- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mahesh Kumar v. Directorate (Medical) Delhi
G. George Paracken, Member (J) This is a second round of litigation by the Applicant. The brief facts of the case are that the Applicant in response to an advertisement dated 2.6.2010 issued by Respondent No.1 applied for the post of Librarian Grade-II in pay band of Rs.5200-20200 with grade pay of Rs.2800. After having assessed the qualifications and performance of the candidates who appeared in interview, vide the Respondents Notice dated 5.10.2010, 4 of them were selected provisionally. But the Applicant was not one among them for the reason that his educational qualifications were not matching with the same in the relevant Recruitment Rules and in the advertisement issued by the Respondents for the aforesaid post. Therefore, he challenged the aforesaid decision of the Respondents earlier before this Tribunal, vide OA No.2010/2011, on the following grounds:- The degree qualification is a measure of quality and is conferred as symbol of proficiency in studies whereas the diploma is simply a document conferring an honour or privilege. In entire Delhi State, there is no opportunity to obtain two years diploma in Library Science, thus, respondents no 1 to 3 (hereinafter referred to as respondent) ought to have equated the qualification of applicant, i.e. degree in Library and Information Science equivalent to two years diploma in Library Science. The selected candidate secured lesser number of marks than applicant.
2. Relying on the judgment of the Apex Court in the case of P.M.Latha and Another Vs. State of Kerala and Another 2003 (3) SCC 541, this Tribunal, vide its order dated 25.04.2012, disposed of the aforesaid OA with a direction to the 2nd Respondent to examine the impact of the following distinguishing features on the selection in question and the claim of the Applicant for appointment as Librarian Grade-II:- (i) In the counter affidavit filed on behalf of respondents No. 1 to 3, a false deposition is made. Such deposition read as under:- The respondent submits that the applicant had scored less marks in comparison of selected candidates and he was not having the required qualification as per the advertisement.
(ii) The photocopy of application form placed on record along with additional affidavit revealed that the application of Ms. Meenakshi Pall one of the selected candidates was not even dated. Not mentioning the date of the application form become considerable issue for the reason that the learned counsel appearing for applicant has raised an allegation that she had not submitted her application within prescribed time limit for the purpose i.e. on or before 15.6.2010. As far as justification advanced by learned counsel for applicant for mentioning the date 18.06.2010 as date of retrieving the postal order is concerned, when on application of Shri Satinder Kumar a stamp to such effect is mentioned on the application form of Meenakshi Pall no stamp is fixed.
(iii) The qualification i.e degree or diploma in Library Science (one year course) after graduation from recognized University or its equivalent is qualification prescribed for the post of Library Grade-I in ESIC itself.
(iv) Despite specific direction given by this Tribunal respondent could not explain whether there is any Co-Ed Polytechnic at Delhi offering diploma course in Library Science and if there is no such institute at Delhi whether those who acquire degree in library science from available institute in Delhi should be considered eligible for the post of Librarian Grade-II or not.
3. Pursuant to the aforesaid directions, the Respondents have issued the impugned order dated 18.01.2013. The relevant part of the said order reads as under:- 5. In compliance of the aforesaid order of the Honble CAT and on perusal of relevant records, I hereby communicate the following to the Applicant:-
(I) Respondents 1 to 3 had filed affidavit on 28.03.2012 mentioning in para 7 that the error in submission is due to some typographical error and the same was not deliberate or intentional. Director General, Employees State Insurance Corporation has been directed to enquire into the matter so as to ascertain whether the said disposition was deliberate. He has been further directed that in case it is substantiated that there was willful negligence in filing the said deposition, disciplinary action be initiated against all officers including the approving officer, who were instrumental in filing the aforesaid affidavit.
(II) The Register, wherein entry of application forms has been made, was verified and it appears that the application of Ms. Meenakshi Pall was received within prescribed time. Further, Post Master, Rohini Sector VII Post Office vide his letter No.RHN/Misc./12-13 dated 30.11.2012 has confirmed that the Postal Orders No.73F 405924 for Rs.20/- and No.47C 230764 for Rs.5/- were issued on 14.06.2010. This is the postal order which has been attached with the application of Ms.Meenakshi Pall.
