Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M.N.Muraleedharan Nair v. Union of India

Central Administrative Tribunal
Sep 15, 2014

HON'BLE SHRI PRASANNA KUMAR PRADHAN, MEMBER (A): The applicant has filed this Original Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following reliefs; O.A.No.637/20122

HON'BLE SHRI PRASANNA KUMAR PRADHAN, MEMBER (A): The applicant has filed this Original Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following reliefs; O.A.No.637/20122 i. To quash Annexure (A-1) and Annexure (A-2) and to restore the applicant's increment withheld by virtue of order Annexure (A-1), with consequential benefits. The facts of the case in brief are as follows;

2. A proceeding was initiated against the applicant vide Memo No.K- Disc/Misc-Enq(1) dated 19.10.2010 by which he was called upon by the 3rd respondent to show-cause as to why disciplinary action should not be initiated against him. It was alleged in the memo that applicant directed the Junior Officials Smt.Jisharaj S.S, Smt.M.R.Radhika and Shri Deepak R. who were working as Mail Agent, RSA-1 and SA in packet branch respectively to copy down unauthorisedly the names and addresses of persons in the call letters containing hall tickets posted at Thiruvalla HO by Superintendent of Post, Thiruvalla Postal Division for making them available to some public. Further it is alleged that applicant had failed to call the police when outsiders trespassed into the RMS and threatened a lady official and took her photograph. According to the 3rd respondent, the said acts of the applicant are in violations of Rule 11 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 and Rule (5) of Postal Manual Volume VII. Memo No.Disc/Misc-Enq(1) dated 19.11.2010 is at Annexure(A-3). In his representation Annexure (A-4) the applicant explained the incidents that took place on 30.10.2010 and submitted that he had not acted in contravention of the rules.

3. Thereafter 3rd respondent issued Memorandum No.K-Disc/16- 1/2011 dated 06.01.2011 Annexure (A-5) proposing to take action against the O.A.No.637/20123 applicant under Rule 16 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. In the Memorandum it was imputed that the applicant while working as HAS in Thiruvalla RMS/2 dated 20.10.2010 misused his authority as HAS for unlawful collection of address particulars of hall permits utilizing the services of his subordinate officials for divulging the information to the public thus violating Rule 11 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 and Rule 5 of Postal Manual Valume VII and thereby infringing Rule 3(1)(i) and 3(1) (iii) of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964. Further imputation in the memo was that the applicant failed to call the police when outsiders trespassed into RMS and threatened a lady official and took photograph of the lady official, thereby infringing Rule 3(B) (ii) of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.

4. The applicant submitted his written statement of defence on 15.02.2001. He had pointed out the fact of denying him access to the documents production/inspection of which was sought for by him. He denied the charges leveled against him and asserted that he had not done any blameworthy act or omission which can be interpreted as violation or infringement of the quoted rules. He requested that he may be heard in person as per the provisions contained in Rule 16(1) (b) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The applicant submitted that he had not directed any of the staff or Tiruvalla RMS/2 to copy down the names and address of RLs containing hall tickets sent by registered post by the Superintendent, Tiruvalla and had not misused the authority of HAS for any unlawful work. Further he submitted that he had not divulged the information of address particulars of RLs sent by the Superintendent, Tiruvalla to any outsiders or postal officials as alleged O.A.No.637/20124 (Annexure-A-6). On the 2nd charge, the applicant submits that lady official had not given him a written complaint, despite his asking her to do so. In the circumstances he had forwarded a report of the incident to 3rd respondent on the same day. He is not a regular HAS and he did what he thought appropriate in the circumstances. There was no physical violence or vandalism. There were no higher authorities to report the incident to the police. The applicant contended that he had not violated Rule 3(B) (ii) of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964.

