- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ved M. Rao v. Secretary, Ministry Of Information & Broadcasting
Justice V. K. Bali, Chairman: Smt. Ved M. Rao, the applicant herein, who has since superannuated, has filed this Original Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking to set aside order dated 25.5.2010 as also order dated 15.3.2010, vide which her ACRs for the years 1998-99 and 1999-2000 have not been upgraded, and her representation in that regard has been dismissed.
2. We may mention at the very outset that the primary plea that has been raised in support of the present Application is that the ACRs referred to above, which contained the overall grading of the applicant as good only, which is below benchmark, for not having been communicated, as also for the reason that both the reporting and the reviewing officers have since retired, need to be ignored. Counsel representing the applicant in his endeavour to seek the relief as mentioned above, would place reliance upon the judgments of the Honble Supreme Court, the Honble High Court as also of this Tribunal, but is confronted with the inter partes judgment of the Honble High Court of Delhi in WP(C) 14677-79/2006, wherein the only direction given to the respondents is to consider the representation of the applicant dated 6.2.2009 for upgrading her ACRs for the years 1998-99 and 1999-2000, and to decide the representation within a period of two months from the date of the order. It has further been observed in the order aforesaid that if, upon consideration of representation of the applicant (respondent before the High Court), her ACRs were to be upgraded, the petitioner would hold a review DPC and she would be entitled to all benefits, if any, as a result of the review DPC. It is an inter partes judgment and the learned counsel representing the respondents would contend that irrespective of the settled law on the issues, the parties shall be bound by the same, particularly when the directions given by this Tribunal in the earlier OA filed by the applicant were to ignore the said ACRs, but the Honble High Court only directed decision on representation.
3. The undisputed facts of the case as may need necessary mention to comment upon and determine the controversy as raked by the learned counsel representing the parties, as mentioned above, reveal that in October, 2004 a DPC was held to regularise the ad hoc appointments in Junior Administrative Grade (JAG) and the name of the applicant did not figure in the list of persons regularized. Constrained under the circumstances, the applicant immediately made a representation on 21.10.2004 followed by several other representations/reminders against her non-consideration for regularization in JAG of Programme Production Cadre of Doordarshan, Indian Broadcasting (Programme) Service. When the entreaties of the applicant brought no tangible result, she filed an Original Application bearing OA No.2601/2004 in this Tribunal, which, vide order dated 9.8.2005 came to be disposed of with direction to the respondents to hold review DPC to consider the claim of the applicant in accordance with law and to exclude the uncommunicated remarks which were below benchmark, and inasmuch as, the applicant had in the meanwhile been reverted at the same time when she was not regularized, further direction came to be issued by the Tribunal that till the exercise as ordained above was completed, the applicant would not be reverted. Aggrieved of the order passed by this Tribunal, the respondents filed writ petition WP(C) No.14677-79/2006 in the High Court of Delhi. Meanwhile, all the juniors of the applicant who were promoted to JAG on regular basis vide order dated 12.10.2004 were granted Selection Grade (Non Functional) in the pay scale of Rs.14300-18300, vide order dated 12.12.2005. On 29.10.2007, the writ petition aforesaid was adjourned sine die with liberty to parties to get the same revived after the decision of the Honble Supreme Court in the SLP filed by the Union of India against the Full Bench decision of the High Court in J. S. Garg v Union of India & others [2002 (65) Delhi Reported Judgments 607 (FB). The appeal filed against the order aforesaid was dismissed by the Honble Supreme Court, and it is thereafter that the writ petition filed by the respondents against the order of the Tribunal in the case of the applicant was disposed of.
4. We may at this stage refer to the orders passed by this Tribunal in the first OA of the applicant against which the respondents carried writ petition in the High Court, with the result already indicated above. The ACRs of the applicant that were under consideration by the DPC in which the applicant was ignored, have been mentioned as follows: Smt. Ved M. Rao Year Remarks 1998-99 Good 1999-2000 Good 2000-2001 Outstanding 2001-2002 Outstanding 2002-2003 Very Good Admittedly, the benchmark for all the ACRs was to be very good, whereas the applicant as regards her two ACRs for the years 1998-99 and 1999-2000 had obtained the overall grading of good, while other three ACRs were either outstanding or very good. It was admitted position before the Tribunal that the downgraded ACRs which were below benchmark had not been communicated to the applicant. This Tribunal placed reliance upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in U. P. Jal Nigam & others v Prabhat Chandra Jain & others [JT 1996 (1) SC 641], and the Full Bench decision of the High Court of Delhi in J. S. Garg (supra), and held that the downgraded ACRs must be communicated, and if that had not been done, the same had to be ignored. Operative part of the order passed by the Tribunal reads as follows: 13. In the present case before us, as already referred to above, the uncommunicated remarks, which were below the benchmark, have been considered. In terms of the decisions referred to above which bind this Tribunal, the same could not have been so considered. Necessarily, it had to be ignored. That has not been done in the present case. On an earlier occasion when the matter came up before the High Court, hearing of the writ petition was adjourned sine die with liberty to parties to get the same revived after the decision of the Supreme Court in the SLP in the case of J. S. Garg (supra). When the appeal before the Supreme Court was dismissed, the writ petition filed by the respondents against the order