(III) Different posts carry different qualification and holding of higher qualification by an applicant will not necessarily entitle him to a post where a lower qualification is considered appropriate. If such be the case then it will be difficult for a person having lower and appropriate qualification to get a job which actually requires the qualification possessed by him. Therefore, there is no merit in the plea that since someone possesses qualification required for a higher post, he should automatically be considered for a lower post. However, the officers of Employees State Insurance Corporation cannot absolve themselves from the responsibility of not applying their mind and due diligence in the instant case since the application, which did not match the prescribed qualification, ought to have been rejected either at the level of scrutiny itself or at the level of its consideration by the Interview Board. It is completely inappropriate for the Interview Board to simultaneously rate the applicants who did not possess the requisite qualification and reject them on the ground that they do not possess the requisite qualification. Therefore, Director General, Employees State Insurance Corporation has been directed to initiate disciplinary action against all officers who constituted the Interview Board for not applying due diligence in the instant case resulting in unnecessary litigation for the Corporation and the Government.
(IV) Employees State Insurance Corporation is an all India Organisation and, therefore, applications for recruitment to any post are not restricted to any particular area. In the light of this fact, Employees State Insurance Corporation cannot make specific provisions in the Recruitment Rules for a particular area such as Delhi. Therefore, the contention that since there is no Co-Ed Polytechnic in Delhi offering Diploma Course in Library Science, persons who possess a higher qualification ought to be considered for this post, does not hold ground so far as the present recruitment is concerned. Place:NewDelhi. Sd/- (Mrutynjay Sarangi) Date: 18.01.2013 Secretary, Govt. of India Ministry of Labour & Employment.
4. The Applicant has again challenged the aforesaid order in this OA stating that the reason given by the Respondents for not selecting him is fallacious, flimsy and unsustainable. According to him, the reason that if a person with higher qualification is selected, it would be difficult for other persons with lower qualifications to get a job is not relevant at all. According to him, if one goes by the aforesaid contention of the Respondents that the lesser qualified persons also should get equal opportunity for appointment, then in all Civil Services and All India Services, only those who have got the qualification of graduation should be appointed and those with higher qualification like Ph.Ds, MDs etc. have to be ignored. He has also refuted the contention of the Respondents that there was no merit in his plea that one who possessed higher qualification should automatically be appointed to a lower post. His further contention is that as he was assessed and ranked higher than those who were appointed, he could not have been ignored and his candidature could not have been rejected merely because he was possessing the higher qualifications as well. He has also reiterated his earlier contention that there was no co-educational Institutes in Delhi awarding 2 years Diploma in Library Science and, therefore, rejection of his candidature was arbitrary and irrational. Further according to him, a holder of Grade-II post of Librarian has all India transfer liability as per their own advertisement meaning thereby an appointee in Delhi can be transferred to Bombay and vice-versa. When the duties and functions of the Librarian Grade-II are same throughout the organization and a degree holder recruited in Bombay can discharge his duties and functions with ease in Delhi, it will be illogical to say that he will not be able to perform his duties, if he is recruited in Delhi. Further, when a direct Grade-I Librarian in Delhi who is the holder of degree in Library Science or one year diploma therein besides holding a bachelors degree like him is considered competent for that job and when a Grade-II Librarian is promoted to Grade-I post only after 8 years service in that grade, it is irrational and illogical to say that a degree holder in Library Science would be incompetent to do the job of Grade-II. He has also argued that the Recruitment Rules (RRs for short) only lay down the minimum qualification for recruitment and it does not rule out the maximum. There is also no prohibition in RRs for appointment of persons with higher qualifications. Moreover, the Selection Board comprises experts in the specific field to assess a candidate for appointment on a post in that field and they do so by assessing his qualifications, intelligence, capabilities, grasp and commitment etc. for doing that specific job. He has also stated that degree course in Library and Information Science from IGNOU from where he obtained degree, two of the three alternate essential requirements for admission to that course were (i) a bachelors degree with diploma in Library Science or (ii) a bachelor degree with 2 years working experience in Library which shows that a degree in Library Science is not only higher than a diploma but is also in the same stream and subsumes all that is taught in a diploma course.
5. In support of his aforesaid submissions, his learned counsel has relied upon the following judgments:-
(i) Rajpal Vs. State of Haryana and Another 2002 (10) SCC 588. In the said judgment the Apex Court held that where the candidate for the post of Canal Patwari possessed the higher qualification of 10+2 examination from an appropriate Board (Haryana Education Board), the point that he has passed matriculation examination conducted by a Vishwavidyalaya which was not a university established or deemed to be so by law, was inconsequential. The relevant part of the said order reads as under:- 2. It is brought to our notice that the appellant had passed 10+2 examination held by the Haryana Education Board which qualification is not suspected or doubtful. When the appellant possesses higher qualification from an appropriate board, we do not think it was necessary for the High Court to examine other aspects of the matter. In that view of the matter, the High Court should have allowed the writ petition rather than to dismiss it.
