Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

K.K. Bhardwaj v. Union Of India

Central Administrative Tribunal
Nov 21, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Structured Summary of the Opinion (Member (J) V. Ajay Kumar)

Factual and Procedural Background

The applicant, a Data Processing Assistant-B in the National Crime Records Bureau, filed the present Original Application (O.A.) challenging the respondents' action in relation to the Annual Confidential Report (ACR) for the year 2005-06. The applicant's ACR for 2005-06 contained an overall grading of "Average" (described in the opinion as a below-benchmark grading), which the applicant sought to have expunged.

Procedural history in the opinion:

  • Respondents forwarded the applicant's ACR for 2005-06 by Office Memorandum dated 29.11.2011/07.12.2011, indicating a below-benchmark grading ("Average") and directing the applicant to make a representation within 15 days.
  • The applicant submitted a detailed representation on 20.12.2011.
  • The respondents rejected the representation by an impugned office memorandum dated 23.03.2012.
  • The Tribunal heard counsel for both parties and considered pleadings and authorities before arriving at its decision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a below-benchmark ACR entry ("Average") that was not accompanied by reasons and was communicated to the employee after a long delay (five years) violated the legal principles governing ACR communication and the ACR Scheme.
  2. Whether non-communication of reasons and failure to warn or put the employee on notice (with reference to specific instances or attributes) before recording an adverse or below-benchmark entry renders the ACR arbitrary and excluded from consideration for promotion/financial upgradation (MACP).
  3. Whether the respondents' rejection of the applicant's representation and their continued consideration of the 2005-06 ACR for service consequences was legally sustainable.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments

  • The applicant's historical ACR gradings from 1991-92 to 2007-08 show consistent gradings of "Good" or above except for 2005-06, which alone recorded "Average".
  • It is inconsistent with the ACR scheme to label an employee "Average" without giving reasons or citing specific instances; neither the Reporting Officer nor Reviewing Officer provided specific instances to substantiate the "Average" grading.
  • The ACR system is meant to advise and enable improvement; the applicant was not given any notice, memo, advisory note, or chargesheet in 2005-06 to indicate areas needing improvement; allegations of verbal advice were denied as unsupported.
  • The ACR for 2005-06 was communicated only in December 2011, after a lapse of more than five years; delayed communication prejudices the employee and violates principles of natural justice and the purpose of the ACR scheme.
  • The applicant relied on case law (S. Ramachandra Raju; Bishwanath Prasad Singh; U.P. Jal Nigam; Yamuna Shanker Misra) and Paras 16 and 39 of Swamy's Compilation on Confidential Reports to support the contention that the entry should have been communicated with reasons within a reasonable time and that lack of such compliance invalidates the adverse/below-benchmark entry.

