- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bhagirath Lal v. Union Of India
Mr. Shanker Raju, Member (J): Though delay defeats justice, but a juxtaposition should also be avoided under the rule of law to throw at the outset a meritorious claim, when on discretion the Court is bound to liberally construe limitation, as ruled by the Apex Court in A. Mohan Lodh Vs. State of Tripura, 2004 SCC (L&S) 10.
2. Also held in Divisional Manager Vs. Mannu Barrick, 2005 SCC (L&S) 200, that when serious question of law is involved, delay is to be condoned.
3. Also held in State of Bihar Vs. Kameshwar Prasad Singh, 2001 (1) SLJ SC 76, that the delay when explained and does not smack of malafide or dilatory tactics, on sufficient cause to dispense justice, the Court must show utmost consideration in condoning the delay.
4. Applicant an Ex-Sub Postmaster by virtue of this OA impugns an order dated 31.1.2001 passed in pursuant to disciplinary proceedings whereby a penalty of removal from service has been inflicted upon him. Also assailed is an order passed in revision on 21.6.2003, whereby the penalty has been upheld and also an order passed by the reviewing authority dated 23.032005 whereby the punishment of removal has been upheld.
5. While working as SPM Dubladhan, Rohtak (Haryana), applicant has been proceeded against for a major penalty on the ground of misappropriation of public money and also making forged signature of the depositor by committing fraud. Simultaneously the applicant has also been involved in a criminal case vide FIR No.151 dated 20.07.2000 under section 409/420 IPC. The enquiry officer on the basis of evidence, held applicant guilty of the charge, which when represented against, results in penalty of removal. Though no appeal was preferred, yet we find from the record of the respondents the appellate order passed on 06.09.2002. After rejection of the revision and review applicant filed the present OA.
6. In the criminal prosecution, Judicial Magistrate 1st Class Jhajjhar, vide judgment dated 18.05.2005 after taking cognizance of the alleged confession of the applicant in the disciplinary proceedings, as the prosecution has miserably failed to establish the guilt of the accused, acquitted him of the charges. The aforesaid fact by the time the review petition was disposed of, could not have been brought to the notice of the respondents, but was brought to the notice of the postal authorities and through the Minister of State for communication, non-consideration of his request was communicated.
7. Learned counsel of the applicant Shri D.P. Sharma, at the outset, states that applicants statement made on 08.11.2000 was a conditional one, which could not have been relied upon and as the enquiry despite this statement has been proceeded against with examination of witnesses subsequently it cannot be taken into consideration. Learned counsel also states that once applicant has been acquitted, he cannot be subjected to a departmental punishment.
8. On the other hand, Shri K.R. Sachdeva, learned counsel of the respondents vehemently opposed the contentions and stated that the MA filed by the applicant for condonation of delay of about two years and six months is based on flimsy grounds and as the applicant has not even exhausted the remedy of appeal, on the basis of evidence adduced in the enquiry and more particularly his confession dated 8.11.2000, punishment inflicted upon the applicant is not only in accordance with the procedure but also, is proportionate to the charges levelled.
9. As regards criminal proceedings, it is stated that the proceedings are distinguishable.
10. We have carefully considered the rival contentions of the parties and perused the material on record.
11. In the MA filed by the applicant for condonation of delay, applicant states that on completion of 30 years of service when he was at the fag end of his service he was removed and went in depression and without financial assistance he could not have filed the OA. But it is stated that the case is good on merits.
12. In our considered view, as supported by the decisions of the Apex Court (supra), and as per the decision of the Apex Court in Madras Port Trust Vs. Himanshu International, 1979 (4) SCC 176 in the matter of limitation, technical plea is to be avoided by the Government. The grounds adduced with the background of the substantive point of law involved and a meritorious claim, using our discretion by liberally construing the provisions of limitation. Also balancing the pros and cons, as the punishment of removal after 30 years of service is imposed, we condone the delay by allowing the MA.
