- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Suresh Kumar v. Union Of India
Shri Shanker Raju: The cut-off date set out by the Government on administrative side is their prerogative. However, in judicial review, this can be interfered with if it is per se arbitrary and irrational. It is also trite law that a cut-off date either should be specified in the rules or in the advertisement and if it is not mentioned therein, then the last date of submission of application should be the cut-off date, on which date the candidate should possess the requisite eligibility criteria.
2. In the above backdrop, applicant, who appeared in the Limited Departmental Competitive Examination 2008 (LDCE 2008) for the post of Junior Engineer (Civil) in the CPWD and was not possessing diploma in Civil Engineering as on 30.12.2007, which he possessed subsequently in September 2008, has challenged fixation of date of 31.12.2007 in the notice of examination for possession of diploma in Civil Engineering.
3. As per the rules of LDCE for the post of Junior Engineer (Civil & Electrical) in CPWD, no cut-off date has been mentioned as a past practice in any of the notification issued and the last date of submission of application form was set out as a cut-off date. This has held good for the notification issued by the respondents in 2007 for the post of Junior Engineer (Civil & Electrical). However, in the notification issued on 5.9.2008 in clause 3, the cut-off date as on 31.12.2007 has been set out with following stipulations: 3. The examination will be open to the employees (work charge / regular) working in CPWD and possessing diploma or any higher qualification in Civil/Electrical/Mechanical Engineering from an Institute recognized by the Central Government or equivalent qualification as on 31.12.2007 and who have joined on or before 1.1.2000 in the Department and have a minimum of five years qualifying service as on 1.1.2005 shall be eligible to appear in the examination. However, after the examination, merit list based on aggregate marks finally awarded to each candidate will be prepared separately in the respective discipline (i.e. Civil / Electrical).
4. Applicant applied for the post with requisite proof of educational / technical qualifications on 30.9.2008 before the last date of submission of the application form, which was 30.10.2008. However, on 21.10.2008, applicants candidature was rejected.
5. Learned counsel for applicant would challenge the cut-off date on the ground that earlier in LDCE 2008, no cut-off date was prescribed and as a past practice earlier also, the cut-off date was always the last date for submission of the application forms. As such adoption of this criteria without any justification is arbitrary and irrational.
6. Learned counsel would also contend that LDCE 2008 is held for the vacancy years 2005-2006, as such the applicant has been discriminated in the matter of cut-off date with his counterparts of 2007 batch.
7. Learned counsel would also contend that under the rules of examination, as no amendment has been carried out, the cut-off date prescribed is against the rules.
8. Learned counsel has also stated that the cut-off date, i.e., 31.12.2007, is not based on any intelligible differentia having reasonable nexus with an object sought to be achieved. As such the same is unreasonable.
9. Learned counsel by quoting examples of two candidates, namely, Shri Om Prakash and Shri Ajay Kumar, who acquired the requisite qualifications only in 2008, issue of admit cards to them has been projected as an invidious discrimination violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India.
10. On the other hand, learned counsel for respondents vehemently opposed the contentions and stated that LDCE 2008 being open to the employees (work charge/regular) working in CPWD, possession of diploma as on 31.12.2007 was the valid criteria.
11. It is also stated that issuance of admit cards to Shri Om Prakash and Shri Ajay Kumar, though they did not possess the diploma on 31.12.2007 but having appeared in the final examination before the above crucial date, they have been issued admit cards.
12. In pursuance of an interim order dated 31.10.2008, applicant was allowed to appear provisionally in the departmental examination, which was to be held on 9.11.2008 but the results have been withheld subject to the outcome of the OA.
13. Learned counsel for respondents relied upon the decision of the High Court in Mrs. Ravita & others v. M.C.D. & another (WP (C) No.6466/2008) decided on 18.11.2008 where a cut-off date fixed has been found to be apt in law and not being arbitrary was upheld.
14. We have carefully considered the rival contentions of the parties and perused the material placed on record.
15. Insofar as the cut-off date is concerned, the Apex Court in Ashok Kumar Sonkar v. Union of India & others, (2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 19 while referring to 3-Judge Bench decision in Ashok Kumar Sharma v. Chander Shekhar, (1997) 4 SCC 18, on a reference, following has been observed: "(1) Whether the view taken by the majority (Honble Dr Thommen and V. Ramaswami, JJ.) that it is enough for a candidate to be qualified by the date of interview even if he was not qualified by the last date prescribed for receiving the applications, is correct in law and whether the majority was right in extending the principle of Rule 37 of the Public Service Commission Rules to the present case by analogy?"
