- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bam Bahadur Pal v. Union Of India
Shri Shanker Raju: Heard the parties counsel.
2. Automobile Association of Upper India (AAUI) provides casual workers as Driver to the respondents. In one of the decisions in Dharmender Hooda v. Union of India & others (OA-2824/2004) decided on 26.10.2005, it has been ruled that the relationship between the Drivers provided by AAUI and the requisitioning authority is not of master and servant relationship.
3. In the above backdrop, learned counsel for applicant would insist upon calling of records to see the real intent and reason behind the termination of applicant.
4. Applicant, who has been requisitioned from AAUI as Driver on casual basis, having not performed satisfactorily, his services have been dispensed with.
5. Learned counsel, in this backdrop, states that despite five sanctioned posts of Staff Car Drivers, respondents are not continuing the applicant and the persons with lesser stay have been retained.
6. Learned counsel also contends that the income tax has also been deducted from his salary, which clearly shows that the discrimination has been meted out to the applicant in violation of Articles, 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India.
7. In our considered view, after the decision of the Constitution Bench of Apex Court in Secretary, State of Karnataka & others v. Umadevi & others,(2006) 4 SCC 1, regularization of a casual worker is not the legal mode to be appointed in government service. The only exception is that the casual worker having continued on being irregularly appointed for more than ten years.
8. In the instant case, services of the applicant, which were requisitioned from AAUI, a non-governmental organization, are akin to the contract, though the nomenclature is casual worker.
9. In the above backdrop, applicant when has not performed, it is the discretion of the respondents vested in law to dispense with the services and to take services from AAUI. Insofar as the filling up the sanctioned posts are concerned, as and when the posts are notified by the Department, nothing precludes the applicant, if he fulfills the eligibility, to apply for the same, for which law shall take its own course.
10. In such a situation, regularization of daily wager on contract service when requisitioned from an outside authority is out of question, as ruled by the Apex Court in Ram Singh v. U.T. of Chandigarh & others, 2004 (1) SC SLJ 322 and State of Haryana v. Charan Singh, 2006 (1) SC SLJ 1.
11. In the light of above, having no indefeasible right to be continued till regular appointment is made by the respondents, OA is found bereft of merit, which is accordingly dismissed. No costs. ( Dr. Veena Chhotray ) ( Shanker Raju ) Member (A) Member (J) /sunil/
Alert