13. Though disciplinary and criminal proceedings are on different context but in a given case when the allegations levelled in the departmental enquiry and the material relied upon is also forming part of the criminal prosecution and the allegations in the criminal case are founded on grave and complicated question of facts and law, the trite law warrants holding the enquiry in abeyance till the final outcome of the criminal case, yet when a finding of acquittal is recorded by a judicial body, where the evidence is scanned in a very strict manner, in the light of the procedural rules of criminal law as well as Indian Evidence Act, 1872, the finding recording therein by no stretch could be overridden by a finding recorded on preponderance of probability by a quasi judicial authority. However, the exception is when the charges are different in both the proceedings. The Apex Court in Managing Director S.D. of Hyderabad and another Vs. P. Kata Rao, 2008 (6) SCALE 575, when confronted with the identical situation, taking stock of plethora of decisions ruled that when a person is acquitted of an identical offence constituted by common facts, he should not be punished departmentally. The Apex Court in Union of India Vs. Naman Singh Shekhawat, 2008 (4) SCALE 360, ruled as under:-
30. In Ajit Kumar Nag vs. General Manager (PJ), Indian Oil Corporation Ltd., Haldia and others : (2005) 7 SCC 764 this court opined that acquittal of a delinquent by a criminal court would not preclude an employer from taking action by the disciplinary authority, if it is otherwise permissible. Such a departmental proceeding, however, cannot be initiated mala fide. It must be conducted in accordance with law. An acquittal of a delinquent ipso facto may not absolve him from undergoing disciplinary inquiry. However, where the charges are absolutely identical, ordinarily the same would not be taken resorted to. We may notice that in Ajit Kumar Nag (supra) the order of dismissal was found to have been legally proved despite the fact that the delinquent was acquitted by the court of law. If the Inquiry Officer is biased, no action could have been be taken on the basis thereof. It renders the proceeding a nullity. Such an inherent defect in the disciplinary proceeding cannot be cured by an order of the appellate authority. An order which is void cannot be validated by the appellate authority as the materials which were not brought on record could not be taken into consideration by it. In Ajit Kumar Nag (supra) it was held :- "44. We are aware of the normal rule that a person must have a fair trial and a fair appeal and he cannot be asked to be satisfied with an unfair trial and a fair appeal. We are also conscious of the general principle that pre-decisional hearing is better and should always be preferred to post- decisional hearing. We are further aware that it has been stated that apart from Laws of Men, Laws of God also observe the rule of audi alteram partem. It has been stated that the first hearing in human history was given in the Garden of Eden. God did not pass sentence upon Adam and Eve before giving an opportunity to show cause as to why they had eaten forbidden fruit. [See R. v. University of Cambridge]. But we are also aware that principles of natural justice are not rigid or immutable and hence they cannot be imprisoned in a straight-jacket. They must yield to and change with exigencies of situations. They must be confined within their limits and cannot be allowed to run wild. It has been stated ; "To do a great right after all, it is permissible sometimes to do a little wrong".
31. Reliance has also been placed on Commissioner of Police, New Delhi vs. Narender Singh : (2006) 4 SCC 265 wherein this Court was dealing with a case of a police constable, who was accused of committing theft of arms. He made a confession of his involvement. It was found to be inadmissible in the criminal proceeding. In that factual backdrop this Court held :- "12. It is not in dispute that the standard of proof required in recording a finding of conviction in a criminal case and in a departmental proceeding are distinct and different. Whereas in a criminal case, it is essential to prove a charge beyond all reasonable doubt, in a departmental proceeding reponderance of probability would serve the purpose. [See Kamaladevi Agarwal v. State of W.B.].
13. It is now well-settled by reason of a catena of decisions of this Court that if an employee has been acquitted of a criminal charge, the same by itself would not be a ground not to initiate a departmental proceeding against him or to drop the same in the event an order of acquittal is passed. "
32. It is not a case where a mere benefit of doubt had been given to the respondent in the criminal proceeding. The criminal court has given a positive finding that the prosecution has not been able to prove that the accused had misappropriated the goods. His visit to the border for discharging his duties did not tantamount to misuse of the post or the authority. No evidence has been presented that he did not have the authority to go to the border side on official duties and even the department had not forbidden him from going to that place. It was held that as misappropriation of the property has not been proved, the question of any criminal conspiracy did not arise. No evidence had been adduced to bring home the charge of criminal conspiracy, which is an independent crime.
33. Respondent was found to have been carrying the official revolver for his safety. No evidence was also adduced to establish that when confronted by the police party, he had tried to show or used the same or threatened them with the same or used the official revolver with the intention of doing illegal work. That the respondent was allotted a jeep and also allowed to carry with him the official revolver, was accepted by the prosecution side in the criminal case, and thus, he was found not guilty under Section 27 of the Arms Act.
