- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Suresh Chand v. Govt. Of Nct Of Delhi
Mr. A.K. Bhardwaj: The applicants, six in number, initially joined as Investigators and Junior Matrons in the Department of Social Welfare & Women & Child Development, Govt. of NCT of Delhi with effect from the dates mentioned in paragraph 4.1 of the O.A. In terms of office order F.No.45(52)/2012/ DSW/Estt./3288-3303 dated 31.5.2013, on recommendations of the Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC), they were appointed to the posts of House Father/House Mother/Matron in the pay scale of Rs.4000-6000 (pre-revised) with immediate effect.
2. In the present O.A. filed under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, the applicants have sought issuance of direction to the respondents to antedate their promotion to the dates/years of availability of the vacancies, i.e., from the years 1999 to 2012. To buttress the claim of the applicants, Mr. Yogesh Sharma, learned counsel submitted:
i) It is essential for the concerned appointing authority to initiate the action to fill up the existing as well as anticipated vacancies well in advance. ii) The right to be considered for promotion on fair and equitable basis without discrimination is legal and fundamental right under Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. iii) Promotion is normal incidence of service and Court can issue direction even for creation of avenues for promotion. iv) The respondents have followed not the time schedule prescribing consideration for promotion.
v) The promotional posts, i.e., House Mother/House Father/Matron are non-selection posts, thus it is not so that the respondents were required to make any arrangement for selection of the candidates from the feeder category.
3. Finally, Mr. Sharma relied upon the following Orders of the Tribunal:
i) P.K. Udgata & others v. Union of India & another (O.A.No.1563/2011 with connected matters) decided on 1.3.2012, ii) M.S. Narwal v. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & others (O.A. No.1467/2012) decided on 13.9.2013. iii) P. Kulshrestha & others v. National Technical Research Organization (O.A. No.2142/2011 with connected matter) decided on 15.3.2013.
4. On the other hand, Ms. Rashmi Chopra, learned counsel for respondents espoused:
i) There is no such provision of law, which provides for promotion either from the date of eligibility of the incumbent of the post in the feeder category or availability of vacancies and the promotion becomes effective either from the date of the DPC or that of assumption of charge of the promotional post by the promotee, whichever is later. ii) No junior of the applicants could be promoted ahead of them.
5. She finally relied upon the following Orders of the Honble High Court: Order of Tribunal:
i) Jagdish Chand Bhardwaj & another v. Delhi High Court & others (W.P. (C) No.1910/2011) decided on 23.3.2011. ii) Rakesh Verma v. Government of NCT & another (W.P. (C) No.4903/1997) decided on 5.2.2013 iii) Union of India & another v. K.L. Taneja & another W.P. (C) No.8102/2012 with connected matters) decided on 12.4.2013. iv) M.A. Ansari v. Union of India (W.P. (C) No.3056/2012) decided on 17.4.2013
v) Union of India & another v. B.P. Gairola & others (W.P. (C) No.6708/2013) decided on 4.8.2014 vi) Jasbir Singh Gill v. Union of India & others (W.P. (C) No.947/2013) decided on 12.9.2014
6. We heard the learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
7. The sole controversy arises to be determined in the present O.A. is whether a government servant is entitled to get promotion from the date of availability of the vacancies. Way back in the year 1977, the Honble Supreme Court in Union of India & others v. Majji Jangamayya & others, 1977 SCC (L&S) 191 ruled that no employee has any right to have a vacancy in the higher post filled as soon as the vacancy occurs and promotions are to be made prospectively and not retrospectively. Relevant excerpt of the said Judgment reads thus: 58. The observations of this Court in Bishan Sarup Gupta's case (supra) are that if as a result of the fresh seniority list it is found that any officer was eligible for promotion to the post of Assistant Commissioner on account of his place in the new seniority list, the department might have to consider his case for promotion on his record as on the date when he ought to have been considered, and if he would be selected his position will be adjusted in the seniority list of Assistant Commissioners. The object is to see that the position of such a person is not affected in the seniority list of Assistant Commissioners because he is actually promoted later pursuant to the new seniority list, although according to the new seniority list itself he should have been promoted earlier. The observations do not mean that although the Committee can meet for the selection of officers for promotion to the post of Assistant Commissioner only after the seniority list is approved by this Court, the selection would be deemed to be made at the time when a vacancy in the post of Assistant Commissioner occurred and the eligibility of officers for selection will be determined by such deemed date of selection. No employee has any right to have a vacancy in the higher post filled as soon as the vacancy occurs. Government has the right to keep the vacancy unfilled as long as it chooses. In the present case, such a position does not arise because of the controversy between two groups of officers for these years. The seniority list which is the basis for the field of choice for promotion to the post of Assistant Commissioner was approved by this Court on 16 April, 1974. Promotions to the post of Assistant Commissioners are on the basis of the selection list prepared by the Committee and are to be made prospectively and not retrospectively. (emphasis supplied)