Respondents' Arguments

  • Upgrading or downgrading an ACR is a function of competent authorities who are better placed to know the employee's work; litigation cannot substitute for that administrative competence.
  • The Reporting Officer asserted in comments on the representation that the applicant failed to improve performance despite repeated verbal advice; the applicant did not controvert that assertion in pleadings.
  • Prior to the DoP&T Office Memorandum dated 13.04.2010, there was no requirement to communicate ACRs containing below-benchmark gradings; therefore non-communication of the 2005-06 ACR prior to 2011 cannot be a ground for interference.
  • The respondents argued there was no allegation of irregularity in decision-making process, no statutory violation, and thus no cause of action to entertain the O.A.
  • The respondents relied on case law (Ekta Shakti Foundation; G.J. Fernandes; Chief Commercial Manager, South Central Railway) to argue that judicial review is limited and executive administrative instructions, if breached, do not necessarily give rise to writ remedies.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
S. Ramachandra Raju v. State of Orissa, 1994 Supp (3) SCC 424 Confidential reports should be written objectively and communicated at the earliest to pave way for improvement by the subordinate officer. The court relied on this authority to emphasize the need for objective reporting and early communication as part of the ACR scheme's purpose.
Bishwanath Prasad Singh v. State of Bihar, (2001) 2 SCC 305 Confidential entries should reflect objective assessment, fairness and be aimed at guiding improvement; entries are complex and should be fair and just. Used to underscore the requirement of objectivity and fairness in confidential reports and the need for justness in making entries.
U.P. Jal Nigam & Others v. Prabhat Chandra Jain & Others, (1996) 2 SCC 363 Discussed whether downgrading entries are "adverse" and their communicability; observed downgraded ACRs are to be communicated. The court noted this decision's holding that downgraded ACRs are to be communicated and considered its reasoning in the conspectus of cases.
State of U.P. v. Yamuna Shanker Misra, (1997) 4 SCC 7 Confidential reports aim to give opportunity to improve; reporting officers have duty to write objectively and, before making adverse remarks, should share and confront information with the officer. Relied upon for the proposition that adverse remarks should be founded on facts and that the employee should be given opportunity to respond before adverse entries are made.
Ekta Shakti Foundation v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, AIR 2006 SC 2609 Courts' judicial inquiry is confined to whether government decisions violate statutory provisions or fundamental/constitutional rights; courts are not appellate authorities in administrative decisions. Noted by the respondents; the court referenced it when summarizing limits of judicial review as argued by respondents.
G.J. Fernandes v. State of Mysore and Others, AIR 1967 SC 1753 Administrative instructions (e.g., PWD Code) are not statutory rules and their breach does not automatically confer a right to approach the courts. Referred to by respondents to argue that breach of executive instructions does not necessarily create a judicial remedy.
Chief Commercial Manager, South Central Railway v. G. Ratnam & Others, (2007) 8 SCC 212 Breach of executive instructions (such as vigilance manual) does not automatically confer a right to a writ against the government. Relied on by respondents to support the contention that violation of administrative instructions does not per se entitle an employee to judicial relief.
M.A. Rajshekhar v. State of Karnataka, (1996) 19 SCC 369 An adverse remark must point out the specific instance in which the officer did not perform satisfactorily so that the officer has an opportunity to correct. Used to support the requirement that specificity of instances should be given to allow correction and that omission of such specifics is untenable.
S.T. Ramesh v. State of Karnataka & Anr., (2007) 9 SCC 436 Court must consider whether adverse remarks justify an overall assessment of "Average" when the officer had consistently excellent reports before and after. Referred to when assessing whether the single "Average" entry for 2005-06 was sufficient to warrant exclusion or adverse consequence given the applicant's earlier and later records.
Dev Dutt v. Union of India, 2008 (8) SCC 725 Non-communication of adverse or below-benchmark remarks is arbitrary, violative of Article 14 and warrants exclusion of such ACRs from consideration. Relied upon by the court as part of the conspectus establishing that non-communication of below-benchmark entries is legally impermissible.
Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar v. Union of India, 2009 (16) SCC 146 Non-communication of below-benchmark remarks (such as "good") is arbitrary and violative of Article 14; such ACRs may be excluded. Also cited to support the proposition that non-communication of below-benchmark entries can render them arbitrary and liable to exclusion.
K.M. Mishra v. Central Bank of India, (2008) 9 SCC 120 Expressed view that non-communication of below-benchmark ACRs does not necessarily warrant exclusion. Noted by the court as representing a contrary view in the case law matrix that was later addressed by Sukhdev Singh.
Satya Narain Shukla v. Union of India & Others, (2006) 9 SCC 69 Also represented a contrary view that non-communication of below-benchmark ACRs may not require exclusion. Recorded by the court as part of the conflicting authorities that were subsequently considered in Sukhdev Singh.
Union of India & Anr. v. Major Bahadur Singh, 2006 (1) SCC 368 Expressed a view differing from U.P. Jal Nigam and observed that U.P. Jal Nigam's decision applies to that authority alone. Noted by the court as one of the decisions forming the backdrop to the reference resolved in Sukhdev Singh.
Sukhdev Singh v. Union of India & Others, 2013 (9) SCC 566 Three-Judge Bench held that every entry in ACR—poor, fair, average, good or very good—must be communicated within a reasonable period; contrary decisions declared not to lay down good law. The court relied on this decision as settling that every ACR entry must be communicated within a reasonable time and that non-compliance results in arbitrariness and Article 14 violation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Tribunal first surveyed the relevant case law and the stated objects of the ACR/APAR mechanism (as reflected in Swamy's Compilation excerpts included in the record). The court set out the twin objectives of APAR/ACR: (1) to improve the subordinate's present performance by identifying defects and shortcomings, and (2) to assess potential and provide feedback for correcting deficiencies.

