Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sudhanshu Paliwal v. Union Of India

Central Administrative Tribunal
Mar 8, 2010

Justice V. K. Bali, Chairman: Sudhanshu Paliwal, the applicant herein, sequel to a departmental enquiry conducted against him, has been visited with the major penalty of compulsory retirement, vide order dated 2.2.2007. He has filed the present Original Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking a direction to be issued to the respondents to calculate his qualifying service in terms of FR-54 read with rule 27 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, and to direct the respondents to fix his pay upon compulsory retirement after re-calculating qualifying service, as also to fix his pension and release his post-retiral dues.

2. There would be no need to give facts in all their minute details, as surely and admittedly, during pendency of the present Application, the applicant has been made over his post-retiral dues and pension as well. The surviving dispute is only with regard to calculating the service of the applicant from 4.12.2000 to 2.2.2007 for purposes of fixing his pension. Whereas, it has been the case of the applicant that despite the fact that the disciplinary authority while imposing the penalty of compulsory retirement upon him, had clearly mentioned that the period of his unauthorized absence from duty with effect from 4.12.2000 till the date of issue of the order would be treated as dies non without break in service for purposes of grant of pensionary benefits in terms of rule 27 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, the respondents are yet deducting the said period for fixing his pension. In the counter reply filed on behalf of the respondents, it has inter alia been mentioned in para 4.8 the total qualifying service for pension purposes has been calculated under provisions of the Pension Rules, and the same has been authenticated by the Pay and Accounts Officer, whereas in para 4.10 it has been pleaded that the qualifying service for pension purposes has been calculated as per Pension Rules and the period w.e.f. 4.12.2000 to 2.2.2007 stood dies non and hence, would not qualify for pensionary purposes.

3. When the matter came up before us for hearing on 12.11.2009, there was a confusion as to the period as mentioned above for being calculated for fixing pension or not. That being so, we recorded the following order on the said date: The only surviving dispute in the present case is as to whether respondents have calculated the service of the applicant from 4.12.2000 to 2.02.2007 for the purpose of pension. We may mention here that in departmental enquiry applicant was compulsorily retired and the period of absence, as mentioned above, was treated as dies non without break in service for which pension shall be paid to the applicant. Counsel for the applicant states that pension has been worked out while deducting the period mentioned above. Counsel for respondents states that the said period has been included. In the reply filed by the respondents there is no mention with regard to period mentioned above. Counsel for respondents will file an additional affidavit to clarify the position. List on 30.11.2009. The respondents have filed an additional affidavit pursuant to our order as reproduced above, wherein it is now admitted in clear terms that the period from 4.12.2000 to 2.2.2007 has not been counted towards qualifying service for pension in view of directions of the disciplinary authority that the period of the unauthorized absence of the applicant with effect from 4.12.2000 till the date of issue of the order would be treated as dies non.

4. Having heard the learned counsel representing the parties and examined the records of the case with their assistance, we are of the view that once the disciplinary authority in the same very order whereby the applicant was visited with the major penalty of compulsory retirement, had clearly recorded that the period of his unauthorized absence from duty with effect from 4.12.2000 till the date of issue of this order shall be treated as DIES NON without break in service for the purpose of grant of pensionary benefits in terms of Rule 27 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, it would not be permissible for the respondents to deduct the said period for purposes of fixing pension of the applicant. The learned counsel representing the applicant for the proposition that an employee even in a case of unauthorized absence, in certain circumstances, would be entitled to count the said period for pension, has relied upon a judgment of the Honble High Court of Delhi in the matter of DTC & Another v Satya Pal Singh & Another [LPA No.1737/2006 decided on 11.8.2006], wherein it has been held that a reading of Rule 27 of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 indicates that an authorized leave of absence, which would naturally include in certain circumstances leave without pay, and in certain circumstances, even unauthorized absence in continuation of authorized leave of absence so long the post of absentee is not filled substantively, are all to be reckoned as constituting part of the qualifying service. Thus, in terms of Rule 27, such periods are not to be excluded for computing the period of qualifying service. It appears to us that we need not go into any other question inasmuch as, when the order itself states that the period of unauthorized absence would be counted for purposes of pensionary benefits, even though the said period may have been treated as dies non, the applicant would be entitled to pension including the period of his unauthorized absence. Learned counsel representing the respondents has not even mentioned that there is a flaw in the order. Assuming to be so, as long as the flaw is not removed, if permissible under law, the respondents would have no choice but for to fix the pension of the applicant for the total service rendered by him including the period as mentioned above.

5. In view of the observations made above, we allow this Application with direction to the respondents to re-calculate the pension of the applicant by including the period aforesaid in his total service, as expeditiously as possible and preferably within a period of six weeks from today, and disburse the arrears to the applicant that may be due to him within next two weeks. There shall, however, be no order as to costs. ( L. K. Joshi ) ( V. K. Bali ) Vice-Chairman (A) Chairman /as/