Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ramesh Chand v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi

Central Administrative Tribunal
Jan 5, 2005
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Ramesh Chand)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant, Head Constable Ramesh Chand (No.537/W) of Delhi Police, sought quashing of disciplinary orders dated 30.4.2003 by which the disciplinary authority permanently forfeited five years of his approved service, reduced his pay from Rs.4305/- to Rs.3880/- per month, and treated his suspension period as time not spent on duty. The applicant also challenged an appellate order by the Joint Commissioner of Police dated 17.5.2004 which dismissed his appeal.

The disciplinary proceedings originated from allegations arising from incidents on 2–3 October 2000. A PCR call reported a quarrel on 2.10.2000 at Gali No.32, Sant Garh, Tilak Vihar (recorded as DD No.5 dated 2-10-2000), and another entry on 3.10.2000 (DD No.25 dated 3-10-2000) concerning the death of a maid servant, Smt. Darpana, allegedly assaulted with acid. The applicant, who was entrusted with the daily diary entry for the earlier call, attended with Constable Hoshiar Singh. It was alleged that he conducted a casual enquiry, filed the call relying on a statement of Charanjit Kaur, failed to record Darpana’s statement, did not get her admitted for medical treatment, and failed to register appropriate legal action. A formal charge was framed alleging gross misconduct, negligence and dereliction in violation of rule 3(i)(iii) of the C.C.S. (Conduct) Rules, 1964, and invoking disciplinary provisions (section 21 of the DP Act, 1978). The inquiry officer found the charge proved.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the inquiry officer exceeded his role by effectively cross-examining witnesses rather than asking only clarificatory questions, thereby prejudicing the fairness of the disciplinary inquiry.
  2. Whether the applicant was denied a fair opportunity to produce defence evidence and to have certain government/officer witnesses summoned and examined—which could have been material to his defence.
  3. Whether, in view of any procedural unfairness identified, the disciplinary orders (including the appellate dismissal) should be quashed and the inquiry remitted for further proceedings from a particular stage.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The inquiry officer did not act fairly and, instead of asking clarificatory questions, proceeded to cross-examine witnesses; this conduct made the proceedings unsustainable (relying on the Tribunal's decision in ASI Sher Singh v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Others, O.A. No.2827/2003).
  • The applicant was denied a fair opportunity to produce defence witnesses. He had sought examination of defence witnesses such as Satpal and Nirmal Singh to establish particular facts (e.g., what was stated at the spot and whether Darpana declined to make a statement), and also sought to have official witnesses summoned (Reader to ACP/Tilak Nagar, Head Constable Jai Kishan, and M.H.C.(R) P.S. Tilak Nagar) to prove attendance and related official records.
  • Because these witnesses were not permitted or were rejected by the inquiry officer as "not relevant", the applicant's right to a reasonable opportunity to defend himself was infringed.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The respondents pointed out that the witnesses the applicant sought were not produced.
  • The record before the inquiry officer supported the finding that the charge was made out (the inquiry officer had, on the material before him, concluded the charge was proved).
  • Beyond these points, the opinion does not set out additional detailed arguments advanced by the respondents in the text provided.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
ASI Sher Singh v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Others, O.A. No.2827/2003, decided 7.7.2004 (Tribunal) The enquiry officer may ask clarificatory questions but must not proceed to cross-examine witnesses; if he does so he must indicate it and permit further cross-examination/rights of the delinquent—failure to do so is a procedural flaw. The court applied this principle to conclude that the inquiry officer in the present case was not seeking mere clarifications but was cross-examining witnesses (particularly PW-2), including asking leading questions. This supported the view that the inquiry procedure was flawed.
Deoki Nandan Kulshreshtha v. State of Rajasthan and Another, 1986 (4) SLR 734 (Rajasthan High Court) An enquiry officer must summon government witnesses and production of official documents in government custody when a delinquent requests them; refusal to permit production/summoning of such witnesses/documents can amount to denial of a reasonable opportunity to defend. The court relied on this authority to reject the respondents' suggestion that the relevant government witnesses were simply not produced and to hold that the denial of opportunity to summon/produce those witnesses was not acceptable—supporting the applicant's claim of being denied a fair opportunity.
Ravinder Singh v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Others, O.A. No.1125/2004, decided 15.10.2004 (Tribunal) Consistent Tribunal authority that denial of opportunity to adduce defence evidence (including calling official witnesses) can vitiate disciplinary proceedings. The court cited this Tribunal decision as reflecting an identical view and used it to reinforce the conclusion that the applicant had not been afforded a fair opportunity to produce defence evidence.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed the record on two principal procedural grounds advanced by the applicant: (1) improper cross-examination by the inquiry officer; and (2) denial of a fair opportunity to produce defence witnesses.