The Tribunal then considered the conflicting precedents and noted that the three-Judge Bench decision in Sukhdev Singh had resolved the conflict by endorsing the proposition in Dev Dutt and related cases: every entry in an ACR—whether adverse or below-benchmark—must be communicated to the public servant within a reasonable period. The Tribunal recorded that contrary views in earlier decisions were declared not to lay down a good law by Sukhdev Singh.

Applying these settled principles to the facts before it, the Tribunal examined the respondents' conduct:

  • The respondents failed to demonstrate that the applicant had been warned or put on notice with reference to any specific instance or attribute before recording the "Average" remark for 2005-06.
  • The respondents did not give reasons of any kind for recording the "Average" remark in the ACR.
  • The ACR for 2005-06 was communicated to the applicant only in 2011—about five years after the period under review—which the Tribunal treated as outside the reasonable period required by the case law cited.

The Tribunal concluded that these facts—absence of specific reasons, failure to show prior warning/notice, and excessive delay in communication—constituted non-compliance with the law and the objectives of the ACR scheme. The Tribunal characterized the respondents' action as violative of the legal principle requiring communication and reasons and as arbitrary under Article 14 (as articulated in the cited authorities).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Tribunal QUASHED the impugned orders rejecting the applicant's representation, and directed that the ACR for the year 2005-2006 shall not be considered for any purpose, including promotion and financial upgradation under MACP, of the applicant. The O.A. was allowed and there was no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The specific ACR entry for 2005-06 is excluded from consideration for any departmental purpose (including promotion/MACP) in the applicant's service record as ordered by the Tribunal.
  • The Tribunal based its order on established Supreme Court precedents (notably Sukhdev Singh and those it relied upon) requiring timely communication of every ACR entry with reasons; the Tribunal did not purport to create new law but applied those precedents to the facts of this case.
  • No broader or novel precedent was declared by the Tribunal beyond applying the settled position of higher courts to the facts: failure to communicate reasons and failure to communicate within a reasonable period (here, five years) renders the ACR entry vulnerable to exclusion.

End of summary.

Show all summary ...

By Mr. V. Ajay Kumar, Member (J) The applicant, a Data Processing Assistant-B in the respondent  National Crime Records Bureau, filed the present O.A. aggrieved by the action of the respondents in not expunging the adverse remarks of Average and the consequential below benchmark grading of Average for the year 2005-06.

2. The respondents vide Office Memorandum dated 29.11.2011/07.12.2011, forwarded the ACR of the applicant for the year 2005-06 in which the grading given to the applicant is below benchmark grading of Average for next promotion/financial upgradation under MACP and directed him to make a representation, if any, within 15 days.

3. The applicant submitted a detailed representation on 20.12.2011. However, the respondents vide the impugned office memorandum dated 23.03.2012 rejected the representation of the applicant.

4. Heard Shri A.K. Behera for the applicant and Shri R.N. Singh, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents, and have gone through the pleadings on record.

