Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gurpret Singh v. Zee Learn

District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Aug 18, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The complainant, Gurpreet Singh (presently settled in Canada), filed the complaint through his father/power of attorney Bhupinder Singh under Sections 12 to 14 of the Consumer Protection Act against the Opposite Party (OP) regarding an alleged failure to grant a Kidzee franchise and return the franchise fee.

Relevant factual averments in the complaint (as stated in the opinion): in September 2012 the OP expressed willingness to grant Kidzee franchises; an e-mail was sent to the complainant dated 09.10.2012; the complainant submitted the application and on 24.12.2012 transferred Rs.2,10,000/- by RTGS to the OP's ICICI Bank account. In January 2013 the OP provided art works and colour codes and invited the complainant to an event at its Noida office. The complainant remained in contact; during a November 2014 visit he was told the application was under process. The complainant alleges he was never issued the required certificate/agreement format, the OP did not inform him if the application was refused, and the Rs.2,10,000/- was not returned. In January 2016 the complainant discovered that the OP had started a Kidzee school at Sirhind. He served a legal notice and sought damages of Rs.5,00,000/-.

The OP contested the complaint, filed a written reply and raised preliminary objections: the complaint is not maintainable; no cause of action; barred by limitation; and that the dispute is commercial and not entertainable by the Forum under the Consumer Protection Act. The OP maintained that the complainant was slow to execute the agreement, did not comply with a condition to start the centre within 60 days, failed to deposit an Illume Kit fee of Rs.3,50,000/-, and that the Rs.2,10,000/- was a one-time non-refundable franchise fee. The OP produced documents (agreement dated 26.12.2012 Ex. OP-1, show cause notice dated 29.08.2013 Ex. OP-2, resolution dated 29.08.2016 Ex. OP-3, affidavit Ex. OP-4).

The complainant produced evidence including power of attorney (Ex. C-1), rent deed (Ex. C-2), e-mail (Ex. C-3), bank statement (Ex. C-4), affidavit (Ex. C-5) and other documents (Ex. C-6 to Ex. C-11). Oral arguments were heard on 04.08.2017 and the reserved order was pronounced on 18.08.2017.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the complainant qualifies as a "consumer" within the meaning of Section 2(d) of the Consumer Protection Act in respect of the alleged franchise transaction.
  2. Whether the complaint is maintainable before the Forum given the OP's objections that the dispute is commercial in nature and/or barred by limitation and that no cause of action has arisen.

Arguments of the Parties

Opposite Party's Arguments

  • The complainant is not a "consumer" under Section 2(d) because he purchased the franchise for commercial purposes (to earn profit) and thus is outside the Act's protection as framed by relevant case law.
  • The complainant was slow and failed to execute the agreement and to comply with express conditions (including starting the centre within 60 days and depositing Rs.3,50,000/- for an Illume Kit).
  • The Rs.2,10,000/- was a one-time non-refundable franchise fee; there is no deficiency in service on the OP's part.
  • The OP lost business opportunities due to the complainant's conduct and was entitled to offer the franchise to another party.
  • Preliminary objections: the complaint is not maintainable, barred by limitation, and the dispute is commercial and not entertainable by the Forum.
  • The OP relied on prior decisions (cited in the opinion) to support that a franchisee is not a consumer vis-à-vis the granter of the franchise.

Complainant's Arguments

  • The complainant argued the matter should be adjudicated on merits and that the franchise was purchased for earning his livelihood rather than for profit; he disputed the applicability of the case law relied upon by the OP as factually distinguishable.
  • The complainant asserted he fulfilled the OP's requirements, paid the stated amount, obtained a rented building by lease deed, and was not provided the agreement/certificate nor the return of the fee.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
National Commission others Vs. R. Kannan, 1994(1) C.P.J.14 The franchise holder is a licensee rendering service to the grantor of the franchise and therefore cannot be treated as a "consumer" under the Act in that inter se relationship. The court accepted this ratio as supporting the OP's contention that a franchise holder is not a consumer vis-à-vis the granter; it formed part of the basis for finding the complainant not to be a consumer.
Harmanjit Singh Dhillon Vs. M/s S.K. Education Pvt. Ltd., FA No.1228 of 2013 (decided 13.02.2014) Held that the franchise holder who was to run a school was not a consumer vis-à-vis the granter of the franchise; the ratio was applied to franchise relationships. The court relied on the ratio in this State Commission decision to support the conclusion that the complainant (franchise holder) was not a consumer in relation to the OP (granter), and upheld that approach in disposing the complaint.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first considered the OP's preliminary objections, with particular focus on whether the complainant qualifies as a "consumer" under Section 2(d) of the Act. The court evaluated the evidence tendered by both sides and the oral and written submissions. It gave weight to the OP's submissions and the case law cited by the OP (R. Kannan and Harmanjit Singh Dhillon).