On the first issue, the court compared the inquiry conduct with the standard set out in ASI Sher Singh. It found that the inquiry officer was not merely seeking clarificatory information but was cross-examining witnesses—specifically Constable Hoshiar (PW-2) and others—and asked leading questions. The court observed the absence of any indication in the record that the inquiry officer intended to switch to cross-examination mode or that the delinquent was afforded the further rights that would attend such a shift. On this basis, the court concluded there was procedural unfairness in the manner the inquiry was conducted.

On the second issue, the court examined the applicant's requests to summon and examine certain defence and official witnesses (Satpal, Nirmal Singh and three official witnesses: Reader to ACP/Tilak Nagar, Head Constable Jai Kishan, and M.H.C.(R) P.S. Tilak Nagar). The court held that while an inquiry officer may legitimately exclude evidence that is irrelevant or incompetent for departmental purposes, the relevance of evidence for the defence must be considered; evidence that may appear irrelevant to the department may nonetheless be material to the accused’s defence. The court concluded that the evidence the applicant sought to produce could show attendance at the scene and that Darpana had refused to make a statement—matters that could be material.

The respondents' contention that these witnesses were not produced did not, in the court's view, absolve the enquiry officer from the duty to summon government witnesses when requested; for this proposition the court relied on Deoki Nandan Kulshreshtha and the similar Tribunal decision in Ravinder Singh. Applying these authorities, the court found that the applicant's claim of denial of a fair opportunity to produce defence evidence was justified.

Having reached these conclusions on procedural unfairness, the court stated that it was unnecessary to consider other pleas (for example, issues about earlier statements being considered). The appropriate remedy, in the court's view, was to quash the impugned orders and permit re-opening of the disciplinary proceedings from the point indicated (stage when PW-2 was being examined).

Holding and Implications

The impugned disciplinary orders are quashed.

Implications and direct consequences as set out in the opinion:

  • The disciplinary authority is directed, if it deems appropriate, to initiate disciplinary proceedings afresh from the stage when PW-2 (Constable Hoshiar Singh) was being examined.
  • The applicant (Ramesh Chand) is entitled to all consequential benefits flowing from the quashing of the impugned orders.
  • The court expressly observed that, given its findings of procedural unfairness, it was unnecessary to consider the other pleas raised by the parties.

The opinion does not articulate broader legal doctrines or state that it is creating a new precedent beyond applying and relying on the authorities cited; its practical effect is to set aside the specific disciplinary decision and to direct re-opening of the inquiry at a specified stage.

Show all summary ...

By Mr. Justice V.S.Aggarwal: Applicant (Ramesh Chand) is Head Constable in Delhi Police. By virtue of the present application, he seeks quashing of the orders imposed in disciplinary proceedings against him by the disciplinary authority dated 30.4.2003 whereby penalty of forfeiture of five years approved service permanently entailing reduction in his pay had been imposed. The operative part of the said order reads: In view of the directions of the Honble CAT and after considering all aspects of the case, I, hereby order to forfeit five years approved service of HC Ramesh Chand No.537/W (2007/DAP) permanently, entailing reduction in his pay from Rs.4305/- P.M. to Rs.3880/- P.M. and his above mentioned suspension period is also treated as period not spent on duty for all intents & purposes.

2. The applicant also assails the order passed in appeal by the Joint Commissioner of Police on 17.5.2004 whereby the appeal was dismissed.