5. Shri A.K. Behera, the learned counsel for the applicant, in support of the O.A. averments, inter alia, contended as under:

(i) The gradings awarded to the applicant in the ACRs from the year 1991-92 to 2007-08 are as under: 1992-92 : Very Good 1992-93 : Very Good 1993-94 : Very Good 1994-95 : Very Good 1995-96 : Good 1996-97 : Good 1997-98 : Good (1.4.97 to 25.8.97) 1997-98 : Very Good 1998-99 : Good 1999-2000 : Good 2000-01 : Good 2001-02 : Very Good 2002-03 : Outstanding 2003-04 : Good 2004-05 : Good 2005-06 : Average 2006-07 : Good 2007-08 : Good The applicant was given the grading of Good or above consistently in all the years from 1991-92 to 2007-08 except for the subject year, i.e. 2005-06, wherein the grading of Average was awarded to the applicant. No person can become a great performer or a non-performer all of a sudden. Simply, saying the performance of the applicant as average, against certain attributes in the ACR, without giving any reasons or without mentioning any specific instances, is against to the ACR Scheme itself. The Reporting Officer or Reviewing Officer even in their comments on the representation of the applicant failed to substantiate their action by giving any specific instances which prompted them to record the remarks of Average to the applicant. The respondents even in their counter to the O.A. also not given any specific instances.

(ii) The purpose and object of the ACRs is to give an opportunity to the employee to improve his performance by specifically bringing to his notice the various instances in which he did not perform the duty satisfactorily or the fields whereunder he requires to be improved himself. However, during the year 2005-2006, for which year, all of a sudden, the grading of the applicant was reduced to Average, no notice, no memo, no advisory note, no chargesheet etc. was ever communicated to the applicant. Hence, the contention of the respondents that the Reporting Officer in his comments on the representation of the applicant stated that the applicant was, time and again, advised verbally to amend, is totally false, untenable and without any supporting material.

(iii) The respondents communicated the below benchmark grading of Average for the year 2005-06 in December, 2011, i.e. after a lapse of more than 5 years. The ACRs, in view of the purpose and object for which the ACR system has been introduced, are required to be communicated to the concerned employee within a reasonable time, i.e. in any event before the commencement of the next ACR period. Then only that all the concerned, i.e. the employee, Reporting and Reviewing Officers would be able to remember and substantiate the events and various remarks made by them in the relevant ACR. If the communication of the ACR is delayed beyond a period of more than one year, the same amounts to violation of principles of natural justice, inasmuch as the said delay will prejudice the right of the employee.

(iv) The learned counsel placed reliance on the following judgments:

1. S. Ramachandra Raju Vs. State of Orissa, 1994 Supp(3) SCC 424.

2. Bishwanath Prasad Singh Vs. State of Bihar, (2001) 2 SCC 305.

3. U.P. Jal Nigam & Others Vs. Prabhat Chandra Jain & Others, (1996) 2 SCC 363.

4. State of U.P. Vs. Yamuna Shanker Misra, (1997) 4 SCC 7.

(v) The learned counsel also placed reliance on Paras 16 and 39 of the Swamys Compilation on Confidential Reports.

6. Per contra, Shri R.N. Singh, the learned counsel appearing for the respondents would contend as under:

(i) The applicant sought for upgradation of grading in the O.A. and the same is not permissible, since upgrading or downgrading of an ACR can only be done by the Competent Authorities, which are having full knowledge of the working of the concerned employee.

(ii) The Reporting Officer, in his comments to the representation of the applicant, categorically stated that the applicant failed to improve his performance, inspite of his repeated verbal advises. The applicant, who has not controverted the said fact in his pleadings, cannot contend that no notice or memo was ever issued to him to improve his performance with reference to any specific instance or attribute.

(iii) Prior to issuance of the DoP&T Office Memorandum dated 13.04.2010, there was no provision for communication of ACRs containing below benchmark gradings. Hence, non-communication of the subject ACR, i.e. for the year 2005-06, prior to 2011 cannot be a ground in interfering the same.

(iv) Since there was no allegation that any irregularity was committed by the respondents in decision making process, this Tribunal would not entertain the O.A.

(v) There is no cause of action to the O.A. as there was no violation of any statutory provision by the respondents, as alleged.