A key factual-administrative finding was that the complainant had not pleaded that the franchise was purchased for the purpose of earning his livelihood, nor had he stated that in his affidavit (Ex. C-5). The court treated the nature of the franchise transaction and the relationship between granter and franchisee through the lens of the cited precedents, which hold that a franchise holder in that inter se relationship is not a "consumer" for purposes of the Consumer Protection Act.

Applying those precedents to the facts and noting the absence of a pleaded claim that the franchise was for livelihood, the court concluded that the complainant did not meet the definition of "consumer" under the Act and therefore the complaint was not maintainable before the Forum.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court held that the complainant is not a "consumer" within the meaning of the Consumer Protection Act in relation to the franchise transaction and consequently the complaint is not maintainable before the Forum. The court ordered that the complaint along with all documents be returned to the complainant so he may seek redressal before the appropriate court of law.

Implications:

  • The direct effect is procedural: the Forum did not adjudicate the merits and returned the complaint and documents for the complainant to pursue other appropriate fora.
  • The opinion applies existing case law about franchise relationships and does not purport to establish a new legal principle; the court relied on prior authorities to resolve the maintainability issue.

Order dates in the opinion: arguments heard 04.08.2017; order pronounced 18.08.2017. (Pronounced by A.P.S. Rajput, President; Inder Jit, Member.)

Show all summary ...