5. The 3rd respondent by an order dated 21.02.2011 denied the request of the applicant for holding a detailed enquiry into the allegations leveled against him. Request of perusal of all documents relating to the preliminary investigation and personal hearing by the Disciplinary Authority were however permitted. After perusal of documents on 22.02.2011 the applicant represented that the statements given by Smt.Jisharaj S.S, Radhika M.R and Deepak R Before Shri C.V.Raju, ASP Tiruvalla RMS during preliminary enquiry and before Shri S.Narendran, ASP (HQ) who carried a Divisional level enquiry are contradictory and hence the truth will come out only on cross examination of witnesses. Once again he requested that an enquiry as contemplated under Rule 16(1) (b) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 be held. The 3rd respondent however turned down the request as per his order No.K-Disc/16- 1/2011 dated 09.03.2011 Annexure (A-7) and directed the applicant to submit his `defence representation', if any, within five days of receipt of that memo. In response the applicant submitted representation dated 21.03.2011 Annexure (A-8) to the 3rd respondent, once again requesting him to conduct a fact finding O.A.No.637/20125 enquiry under Rule 16(1) (b) of CCS (CCA) Rules 1965. Thereafter order of punishment was issued Annexure (A-1). Aggrieved by the same applicant submitted an appeal Annexure (A-9) to the 2nd respondent but same was turned down by order Annexure (A-2). In these circumstances the applicant approached this Tribunal for appropriate relief.

6. In the Original Application the applicant further submitted that he was denied a reasonable opportunity to defend his case as no enquiry as contemplated under Rule 16(1)(b) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 was conducted in this case despite him repeatedly requesting for the same highlighting the necessity of such an enquiry on the basis of valid and relevant reasons. He also referred to a decision reported in 2002(1) KLT 420 considering an analogue situation the Hon'ble High Court held thus; "As per R.16 r/w. R.11 of the Kerala Civil Services (C.C.A) Rules 1960, punishment of barring of increments with cumulative effect is a minor penalty. To impose a minor penalty, the procedure prescribed under R.16 along need be followed. R.16(1) of the said Rules reads; (1) No order imposing any of the penalties specified in items (i) to iv) of R.11(1) shall be passed except after, (a) the Government servant is informed in writing of the proposal to take action against him and of the allegations on which it is proposed to be taken and given opportunity to make any representation he may wish to make; O.A.No.637/20126 (b) such representation, if any, is taken into consideration by the Disciplinary Authority; and (c) the Commission is consulted in cases where such consultation is necessary. Under R.16 of the KCS (CC&A) Rules, a formal enquiry is not a must. The procedure prescribed under R.15 for imposing major penalty contemplates a formal enquiry necessitating the examination of witnesses and production of documents with opportunity to the accused employee to cross examine witnesses and adducing his own evidence. But this does not mean that a minor penalty can be inflicted on the accused employee irrespective of the nature of the allegations and the evidence required to prove those allegations. There may arise, in minor penalty proceedings also, the necessity to adduce evidence; without such evidence the charges cannot be held to have been established against the employee. The need to adduce evidence arises in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case, the nature of the allegations leveled against the delinquent employee and the defence pleaded in his written statement. It cannot be said as an absolute rule in all cases, where a minor penalty alone is proposed to be imposed on the delinquent employee that the ordeal of an enquiry can be done away with. It is true that the penalty to be imposed is a relevant facts but equally important is the nature of the allegations as also the facts to be established to O.A.No.637/20127 substantiate the charges. When charges are founded on complicated facts or those involving serious allegations, it will be arbitrary to find the employee guilty, without holding an enquiry. A meaningful application of the principles of natural justice and the doctrine of reasonable opportunity to the accused employee come into play on such occasions.

7. The above observations contained in the judgment quoted above apply with equal vigor to the facts and circumstances of the case in hand. Hence he is entitled to the relief sought for.

8. The respondents in their reply statement contended that the applicant Sri M.N.Muraleedharan Nair has been working as Sorting Assistant (SA for short) in Sub Record Office (SRO for short), Railway Mail Service (RMS for short), `TV' Division, Thiruvalla. On 30.10.2010 the applicant worked as Head Sorting Assistant (HAS in short) in Tiruvalla RMS/2. Being head of the Unit applicant had to supervise the entire work force of the Unit and see that all the work was properly carried out and mails received from the post offices were immediately sorted and dispatched by the next available conveyance. The day coincided with the posting of call letters for written test by Tiruvalla and Pathanamthitta Postal Divisions for the recruitment of Postal Assistants. At abut 18.30 hours Mail bag from Tiruvalla Head Office was brought to Tiruvalla RMS. The bag was opened by the Mail Sorting Assistant (MSA in short) as per rules, and registered bag was transferred to Computerized Registration Centre O.A.No.637/20128 (CRC in Short), Tiruvalla RMS/2, where registered articles are processed. The bag contained 366 registered articles and 90% of registered letters were call letters from Superintendent of Post Offices, Tiruvalla destined to applicants at various places. Smt.M.R.Radhika, SA who was working in the registration branch had to open the registered bag from Tiruvalla HO. However Shri M.N.Muralieedharan Nair, HAS, who had only to supervise the work, went to CRC and took unusual interest in opening the bag and assisted the Registration Sorting Assistant (RSA for short) in sorting the Registered Letters. The applicant separated the Registered letters containing hall permits and retained the same without dispatching by next available train.

