Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sucha Singh Sodhi (Dead) Through Legal Representatives v. Baldev Raj Walia And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 13, 2018
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

In 1996, Sucha Singh (since deceased, now represented by the appellants) agreed to purchase the basement and half of the first floor of a property in Sanwar Nagar, New Delhi from Respondent 1 for ₹11,50,000 and paid an advance of ₹2,00,000 (later another ₹36,000). Possession was allegedly delivered in February 1996. On 10-10-1996 Respondent 1 threatened to dispossess the plaintiff, prompting Civil Suit No. 705/1996 for permanent injunction before the Senior Civil Judge, Delhi.

Respondent 1 pleaded that he had already transferred the premises to Respondent 2 and suggested the proper remedy was a suit for specific performance. On 27-11-1998 the plaintiff withdrew the injunction suit, expressly stating an intention to seek appropriate relief before the competent forum; the court permitted withdrawal subject to costs.

On 25-2-1999 the plaintiff instituted Civil Suit No. 54/1999 (later renumbered 135/2008) in the Court of the Additional District Judge, Tis Hazari, seeking specific performance of the 27-2-1996 agreement. Respondent 2 was impleaded and moved an application under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC, asserting a bar under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC. The trial court allowed that application and dismissed the suit on 8-5-2012; the Delhi High Court affirmed on 18-2-2014. The plaintiffs appealed to the Supreme Court, which granted leave and decided the present matter.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the subsequent suit for specific performance is barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure because the relief was not sought in the prior injunction suit.
  2. Whether the absence of a specific, recorded liberty to file a fresh suit in the withdrawal order of 27-11-1998 precludes the plaintiffs from maintaining the present suit for specific performance.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent 2 (Applicant under Order 7 Rule 11)

  • The specific performance suit is hit by Order 2 Rule 2 CPC because the relief could and ought to have been claimed in the earlier suit for permanent injunction based on the same transaction.

Appellants (Plaintiffs)

  • Order 2 Rule 2 is inapplicable; the causes of action for injunction and for specific performance are distinct in fact and in law, governed by different limitation provisions.
  • Even if explicit liberty was not recorded in so many words, the plaintiff’s statement while withdrawing the first suit and the court’s order together satisfy Order 23 Rule 1(3), permitting a fresh suit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Rathnavathi v. Kavita Ganashamdas (2015) 5 SCC 223 Distinct causes of action for injunction and specific performance; Order 2 Rule 2 bar not attracted when reliefs arise from different causes of action. Followed to hold that the present specific performance suit is not barred under Order 2 Rule 2.
Gurinderpal v. Jagmittar Singh (2004) 11 SCC 219 Fresh suit maintainable even when withdrawal order does not expressly mention liberty, if plaintiff’s statement and order read together indicate such liberty. Applied to reject the contention that lack of explicit liberty in the 1998 withdrawal order bars the present suit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court found both the trial court and High Court erred in invoking Order 2 Rule 2 via Order 7 Rule 11. It reasoned as follows:

  • The “sine qua non” for an Order 2 Rule 2 bar is that the second suit’s relief was available on the earlier cause of action. Here, the causes of action differ: one arose from a threat to possession (injunction) and the other from non-performance of a contract (specific performance).
  • The respective causes of action are governed by separate limitation articles: Articles 85-87 (injunction) versus Article 54 (specific performance) of the Limitation Act, 1963, underscoring their distinct nature.
  • Because the reliefs are not identical and are based on different factual ingredients, they could not be combined in one suit; therefore Order 2 Rule 2(2) is not triggered.
  • The plaintiff’s statement on 27-11-1998 that he sought withdrawal to approach the “appropriate forum” coupled with the court’s acceptance satisfies Order 23 Rule 1(3); following Gurinderpal, explicit mention of liberty is unnecessary.
  • Accordingly, the Order 7 Rule 11 application lacked merit; the plaint should be restored and tried on its merits.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED; TRIAL COURT AND HIGH COURT ORDERS SET ASIDE.