By Ajit Pal Singh Rajput, President Complainant, Gurpreet Singh son of Bhupinder Singh R/o village Ramgarh Sainian, Tehsil and District Fatehgarh Sahib, who is presently settled in Canada, has filed this complaint through his father/power of attorney Bhupinder Singh son of Jagir Singh against the Opposite Party (hereinafter referred to as the OP) under Sections 12 to 14 of the Consumer Protection Act. The brief facts of the complaint are as under: The OP, in the month of September 2012, expressed its willingness to give Kidzee Franchises to the complainant with detail of terms and conditions as per the E-mail delivered by the OP to the complainant on 09.10.2012. The complainant consulted his father and has gone through all the terms and conditions issued by the OP. The OP had contacted the complainant on telephone through their authorized officer Mr. Mukesh and has agreed to receive the complete Kidzee Application Form along with required amount as per terms and conditions settled by the OP. The complainant had already fulfilled all the terms and conditions as mentioned in Kidzee Application Form and also obtained a building situated at Preet Nagar, Ward No.6, Sirhind, Tehsil and District Fatehgarh Sahib on rent from its owner through valid and registered lease deed. The complainant had also transferred the amount of Rs.2,10,000/- in the Bank Account of the OP i.e. ICICI Bank Ltd., having account No. 000405004775 through RTGS on 24.12.2012 from his bank account in Punjab National Bank, Branch Badali Alla Singh. In the month of January 2013, after accepting the Application Form and other concerned documents, the OP had also issued the Art Works and Colour Codes for the center at the address of complainant and in this regard an invitation for Alchemy at Noida Office was also issued. The complainant remained in regular contact with the OP through their authorized officers, by telephonic conversation and e-mail and even in the month of November 2014, the complainant visited the Noida Office and he was assured by the concerned authorized officer Mr. Ashok Pal, that the application is under process. Despite the various requests, the complainant was never told regarding the next step to start the Kidzee Play Schools at Fatehgarh Sahib. The concerned dealing hand never issued the certificate of initiative the Pre Schools, even the specific format of agreement was not issued to the complainant. The OP neither issued any information to the complainant regarding the refusal of application form nor even returned the above mentioned amount of Rs.2,10,000/- obtained by the OP in a fraudulent manner. In the month of January 2016, the complainant was stunned to know that the OP had already started a Kidzee School at Sirhind without giving any information to the complainant, which is purely unfair trade practice on the part of the OP. The complainant also served a legal notice on the OP but all in vain. Hence, this complaint for giving directions to the OP to pay the damages, compensation and economic loss amounting to Rs.5,00,000/-. The complaint is contested by the OP, who filed its written reply. In reply to the complaint, OP raised certain preliminary objections, inter alia, that the complaint is not maintainable in the present form; no cause of action has arisen in favour of the complainant to file the present complaint; the present complaint is barred by limitation and the present dispute being commercial in nature is not entertainable under the summary jurisdiction vested with the Forum under the Consumer Protection Act. As regard the facts of the complaint, OP stated that the complainant himself approached the OP for giving him a franchisee for opening a pre-school under the guidance of the OP. The complainant was hopelessly slow in execution of the agreement, so much so, inspite of the express condition No.5.1 in the Agreement to start the Centre within 60 days of the signing of the agreement, still the complainant did not do anything for a period of more than 243 days, as such letter dated 29.08.2013 was issued to the complainant. Despite having received the letter, the complainant did not show any interest. As per agreement the complainant was to deposit Rs.3,50,000/- for Illume Kit but the same was never deposited. The sum of Rs.2,10,000/-, which was deposited by the complainant, was by way of a one time non-refundable franchisee fee towards the grant of the license in favour of the Complainant to run a franchise of Kidzee Pre-School. The complainant has failed to show that he had taken any steps to execute the agreement. The OP lost on business opportunities and revenues in this region due to the reckless conduct of the complainant. The complainant failed to commence the Kidzee Centre despite a long lapse of time. The OP could not wait indefinitely for the complainant to respond, and as such, were within their right to offer the franchisee to any other deserving party. There is no deficiency in service on their part. After denying the other averments made in the complaint, it prayed for dismissal of the complaint. In order to prove his case, the complainant tendered in evidence power of attorney Ex. C-1, rent deed Ex. C-2, copy of email Ex. C-3, copy of statement of bank account Ex. C-4, his affidavit Ex. C-5, copies of documents Ex. C-6 to Ex. C-11 and closed the evidence. In rebuttal the OP tendered in evidence true copies of documents i.e. agreement dated 26.12.2012 Ex. OP-1, show cause notice dated 29.08.2013 Ex. OP-2, resolution dated 29.08.2016 Ex. OP-3, affidavit of Deepa Josh George Ex.OP-4 and closed the evidence. Learned counsel for the OP has, at the outset, submitted that his preliminary objections be adjudicated first, before deciding the case on merits. He stated the complainant is not a consumer as per Section 2(d) of the Act. Learned counsel further submitted that complainant had opted to purchase the franchisee for commercial purpose and complainant has failed to prove that it was not for earning profit. The learned counsel in order to support his contentions relied on the case titled as; The General Manager, Madras Telephones and , wherein the Hon'ble National Commissionothers Vs. R. Kannan, in 1994(1) C.P.J.14 held that, " A franchise holder is only a licensee of the grantor of the franchise for operating the STD/PCO and collecting the call charges on behalf of the franchiser- It is the franchise holder who is rendering service to the grantor of the franchise who cannot be said to be Consumer under the Act- The mere fact that the franchise holder has been described as the hirer of the PCO does not make him a person who renders service to the Telecom Department for consideration- He renders the service to those who use the public call office- order of State Commission granting relief to the The Ld. counsel further relied on the case titled as; respondent/complainant, set aside". . decided on 13.02.2014 in FAHarmanjit Singh Dhillon Vs. M/s S.K. Education Pvt. Ltd No.1228 of 2013, wherein the Hon'ble State Commission held in para No.7 that " No doubt, it was a case regarding the operating of the STD/PCO but the ratio thereof is applicable so far as the inter se relationship of the franchise holder and granter of the franchise is concerned. In view of the ratio of this judgment, it is to be held that the complainant, who was the franchise holder and was to run the School, was not a consumer vis--vis the opposite party, who was the granter of the franchise. A correct finding to that effect was recorded by the District Forum and the same is hereby .upheld" On the other hand, the ld. counsel for the complainant objected to the submissions made by the ld. counsel for the OP and stated that the present case deserves to be adjudicated on merits. He further stated that the franchise was purchased for earning his livelihood and not for earning profit. Learned counsel argued that the case laws citied by the OP cannot be relied upon, as the facts of the said cases are different and the same is not applicable. After hearing the Ld. Counsel for the parties and going through the pleadings, evidence produced by the parties and the oral arguments and written submissions, we find force in the submissions made by the learned counsel for the OP and the case laws citied by him. Complainant has not pleaded in his pleadings that the said franchise was purchased for the purpose of earning his livelihood nor it has been stated in the statement in shape of affidavit