3. Some of the relevant facts are that it was alleged against the applicant that on 3.10.2000, a call was received from the Police Control Room (for short `PCR) regarding death of one maid servant owing to throwing of acid. The call was marked to Sub Inspector Sita Ram. The Assistant Commissioner of Police and Officer-Incharge of the Police Station also visited the place of occurance and found dead body of Smt. Darpana aged about 28 years. She had burn injuries between her naval and genitals as well as on right thigh and right hip. She was having injury marks on her right hand and in and around left eye. On further enquiry made by the Assistant Commissioner of Police, it revealed that on 2.10.2000 a call was received regarding quarrel at Gali No.32, Sant Garh, Tilak Vihar. The daily diary entry was entrusted to the applicant who alongwith Constable Hoshiar Singh reached the spot. He enquired into the matter in a very casual manner. It was alleged that the applicant recorded the statement of Charanjit Kaur and filed the call despite knowing well that Darpana had been assaulted by another person with acid. Had the applicant acted in a dutiful manner, precious life of the injured Darpana could have been saved. The applicant did not take any legal action nor he got the injured admitted in the hospital.

4. The inquiry officer on these allegations after recording the reasons, had framed the following charge: I Inspr. P.N. Malhotra, Incharge Vigilance West Distt. Delhi, the enquiry officer, charge you H.C.Ramesh Chand No.537/W (PIS No.28790167) that while you were posted to P.P. Tilak Vihar under P.S.Tilak Nagar, West Distt. Delhi, a wireless call about the death of one Darpana, a maid servant was recorded vide DD No.25 dated 3-10-2000 P.P. Tilak Vihar due to the throwing acid on her. During an enquiry into the said DD entry, it was revealed that Smt. Darpana was a maid servant of one Parivar Singh @ Kukku, who had thrown acid on Darpana on 2-10-2000 at WZ-56 Gali No.32, Sant Garh, causing certain injuries on her person a case vide FIR No.826 U/s 302/120-B IPC was registered on 3-10-2000 at P.S. Tilak Nagar. During inquiry it also came out that on 2-10-2000, a PCR call about the quarrel at WZ-56, Gali No.32, Sant Garh, was also received at P.P.Tilak Vihar vide DD No.5 dated 2-10-2000 which was attended by you H.C. Ramesh Chand No.537/W and on the basis of the statement of one Charanjeet Kaur, the mother of said Parivar Singh had disposed off the case vide DD No.15 dt. 2-10-2000 P.P. Tilak Vihar though it came to you knowledge during enquiry that Darpana was beaten by Parivar Singh @ Kukku and had thrown acid on her resulting burn injuries on her person, you had neither recorded the statement of Darpana nor had taken her to the Hospital for medical examination and treatment. You also failed to register a case under the appropriate section of law and thereby, you had concealed the facts for the reasons best known to you. The above mentioned acts on the part of you H.C. Ramesh Chand No.537/W constituted gross misconduct, negligence, carelessness and dereliction in the discharge of your official duty, which rendered you unbecoming of a member of the disciplined force in violation of rule 3(i)(iii) of C.C.S. (Conduct) Rules 1964. Hence you are liable for punishment U/s. 21 of DP Act 1978.

5. The inquiry officer considering the evidence and material on record, came to the conclusion that the charge against the applicant stood proved.

6. The application is being contested.

7. The learned counsel for the applicant contended that in the present case, the inquiry officer did not act fairly and started cross-examining the witnesses and, therefore, the impugned orders cannot be sustained. Reliance was being placed on the decision of this Tribunal in the case of ASI SHER SINGH v. GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & OTHERS, O.A.No.2827/2003, decided on 7.7.2004. The findings read: 8. We do not dispute the right of the enquiry officer to seek clarificatory questions. After all they are semi-judicial proceedings and the enquiry officer is not a silent spectator. However, if he intends to seek clarification, it should be so specifically indicated. The enquiry officer cannot start cross-examining the witnesses and then not permitting the delinquent thereafter a further right. It is this flaw which has crept into the proceedings which prompts us to conclude that in the facts before us, the impugned order cannot be sustained. The record reveals that the enquiry officer cros-examined Mohd. Hanif, applicant, PW-3 and even Sub-Inspector Amit Bikram from the CBI. The record does not reveal that the clarifications were being sought. It also does not reveal that further cross-examination in this regard was permitted.

8. When the present matter is examined on the touchstone of the aforesaid, it is obvious that the inquiry officer was not asking clarificatory questions. Instead he was cross-examining the witnesses particularly Constable Hoshiyar Singh, PW-2. During the course of the inquiry, certain leading questions had been asked. This clearly shows that it was not clarificatory question that had been put forward.