The Order 7 Rule 11 application is dismissed and Civil Suit No. 54/1999 (renumbered 135/2008) is restored for trial on merits. The trial court is directed to dispose of the suit expeditiously, preferably within one year, uninfluenced by observations in this judgment. No broader precedent is newly created; the Court re-affirms existing principles on Order 2 Rule 2 and Order 23 Rule 1.

Show all summary ...

Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.— Leave granted. This appeal arises from the final judgment and order dated 18-2-2014 passed by the High Court of Delhi at New Delhi in Sucha Singh Sodhi v. Baldev Raj Walia (2014) 3 HCC (Del) 294, 2014 SCC OnLine Del 750 whereby the Single Judge of the High Court dismissed the appeal filed by the appellants herein and upheld the judgment and order dated 8-5-2012 passed by the Additional District Judge, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi in Suit No. 135 of 2008 by which the suit of the appellants was dismissed by taking recourse to the powers under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (hereinafter referred to as, “the Code”).

2. In order to appreciate the short legal issue involved in the appeal, few relevant facts, which lie in a narrow compass, need to be mentioned hereinbelow.

3. The appellants are the plaintiffs whereas the respondents are the defendants in the civil suit out of which this appeal arises.

4. On 11-10-1996, Sucha Singh (original plaintiff) since dead and now being represented by his legal representatives (Appellants 1 to 4 herein) filed a suit being Civil Suit No. 705 of 1996 against Respondent 1 in the Court of Senior Civil Judge, Delhi. The suit was filed only for grant of permanent injunction.

5. The plaint was founded on the allegations, inter alia, that Respondent 1 was the owner of the house i.e. basement and half of the first-floor of the premises in Plot No. 1, Gali No. 9 situated at Sanwar Nagar Post Office Raipur Khurd, New Delhi, as detailed in the plaint (Annexure P-2) (hereinafter referred to as “the suit premises”). Respondent 1, on 27-2-1996, agreed to sell the suit premises to Sucha Singh (plaintiff) for Rs 11,50,000 and out of the total amount, Sucha Singh paid a sum of Rs 2,00,000 by way of advance to Respondent 1 by cheque.

6. It was further averred that Sucha Singh was placed in possession of the suit premises in February 1996. It was alleged that in May 1996 Respondent 1 demanded more money from Sucha Singh pursuant to which Sucha Singh further paid Rs 36,000 in cash to Respondent 1.

7. It was alleged that on 10-10-1996, Respondent 1 threatened to dispossess Sucha Singh from the suit premises and made unsuccessful attempt to dispossess him with the help of henchmen (Para 13 of the plaint).

8. It is on this cause of action, Sucha Singh filed a civil suit for permanent injunction on 11-10-1996 against Respondent 1 in relation to the suit premises restraining him from interfering with his possession over the suit premises.

9. Respondent 1 filed the written statement, inter alia, alleging therein that he has already transferred the suit premises to Respondent 2 herein and, therefore, the remedy of plaintiff Sucha Singh, if any, would be to file a civil suit for specific performance of the agreement against Respondent 1 but not in prosecuting the suit for permanent injunction.

10. On 27-11-1998, Sucha Singh (plaintiff) made a statement in the Court that he wants to withdraw the civil suit. He also made a statement that he is withdrawing the civil suit with a view to file proceedings before the competent forum to claim appropriate relief against Respondent 1.

11. The trial court, on 27-11-1998, allowed the original plaintiff (Sucha Singh) to withdraw the civil suit and passed the following order:

“It is submitted by the counsel for the plaintiff that he wants to withdraw the suit from this court to be filed before the appropriate forum. The counsel for defendant has no objection for withdrawal of the suit by the plaintiff, however, asking for cost incurred. Statements of both the parties have been recorded separately. Parties shall be bound by their statements as their undertakings in the court.
I have perused the records of the file and statements of both the parties. The plaintiff is allowed to withdraw the suit subject to cost of Rs 500 to be paid to the defendant. Cost paid in the court. After completion file be consigned to record room.”
(Archana Sinha)
Civil Judge, Delhi.
27-11-1998.”

12. On 25-2-1999, Sucha Singh, filed Civil Suit No. 54 of 1999 (Re-numbered as Suit No. 135 of 2008) in the Court of Additional District Judge, Tis Hazari Courts, Delhi against Respondent 1 for specific performance of the agreement dated 27-2-1996. In para 13, the plaintiff stated the facts for constituting the accrual of cause of action for filing the suit for specific performance of the agreement.