(ii) Chandrakala Trivedi Vs. State of Rajasthan and Others 2012 (3) SCC 129. In the said case, the Apex Court has made a distinction between equivalent and exact and held that once a person is provisionally selected, certain degree of reasonable expectation of selection being continued comes into existence. The relevant part of the said order reads as under:- 8. The word 'equivalent' must be given a reasonable meaning. By using the expression, 'equivalent' one means that there are some degrees of flexibility or adjustment which do not lower the stated requirement. There has to be some difference between what is equivalent and what is exact. Apart from that after a person is provisionally selected, a certain degree of reasonable expectation of the selection being continued also comes into existence.
9. Considering these aspects of the matter, we are of the view that the appellant should be considered reasonably and the provisional appointment which was given to her should not be cancelled. We order accordingly. However, we make it clear that we are passing this order taking in our view the special facts and circumstances of the case.
(iii) State of Haryana and Another Vs. Abdul Gaffar Khan and Another 2006(11) SCC 153. In the said judgment the Apex Court held that when the candidate possessed the required qualification from a recognized university/institution or Board and thus eligible for appointment to the post of Unani Dispenser, he could not be denied appointment to the aforesaid post. The relevant part of the said order reads as under- 7. We have perused the order passed by the High Court. As rightly pointed by the High Court and as per Haryana Ayurvedic/Homeopathic and Unani Technical Group (C) Service Rules, 1997, they do not expressly exclude the degree in Unani Medicine and Surgery for the post of Unani Dispenser. Admittedly, the respective contesting respondents in these appeals possess required qualifications from a recognized University/Institution or Board and are thus, in our opinion, eligible for appointment to the posts of Unani Dispenser. A close scrutiny of the advertisement issued does not anywhere stipulate the diploma as the required qualification. We, therefore, affirm the order passed by the High Court and direct the appellant-State of Haryana to appoint the respective respondents to the posts of Unani Dispenser within a period of one month from the date of receipt of the order from this Court or on production of the same by the respective respondents herein whichever is earlier. The appeals are accordingly dismissed. There shall be no order as to costs.
(iv) Domendra Kumar Sahu Vs. State of Chattisgarh and Others 2013 (1) SCT. The Honble Chhatisgarh High Court in the said judgment held that there is nothing arbitrary or unreasonable in the employer preferring a candidate with higher qualification for service.
(v) Mrs. Manju Pal Vs. Government of NCT of Delhi and Another 2002(1) ALSLJ 377. In the said case the Honble High Court of Delhi held that Appellant had passed B.A. with Hindi but not Higher Secondary. Hence he was treated as ineligible. The High Court found no justification for his non-selection as B.A. with Hindi could not be said to be lesser qualified than Higher Secondary with Hindi, nor there was any nexus in laying down the qualification. The relevant part of the said judgment reads as under:- 7. It is significant to note that nothing is stated in the counter affidavit as to how Hindi at the Higher Secondary level is helpful for teaching primary level students. What is so special about Hindi at the secondary level, which attribute Hindi at higher level is lacking has not been explained in the counter affidavit or the arguments of the learned counsel for the respondents. Hindi as a language has not been mentioned in the advertisement as a special qualification for imparting education to the students at the primary level. It cannot be assumed by any stretch of imagination that a candidate possessing higher qualification like B.A. with Hindi or M.A. with Hindi will be less efficient in teaching primary classes than a person possessing lesser qualification such as higher secondary with Hindi.