9. After 19.30 hours the applicant collected the registered letters from Smt.M.R.Radhika, RSA and handed over to Smt.Jisha Raj S.S, SA who worked as Mail Agent in Tiruvalla RMS/2 at her table. The applicant then directed Smt.Jisha Raj to copy down the address particulars of Registered Letters (RL for short) containing Hall permits and she started the work. In the meantime the applicant completed the essential work of the Mail Agent to that her service could be fully utilized for copying the address. At about 20.00 hours some outsiders, alleged postal staff from Tiruvalla HO belonging to the rival union came to RMS and saw Smt.Jisharaj copying the address of RLSs in a paper. They immediately returned and at about 21.30 hours they appeared again with more strength and surrounded the table of the MA and questioned her authority in doing the above work and made altercation on this account. Smt.Jisharaj frightened on this, had admitted that what she was doing was as O.A.No.637/20129 per the directions of the applicant. Some members of the crowd photographed and video-graphed all these incidents using mobile phone. Some members of the crowd approached the applicant and asked him to supply copy of the address list to them also which was refused by the applicant. There occurred a verbal dual between the outsiders and the applicant for some time. The outsiders went away at about 22.00 hours. After this incident the applicant took the remaining RLs from the table of MA and returned to CRC and got the address particulars copied down by directing junior most officials namely Deepak R and Radhika MR. Applicant has done with unauthorized activity obviously to divulge the information to his union leaders so that they can canvas the candidates to become members of their union.

10. According to the respondents the act done by the applicant was crossing all limits of discipline and procedure including unwarranted detention of RLs and taking risk on the safety and security of registered postal mail. The applicant in his capacity as HAS of the set failed to call the police when there was an attack on the dignity and modesty of a woman working in his office. The applicant was served with shown cause notice on 19.11.2010. The applicant denied the allegation against him. Since the reply was not satisfactory, action under Rule 16 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 was initiated against the applicant and the penalty of withholding the applicant's next increment for two years without cumulative effect was awarded. The applicant appealed against this order to 2nd respondent, who subsequently confirmed the punishment imposed by this respondent. O.A.No.637/201210

11. The respondents further submitted that, the applicant has no put- forth any valid grounds warranting intervention of this Tribunal. The respondents have scrupulously followed all instructions and rules in conducting the inquiry and all reasonable opportunity has been given to the applicant to present his case in the inquiry. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has held in the decision reported in the case of Union of India and another Vs. K.G.Sony-2006 SCC(L&S) 1568 that punishment being not one shocking to the conscience of the court, to interfere therewith is not called for and that the judicial review is confined to the decision making process. It was held that Court should not interfere with the administrative decisions unless it illogically suffers from procedural impropriety and that the court should not go into the correctness of the points made by the administrator. In the instant case this respondent awarded the penalty of withholding of next increment of the applicant for a period of two years without cumulative effect. Though the circumstances deserved a more severe penalty against the applicant, this respondent took a very lenient view since the applicant had regretted.

12. The applicant requested perusal of some of the documents and requested to be heard in person and for enquiry. The applicant was allowed to inspect the documents on 22.02.2011 and called for personal hearing on the same day. Regarding his request for holding a formal inquiry, this respondent after carefully examining all the facts and circumstances and the reasons urged in the representation for holding a detailed inquiry, concluded that no inquiry O.A.No.637/201211 as requested by the applicant was necessary as the evidence collected during the preliminary enquiry was not of a complicated nature. This decision was intimated to the official vide Memo No.K-Disc/16-1/2011 dated 21.02.2011. When the applicant again requested for an inquiry as per Rule 16(1)(b) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, it was decided that request for a formal enquiry was not necessary in this case and the decision was intimated to the applicant vide memo at Annexure-A-7. It was also clearly intimated that if no representation is received within the time limit, the case will be decided on merit by treating representation of the applicant dated 15.02.2011 as his defence. The contention of the applicant that he was denied natural justice is totally infactual. The applicant was given all opportunities to defend the case. All the requests like perusal of documents, personal hearing etc., were granted.