(vi) If a particular grading is awarded to an employee in a particular year basing on his performance in that year, it cannot be said that he should be given the same grading or a higher grading in the subsequent years.

(vii) The learned counsel placed reliance on the following judgments:

1. Ekta Shakti Foundation Vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, AIR 2006 SC 2609.

2. G.J. Fernandes Vs. State of Mysore and Others, AIR 1967 SC 1753.

3. Chief Commercial Manager, South Central Railway, Secunderabad and Others Vs. G. Ratnam & Others, (2007) 8 SCC 212.

7. In S. Ramachandra Raju (supra), it was held as under:  xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx Therefore, writing the confidential reports objectively and constructively and communication thereof at the earliest would pave way for amends by erring subordinate officer or to improve the efficiency in service. At the same time, the subordinate-employee/officer should dedicate to do hard work and duty; assiduity in the discharge of the duty, honesty with integrity in performance thereof which alone would earn his usefulness in retention of his service. Both would contribute to improve excellence in service.

8. In Bishwanath Prasad Singh (supra), it was held as under:  xxxx xxxx xxxx xxxx The entry in the confidential rolls should not be a reflection of personal whims, fancies or prejudices, likes or dislikes of a superior. The entry must reflect the result of an objective assessment coupled with an effort at guiding the judicial officers to secure an improvement in his performance where need be; to admonish him with the object of removing for future, the shortcoming found; and expressing an appreciation with an idea of toning up and maintaining the immutable qualities by affectionately patting on the back of meritorious and deserving. An entry consisting of a few words, or a sentence or two, is supposed to reflect the sum total of the impressions formulated by the inspecting Judge who had the opportunity of forming those impressions in his mind by having an opportunity of watching the judicial officer round the period under review. In the very nature of things, the process is complex and the formulation of impressions is a result of multiple factors simultaneously playing in the mind. The perceptions may differ. In the very nature of things there is a difficulty nearing an impossibility in subjecting the entries in confidential rolls to judicial review. Entries either way have serious implications on the service career. Hence the need for fairness, justness and objectivity in performing the inspections and making the entries in the confidential rolls.

9. In U.P. Jal Nigam (supra), the appellants plea was that downgrading entries in confidential reports cannot be termed as adverse entries so as to obligate the Nigam to communicate the same to the employee and attract a representation. While observing as under: The Nigam has rules, whereunder an adverse entry is required to be communicated to the employee concerned, but not down grading of an entry. It has been urged on behalf of the Nigam that when the nature of the entry does not reflect any adverseness that is not required to be communicated. As we view the extreme illustration given by the High Court may reflect and adverse element compulsorily communicable, but if the graded entry is of going a step down, like falling from 'very good' to 'good' that may not ordinarily be an adverse entry since both are a positive grading. All what is required by the Authority recording confidentials in the situation is to record reasons for such down grading on the personal file of the officer concerned, and inform him of the change in the form of an advice. If the variation warranted be not permissible, then the very purpose of writing annual confidential reports would be frustrated. Having achieved an optimum level the employee on his part may slacken in his work, relaxing secure by his one time achievement. This would be an undesirable situation. All the same the sting of adverseness must, in all events, be not reflected in such variations, as otherwise they shall be communicated as such. It may be emphasised that even a positive confidential entry in a given case can perilously be adverse and to say that an adverse entry should always be qualitatively damaging may not be true. it was held that downgraded ACRs are to be communicated.