By Ajit Pal Singh Rajput, President Complainant, Gurpreet Singh son of Bhupinder Singh R/o village Ramgarh Sainian, Tehsil and District Fatehgarh Sahib, who is presently settled in Canada, has filed this complaint through his father/power of attorney Bhupinder Singh son of Jagir Singh against the Opposite Party (hereinafter referred to as the OP) under Sections 12 to 14 of the Consumer Protection Act. The brief facts of the complaint are as under: The OP, in the month of September 2012, expressed its willingness to give Kidzee Franchises to the complainant with detail of terms and conditions as per the E-mail delivered by the OP to the complainant on 09.10.2012. The complainant consulted his father and has gone through all the terms and conditions issued by the OP. The OP had contacted the complainant on telephone through their authorized officer Mr. Mukesh and has agreed to receive the complete Kidzee Application Form along with required amount as per terms and conditions settled by the OP. The complainant had already fulfilled all the terms and conditions as mentioned in Kidzee Application Form and also obtained a building situated at Preet Nagar, Ward No.6, Sirhind, Tehsil and District Fatehgarh Sahib on rent from its owner through valid and registered lease deed. The complainant had also transferred the amount of Rs.2,10,000/- in the Bank Account of the OP i.e. ICICI Bank Ltd., having account No. 000405004775 through RTGS on 24.12.2012 from his bank account in Punjab National Bank, Branch Badali Alla Singh. In the month of January 2013, after accepting the Application Form and other concerned documents, the OP had also issued the Art Works and Colour Codes for the center at the address of complainant and in this regard an invitation for Alchemy at Noida Office was also issued. The complainant remained in regular contact with the OP through their authorized officers, by telephonic conversation and e-mail and even in the month of November 2014, the complainant visited the Noida Office and he was assured by the concerned authorized officer Mr. Ashok Pal, that the application is under process. Despite the various requests, the complainant was never told regarding the next step to start the Kidzee Play Schools at Fatehgarh Sahib. The concerned dealing hand never issued the certificate of initiative the Pre Schools, even the specific format of agreement was not issued to the complainant. The OP neither issued any information to the complainant regarding the refusal of application form nor even returned the above mentioned amount of Rs.2,10,000/- obtained by the OP in a fraudulent manner. In the month of January 2016, the complainant was stunned to know that the OP had already started a Kidzee School at Sirhind without giving any information to the complainant, which is purely unfair trade practice on the part of the OP. The complainant also served a legal notice on the OP but all in vain. Hence, this complaint for giving directions to the OP to pay the damages, compensation and economic loss amounting to Rs.5,00,000/-. The complaint is contested by the OP, who filed its written reply. In reply to the complaint, OP raised certain preliminary objections, inter alia, that the complaint is not maintainable in the present form; no cause of action has arisen in favour of the complainant to file the present complaint; the present complaint is barred by limitation and the present dispute being commercial in nature is not entertainable under the summary jurisdiction vested with the Forum under the Consumer Protection Act. As regard the facts of the complaint, OP stated that the complainant himself approached the OP for giving him a franchisee for opening a pre-school under the guidance of the OP. The complainant was hopelessly slow in execution of the agreement, so much so, inspite of the express condition No.5.1 in the Agreement to start the Centre within 60 days of the signing of the agreement, still the complainant did not do anything for a period of more than 243 days, as such letter dated 29.08.2013 was issued to the complainant. Despite having received the letter, the complainant did not show any interest. As per agreement the complainant was to deposit Rs.3,50,000/- for Illume Kit but the same was never deposited. The sum of Rs.2,10,000/-, which was deposited by the complainant, was by way of a one time non-refundable franchisee fee towards the grant of the license in favour of the Complainant to run a franchise of Kidzee Pre-School. The complainant has failed to show that he had taken any steps to execute the