9. Yet another limb of the argument was in terms that the applicant was not given fair opportunity to produce his defence witness. The inquiry officer had rejected the claim stating that the evidence is not relevant. In the application that had been filed for summoning certain witnesses, the applicant wanted Satpal to be examined so as to state that on the applicants visit in response to PCR call, Charanjit Kaur had stated that her son had come there under drunken state and that even Darpna declined to make a statement. He further examined Nirmal Singh to corrborate the statement of Sat Pal. Both these witnesses have been allowed to be examined. The controversy however was pertaining to the three official witnesses, namely: 3. Reader to ACP/Tilak Nagar. With special report on file where in which while making special report that ACP had mentioned that on 2.10.00 when I visited to attend the call of PCR Darpna and other concealed the facts knownly and did not tell me about any injury sustained by Darpna & similarly did not offer herself for medical examination. 4.HC Jai Kishan No.320/W P.S. Anand Parbat. He will depose that earlier he enquired into D.D. No.34 dt. 7.8.2000 P.P. Tilak Vihar in which Darpna refused to make any Complaining statement against Parivar Singh.

5. M.H.C.(R) P.S. Tilak Ngr. With FIR No.826/2000. He will prove that the Challan of the case has been put to Court & Ct. Hoshyiar Singh is a P.W. at serial No.____. He will identity the writing of Insp. J.L.Meena, the statement of said P.W. in his statement u/s 161 Cr. P.C.

10. We do not dispute the right of the inquiry officer to reject the evidence which is irrelevant and incompetent. The evidence may not be relevant for the department but for the defence, it could be relevant. Therefore, the plea as such cannot be rejected because the official witnesses referred to above were to be examined to show that the applicant attended the call of the PCR and had visited the spot. He was not told about any injury. He also wanted Head Constable Jai Kishan to be examined so as to prove that Darpana had refused to make any statement and the three witnesses M.H.C. (R) P.S. Tilak Nagar to state that the challan had put in Court.

11. It cannot be stated that in the peculiar facts, that statements were totally irrelevant.

12. On behalf of the respondents, it was pointed that these witnesses were not produced. We have no hesitation in rejecting this particular plea and refer with advantage to the decision of the Rajasthan High Court in the case of DEOKI NANDAN KULSHRESHTHA v. STATE OF RAJASTHAN AND ANOTHER, 1986 (4) SLR 734. The findings read: 11. . .  The witnesses whom the petitioner wanted to produce were all government officers and it was not within the power of the petitioner to produce them on his own and they had to be summoned by the Enquiry Officer. Similarly, as the documents which the petitioner wanted to produce were in the custody of the government officers which could have been produced only by summoning the same through the Enquiry Officer. Since the request for the production of the witnesses and the documents was made by the petitioner immediately after the Enquiry Officer had recorded the statement of the petitioner on 4th January, 1971, it cannot be said that the petitioner was trying to delay the inquiry. The request of that was made by the petitioner on 19th January, 1971 for postponing the inquiry was for the reason that the petitioner was ill and that the witness and the documents may be summoned. The Enquiry Officer, in my view, was not justified in refusing the said reasonable request of the petitioner and on account of the denial by the Enquiry Officer of the request of the petitioner to adduce evidence, oral as well as documentary, in support of his defence the petitioner has been denied a reasonable opportunity to defend himself in the inquiry.

13. Identical has been the view taken by this Tribunal in the case of RAVINDER SINGH v. GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI & OTHERS, O.A. No.1125/2004, decided on 15.10.2004.

14. Taking stock of these facts, it is obvious that the applicant is justified in claiming that fair opportunity to produce the defence evidence was not granted.

15. In face of the above said findings, it becomes unnecessary to consider any other plea including as to if earlier statement could be taken into consideration in the facts and circumstances of the case or not.

16. For these reasons, the impugned orders are quashed and it is directed that the disciplinary authority, if deemed appropriate, may initiate the disciplinary proceedings from the stage PW-2 was being examined. The applicant would be entitled to all the consequential benefits. (S.A.Singh) (V.S.Aggarwal) Member (A) Chairman /NSN/