8. In Jagdish Chand Bhardwajs case (supra), Honble High Court of Delhi ruled that there is no right much less legal right available to the employees on the basis of which they can contend that the steps need to be taken to fill up the post immediately after the vacancies arise. Relevant excerpt of the said Judgment reads thus:- 6. It is stated at the cost of repetition that six vacancies of the Superintendent arose only on 20.09.2010. There is no right much less legal right to the petitioners on which the petitioners can contend that steps be taken and posts filled up immediately after the vacancies have arisen. It is only a fortuitous circumstance that when those vacancies of Superintendents arose, the petitioners were about to retire and before the steps could be taken, they stood retired
9. In K.L. Tanejas case (supra), a Division Bench of Honble High Court of Delhi ruled that the service jurisprudence does not recognize any retrospective promotion, i.e., promotion from a back date. Relevant excerpt of the Judgment, passed by their Lordships taking note of catena of judgments, reads thus:- 11. In the decision reported as (1998) 7 SCC 44 Baij Nath Sharma vs. Hon'ble Rajasthan High Court At Jodhpur & Anr., relying upon the law declared in K.K.Vadera's case (supra), since no rule was shown which could justify a retrospective promotion, and no mala fides pleaded or proved in delaying promotions, the Supreme Court held that the appellant, a Member of the Rajasthan Judicial Service, could not be promoted from the date a vacancy accrued in the Rajasthan Higher Judicial Service against which vacancy he was ultimately promoted.
12. The same view was reiterated in the decisions reported as AIR 2004 SC 3460 Sanjay K.Sinha & Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Ors., 2006 (13) SCALE 246 State of Uttaranchal & Ors. Vs.Dinesh Kr.Sharma and 2008 (14 ) SCC 29 Nirmal Chandra Sinha vs. UOI & Ors. The last decision i.e. in Nirmal Chandra Sinha's case (supra) referred to certain observations made by the Supreme Court in the decision reported as 1997 (8) SCC 89 UOI vs. B.S.Aggarwal which tends to show to the contrary, as being made on the special circumstances of that case and on humanitarian consideration (refer para 9 of the decision in Nirmal Chandra's case.)
13. In the decision reported as (2007) 1 SCC 683 State of Uttaranchal & Anr. vs. Dinesh kumar Sharma it was observed:- "Respondent was working as a Subordinate Agriculture Services Group-I. Subsequently, he became eligible for promotion. A promotional post became vacant and thereafter, substantive appointment of Respondent to said post was made. Respondent claimed seniority and consequential benefit from date when promotional post became vacant. State Government rejected claim made by Respondent. On writ, Division Bench of High Court directed state to reconsider case of Respondent. Hence the appeal was filed which was allowed and it was held that under Rule 8 of Uttar Pradesh Government Servants Seniority Rules, 1991 a person appointed on promotion shall not get seniority of any earlier year but shall get seniority of year in which his/her appointment is made. Hence respondent was not entitled to seniority from date when promotional post became vacant as no retrospective effect could be given to order of appointment order under the Rules."
14. The decision is in line with the reasoning that unless a rule to the contrary exists, promotions cannot be made or directed to be made retrospectively.
15. With reference to the decisions where benefit of promotion from a retrospective date was accorded, we find an unreported decision of the Supreme Court disposing of Civil Appeal No.1655/1997 titled Union of India & Anr. vs. Santhanakrishnan & Ors.. The facts were that there was delay in holding the examination to fill up posts which had fallen vacant in the 33.33% quota known as Limited Departmental Competitive Examination under Rule 2(iii) of the Relevant Rules. Whereas vacancies in the remaining 66.66% quota were being filled up in the year said vacancies arose, this was not done with respect to posts falling vacant in the 33.33% quota. The question involved was the computation of required minimum period of service among the class of promotees whose results were published in May 1985 whereas the actual promotions were effected in June 1985, for further promotion as Senior Assistant Engineer. The Tribunal gave due leavage for completing the process of examination and fixed the notional date of promotion as 12.9.1982. Supreme Court observed that view taken by the Tribunal was right keeping in view that by virtue of such notional date of promotion, the department was not put to any monetary loss and the promotees concerned were not entitled to any arrears of salary from that date, though for other purposes, including seniority it was ordered to be counted.