agreement. The OP lost on business opportunities and revenues in this region due to the reckless conduct of the complainant. The complainant failed to commence the Kidzee Centre despite a long lapse of time. The OP could not wait indefinitely for the complainant to respond, and as such, were within their right to offer the franchisee to any other deserving party. There is no deficiency in service on their part. After denying the other averments made in the complaint, it prayed for dismissal of the complaint. In order to prove his case, the complainant tendered in evidence power of attorney Ex. C-1, rent deed Ex. C-2, copy of email Ex. C-3, copy of statement of bank account Ex. C-4, his affidavit Ex. C-5, copies of documents Ex. C-6 to Ex. C-11 and closed the evidence. In rebuttal the OP tendered in evidence true copies of documents i.e. agreement dated 26.12.2012 Ex. OP-1, show cause notice dated 29.08.2013 Ex. OP-2, resolution dated 29.08.2016 Ex. OP-3, affidavit of Deepa Josh George Ex.OP-4 and closed the evidence. Learned counsel for the OP has, at the outset, submitted that his preliminary objections be adjudicated first, before deciding the case on merits. He stated the complainant is not a consumer as per Section 2(d) of the Act. Learned counsel further submitted that complainant had opted to purchase the franchisee for commercial purpose and complainant has failed to prove that it was not for earning profit. The learned counsel in order to support his contentions relied on the case titled as; The General Manager, Madras Telephones and , wherein the Hon'ble National Commissionothers Vs. R. Kannan, in 1994(1) C.P.J.14 held that, " A franchise holder is only a licensee of the grantor of the franchise for operating the STD/PCO and collecting the call charges on behalf of the franchiser- It is the franchise holder who is rendering service to the grantor of the franchise who cannot be said to be Consumer under the Act- The mere fact that the franchise holder has been described as the hirer of the PCO does not make him a person who renders service to the Telecom Department for consideration- He renders the service to those who use the public call office- order of State Commission granting relief to the The Ld. counsel further relied on the case titled as; respondent/complainant, set aside". . decided on 13.02.2014 in FAHarmanjit Singh Dhillon Vs. M/s S.K. Education Pvt. Ltd No.1228 of 2013, wherein the Hon'ble State Commission held in para No.7 that " No doubt, it was a case regarding the operating of the STD/PCO but the ratio thereof is applicable so far as the inter se relationship of the franchise holder and granter of the franchise is concerned. In view of the ratio of this judgment, it is to be held that the complainant, who was the franchise holder and was to run the School, was not a consumer vis--vis the opposite party, who was the granter of the franchise. A correct finding to that effect was recorded by the District Forum and the same is hereby .upheld" On the other hand, the ld. counsel for the complainant objected to the submissions made by the ld. counsel for the OP and stated that the present case deserves to be adjudicated on merits. He further stated that the franchise was purchased for earning his livelihood and not for earning profit. Learned counsel argued that the case laws citied by the OP cannot be relied upon, as the facts of the said cases are different and the same is not applicable. After hearing the Ld. Counsel for the parties and going through the pleadings, evidence produced by the parties and the oral arguments and written submissions, we find force in the submissions made by the learned counsel for the OP and the case laws citied by him. Complainant has not pleaded in his pleadings that the said franchise was purchased for the purpose of earning his livelihood nor it has been stated in the statement in shape of affidavit i.e Ex.C-5. Accordingly, in view of our aforesaid discussions and the case laws cited by the OP in , we find that the complainantR.Kannan's and Harmanjit Singh Dhillon's cases(Supra) is not a consumer, hence complaint alongwith with all the documents be returned to the complainant so that he may seek redressal of his grievances before the appropriate court of law.

9. The arguments on the complaint were heard on 04.08.2017 and the order was reserved. Now the order be communicated to the parties. Copy of the order be sent to the parties free of cost and thereafter the file be consigned to the record room. Pronounced Dated:18.08.2017 (A.P.S.Rajput) President (Inder Jit) Member