8. We are supported in our view by a decision of the Allahabad High Court in Laxmi Narayan Yadav Vs. District Inspector of Schools and Ors. 1988 (3) SLR Allahabad 42 in which it was held as follows:- As regards the eligibility of respondent No. 3 for the post of Lecturer in Hindi, the learned counsel for the respondents drew out attention to N.B. (Note)(2) below the rule prescribing minimum qualifications for 'Hindi Teachers for Intermediate' contained in Appendix A which provides as follows: "The Hindi Teachers may not be required to have a Degree in Sanskrit in those institutions where qualified Sanskrit teacher is available to teach the Sanskrit portion of the Hindi Court". The above note clarifies the intention why B.A. with Sanskrit was kept as an essential qualification for a Hindi Teacher for Intermediate Classes. The person should be such who can also teach Sanskrit portion of the Hindi Course. The qualification prescribed for Sanskrit Teacher for Intermediate' is 'M.A. with Sanskrit preferably trained'. As respondent no. 3 is M.A. in Sanskrit, he is fully qualified to teach Sanskrit also. Consequently, respondent no. 3 cannot be said to be disqualified for being appointed teacher in Hindi simply because he is not 'B.A. with Sanskrit', especially when he is M.A. in Sanskrit and is qualified to teach Sanskrit portion of Hindi Court, so that requirement of 'B.A. with Sanskrit' is not applicable in his case. Moreover, respondent no. 3 may not be having Sanskrit as a subject for his Bachelors' degree. He is, however, having Master's Degree in Sanskrit, which is certainly a higher qualification than B.A. with Sanskrit. Consequently, the claim of respondent no. 3 could not be rejected merely on the ground that he is not 'B.A. with Sanskrit', when he is admittedly M.A. Sanskrit'.
6. The Respondents have filed their reply reiterating their position in their impugned letter dated 18.01.2013. The learned counsel for the Respondents has relied upon the following judgments in support of the stand taken by the Respondents in the aforesaid letter:-
(i) Secretary (Health) Department of Health and Family Welfare and Another Vs. Dr. Anita Puri and Others 1996 (60 SCC 282. In the said judgment, the Apex Court has held that when an advertisement stipulates a particular qualification as the minimum qualification for the post and further stipulates that preference will be given for higher qualification, the only meaning it conveys that some additional weightage has to be given to the higher candidates with higher qualification. The relevant part of the said judgment reads as under:- 7. Admittedly, in the advertisement which was published calling for applications from the candidates for the posts of Dental Officer it was clearly stipulated that the minimum qualification for the post is B.D.S. It was also stipulated that preference should be given for higher dental qualification. There is also no dispute that M.D.S. is a higher qualification than the minimum qualification required for the post and Respondent 1 was having that degree. The question then arises is whether a person holding a M.D.S. qualification is entitled to be selected and appointed as of right by virtue of the aforesaid advertisement conferring preference for higher qualification? The answer to the aforesaid question must be in the negative. When an advertisement stipulates a particular qualification as the minimum qualification for the post and further stipulates that preference should be given for higher qualification, the only meaning it conveys is that some additional weightage has to be given to the higher qualified candidates. But by no stretch of imagination it can be construed to mean that a higher qualified person automatically is entitled to be selected and appointed. In adjudging the suitability of person for the post, the expert body like public service commission in the absence of any statutory criteria has the discretion of evolving its mode of evaluation of merit and selection of the candidate. The competence and merit of a candidate is adjudged not on the basis of the qualification he possesses but also taking into account the other necessary factors like career of the candidate throughout his educational curriculum, experience in any field in which the selection is going to be held, his general aptitude for the job to be ascertained in course of interview, extracurricular activities like sports and other allied subjects, personality of the candidate as assessed in the interview and all other germane factors which the expert body evolves for assessing the suitability of the candidate for the post for which the selection is going to be held. In this view of the matter, the High court in our considered opinion was wholly in error in holding that a M.D.S. qualified person like Respondent 1 was entitled to be selected and appointed when the government indicated in the advertisement that higher qualification person would get some preference. The said conclusion of the High court, therefore, is wholly unsustainable and must be reversed.
(ii) P.M. Latha and Another Vs. State of Kerala and Others 2003 (3) SCC 54. The Supreme Court in this case has held that there is no force in the argument that B.Ed qualification is a higher qualification than TTC and, therefore, the B.Ed candidates should be held to be eligible to compete for the aforesaid post. The relevant part of the said judgment reads as under:- 10. We find absolutely no force in the argument advanced by the respondents that B.Ed. qualification is a higher qualification than TTC and therefore, the B.Ed. candidates should be held to be eligible to compete for the post. On behalf of appellants, it is pointed out before us that Trained Teachers Certificate is given to teachers specially trained to teach small children in primary classes whereas for B.Ed. degree, the training imparted is to teach students of classes above primary. B.Ed. degree holders, therefore, cannot necessarily be held to be holding qualification suitable for appointment as teachers in primary schools. Whether for a particular post, the source of recruitment should be from the candidates with TTC qualification or B.Ed. qualification, is a matter of recruitment policy. We find sufficient logic and justification in the State prescribing qualification for post of primary teachers as only TTC and not B.Ed. Whether B.Ed. qualification can also be prescribed for primary teachers is a question to be considered by the authorities concerned but we cannot consider B.Ed. candidates, for the present vacancies advertised, as eligible.