16. The decision is purely on facts and from the observations: 'After hearing the learned counsel appearing on either side, we are of the view that de-hors the niceties of the legal issues involved as also the interpretation of the relevant rules, substantial justice seems to have been rendered by attempting to resolve an unprecedented and one time problem which seems to have cropped up' it is but apparent that the Supreme Court had in mind 'substantive justice' and thus the decision can be traced to the power of the Supreme Court under Article 142 of the Constitution of India.
17. In the decision reported as AIR 2004 SC 255 P.N Premachandran vs. The State of Kerala & Ors., the private respondents before the Supreme Court could not be promoted on Regular Basis as Assistant Directors in time on account of administrative lapses; however they were granted temporary promotions; DPC were not convened from the year 1964 to 1990 and hence the State of Kerala took a conscious decision that those who had been acting in a higher post for a long time, although on a temporary basis, but were qualified at the time when they were so promoted and were subsequently found to be eligible by the Departmental Promotion Committee to be promoted at a later date, should be granted benefit of promotion with retrospective effect. In these circumstances noting a residual provision conferring power upon the State Government being Rule 39 of Kerala State & Subordinate Services Rules 1958, the Supreme Court upheld the grant of promotion to the private respondents with effect from a retrospective date.
18. The decision is in conformity with the consistent view taken by the Supreme Court that where an ad-hoc, temporary or stop- gap promotion which is not fortuitous is followed by regular promotion and on the date of ad-hoc, temporary or stop-gap promotion the person was eligible for regular promotion and there existed a vacancy in the quota applicable and it was followed by a regular promotion, for purposes of service benefits past service could be reckoned as a regular service if a Rule so permitted.
19. In the decision reported as 1995 (4) SCC 246 Vinod Kumar Sangal vs.UOI& Ors. due to reorganization of the cadre, DPC could not meet from the year 1979 to 1984. Bunching all the vacancies DPC was held in the year 1985, which was obviously wrong. The Supreme Court directed DPC to be convened with reference to vacancies accruing each year. It was directed that benefit of retrospective promotion would be given. But we find no discussion on the legal issue whether as a matter of rule retrospective promotion can be effected, and it appears that the consequential directions found a mention and a place in the decision not as a result of a conscious view taken pursuant to a debate.
20. In a latest decision reported as 2010 (4) SCC 290 UOI & Anr. vs. Hemraj Singh Chauhan & Ors., the facts were that the respondents, Members of the State Civil Service, were expecting promotion to the Indian Administrative Service under the promotion quota requiring State Cadre review to be done well in time as per Rule 4(2) of the Indian Administrative Service (Cadre) Rules 1954 and the panel to last only for 60 days. There was an unexplainable delay causing severe prejudice to the respondents. Expressly invoking its power under Article 142 of the Constitution of India benefit of retrospective promotion was granted.
21. The cornucopia of case law above noted brings out the position:-
(i) Service Jurisprudence does not recognize retrospective promotion i.e. a promotion from a back date.
(ii) If there exists a rule authorizing the Executive to accord promotion from a retrospective date, a decision to grant promotion from a retrospective date would be valid because of a power existing to do so.
(iii) Since mala fides taints any exercise of power or an act done, requiring the person wronged to be placed in the position the person would find himself but for the mala fide and tainted exercise of power or the act, promotion from a retrospective date can be granted if delay in promotion is found attributable to a mala fide act i.e. deliberately delaying holding DPC, depriving eligible candidates the right to be promoted causing prejudice.
(iv) If due to administrative reasons DPC cannot be held in a year and there is no taint of malice, no retrospective promotion can be made.
