- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ashok Kumar Khanna v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi
Factual and Procedural Background
The applicant was directed by Memorandum No.SV/WP/421 dated 8.10.2012 to deposit Rs.50,244/- with the respondents on account of an alleged overpayment of Travel Allowance (TA). The applicant filed an Original Application (OA) under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, challenging the said Memorandum, primarily on the ground that no show cause notice was served upon him prior to the issuance of the impugned Memorandum. The respondents filed a counter reply stating that the recovery order was issued pursuant to a Department of Personnel and Training Office Memorandum dated 5.4.2010 and that the overpayment was not attributable to the applicant. The respondents acknowledged that no show cause notice was issued before the impugned Memorandum and relied on Supreme Court judgments to justify recovery of excess payments, including from retired employees, while recognizing possible hardship in such cases.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the impugned Memorandum dated 8.10.2012 directing recovery of the alleged TA overpayment was validly issued without serving a show cause notice to the applicant, thereby violating the principles of natural justice.
- Whether recovery of excess payment made to an employee, including a retired employee, is permissible even if the overpayment was not due to any fault or misrepresentation on the part of the employee.
- What is the appropriate course of action when recovery of an excess payment may cause undue hardship to the employee, particularly a retired employee.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant's Arguments
- The applicant contended that no show cause notice was served before issuing the impugned Memorandum, depriving him of an opportunity to be heard, which violates the principles of natural justice.
- He relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Bhagwan Shukla vs. Union of India, which emphasized the necessity of notice and hearing before passing orders causing financial loss to an employee.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents stated that the impugned order was issued pursuant to a government Office Memorandum and that the overpayment was not attributable to the applicant.
- They acknowledged that no show cause notice was issued before the recovery order but relied on Supreme Court precedents to assert that recovery of overpayments, even from retired employees, is legally permissible.
- The respondents cited the case of Chandi Prasad Uniyal v. State of Uttarakhand, which recognizes that recovery may cause hardship to retired employees and that leniency is warranted in such cases.
- They also cited Union of India vs. S.R. Dhingra to support the proposition that mistakes resulting in overpayment can be corrected and recovery made.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bhagwan Shukla vs. Union of India and others, Civil Appeal No.5447 of 1994 | Principle of natural justice requiring notice and opportunity of hearing before passing orders causing financial loss to employee. | The court emphasized that failure to serve show cause notice violates natural justice and invalidates recovery orders. |
| Chandi Prasad Uniyal v. State of Uttarakhand, (2012) 8 SCC 417 | Recovery of overpayment is permissible even if not attributable to employee; however, leniency may be exercised to avoid hardship to retired employees. | The court recognized the possibility of hardship in recovery from retired employees and directed lenient approach in such cases. |
| Union of India vs. S.R. Dhingra, (2008) 2 SCC 229 | Mistakes causing overpayment can be corrected; excess payments made due to clerical or other errors can be recovered. | The court applied this principle to uphold recovery of excess pension payments resulting from clerical errors. |
| Col. B.J. Akkara (retd.) case | Equity and judicial discretion may restrain recovery of excess payments to avoid undue hardship, especially where employee was unaware of overpayment. | The court cited this case to highlight circumstances where recovery may be denied to prevent hardship. |
| Syed Abdul Qadir case | Recovery of excess payments may be restrained in cases where employees had no knowledge of overpayment and recovery would cause hardship, especially near or after retirement. | The court referred to this case to support a lenient approach to recovery in the present facts. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the issue of recovery of the alleged overpayment in light of the principles of natural justice and relevant Supreme Court precedents. It observed that the impugned Memorandum was issued without serving a show cause notice, which is a clear violation of the principle of natural justice since recovery orders entail civil consequences for the employee. The court acknowledged the respondents' reliance on the Department of Personnel and Training's Office Memorandum and Supreme Court rulings permitting recovery of excess payments, even if the overpayment was not attributable to the employee. However, it emphasized that such recovery must be preceded by a fair opportunity to be heard. The court also considered the hardship that recovery might cause to the applicant, a retired employee, as highlighted in the Chandi Prasad Uniyal case and Syed Abdul Qadir case. While recognizing that excess payments of public money can generally be recovered to avoid unjust enrichment, the court underscored the need for judicial discretion and equitable considerations in cases involving retired employees. Therefore, the court quashed the impugned Memorandum but permitted the respondents to initiate recovery proceedings afresh, adhering strictly to the principles of natural justice and taking into account the possibility of hardship to the applicant.