(iii) Yogesh Kumar and Others Vs. Government of NCT of Delhi and Others 2003 (3) SCC 548. In this case the Supreme Court held that Appellant has B.Ed qualification, although a well-recognized qualification in the field of teaching and education, being not prescribed in the advertisement, only some of the B.Ed candidates who took a chance to apply for the post cannot be given entry in the field of selection. The relevant part of the said order reads as under:- 5. The division bench of the Delhi High Court in the impugned judgment has dealt with the above two arguments in great detail. In our considered opinion it has rightly come to the conclusion that B.Ed. qualification, although a well recognised qualification in the field of teaching and education- being not prescribed in the advertisement, only some of the B.Ed. candidates who took a chance to apply for the post cannot be given entry in the field of selection We also find that the High Court rightly came to the conclusion that teacher training imparted to teachers for B.Ed. course equips them for teaching higher classes. A specialized training given to teachers for teaching small children at primary level cannot be compared with training given for awarding B.Ed. degree. Merely because primary teachers can also earn pro motion to the post of teachers to teach higher classes and for which B.Ed. is the prescribed qualification, it cannot be held that B.Ed. is a higher qualification than TTC. Looking to the different nature of TTC qualification the High Court rightly held that it is not comparable with B.Ed. degree qualification and latter cannot be treated as higher qualification to the former. XXX XXX XXX
8. This last argument advanced also does not impress us at all. Recruitment to Public Services should be held strictly in accordance with the terms of advertisement and the recruitment rules, if any. Deviation from the Rules allows entry to ineligible persons and deprives many others who could have cornpeted for the post. Merely because in the past some deviation and departure was made in considering the B.Ed, candidates and we are told that was so done because of the paucity of TTC candidates, we cannot allow a patent illegality to continue. The recruitment authorities were well aware that candidates with qualification of TTC and B. Ed. are available yet they chose to restrict entry for appointment only to TTC pass candidates. It is open to the recruiting authorities to evolve a policy of recruitment and to decide the source from which the recruitment is to be made. So far as B.Ed. qualification is concerned, in the connected appeals [CA No. 1726-28 of 2001] arising from Kerala which are heard with this appeal, we have already taken the view that B. Ed. qualification cannot be treated as a qualification higher than TTC because the natures of training imparted for grant of certificate and degree are totally different and between them there is no parity whatsoever. It is projected before us that presently more candidates available for recruitment to primary school are from B.Ed. category and very few from TTC category. Whether for the aforesaid reasons, B.Ed. qualification can also be prescribed for primary teachers is a question to be considered by the authorities concerned but we cannot consider B. Ed. candidates for the present vacancies advertised as eligible. In our view, the division bench of the Delhi High Court was fully justified in coming to the conclusion that B. Ed. candidates were rightly excluded by the authorities from selection and appointment as primary teachers. We make it clear that we are not called upon to express any opinion on any B. Ed. Candidates appointed as primary teachers pursuant to advertisements in the past and our decision is confined only to the advertisement which was under challenge before the High Court and in this appeal.
(iv) Dilip Kumar Ghosh and Others Vs. Chairman and Others 2005 (7) SCC 567. In this judgment the Apex Court held that the Appellants holding B.Ed degrees were rightly denied marks against the training qualifications as they were not holders of JBT/PTTC. As for the post of Primary School Teachers, qualification required was JBT/PTTC and not higher qualification of B.Ed. The relevant part of the said judgment reads as under:- What emerges from the above interpretation of rules, curriculum, syllabus for appointment of teachers in primary schools are these:
(i) In the case of the Junior Basic Training and Primary Teachers Training Certificate the emphasis is on the development of child. The Primary Education is up to IV standard. Thereafter there is middle education and then the secondary and higher secondary education. But in the primary school one has to study the psychology and development of child at tender age. The person who is trained in B.Ed. Degree may not necessarily be equipped to teach a student of primary class because he is not equipped to understand psychology of a child at that early stage.
(ii)This is only peculiar to the curriculum of the Junior Basic Training Course and Primary Teachers Training Certificate Course. Therefore, looking to the curriculum one can appreciate the distinction between the two courses and same policy is reflected in Rules framed by the State in exercise of its statutory power.