of the Tribunal in the case of the applicant came up for disposal. The short order dated 20.7.2009 that came to be recorded in the case of the applicant, reads as follows: Both learned counsel say that this case is covered by the decision of the Supreme Court in Dev Dutt v Union of India and others, (2008) 8 SCC 725. In view of the above, the Petitioner should consider the representation made by the Respondent on 6th February, 2009 for upgrading the ACRs for the years 1998-1999 and 1999-2000. The representation be considered within a period of two months from today. If, upon consideration of representation of the Respondent, the ACRs of the Respondent are upgraded, the Petitioner will hold a review DPC and the Respondent will be entitled to all benefits, if any, as a result of the review DPC. The writ petition is disposed of in view of the above. The respondents, pursuant to directions of the Honble High Court, communicated to the applicant her ACRs for the years 1998-99 and 1999-2000, wherein the overall grading of the applicant was good which was below benchmark. The applicant has annexed communication dated 15.3.2010 in that regard with the OA as Annexure A-1A. Relevant part thereof reads as follows: ACRs for the period 1998-99 P-III (Assessment of reporting officer). Nature and quality of work:- The primary assignment of Ms Ved M Rai was planning & production of plays/serials in view of her professional qualifications & experience. But she under to-production of some music programme only, grading Good. P-V Remarks of the Reviewing Officer A Good Officer. ACR for the period 1999-2000 0 Remarks of reporting officer Grading Good. Remarks of the Reviewing officer The output, quantum or work & qualities of work may be graded as Good only. The respondents vide impugned order dated 25.5.2010 have decided not to upgrade the ACRs for the years 1998-99 and 1999-2000. The impugned order is a speaking order and gives reasons for not upgrading the ACRs of the applicant. The plea raised by the learned counsel representing the applicant is that since the ACRs of the years 1998-99 and 1999-2000 are uncommunicated and the reporting and reviewing officers have since retired, the same have to be ignored while considering promotion of the applicant, and the DPC, instead had to take into consideration two ACRs of the applicant preceding the ACRs referred to above. The counsel states that he has judicial precedents in support of the plea raised by him. We, however, find an insurmountable difficulty in the way of the applicant in granting relief to her by directing to ignore the ACRs for the years 1998-99 and 1999-2000. As fully detailed above, this Tribunal while disposing of OA No.2601/2004 of the applicant, filed first in point of time, clearly directed to ignore the uncommunicated downgraded ACRs of the applicant. This order was challenged by the respondents in the High Court with the result already indicated above. In the opening part of the order passed by the High Court it has been mentioned that the learned counsel for parties would admit that the matter was covered by the decision in Dev Dutt v Union of India & others [(2008) 8 SCC725]. The directions that came to be issued have already been adverted to above. This is an inter partes judgment and is binding upon the parties as also the Tribunal. Learned counsel representing the applicant would, however, contend that when the settled law on the issue is to ignore such ACRs, we may repeat the directions that we have given in the earlier OA of the applicant. We are of the firm view that to ask for directions so as to ignore the uncommunicated below benchmark ACRs for which both the reporting and the reviewing authorities have retired, the applicant shall have to knock at some other door. We are conscious of the fact that the plea as regards ignoring the ACRs for the reason that reporting and reviewing officers have retired, was not a subject matter of issue before the Tribunal when the earlier OA of the applicant was disposed of, but such a plea was indeed available to the applicant when the order was being passed by the High Court. It is not the case of the applicant that the reporting and reviewing officers retired after 20.7.2009 when the Honble High Court passed the order. In fact, even in the present OA there are no pleadings as to when the said officers retired. All that is mentioned is that the representation of the applicant could not be decided without taking into consideration the comments of the reporting and reviewing officers. Be that as it may, once the ultimate direction by the High Court is to consider the representation of the applicant, we cannot give a direction that the ACRs of the applicant for the years 1998-99 and 1999-2000 be ignored. Insofar as, the merit of the controversy is concerned, we may only mention that the representation of the applicant has been disposed of by a speaking order, and so as to interfere with the same, there is hardly any plea that might have been raised by the learned counsel. That apart, there is little scope for judicial review in such matters. The Apex Court in Nutan Arvind (Smt.) v Union of India & another [(1996) 2SCC 488] has dealt with such a situation and held as follows: 6. When a high level committee had considered the respective merits of the candidates assessed the grading and considered their cases for promotion, this Court cannot sit over the assessment made by the DPC as an appellate authority. The DPC would come to its own conclusion on the basis of review by an officer and whether he is or is not competent to write the confidentials is for them to decide and call for report from the proper officer. It had done that exercise and found the appellant not fit for promotion. Thus we do not find any manifest error of law for interference. In Union Public Service Commission v H. L. Dev & others [AIR 1988 SC 1069], it has been held that it is exclusively the function of the selection committee to categorize and make assessment of the concerned officers, and that it is not the function of the Court/Tribunal to hear the matter as if it is an appeal against the same.
5. In view of the discussion made above, we have no choice but for to dismiss this Original Application. Ordered accordingly. There shall, however, be no order as to costs. ( Dr. Ramesh Chandra Panda ) ( V. K. Bali ) Member (A) Chairman /as/
Alert