10. In Yamuna Shanker Misra (supra), it was held as under: It would, thus, be clear that the object of writing the confidential reports and making entries in the character rolls is to give an opportunity to a public servant to improve excellence. Article 51-A(j) enjoins upon every citizen the primary duty to constantly endeavour to prove excellence, individually and collectively, as a member of the group. Given an opportunity, the individual strives to improve excellence and thereby efficiency of administration would be augmented. The officer entrusted with the duty to write confidential reports, has a public responsibility and trust to write the confidential reports objectively, fairly and dispassionately while giving, as accurately as possible, the statement of facts on an overall assessment of the performance of the subordinate officer. It should be founded upon the facts or circumstances. Though sometimes, it may not be part of record, but the conduct, reputation and character acquire public knowledge or notoriety and may be within his knowledge. Before forming an opinion to be adverse, the reporting officers writing confidentials should share the information which is not a part of the record with the officer concerned, have the information confronted by the officer and then make it part of the record. This amounts to an opportunity given to the erring/corrupt officer to correct the errors of the judgment, conduct, behaviour, integrity or conduct/corrupt proclivity. If, despite given giving such an opportunity, the officer fails to perform the duty, correct his conduct or improve himself necessarily, the same may be recorded in the confidential reports and a copy thereof supplied to the affected officer so that he will have an opportunity to know the remarks made against him. If he feels aggrieved, it would be open to him to have it corrected by appropriate representation to the higher authorities or any appropriate judicial forum for redressal. Thereby, honesty, integrity, good conduct and efficiency get improved in the performance of public duties and standards of excellence in services constantly rises to higher levels and it becomes successful tool to manage the services with officers of integrity, honesty, efficiency and devotion.

11. In Ekta Shakti Foundation (supra), the Honble Apex Court, while dealing with the legality of certain terms in inviting offers for implementation of the scheme called the "Detailed Scheme for Capacity Building of Self Help Groups to Prepare and Supply Supplementary Nutrition under the Integrated Child Development Service (in short the 'ICDS') Programme held that: In such matters the power of judicial enquiry of the Courts is confined to the question whether the decision taken by the Government is against any statutory provisions or is violative of the fundamental rights or constitutional provisions and the Court cannot act as an Appellate Authority.

12. In G.J. Fernandes (supra), the Honble Apex Court, while again dealing with the issue of tenders for construction of the right bank masonry dam called Hidkal Dam by the PWD held that: The instructions contained in the PWD Code are mere administrative instructions and are not statutory rules. Therefore, even if there has been any reach of such executive instructions that does not confer any right on the appellant to apply to the court.

13. In Chief Commercial Manager, South Central Railway (supra), while dealing with the penalty orders of a Railway employee and after considering the instructions in Indian Railways Vigilance Manual, the Apex Court held that: Even if, there has been any breach of such executive instructions that does not confer any right on any Member of the public to ask for a writ against the Government.

14. The objects of the Annual Confidential Reports/Annual Performance Assessment Report mechanism as per Swamys Compilation on Confidential Reports (incorporating orders received upto October, 2012) are as under: 1. Object

1. The performance of every Government servant is assessed annually through the Assessment Report that is written by his Superior Officer. Since the Assessment Report guides him about his defects and shortcomings, which decides his future career advancement, it is supposed to be a very important document in his career.

2. It is in the interest of every Government servant that he should know how well or otherwise, he is performing the job assigned to him. He can plan his career development in a systematic manner only when he comes to know of his defects and takes remedial measures.

3. The ultimate goal of writing of APAR on the performance of a Government servant is to optimize the achievement of Government policies and programmes. The main focus of the Reporting Officer should be developmental, rather than judgemental.

4. Thus the system of APAR has two principal objectives. First and foremost is to improve the performance of the subordinate in his present job. The second one is to assess his potentialities and provide him appropriate feedback and guidance for correcting his deficiencies and improve his performance.

5. The APAR provides the basic and vital inputs for assessing the performance of an officer and his advancement in his career as also to serve the data for judging his comparative merits when questions arise of confirmation, promotion, selection grade, crossing efficiency bar, continuance in service beyond certain age or completion of certain years service. Government have accepted the principle that these factors should be based solely on the assessment of the confidential dossiers.

15. Before, arriving to any conclusion, it is relevant to note the following judgments also.

16. In M.A. Rajshekhar Vs. State of Karnataka, (1996) 19 SCC 369, it was held that : It must be pointed out with reference to the specific instance in which he did not perform that duty satisfactorily, so that he would have an opportunity to correct himself.

