Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Raj Kumar v. Union Of India

Central Administrative Tribunal
Apr 2, 2008

Justice V.K. Bali, Chairman: MA No. 614/2008 For the reasons mentioned in MA No. 614/2008 seeking restoration of Original Application, which was dismissed in default on 21.02.2008, the same is allowed and Original Application is restored to its original number. OA No.398/2008

2. Raj Kumar, applicant herein, through present Application filed by him under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeks direction to the respondents to withdraw adverse remarks from the work and conduct report/CR bearing No. 10-8/92-RMLH(Tech)/1752 dated 23.10.2007. Inasmuch as, the applicant has not been promoted because of adverse remarks, referred to above, he, in consequence of setting aside the said adverse remarks, seeks promotion as Dark Room Assistant with effect from the date of last DPC i.e. 21.01.2008 with all consequential benefits.

3. Brief facts, as set out in the Application, reveal that the applicant joined the services in Ram Manohar Lohia Hospital as Sweeper on daily rates on 17.05.1991. His services were declared permanent vide order dated 26.04.1994. The applicant had worked in Radiology Department upto 26.02.2007 and had rich experience in the field of dark room. Head of the Department of Radiology, considering the services of the applicant, issued him two appreciation letters on 23.08.2000 and 29.06.2001. It is further the case of the applicant that from 2001 to 2005, he was declared fit for promotion. Things, however, changed thereafter as Mr. Rajan Koshi, Supervisor of Radiology Department under provocation and instigation of vested interests, harassed and tortured the applicant. He requested the Supervisor not to react on hearsay of others but he was adamant and had gone to the extent of passing extreme sarcastic castiest remarks against him for which he made a written complaint to Dr. Barua, Head of Department. He made representation to higher authority also. It is his further case that the second respondent initiated departmental enquiry in which some fake evidence was recorded which was neither relevant nor had any nexus with the incident. Without giving outcome of the enquiry aforesaid, the applicant was intimated by simply mentioning that Mr. Rajan Koshi was given clean chit. It is further the case of the applicant that he was harassed and mentally tortured to the extent that he became patient of hypertension and nervous break down for which he had taken treatment from the hospital. The attending doctor advised him admission and consequently he was admitted, but Mr. Rajan Koshi took the concerned doctor in his confidence and treatment of the applicant was stopped. Guessing ill motives of Mr. Rajan Koshi, Supervisor and his connivance with other officials/doctors, the applicant left the hospital and took treatment from private doctor who, later on, referred the matter to Sucheta Kriplani Hospital and thereafter, after being declared fit, he approached the department for joining duty but he was denied the same. Thereafter, he made a representation and then only he could join his duty. It is his case that Mr. Rajan Koshi threatened him to destroy his life and career for no fault of his. In the DPC, which was scheduled to be held on 21.01.2008, name of the applicant was included in the list of eligible candidates but he was not given due promotion as his work and conduct report had been destroyed at the instance of Mr. Rajan Koshi, Supervisor, Radiology Department. It is further the case of the applicant that his work and conduct has always been good and it is for the first time in his 17 years of service, that adverse remarks came to be recorded in his confidential report for the year 2007 and, consequently his name was not recommended by the DPC for promotion that was held on 21.01.2008 and persons junior to him were promoted.

4. Shri Hari Prakash, learned counsel representing the applicant, has urged that record of the applicant has always been unblemished, and right upto the year 2005, comments made with regard to his work and conduct have been good or very good, and in the relevant column, it has also been mentioned that he is fit for promotion. Sudden change in the confidential report of the applicant came about only on account of animosity of Mr. Rajan Koshi, Supervisor and, therefore, adverse remarks need to be expunged and the applicant promoted.

5. We find from record of the case that when the respondents were considering promotion to the post of Dark Room Assistants, they required concerned authority to issue a certificate in respect of Group D employees. The information supplied on 22.03.2007 Annexure A-5 with regard to the applicant, reads as follows:-

(i) Whether you consider the candidate fit for promotion to the post of Dark Room Assistant Not fit for promotion

(ii) The overall grading of the candidate keeping in view of the quality of his work Below Average

(iii) General behaviour and conduct of the candidate Insubordination, threatening to superiors and colleagues, Rude behaviour with patients. We also find from record, as is the case of the applicant also, that the complaint made by him against Mr. Rajan Koshi was enquired into and was found to be baseless. Order dated 15.11.2007 to that effect has been placed on record as well by the applicant himself at Annexure A-4. It is admitted position that Mr. Rajan Koshi, Supervisor was not the reporting authority of the applicant. There is no averment made in the Application that Mr. Rajan Koshi influenced the reporting authority of the applicant to give him adverse remarks. There is noting on record to suggest that reporting authority of the applicant had reasons to be influenced by Mr. Rajan Koshi. The applicant has not even chosen to implead Mr. Rajan Koshi as party respondent in present Application. The mere fact that the applicant had good service record does not mean that his conduct and performance shall always remain good. There is no dearth of cases of employees who may fall from standards of efficiency and honesty despite their work & conduct and good performance earlier in point of time. The allegations made by the applicant against Mr. Rajan Koshi had been the subject matter of enquiry and the same were held baseless. The very basis of the case of the applicant that adverse remarks in his confidential report came to be recorded because of animosity of Mr. Rajan Koshi has no legs to stand. No mala fide has been alleged against the reporting authority of the applicant.

5. We find no merit in present Application and the same is dismissed in limine. (L.K. Joshi) (V.K. Bali) Vice Chairman (A) Chairman /naresh/