondents have taken action against the applicant at the fag end of his career. Perusal of the OA 799 /11 Charge Sheet at Annexure A-3 does not reflect any attempt to purposely delay the initiation of the proceedings. If the issue at this distance of time raised has prejudiced the applicant, then it is for the applicant to prove the same before the inquiry authority. At one point of time, the senior Counsel stated that the said Annexure A-3 Charge Memo had been issued after the retirement of the applicant. We have to differ from the Senior counsel in this regard, for the date of issue of charge memo is 27 -2-2011, while the date of superannuation of the applicant is 30-04-2011.

19. Lastly, the question about the judicial review at the threshold level of issue of charge sheet. At the charge sheet level, no finding has been rendered by the authorities about the misconduct. Thus, only when the very charge sheet has been issued by an incompetent authority or the allegation is such that no man of common prudence would arrive at the conclusion that the individual's act would become misconduct, that judicial intervention could be justified, as held by the Apex Court in the case of Upendra Singh vs .Union of India, (1994) 3 SCC

357 wherein the Apex Court has held as under:- "6. In the case of charges framed in a disciplinary inquiry the tribunal or court can interfere only if on the charges framed (read with imputation or particulars of the charges, if any) no misconduct or other irregularity alleged can be said to have been made out or the charges framed are contrary to any law. At this stage, the tribunal has no jurisdiction to go into the correctness or truth of the charges. The tribunal cannot take over the functions of the disciplinary authority. The truth or otherwise of the charges is a matter for the disciplinary authority to go into. Indeed, even after the conclusion of the disciplinary proceedings, if the matter comes to court or tribunal, they have no jurisdiction to look into the truth of the charges or into the correctness of the findings recorded by the disciplinary authority or the appellate authority as the case may be." (The above decision was followed in the case of District Forest Officer v. R. OA 799 /11 Rajamanickam, (2000) 9 SCC 284, wherein the Apex Court has held that the Tribunal was not justified under law to interfere with the correctness of the charges levelled against the delinquent officer.)

20. Now a look at the case laws cited by the Senior Counsel for the applicant. In the case of Kanailal Bera vs Union of India (2007) 11 SCC 517, wherein the Apex Court has held as under:- "Once a disciplinary proceeding has been initiated, the same must be brought to its logical end meaning thereby a finding is required to be arrived at as to whether the delinquent officer is guilty of charges levelled against him or not. In a given situation further evidences may be directed to be adduced but the same would not mean that despite holding a delinquent officer to be partially guilty of the charges levelled against him another inquiry would be directed to be initiated on the selfsame charges which could not be proved in the first inquiry."

21. The above decision does not assist the case of the applicant, for, the second charge sheet is not on the basis of the self same sets of facts. Again, the first one having been closed no prejudice has been caused to the applicant by virtue of such closure of the charge sheet.

22. The second case relied upon by the Senior Counsel for the applicant is Bhagat Singh vs Union of India, (1994) 28 ATC 306 (Cal), which has been cited to hammer home the point that it is mandatory to conclude the proceedings and that public policy is involved in departmental case in terms of the CCS (CCA) Rules. Here again, the applicant cannot derive any benefit out of this decision, for, as stated earlier, closure of the charge sheet issued under Rule 16 is by virtue of the fact that even if the proceedings are completed, no penalty could be imposed after retirement as the penalty proceedings survive after retirement only in respect of grave misconduct. As regards public policy, the same is fully applicable in this case as the term public policy refers to a OA 799 /11 concerted course of action followed to achieve certain ends by the Government. It has been held in the aforesaid case of Bhagat Singh that in government service two ingredients are extremely important; one is a sense of discipline to which all the government employees are subjected to and the other is the protection under the Constitution which they enjoy. Here the two are adequately ensured by holding the inquiry wherein full opportunity is given to the applicant for his exculpation.

23. In view of the above, there is absolutely no illegality in the issue of the charge sheet under Rule 14. At best, if the three Bills of Entry as contained in Annexure A-1 charge Memorandum have been included in the Annexure A-3 Charge Memorandum, in that case, while holding the inquiry, these shall have to be excluded in view of the fact the under Rule 16, the same having figured in, and the said charge sheet having been closed, there is no question of considering the same now. Further, the Tribunal was informed that when the applicant had requested for supply of documents to make an effective reply to the Charge Memo, the same have been made available only recently i.e. almost

10 months after the issue of the charge sheet. The applicant having retired from service, respondents shall ensure concluding the proceedings within a reasonable time. With this observation, the OA is dismissed.

24. No costs. K.NOORJEHAN Dr K.B.S.RAJAN ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER JUDICIAL MEMBER