22. The Tribunal has not kept afore-noted distinctions in mind and thus it has to be held that the impugned decision dated March 01, 2012 is required to be set aside, but before passing formal orders, we need to note something more. (emphasis supplied)
10. In B.P. Gairolas case (supra) again the Honble High Court of Delhi ruled that retrospective promotion can be granted only if rule supports such promotion. Paragraph 12 of the Judgment reads thus:- 12. This Court in Rajendra Roy (supra) and subsequently in R.N. Malhotra (supra) had the occasion to deal with the same office memorandum. The Division Bench on both the occasions applied the law declared by the Supreme Court in K.K. Vadera (supra) and Baij Nath Sharma (supra). We notice that in K.L Taneja (supra) too, an identical issue was involved, i.e. claim for retrospective promotion. While summarising the law in para 21, the Court stated that it is only if a rule supports the grant of retrospective promotion, that it is admissible and can be claimed. The exceptions to this principle are if a rightful claim of an officer or public servant is denied at the relevant time and his juniors in the cadre are given promotion, or he is able to plead and prove malafide in the given facts of the case.
11. Also in M.A. Ansaris case (supra), a Division Bench of Honble High Court of Delhi categorically ruled that service jurisprudence does not recognize retrospective promotion, i.e., a promotion from a back date. Relevant excerpt of the Judgment reads thus:- 1. On April 12, 2013, we had decided a batch of writ petitions, lead matter being WP(C) No.8102/2012 UOI & Anr. vs.K.L.Taneja & Anr. on the subject as to when can a person be granted promotion from a retrospective date. We had noted various decisions of the Supreme Court on the point as under:-
(i) 1987 (4) SCC 566 K.Madhavan & Anr. vs.UOI & Ors.
(ii) 1989 Supp (2) SCC 625 Union of India & Ors. vs. K.K.Vadera & Ors.
(iii) 1995 (4) SCC 246 Vinod Kumar Sangal vs.UOI& Ors.
(iv) 1998 (7) SCC 44 Baij Nath Sharma vs. Hon'ble Rajasthan High Court At Jodhpur & Anr.
(v) AIR 2004 SC 255 P.N Premachandran vs. The State of Kerala & Ors.
(vi) AIR 2004 SC 3460 Sanjay K.Sinha & Ors. vs. State of Bihar & Ors.
(vii) 2006 (13) SCALE 246 State of Uttaranchal & Ors. Vs.Dinesh Kr.Sharma
(viii) 2007 (1) SCC 683 State of Uttaranchal & Anr. vs. Dinesh kumar Sharma.
(ix) 2008 (14) SCC 29 Nirmal Chandra Sinha vs. UOI & Ors.
(x) 2010 (4) SCC 290 UOI & Anr. vs. Hemraj Singh Chauhan & Ors.
2. We had held that the cornucopia of case law above noted brings out the position :-
(i) Service Jurisprudence does not recognize retrospective promotion i.e. a promotion from a back date.
(ii) If there exists a rule authorizing the Executive to accord promotion from a retrospective date, a decision to grant promotion from a retrospective date would be valid because of a power existing to do so.
(iii) Since mala fides taints any exercise of power or an act done, requiring the person wronged to be placed in the position the person would find himself but for the mala fide and tainted exercise of power or the act, promotion from a retrospective date can be granted if delay in promotion is found attributable to a mala fide act i.e. deliberately delaying holding DPC, depriving eligible candidates the right to be promoted causing prejudice.
(iv) If due to administrative reasons DPC cannot be held in a year and there is no taint of malice, no retrospective promotion can be made.
12. The Orders relied upon by learned counsel for applicants in support of his contention that the applicants are entitled to retrospective promotion are of this Tribunal. In the wake of view taken by Honble High Court of Delhi in the aforementioned cases, particularly in the case of K.L. Taneja (supra) wherein their Lordships reversed the Order of this Tribunal whereby retrospective promotion was ordered, it is not permissible for us to go by the Orders of the Tribunal relied upon by the applicants. Even otherwise also, the legal position is very well settled, i.e., no State can be forced to fill up the vacancies as soon as these arise.
13. As far as the plea of learned counsel for applicants that the respondents did not adhere to the time schedule for convening DPC is concerned, we are of the considered view that the time schedule prescribed for convening the DPC is only a guiding tool and not mandatory. Further, if the schedule is not adhered to, an employee can approach the Court for adherence to the same and non-adherence to the schedule will not entitle an employee to seek retrospective promotion from a particular date.
14. The O.A. is found devoid of merit and is accordingly dismissed. No costs. ( V.N. Gaur ) ( A.K. Bhardwaj ) Member (A) Member (J) /sunil/
Alert