13. Respondent 2 i.e. the alleged subsequent purchaser filed an application under Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code to become a party (defendant) in the suit. The application was allowed and Respondent 2 was arrayed as Defendant 2.

14. Both the respondents (Defendants 1 and 2) filed their written statement and denied the plaintiff's claim on various grounds on facts and in law. Respondent 2 also filed an application under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code for rejection of the plaint.

15. It was, inter alia, alleged that the suit in question (specific performance of agreement) is hit by the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code because the relief of specific performance, which is claimed in the present suit could be and ought to have been claimed by the plaintiff Sucha Singh in the previously instituted suit which he had filed for permanent injunction. It was contended that non-claiming of relief of specific performance of the agreement in the previously instituted suit though available to the plaintiff for being claimed on the cause of action pleaded in the previous suit would attract the bar contained in Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code to the subsequently instituted civil suit wherein a relief of specific performance of agreement is claimed and, therefore, such suit cannot be now tried on merits.

16. During the pendency of the suit, Sucha Singh died on 4-8-2000 and his legal representatives (appellants herein) were brought on record as plaintiffs to continue the lis. The appellants (plaintiffs) opposed the application filed by Defendant 2 (Respondent 2 herein) and contended that the suit for specific performance of agreement is maintainable and not barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code.

17. The trial court, however, by order dated 8-5-2012 allowed Respondent 2's application and, in consequence, dismissed the appellants' suit holding that it is barred by the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code. In other words, the trial court held that the plaintiffs ought to have claimed the relief of specific performance of the agreement in the previous suit, which was filed by Sucha Singh (original plaintiff) for permanent injunction because according to the trial court such relief was available for being claimed when the first suit was filed.

18. The plaintiffs felt aggrieved and filed appeal before the High Court of Delhi. By the impugned judgment, the High Court while concurring with the reasoning and the conclusion of the trial court dismissed the appeal. Against the said judgment, the plaintiffs felt aggrieved and have filed the present appeal by way of special leave in this Court.

19. Heard Mr Bhim Sain Jain, learned counsel for the appellants, Mr Jayant Bhushan, learned Senior Counsel for Respondent 1 and Mr Pramod Dayal, learned counsel for Respondent 2.

20. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record of the case, we are inclined to allow the appeal and while setting aside the judgment and order of the High Court and the trial court, dismiss the application filed by Respondent 2 (Defendant 2) under Order 7 Rule 11 CPC and restore Civil Suit No. 54 of 1999 (re-numbered as Suit No. 135 of 2008) filed by the appellants herein against the respondents out of which this appeal arises for being tried on merits in accordance with law.

21. In our considered opinion, the trial court and the High Court erred in allowing the application filed by Respondent 2 under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code and thereby erred in dismissing the suit as being barred by the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code by taking recourse to the provisions of Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code. In our opinion, the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code are not attracted to the facts of this case and, therefore, civil suit should not have been dismissed as being barred under Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code.

22. Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code reads as under:

“2. Suit to include the whole claim.—(1) Every suit shall include the whole of the claim which the plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of the cause of action; but a plaintiff may relinquish any portion of his claim in order to bring the suit within the jurisdiction of any court.
(2) Relinquishment of part of claim.—Where a plaintiff omits to sue in respect of, or intentionally relinquishes, any portion of his claim, he shall not afterwards sue in respect of the portion so omitted or relinquished.”

23. Order 2 Rule 2(1) of the Code provides that every suit shall include the whole of the claim, which the plaintiff is entitled to make in respect of the cause of action. Liberty is, however, granted to the plaintiff to relinquish any portion of his claim with a view to bring the suit within the jurisdiction of any court.

24. It is clear from the reading of Order 2 Rule 2(1) of the Code that whenever the plaintiff files a suit on the basis of a cause of action pleaded in the plaint, he is under a legal obligation to include and claim all the reliefs against the defendant, which have accrued to him on the cause of action pleaded by him in his plaint. In other words, if on the basis of cause of action pleaded by the plaintiff in the plaint, he is entitled to claim two reliefs, namely, ‘A’ and ‘B’ against the defendant(s), then he is under an obligation to claim both ‘A’ and ‘B’ reliefs together in the suit. Order 2 Rule 2(1) of the Code enables the plaintiff to relinquish any portion of his relief with a view to bring the suit within the jurisdiction of any court.