14. It was held : "So far as the first issue referred to in our Order dated 1-9-1995 is concerned, we are of the respectful opinion that majority judgment (rendered by Dr T.K. Thommen and V. Ramaswami, JJ.) is unsustainable in law. The proposition that where applications are called for prescribing a particular date as the last date for filing the applications, the eligibility of the candidates shall have to be judged with reference to that date and that date alone, is a well-established one. A person who acquires the prescribed qualification subsequent to such prescribed date cannot be considered at all. An advertisement or notification issued/published calling for applications constitutes a representation to the public and the authority issuing it is bound by such representation. It cannot act contrary to it. One reason behind this proposition is that if it were known that persons who obtained the qualifications after the prescribed date but before the date of interview would be allowed to appear for the interview, other similarly placed persons could also have applied. Just because some of the persons had applied notwithstanding that they had not acquired the prescribed qualifications by the prescribed date, they could not have been treated on a preferential basis. Their applications ought to have been rejected at the inception itself. This proposition is indisputable and in fact was not doubted or disputed in the majority judgment. This is also the proposition affirmed in Rekha Chaturvedi v. University of Rajasthan. The reasoning in the majority opinion that by allowing the 33 respondents to appear for the interview, the recruiting authority was able to get the best talent available and that such course was in furtherance of public interest is, with respect, an impermissible justification. It is, in our considered opinion, a clear error of law and an error apparent on the face of the record. In our opinion, R.M. Sahai, J. (and the Division Bench of the High Court) was right in holding that the 33 respondents could not have been allowed to appear for the interview.
15. The said decision is, therefore, an authority for the proposition that in absence of any cut-off date specified in the advertisement or in the rules, the last date for filing of an application shall be considered as such.
16. The Apex Court in Shankar K. Mandal & others v. State of Bihar & others, (2003) 9 SCC 519 has that if there is no cut-off date appointed by the rules, then such date shall be appointed for the purpose in the advertisement calling for the applications and if there is no such appointed date, then the eligibility criteria shall be applied by reference to the last date appointed by which the applications were to be received by the competent authority.
17. In State of T.N. v. Seshachalam, 2008 (1) SCC (L&S) 475, the Apex Court ruled that merely because a cut-off date has been fixed per se cannot be said to be arbitrary, as some date is required to be fixed for that purpose. Though the cut-off date when does not pass the twin test of Article 14 of the Constitution of India, has been held to be arbitrary in the light of Constitution Bench decision of Apex Court in D.S. Nakara & others v. Union of India, 1983 SCC (L&S) 145. However, in a subsequent decision in K.S. Krishnaswamy etc. v. Union of India & another, (2006) 13 SCC 215, the decision in D.S. Nakaras case (supra) was not found to be applicable.
18. If one has regard to the above, when inequality found in treatment, though merely because a cut-off date is prejudicial to a person, as if one is falling on other side of the cut-off date would not per se declare as arbitrary.
19. In Council of Scientific & Industrial Research & others v. Ramesh Chandra Agrawal & another, 2009 (1) SCC (L&S) 547 on fixation of cut-off date and examination in judicial review, the Apex Court ruled as under:- 29. A `State' is entitled to fix a cut off date. Such a decision can be struck down only when it is arbitrary. Its invalidation may also depend upon the question as to whether it has a rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved. 2.5.1997 was the date fixed as the cut off date in terms of the scheme. The reason assigned therefor was that this was the date when this Court directed the appellants to consider framing of a regularization scheme. They could have picked up any other date. They could have even picked up the date of the judgment passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal. As rightly contended by Mr. Patwalia, by choosing 2.5.1997 as the cut off date, no illegality was committed. Ex facie, it cannot be said to be arbitrary.
30. The High Court, however, proceeded on the basis that the cut off date should have been the date of issuance of the notification. The employer in this behalf has a choice. Its discretion can be held to be arbitrary but then the High Court only with a view to show sympathy to some of the candidates could not have fixed another date, only because according to it, another date was more suitable. In law it was not necessary. The court's power of judicial review in this behalf although exists but is limited in the sense that the impugned action can be struck down only when it is found to be arbitrary. It is possible that by reason of such a cut off date an employee misses his chance very narrowly. Such hazards would be there in all the services. Only because it causes hardship to a few persons or a section of the employees may not by itself be a good ground for directing fixation of another cut off date.