Holding and Implications
The court quashed the impugned Memorandum dated 8.10.2012 directing recovery of Rs.50,244/- from the applicant without prior notice or opportunity of hearing.
It held that recovery of excess payments must comply with the principles of natural justice by providing a show cause notice and hearing before any recovery action is taken. The respondents are permitted to proceed with recovery in accordance with these principles and must consider the leniency recommended by the Supreme Court in cases where recovery may cause hardship, particularly to retired employees.
The decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the recovery order issued without due process but does not establish any new precedent beyond reaffirming settled legal principles on natural justice and recovery of excess payments.
Vide Memorandum No.SV/WP/421 dated 8.10.2012, the applicant was directed to deposit Rs.50,244/- with the respondents on account of TA being over paid to him.
2. In the present OA filed by him under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, he has questioned the said Memorandum on several grounds, including one that no show cause notice was served upon him before the impugned Memorandum was issued. The ground 5 C. mentioned in the OA reads as under:- C. Because before passing the impugned order dated 08.10.2012 by the respondent, for recovery of Rs.50,224/- on account of alleged over payment towards T.A., no show cause notice was served upon the applicant as such he has been deprived of an opportunity of being heard in the matter, which is against the principle of natural justice as laid down by Honble Supreme Court in case, Bhagwan Shukla vs. Union of India and others, Civil Appeal No.5447 of 1994. The relevant portion of the judgment is reproduced below:- He was not even put on notice before his pay was reduced by the department and the order came to be made behind his back without following any procedure known to law. There, has, thus, been a fragrant violation of the principles of natural justice and the appellant has been made to suffer huge financial loss without being heard. Fair play in action warrants that no such order which has the effect of an employee suffering civil consequences should be passed without putting the concerned to notice and giving him a hearing in the matter. Since, that was not done, the order (memorandum) dated 25.7.1991, which was impugned before the Tribunal could not certainly be sustained..
3. In the counter reply filed on behalf of the respondents, they have stated that the impugned order has been issued pursuant to OM No.3/19/2009-Estt (Page-II) dated 5.4.2010 issued by the Department of Personnel and Training, Govt. of India. From the stand of the respondents, it is apparent that the over payment of the TA made to the applicant is not attributable to him. Though in view of the law declared by the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Chandi Prasad Uniyal v. State of Uttarakhand, (2012) 8 SCC 417, the over payment made to an employee either on account of a mistake attributable to him or otherwise can be recovered. In the said case itself it has been held that any recovery from retired employee may cause undue hardship to him. In the present case, the applicant retired from the service as TGT on 30.4.2009. His re-employment was also over on 1.4.2011. The recovery of the amount mentioned in the impugned Memorandum may now cause some hardship to him. It is also not denied by the respondents that before issuance of the impugned Memorandum, no show-cause notice was issued to the applicant. The recovery of over payment made to the employee certainly entails civil consequences. It is settled position of law that any action entailing civil consequences may be taken only by following the principle of natural justice. Reliance has also been placed on the judgment in the case of Union of India vs. S.R. Dhingra, (2008) 2 SCC 229. For easy reference, the following observations of the Honble Supreme Court in the said case are reproduced hereinbelow: 23. We are of the opinion that the clarification of the Railway Board issued dated 29-12-1999 clarifying that the running allowance which was already taken into account for pension and other benefits at the time of retirement is not to be added to the pay of pre 1986 retirees revised on notional basis as on 1-1-1986 is valid. It appears that due to clerical error the notional benefits of the respondents w.e.f. 1-1-1986 were wrongly fixed and such retired employees are getting excess pension. It is well settled that a mistake does not confer any right to any party and can be corrected.
24. We are of the opinion that the benefit of running allowance has to be taken into consideration for computing pension only once. It has been taken into consideration while fixing the pension of the respondents at the time of their retirement. In our opinion it is not required to be taken into account again for any future calculation.