25. Order 2 Rule 2(2) of the Code, however, provides that where a plaintiff omits to sue or intentionally relinquishes, any portion of his claim/relief in his suit, then in such event, he shall not be allowed afterwards to sue in respect of the claim/relief so omitted or/and relinquished by him in his suit. In other words Rule 2(2) does not permit the plaintiff to file second suit to claim the omitted or/and relinquished relief.

26. In our opinion, the sine qua non for invoking Order 2 Rule 2(2) against the plaintiff by the defendant is that the relief which the plaintiff has claimed in the second suit was also available to the plaintiff for being claimed in the previous suit on the causes of action pleaded in the previous suit against the defendant and yet not claimed by the plaintiff.

27. Therefore, we have to examine the question as to whether the plaintiff was entitled to claim a relief of specific performance of agreement in the previous suit on the basis of cause of action pleaded by the plaintiff in the previous suit against the respondents/defendants in relation to suit property.

28. In other words, the question that arises for consideration is whether Sucha Singh (original plaintiff) could claim the relief of specific performance of agreement against the respondents/defendants in addition to his claim of permanent injunction in the previously instituted suit.

29. Our answer to the aforementioned question is in favour of the plaintiffs (appellants) and against the defendants (respondents). In other words, our answer to the aforementioned question is that the plaintiff could not claim the relief of specific performance of agreement against the defendants along with the relief of permanent injunction in the previous suit for the following reasons:

29.1. First, the cause of action to claim a relief of permanent injunction and the cause of action to claim a relief of specific performance of agreement are independent and one cannot include the other and vice versa. In other words, a plaintiff cannot claim a relief of specific performance of agreement against the defendant on a cause of action on which he has claimed a relief of permanent injunction.

29.2. Second, the cause of action to claim temporary/permanent injunction against the defendants from interfering in the plaintiff's possession over the suit premises accrues when Defendant 1 threatens the plaintiff to dispossess him from the suit premises or otherwise cause injury to the plaintiff in relation to the suit premises. It is governed by Order 39 Rule 1(c) of the Code which deals with the grant of injunction. The limitation to file such suit is three years from the date of obstruction caused by the defendant to the plaintiff (see Part VII Articles 85, 86 and 87 of the Limitation Act). On the other hand, the cause of action to file a suit for claiming specific performance of agreement arises from the date fixed for the performance or when no such date is fixed, when the plaintiff has noticed that performance is refused by the defendant. The limitation to file such suit is three years from such date (see Part II Article 54 of the Limitation Act).

29.3. Third, when both the reliefs/claims, namely, (1) permanent injunction, and (2) specific performance of agreement are not identical, when the causes of action to sue are separate, when the factual ingredients necessary to constitute the respective causes of action for both the reliefs/claims are different and lastly, when both the reliefs/claims are governed by separate articles of the Limitation Act, then, in our opinion, it is not possible to claim both the reliefs together on one cause of action.

30. This Court in Rathnavathi v. Kavita Ganashamdas (2015) 5 SCC 223 had the occasion to examine this very question on somewhat similar facts in detail. This Court after taking into account the earlier decisions of this Court which dealt with this question held in paras 22 to 31 that bar contained in Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code on such facts is not attracted against the plaintiff so as to disentitle him from filing the subsequent suit to claim specific performance of agreement against the defendants in relation to the suit property.

31. We apply the law laid down in Rathnavathi (2015) 5 SCC 223 and hold that the suit filed by the original plaintiff for specific performance of agreement against the respondents (defendants) is not barred by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code and is held maintainable for being tried on merits.

32. This takes us to examine another question as to whether in the absence of any permission/liberty granted by the trial court to the plaintiff at the time of withdrawing the previous suit filed for permanent injunction, the plaintiff was entitled to file the suit for specific performance of agreement against the defendants in relation to the suit property?