17. In S.T. Ramesh Vs. State of Karnataka & Anr., (2007) 9 SCC 436, it was held that: The Court has to consider whether the adverse remarks were sufficient in themselves to merit the overall assessment of Average when appellant had always been awarded Excellent remarks in his confidential reports both before and after the adverse remarks.

18. In Dev Dutt Vs. Union of India, 2008 (8) SCC 725 and in Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar Vs. Union of India, 2009 (16) SCC 146, the Honble Apex Court held that Non-communication of not only adverse remarks but also below benchmark remarks, such as 'good' would be arbitrary and as such violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and warrant exclusion of such ACRs from consideration.

19. However, the Honble Apex Court expressed contrary view in K.M. Mishra Vs. Central Bank of India, (2008) 9 SCC 120 and Satya Narain Shukla Vs. Union of India & Others, (2006) 9 SCC 69, i.e. to the effect that non-communication of below benchmark ACRs which shows the decline from Very Good to Good etc. does not warrant exclusion of the said ACRs from consideration.

20. The Honble Apex Court in Union of India & Anr. Vs. Major Bahadur Singh, 2006 (1) SCC 368, expressed different view from that of U.P. Jal Nigam (supra) and observed that said decision applies to the employees of U.P. Jal Nigam only.

21. Noticing the contrary view in U.P. Jal Nigam and Major Bahadur Singh, the case of Sukhdev Singh Vs. Union of India & Others, 2013 (9) SCC 566 was referred to a three Judges Bench. While answering the said reference, the three Judges Bench of the Honble Apex Court in Sukhdev Singhs case considered all the aforesaid cases, and held as under: 8. In our opinion, the view taken in Dev Dutt that every entry in ACR of a public servant must be communicated to him/her within a reasonable period is legally sound and helps in achieving threefold objectives. First, the communication of every entry in the ACR to a public servant helps him/her to work harder and achieve more that helps him in improving his work and give better results. Second and equally important, on being made aware of the entry in the ACR, the public servant may feel dissatisfied with the same. Communication of the entry enables him/her to make representation for upgradation of the remarks entered in the ACR. Third, communication of every entry in the ACR brings transparency in recording the remarks relating to a public servant and the system becomes more conforming to the principles of natural justice. We, accordingly, hold that every entry in ACR - poor, fair, average, good or very good - must be communicated to him/her within a reasonable period.

9. The decisions of this Court in Satya Narain Shukla vs. Union of India and others [(2006) 9 SCC 69] and K.M. Mishra vs. Central Bank of India and others [(2008) 9 SCC 120] and the other decisions of this Court taking a contrary view are declared to be not laying down a good law.

22. In view of the conspectus of the above case law, it is clear and unambiguous that every entry in an ACR of a public servant whether he is in Civil, Judicial or Police or any other service (other than Armed Forces), whether it is an adverse remark or a below benchmark remark, i.e. poor, fair, average, good or very good, must be communicated to a public servant by recording reasons for such remark, within a reasonable period. Any non-compliance of the same amounts to arbitrariness and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India, besides against the purpose and object of the ACR Scheme itself.

23. In the present case, the respondents not only failed to show that before recording the remarks of Average in the ACR of the applicant that they have either warned him or put him on notice with reference to any specific instance or attribute to enable him to improve himself, but also, admittedly, failed to give reasons of any sort for recording the said Average remarks. Further, the ACR of the year 2005-06 was communicated to the applicant after a lapse of 5 years, i.e. in the year 2011. All these facts clearly establish that the action of the respondents is in clear violation of law as enunciated by the Honble Apex Court, as observed above.

24. In the circumstances and for the reasons mentioned above, the impugned orders are quashed, and the respondents are directed not to consider the ACR for the year 2005-2006 for any purpose including for promotion/MACP etc. of the applicant. The O.A. is allowed, accordingly. No order as to costs. (P.K. BASU) (V. AJAY KUMAR) Member (A) Member (J) /Jyoti/