4. In the case of Chandi Prasad Uniyal (ibid), the Honble Supreme Court has held as follows:- 12. We may in this respect refer to the judgment of two- Judge Bench of this Court in Col. B.J. Akkara (retd.) case (supra) where this Court after referring to Shyam Babu Verma case, Sahib Ram case (supra) and few other decisions held as follows: "Such relief, restraining recovery back of excess payment, is granted by courts not because of any right in the employees, but in equity, in exercise of judicial discretion, to relieve the employees, from the hardship that will be caused if recovery is implemented. A Government servant, particularly one in the lower rungs of service would spend whatever emoluments he receives for the upkeep of his family. If he receives an excess payment for a long period, he would spend it genuinely believing that he is entitled to it. As any subsequent action to recover the excess payment will cause undue hardship to him, relief is granted in that behalf. But where the employee had knowledge that the payment received was in excess of what was due or wrongly paid, or where the error is detected or corrected within a short time of wrong payment, Courts will not grant relief against recovery. The matter being in the realm of judicial discretion, courts may on the facts and circumstances of any particular case refuse to grant such relief against recovery."
13. Later, a three-Judge Bench in Syed Abdul Qadir case (supra) after referring to Shyam Babu Verma, Col. B.J. Akkara (retd.) etc. restrained the department from recovery of excess amount paid, but held as follows: "Undoubtedly, the excess amount that has been paid to the appellants - teachers was not because of any misrepresentation or fraud on their part and the appellants also had no knowledge that the amount that was being paid to them was more than what they were entitled to. It would not be out of place to mention here that the Finance Department had, in its counter affidavit, admitted that it was a bona fide mistake on their part. The excess payment made was the result of wrong interpretation of the rule that was applicable to them, for which the appellants cannot be held responsible. Rather, the whole confusion was because of inaction, negligence and carelessness of the officials concerned of the Government of Bihar. Learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellants-teachers submitted that majority of the beneficiaries have either retired or are on the verge of it. Keeping in view the peculiar facts and circumstances of the case at hand and to avoid any hardship to the appellants-teachers, we are of the view that no recovery of the amount that has been paid in excess to the appellants-teachers should be made. (emphasis added)"
14. We may point out that in Syed Abdul Qadir case such a direction was given keeping in view of the peculiar facts and circumstances of that case since the beneficiaries had either retired or were on the verge of retirement and so as to avoid any hardship to them.
15. We are not convinced that this Court in various judgments referred to hereinbefore has laid down any proposition of law that only if the State or its officials establish that there was misrepresentation or fraud on the part of the recipients of the excess pay, then only the amount paid could be recovered. On the other hand, most of the cases referred to hereinbefore turned on the peculiar facts and circumstances of those cases either because the recipients had retired or on the verge of retirement or were occupying lower posts in the administrative hierarchy.
16. We are concerned with the excess payment of public money which is often described as "tax payers money" which belongs neither to the officers who have effected over-payment nor that of the recipients. We fail to see why the concept of fraud or misrepresentation is being brought in such situations. Question to be asked is whether excess money has been paid or not may be due to a bona fide mistake. Possibly, effecting excess payment of public money by Government officers, may be due to various reasons like negligence, carelessness, collusion, favouritism etc. because money in such situation does not belong to the payer or the payee. Situations may also arise where both the payer and the payee are at fault, then the mistake is mutual. Payments are being effected in many situations without any authority of law and payments have been received by the recipients also without any authority of law. Any amount paid/received without authority of law can always be recovered barring few exceptions of extreme hardships but not as a matter of right, in such situations law implies an obligation on the payee to repay the money, otherwise it would amount to unjust enrichment.
17. We are, therefore, of the considered view that except few instances pointed out in Syed Abdul Qadir case (supra) and in Col. B.J. Akkara (retd.) case (supra), the excess payment made due to wrong/irregular pay fixation can always be recovered.
5. In the circumstances, the impugned Memo dated 0810.2012 is quashed. It would be open to the respondents to take action for recovery of the said amount in consonance with the principles of natural justice. While doing so, they will also have due regard to the view taken by the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Chandi Prasad Uniyal (ibid) wherein it has been held that in such cases where recovery would cause hardship to an employee, particularly the retired employee, lenient view need be taken.
6. The OA stands disposed of accordingly. No costs. (A.K. BHARDWAJ) MEMBER (J) /ravi/
Alert