13. The Disciplinary Authority had initiated action under Rule 16 and not Rule 14 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. It is not mandatory for a formal enquiry to be conducted if the evidence collected during the inquiry is not complicated. The case against the applicant required only minor penalty procedure (Rules 16) which is in fact a favour to the applicant. Rule 16(ii)(b) prescribes a prolonged procedure on the lines of Rule 14 which was not required in the instant case considering the simple nature of the case. Having given all reasonable opportunity to defend the case, the applicant cannot allege injustice just because the enquiry was not conducted as he desired. It is submitted that the nature of action to be taken against a charged official is O.A.No.637/201212 left to the discretion of the Disciplinary Authority and not at the disposal of the official. Hence they prayed for dismissal of the Original Application.

14. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.

15. The learned counsel for the applicant reiterating the facts submitted in his Original Application emphasized that the applicant was not given an opportunity to cross-examine the witnesses and respondent authorities rejected his request for a formal enquiry. Therefore there has been denial of natural justice in his case. He highlighted the orders of the Hon'ble High Court of Kerala which has been highlighted in the Original Application and mentioned earlier. He emphasized on the order which stating that issue natural justice and reasonable opportunity should be looked into and punishment although minor cannot be inflicted irrespective of nature of allegations and evidences. Therefore, he submits that order of imposing penalty even if it is minor one suffers from serious deficiencies by not allowing cross examination and need to be set aside.

16. The learned counsel for the respondents on the other hand submits that the charges against the applicant were quite serious and have not been denied. The applicant was given a personal hearing and also allowed to peruse all the documents he wanted to examine. The penalty was imposed after considering the facts and circumstances of the case and the detail representation made by the applicant. Therefore there is no denial of any justice. The Appellate Authorities have also passed a detailed and reasoned O.A.No.637/201213 order rejecting his appeal. Therefore there is no merit in the contention made by the applicant and the Original Application is liable to be dismissed.

17. We have carefully considered the facts of the case and also submission made by either side. This is the case of initiation of penalty under Rule 16 of CCS (CCA) Rules. The main issue involved is whether a reasonable opportunity was given to the charge official or not?. There is no dispute that an incident had taken place based on which charge memo was issued. The applicant submitted his request to the Disciplinary Authority for perusal of documents and a personal hearing and also requested for an enquiry under Rule 16 (1) (b) of CCS (CCA) Rules to examine the witnesses. The respondent authorities allowed him the opportunity to peruse all the documents and also gave a personal hearing as requested. Further vide order dated 09.03.2011 the Disciplinary Authority rejected the request for an enquiry. He held that, the witnesses have stated what they did not reveal during the preliminary enquiry, and there is nothing contradictory necessitating to cross examine the witnesses.

18. The provision under Rule 16(1) (b) does provides for holding an enquiry in the manner laid down in sub rule (3) to (23) of Rule 14 of CCS (CCA) Rules, in such case in which the Disciplinary Authority is of the opinion that such enquiry is necessary. But it does not mandate holding of such enquiry only if it is demanded by the charge official. In this case Disciplinary Authority was of the view that such of enquiry is not required and also passed an order citing O.A.No.637/201214 reason for the same. This action can not be held as improper or as violation of the rules. When personal hearing was given and also a opportunity was given to the applicant to examine all the documents it cannot be stated that only because of enquiry was not allowed as per request of the charge official, it would amount to be a case of denial of natural justice. It is evident from the facts cited during the submission that all opportunities were given to the applicant to defend himself and his representation was duly taken into consideration while passing the penalty order. His appeal to the Appellate Authority was also duly considered by the Appellate Authority and a detail order covering all the issues raised by the applicant was passed. Therefore in this case, it cannot be held that there was any instance of denial of natural justice.

19. After due consideration of the facts and circumstances of the case, we therefore hold view that there is no procedural irregularities or denial of natural justice in the present case which would necessitate interference by this Tribunal. Therefore we hold that the Original Application is devoid of merits and liable to be dismissed.

20. Accordingly, the Original Application is dismissed. No order as to costs. (PRASANNA KUMAR PRADHAN) (U.SARATHCHANDRAN) MEMBER (A) MEMBER (J)