34. In Sawai Singh vs. State of Rajasthan : (1986) 3 SCC 454 this Court opined :- "16 . But in a departmental enquiry entailing consequences like loss of job which now-a-days means loss of livelihood, there must be fair play in action, in respect of an order involving adverse or penal consequences against an employee, there must be investigations to the charges consistent with the requirement of the situation in accordance with the principles of natural justice in so far as these are applicable in a particular situation.
17. The application of those principles of natural justice must always be in conformity with the scheme of the Act and the subject matter of the case. It is not possible to lay down any rigid rules as to which principle of natural justice is to be applied. There is no such thing as technical natural justice. The requirements of natural justice depend upon the facts and circumstances of the case, the nature of the enquiry, the rules under which the Tribunal is acting, the subject matter to be dealt with and so on. Concept of fair play in action which is the basis of natural justice must depend upon the particular lis between the parties."
35. In Jasbir Singh vs. Punjab & Sind Bank and others : 2006 (11) SCALE 204 it was held :- "7 The learned counsel for the respondent contended that the decision of this Court has no application. He may be right. But, it is not necessary for us to delve deep into the matter as we are of the opinion that the judgment in civil matter having attained finality, the same was binding on Respondent-Bank."
36. In M.V. Bijlani vs. Union of India and others : (2006) 8 SCC 8 this Court st ated the law in the following terms :- "25. .Although the charges in a departmental proceedings are not required to be proved like a criminal trial, i.e., beyond all reasonable doubts, we cannot lose sight of the fact that the Enquiry Officer performs a quasi-judicial function, who upon analysing the documents must arrive at a conclusion that there had been a preponderance of probability to prove the charges on the basis of materials on record. While doing so, he cannot take into consideration any irrelevant fact. He cannot refuse to consider the relevant facts. He cannot shift the burden of proof. He cannot reject the relevant testimony of the witnesses only on the basis of surmises and conjectures. He cannot enquire into the allegations with which the delinquent officer had not been charged with." In this case, evidence of Mool Singh is totally against the department. He was not cross-examined. It was not held that he had deposed falsely.
37. For the abovesaid reasons, there is no infirmity in the impugned judgment. The appeal fails and is accordingly dismissed.
14. Having regard to the above, non-consideration of the acquittal by the departmental authorities amounts to non-application of mind and would not be a valid consideration in the eyes of law, as ruled by the Apex Court in Bikhubhai Vithlabhai Patel & Ors. Vs. State of Gujrat and another 2008 (4) SCALE 278.
15. Coming to the facts of the case while the Judicial Magistrate 1st Class acquitting the applicant has specifically recorded a finding of his not being guilty on failure of the prosecution to establish the ingredients of offence against the applicant. Moreover, when confronted with the departmental enquiry report, i.e., the alleged confession, the same has not been taken into consideration, as the departmental proceedings are based on preponderance of probability where strict proof as per the Indian Evidence Act is the Rule in criminal trial.
16. The revision and the review preferred by the applicant when confronted the department with the acquittal of applicant, non-consideration of his representation cannot be countenanced in law. This is in derogation of the ratio laid down by the Apex Court. Moreover, the allegations levelled against the applicant in the disciplinary proceedings were forming basis of the charge framed in the criminal prosecution. Once a definite judicial finding has been recorded on the same charges, the punishment arrived at in departmental proceedings has to be overridden and be over-ruled by the judicial pronouncement.
17. As regards alleged confession of applicant dated 8.11.2000, on perusal though there is an admission of alleged deviation in the discharge of duties by the applicant, yet an explanation has been tendered by him to justify it.
18. In order to be a valid confession in law, it has to be unequivocal, unconditional and absolute one. As the confession was with an explanation, it does not qualify to be a valid confession and for this we rely upon the decision of the Apex Court in Jagdish Prasad Saxena Vs. State of Madhya Bharat, AIR 1961 SC 1070.
19. Resultantly, OA stands disposed of with a direction to the reviewing authority to re-examine the contentions of applicant and the factum of his being acquitted from the offence of which he has been charged as a misconduct in the disciplinary proceedings, in the light of our observations and also keeping in mind the binding law declared by the Apex Court under Article 141 of the Constitution of India by passing a speaking order within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order. No costs. (Dr. Ramesh Chandra Panda) (Shanker Raju) Member (A) Member (J) San.
Alert