(iii)To accept a proposition that a candidate who holds a B.Ed. Degree, that is, higher degree cannot be deprived appointment to the post of primary school teacher would negate the aims and objects of the rules for the purpose for which it is framed.
(iv)These rules were framed primarily for recruitment of the teachers for primary schools and in that context the Rules were designed to give a credit to the candidates who are specifically trained to teach in primary schools. The idea behind the framing of these rules was that the Junior Basic Training and Primary Teachers Training Certificate trained teachers should be appointed so that they can impart proper education to the child of tender age who require expert and tending hand.
(v)There is prohibition contained in Rule 6(d) that no extra credit shall be given for higher qualification."
7. We have heard the learned counsel for the Applicant Shri O.P. Gehlaut and the learned counsel for the Respondents Shri Murari Lal. In the reply filed by the Respondents, it is not necessary for us to go into any other controversy except whether the Applicant with higher qualifications than those mentioned in the relevant Recruitment Rules and the advertisement could not have been denied the appointment or not. Admittedly, the appointment of Library Staff is regulated by the Respondents in terms of their Recruitment Rules called The Employees Insurance Corporation (Library Staff) Recruitment Relations, 1978. According to the said Rules, there are two categories of Library Staff, one Librarian Grade-I and other Librarian Grade-II. The educational qualification for Grade-I is as under:- 1. Graduate with Degree or Diploma in Library Science (one years course after graduation) of a recognized University or its equivalent.
2. Two years experience in a public college, University or Departmental Library. The educational qualification prescribed for Librarian Grade-II is as under:- Matric with a Diploma in Library Science (2 years course after Matriculation). It is strictly in terms of the aforesaid rules, the Respondents have issued the advertisement for recruitment to post of Librarian Grade-II, on 02.06.2010. Therefore, the Applicant who did not possess the aforesaid qualifications was not expected to apply for the aforesaid post and the Respondents could not have gone beyond the Recruitment Rules and the terms and conditions for appointment mentioned in the advertisement. Admittedly, the Applicants educational qualification is a bachelors degree and one years degree in Library and Information Science from IGNOU. However, the prescribed qualification for Librarian Grade-II in the Recruitment Rules, as extracted above, is Matric with Diploma in Library Science (2 years course after Matriculation). The question to be considered here is that whether the Applicant is possessing higher qualification than the required qualification or equivalent qualification as prescribed. Undisputedly, the answer shall be in the negative. Therefore, there is no merit in the contention of the Applicant that the Respondents denied him the appointment just because he possessed higher qualification than the prescribed qualification is not correct. Unless the candidates possess the minimum prescribed qualification, it cannot be said that they possess higher qualifications than the minimum qualification. If the intention of the Respondents was that the candidates with higher qualification should also be considered, it would have been so mentioned in the RRs as well as in the advertisement. In the absence of any such prescription, when an advertisement is issued inviting applications only from persons possessing Matric with Diploma in Library Science (2 years course after Matriculation), the candidates who meet the said qualification alone will be considered. Otherwise, the candidates should prove that the qualification that they possess is equivalent qualification as prescribed in the Recruitment Rules. But note that they possess some other qualification which may be of a higher level. In this case, it is not the case of the Applicant that the one year degree course in Library or Information Science obtained by him from IGNOU is equivalent to Diploma in Library Science (2 years after matriculation). Further, in the absence of any stipulation in the advertisement to the extent that candidates with higher qualifications can also apply, by entertaining the application of the Applicant alone ignoring the claim of similarly placed graduates in Library and Information Science is violation of Articles 14 & 16(1) of the Constitution. The merit of the Applicants has to be determined from among the similarly placed candidates having the same qualification or equivalent qualification but not from those who possess higher qualifications. As held by the Apex Court in its judgment in the case of Yogesh Kumar and Others (supra) the Applicant took a chance to apply for the aforesaid post and the Respondents have rightly denied his entry in the field of selection.
8. In the above facts and circumstances of the case, as observed by the Respondents in their impugned letter entertaining the application of the Applicant itself was ab initio wrong. Therefore, we do not see any merit in his contention that in spite of the fact that he got higher qualification he has not been selected whereas persons having qualification lower than him have been selected. Accordingly, this OA is dismissed.
9. There shall be no order as to costs. (SHEKHAR AGARWAL) (G. GEROGE PARACKEN) MEMBER (A) MEMBER (J) Rakesh
Alert