31. The scheme was a one-time measure. The number of posts was not confined to the posts which have been sanctioned. The validity of the scheme has been challenged as unrealistic, illusive, arbitrary or unworkable. We may at this juncture notice that whereas the Tribunal directed framing of a scheme, this Court directed the appellants to consider the same.
32. Cut off date has been fixed for those who are eligible as per the criteria laid down by the scheme. The service rules were framed in terms of the bye-laws of the society. It would bear repetition to state that the Appellant 1 is not a statutory authority. It is a research oriented-organization. It knows its needs. The research fellows and research associates because of their involvement in the research work are to get priority in their appointments. Particular projects whether funded by the Ministry concerned or others would depend upon the nature thereof. It, by a judicial fiat, could not have been made a continuous scheme.
33. Indisputably, a policy decision is not beyond the pale of judicial review. But, the court must invalidate a policy on some legal principles. It can do so, inter alia, on the premise that it is wholly irrational and not otherwise. The contention of the respondents that only two chances are granted for consideration of the candidature of the employees for the purpose of regularization is, in our opinion, misconceived. The scheme being a one-time measure, even one opportunity could have been granted.
20. What discerns from the above that if hardship is caused to one, it may not be a good ground for directing fixation of another cut-off date.
21. With the above position of law, we cannot, simply because a cut-off date has been set out by the respondents, declare it illegal or irrational, as it has prejudiced, yet it is not to be forgotten that fixation of cut-off date is also dependant on the rules, like in the present case for LDCE where no cut-off date is stipulated. However, this does not impede or foreclose the right of the respondents to prescribe the cut-off date in the examination held in LDCE 2008. The cut-off date for the vacancies is fixed as 31.12.2007 and the only justification comes forth for fixing such a cut-off date by the respondents is that when work-charge / regular employees working in CPWD are made eligible to apply in LDCE, the diploma qualification should be made out as on 31.12.2007 and those who have joined on or before 1.1.2000 with five years qualifying service, as on 1.1.2005, shall be eligible to appear in the examination. We do not find any intelligible differentia having reasonable nexus with an object sought to be achieved in fixing such a cut-off date.
22. Moreover, as a model employer, the respondents cannot appropriate and reprobate simultaneously. Having set out the cut-off date as 31.12.2007, their decision to issue admit cards to Shri Om Prakash and Shri Ajay Kumar when they were not possessing the diploma on the crucial date, i.e., 31.12.2007 and have admittedly acquired certificate in June 2008, yet to issue admit cards is a consideration that they have appeared in the final examination of diploma before the crucial date of 31.12.2007. This is the reason tendered to issue the admit cards, which is an example of irrationality and discrimination whereby the respondents have not adhered to their own cut-off date. This cut-off date has been prescribed not only against the rules but also without any object sought to be achieved. This, to our considered view, is not only irrational but also arbitrary, as past practice, which has partaken the character of rule, has not been followed. It should have been the last date of submission of application and if it is so, applicant was eligible. However, if this date is declared as irrational, a cascading effect would be that the others, who were eligible between 31.12.2007 and 3.10.2008, would also assail their rejection and this would unsettle the settled position.
23. We are concerned with only those who have come before us for redressal and in such view of the matter, we do not find distinguishing feature between Shri Om Prakash and Shri Ajay Kumar, who are still to be qualified on the cut-off date, yet they were issued admit cards. This is not the stand of the respondents that they have been given illegally, so that we can hold that the applicant is seeking negative equality, which is not the concept under Article 14 of the Constitution. Applicant being identically situated should also have been meted out the same treatment, failing which it would be an invidious discrimination and infraction to Article 14 of the Constitution.
24. Resultantly, OA is allowed. Impugned order is set aside. Applicant be declared as deemed eligible. The result kept in abeyance be declared and if he is qualified, he be considered for the post of Junior Engineer (Civil) in LDCE 2008 with all consequences in law. No costs. ( Dr. Veena Chhotray ) ( Shanker Raju ) Member (A) Member (J) /sunil/
Alert