33. In our considered opinion, this question does not now survive for consideration in the light of what we have held above. In any event, keeping in view the law laid down by this Court in Gurinderpal v. Jagmittar Singh (2004) 11 SCC 219, the question is answered against the respondents.

34. In somewhat similar facts, the question arose before this Court in Gurinderpal case (2004) 11 SCC 219, namely, if the order granting permission to withdraw the suit under Order 23 Rule 1(3) of the Code does not specifically mention the fact of granting liberty to the plaintiff to file a fresh suit, whether filing of fresh suit would be hit by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code?

35. This Court (three-Judge Bench), speaking through R.C. Lahoti, J. (as his Lordship then was), held that filing of the second suit is not hit by Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code and is maintainable for being tried on merits. This is what this Court held in para 6: (Gurinderpal case (2004) 11 SCC 219)

“6. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, we are satisfied that the judgment of the High Court as also of the first appellate court cannot be sustained to the extent to which the bar enacted under Order 2 Rule 2 CPC has been applied. The provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 CPC bar the remedy of the appellant-plaintiff and, therefore, must be strictly construed. The order of the trial court dated 15-6-1994 passed in the earlier suit, extracted and reproduced hereinabove, has to be read in the light of the statement of the appellant-plaintiff recorded by the court on that very date. The appellant-plaintiff had clearly stated that he was seeking leave to withdraw the suit with the liberty of filing a fresh suit. The trial court recorded that the suit was being dismissed as withdrawn “in view of the statement of the plaintiff”. A conjoint reading of the order of the court and the statement of the plaintiff, clearly suggests that the suit was dismissed as withdrawn because the plaintiff wanted to file a fresh suit, obviously wherein the plaintiff would seek the decree of specific performance and not of a mere injunction as was prayed for in the suit which was sought to be withdrawn. In the subsequent suit, the first appellate court was not right in forming an opinion that liberty to file the fresh suit was not given to the plaintiff in the order dated 15-6-1994. That finding of the first appellate court ought not to have been sustained by the High Court.”

36. Applying the aforementioned principle of law to the case at hand, we find that the original plaintiff (Sucha Singh), in clear terms, had stated in the previous suit that he wants to withdraw the suit because he wants to file appropriate proceedings before the competent forum in relation to the subject-matter of the suit. The trial court recorded his statement on 27-11-1998 and allowed withdrawal of the suit.

37. In our considered opinion, reading of the statement of the original plaintiff (Sucha Singh) coupled with the permission granted by the Court to withdraw the suit satisfies the requirement of Order 23 Rule 1(3) of the Code. It certainly enabled the plaintiff to file a fresh suit, namely, the civil suit for claiming specific performance of the agreement against the defendants. In our view, the Court was entitled to take into consideration the statement made by the original plaintiff (Sucha Singh) for withdrawing the suit and filing it afresh and his statement could be made a part of the order for granting permission to withdraw the civil suit and file a fresh suit as was held in Gurinderpal (2004) 11 SCC 219.

38. In our view, therefore, this submission urged by the learned counsel for the respondents has no merit.

39. The learned counsel for Respondent 2 (Defendant 2) then addressed the Court on the merits of the suit. We are afraid, we cannot go into any question relating to the merits of the controversy involved in the suit. It is for the trial court to now proceed to try the suit on merits and decide the suit in accordance with law.

40. In view of the foregoing discussion, we cannot concur with the reasoning and the conclusion arrived at by the trial court and the High Court which wrongly allowed the application filed by Respondent 2 (Defendant 2) under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code and, in consequence, dismissed the appellants' (plaintiffs') suit as being barred by the provisions of Order 2 Rule 2 of the Code.

41. As a consequence, the appeal succeeds and is accordingly allowed. The impugned judgment is set aside. The application filed by Respondent 2 (Defendant 2) under Order 7 Rule 11 of the Code is dismissed.

42. The civil suit (No. 54 of 1999 renumbered as 135 of 2008) filed by the appellants against the respondents is held maintainable. It is accordingly restored to its original file for being tried on merits and in accordance with law.

43. The trial court is directed to decide the civil suit on merit expeditiously and preferably within one year without being influenced by any of our observations.