- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Chander Bhan v. Union of India
Justice Syed Rafat Alam, Chairman : By means of this Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, the sole applicant has sought quashing of the order of the Ministry of External Affairs dated 25.05.2009 whereby the select list of officers for promotion to the senior scale of the Indian Foreign Service (IFS) from Grade-I of IFS(B) for the recruitment year 2008-09 (supplementary panel) is approved.
2. The applicant is an officer of the Indian Foreign Service. He is aggrieved with the decision of the respondents in not promoting him to the senior scale of IFS from Grade-I of IFS(B) for the year 2008-09, and, therefore, has sought the following relief: (I) Quash and set aside Memo No.Q/PA11/584/1/2008 dated 25th May, 2009 issued by the Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi.
(II) Direct the respondent (Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi) to hold a review DPC for re-considering the candidature of the applicant.
(III) Allow the OA with exemplary cost.
(IV) Pass such other and further orders which their Lordships of this Honble Tribunal deem fit and proper in the light of the existing facts and circumstances of the case.
3. We have heard the applicant who appeared in person and Shri H. K. Gangwani, learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
4. When the matter was taken up on 20.03.2015, an objection was raised on behalf of the respondents about the maintainability of this Application on the ground of abnormal delay. The applicant, who was appearing in person though submitted that his case for promotion to the higher grade was not recommended by the DPC on account of below benchmark ACRs, and, therefore, he sought copy of those ACRs as the same were not served on him, which were supplied only on 27.12.2013 pursuant to his request under the Right to Information Act, 2005, and, therefore, the period of limitation is to be counted w.e.f. 27.12.2013 for the purpose of filing the Application under Section 19 of the Act. He submits that since the Application was filed on 11.02.2014, as such it is within time. However, on the oral prayer, he was granted one weeks time to file an application for condonation of delay, pursuant to which such application was filed on 31.03.2015, after serving copy of the same on the respondents.
5. It is submitted on behalf of the applicant that the ACRs which are alleged to be below benchmark were never communicated to him and as such he did not get an opportunity to represent for upgradation of the same. He placed reliance on the judgments of the Apex Court in Dev Dutt v Union of India & others [(2008) 8 SCC 725], and Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar v Union of India & others [(2009) 16 SCC 146] and argued that the below benchmark ACRs which are not communicated, cannot be taken into account by the DPC. He further submits that in that event the DPC is required to ignore the uncommunicated below benchmark ACR, and instead ACR for the preceding year, i.e., preceding immediately the first ACR under consideration, should be taken into consideration.
6. On the other hand, Shri Gangwani, learned counsel for the respondents opposed the prayer and submitted that at this distance of time, the claim of the applicant cannot be granted, especially when he had retired from service prior to filing of this Application. He, however, is not in a position to controvert that the below benchmark ACRs were not communicated to the applicant.
7. We have considered the submissions made on both sides. So far as the submission of the respondents that the Application is hopelessly barred by time, we do not find any merit in the same for the reason as noted above. The delay has been explained as the ACRs were only supplied to him pursuant to his application under the RTI Act in the month of October, 2013, and thereafter the Application under Section 19 is filed in the month of February, 2014. Therefore, it is difficult to hold that the Application is barred by time. Besides that the applicant since has filed application seeking condonation of delay, and the explanation furnished, in our view, is sufficient to condone the delay, we allow the application and condone the delay.
8. Now coming to the merits of the case, nothing is brought before us to show that ACRs which were below benchmark were communicated to the applicant, and thus the uncommunicated below benchmark ACRs cannot be looked into by the DPC while making assessment of an officer for promotion to the higher grade. In the instant case ACRs for seven years, i.e., from 2001-02 to 2007-08 were taken into consideration, out of which two ACRs, i.e., for 2005-06 and 2006-07 are partly graded as below average and average, which would be below benchmark for consideration for promotion to the next higher grade. These ACRs were supplied to the applicant only on 27.12.2013 pursuant to his RTI application. The DPC meeting for promotion to the senior scale of IFS for the recruitment year 2008-09 (supplementary panel) was held on 06.05.2009, wherein the applicant was declared unfit. Therefore, these ACRs having not been communicated to the applicant, the DPC should have ignored the same, and instead looked into the ACRs of the years immediately preceding the first ACR under consideration, i.e., 2001-02, or the respondents should have communicated the same so that the applicant could have represented against the below benchmark ACRs. The Government of India have also issued office memorandum No.21011/1/2010-Estt.A dated 13.04.2010, which provides that if an employee is to be considered for promotion in a future DPC and his ACRs prior to the period 2008-09 which would be reckonable for assessment of his fitness in such DPC, contain final grading which are below benchmark for his next promotion, before such ACRs are placed before the DPC, the concerned employee will be given a copy of the relevant ACRs for his representation, if any, within fifteen days of such communication. The respondents, therefore, ought to have communicated these two ACRs of 2005-06 and 2006-07 which were below benchmark to the applicant to enable him to make such representation, which, admittedly, has not been done in the instant case. The controversy, therefore, regarding supply of below benchmark ACRs is concluded by the judgments of the Apex Court in Dev Dutt (supra) and Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra), wherein their Lordships were of the view that the below benchmark ACRs have civil consequences as the same would affect the chances of promotion or other benefits, hence non-communication thereof is arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. In the instant case, admittedly, the aforesaid two ACRs of the period 2005-06 and 2006-07 were not communicated to the applicant, though the same were below benchmark, and for that reason he was not recommended by the DPC for promotion to the senior scale of the IFS from Grade-I of IFS-B for the recruitment year 2008-09. It is stated in para 7 of the counter affidavit of the respondents that the applicant was considered along with others for promotion to the senior scale of IFS for the recruitment year 2008-09, but the DPC did not find him fit for promotion as he had below average grading for the part period of the assessment year 2005-06, and average grading for the assessment year 2006-07. Therefore, it is admitted position that on account of these two ACRs, which were never communicated to the applicant, he was declared unfit for promotion. However, in the next meeting for the recruitment year 2009-10, he was again considered by the DPC and recommended for promotion to senior scale of IFS, pursuant to which he was promoted to the senior scale of IFS w.e.f. 31.10.2010 on the vacancy being available for substantive promotion. Therefore, in our view the controversy is squarely covered by the aforesaid two judgments of the Apex Court, i.e., Dev Dutt (supra) and Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra).
9. We, therefore, dispose of this Application with the direction to the respondents to communicate the aforesaid below benchmark ACRs to the applicant within one month for his representation, and on receipt of the same, to examine and take a decision thereon within one month thereafter. In the event the ACRs are upgraded, a review DPC would be convened to consider his case for promotion against the vacancies of 2008-09, and in the event he is found suitable he should be given promotion from the date when his immediate junior was so promoted. However, he shall not be entitled to claim arrears of salary etc. for that period, but the necessary corrections in his pension etc. would be made accordingly. However, if the reporting/reviewing/accepting authorities who had occasion to supervise the work of the applicant is/are not available due to retirement or for any other reason, in that event, the competent authority shall consider the representation on its own merit and the records/documents available, as per DOP&T OM dated 13.04.2010. If the competent authority were to arrive at the conclusion that the offensive remarks for the periods 2005-06 and 2006-07 are not justified and deserve to be upgraded for the reasons to be recorded in writing, a review DPC shall be held to re-consider the claim of the applicant for promotion for the recruitment year 2008-09.
10. The Application stands disposed of in terms of the above order, but without any order as to costs. (Dr. B. K. Sinha) (Syed Rafat Alam) Member (A) Chairman /lg/
Alert