Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

DASARI NIRMALA DEVI, v. THE BRANCH MANAGER

District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Jan 22, 2018

(ORDER BY Sri S.V. CHALAPATHI, PRESIDENT)

1. This complaint is filed under section-12 of Consumer Protection Act, 1986, against the opposite parties 1 to 3, requesting this forum to direct the 3rd opposite party to pay Rs.6,00,000/- under insurance policy, with interest @ 18% p.a., and also to pay a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation and to pay a sum of Rs.10,000/- towards costs of the litigation.

2. The brief averments of the complaint are as follows: The complainant had fixed deposits in Shriram Chits and she was regular customer of Chit Company. While so, in the year 2009, when her fixed deposits matured and when she went to the Branch Office, Chirala, for encashment of F.Ds., at that time, she was misled and lured by the then manager and one office assistant to obtain Shree Plus Policy of Shriram Life Insurance and they did not inform her that it is Ulip Policy and not explained the terms and conditions and took her signatures on papers in hurried manner. Believing the staff of branch office, she took policy in the month of May2009 and paid premium for 3 years up to 2011 and obtained receipts, she stopped payment of premiums, because, she was told by the staff she has to pay premiums only for 3 years. While so, after completion of 6th year and during 7th year on 28.05.2016, she intended to take back her money, but she received phone intimation from Shriram Life insurance, Chennai, stating that, her policy was Auto Surrender, in the year 2014 itself as she did not pay premiums regularly and the offered to pay about Rs.2,45,000/- only. She was surprised, she paid Rs.3,00,000/- and she was assured return of 6,00,000/-, but now, they are offering only about Rs.2,45,000/-. Then, she verified the policy document and came to know she was cheated and even she was given policy bond after free look period is over. The policy bond was sent to Shriram Chits, Chirala and later, it was delivered to her, after free look period is over. She has not received any Auto Surrendered notice from insurance company, the Branch Office, Chirala, also did not inform about Auto Surrender, therefore, she gave a complaint through e-mail and to Shriram Life Insurance on 15.07.2016, but there was no proper reply. Thereafter, she approached IRDA on 26.07.2016. The IRDA accepted the complaint allotted token number, for which, she received reply from insurer with incorrect facts. Thereafter, she again sent representation to IRDA on 12.08.2016, again she received reply stating that, Auto Surrender notice was sent to her in 2014, in ordinary post. In fact, they did not send any notice, it is only the false plea and no notice was addressed to her.

3. Finally, the insurer advised her, to take back Rs.2,47,855/- without interest. In fact, as per IRDA circular dated 13.10.2011, a minimum State Bank of India, Savings Bank interest has to be paid on discontinued fund. She requested and demanded the insurer to pay interest as per rules, but the insurer refused to pay interest. For that reason, she approached Ombudsman, Hyderabd, and filed complaint and relied on Circular No.20 of 2009 and demanded interest, but the insurer failed to pay the interest, therefore, there is clear violation and caused financial loss. The insured deducted excess amount than specified by IRDA. The Ombudsman not considered the fact of misleading her by the staff of insurance company and violation of IRDA Circular, but the Ombudsman awarded interest @ 6% from May2014 to till claim settlement day. The coverage of life risk till 5th year by the insurer is false. The absence of insurer before Ombudsman shows that, he has no defence. The award passed by Ombudsman is not correct, it is illegal, and not according to law, therefore, she approached this forum in view of the order of National Commission. Further, it is pleaded that, even after, Ombudsman award she was entitled for Rs.2,88,000/-, which is less than 3 years premium paid by her. In fact, they assured Rs.6,00,000/-, further, she is Cancer Patient, she was subject to mental agony and therefore, she filed the present complaint, seeking direction to the opposite party No.3 to pay an amount of Rs.6,00,000/- with interest @ 18% p.a., and also to award compensation and costs of litigation.

4. Opposite party No.3 after receiving notice, appeared through advocate and filed written version, whereas, opposite party No.1 filed memo adopting the written version of opposite party No.3. Whereas, opposite party No.2 remained ex-parte and not contesting the case.

5. The brief averments of the written version are as follows:- The opposite party No.3 denied all the averments and pleaded that, the complainant is working as Teacher and she submitted proposal on 20.05.2009 for insurance policy by paying deposit amount of Rs.1,00,000/- towards Unit Linked Insurance Policy named as Shri Plus with policy term of 15 years, annual premium of Rs.1,00,000/- payable for 15 years in yearly mode. The sum assured is Rs.7,50,000/-. The insurance company accepted the proposal and issued policy, containing policy schedule, first premium receipt, terms and conditions, copy of signed proposal form along with covering letter, as per regulation 6(ii) of (protection of policy holders interest) 2002 issued by IRDA. The policy holder is having liberty and option to cancel the policy stating the reason for her objection within 15 days of receipt of policy bond in such a case, the company shall be entitled to repurchase, the units allocated at the unit price prevailing on the business date next following the date of receipt of cancellation request the policy covering letter clearly discloses the intimation. The complainant after receipt of policy document never raised any complaint and therefore she is estopped from making allegations. The complainant not paid the renewal premium for the year 2012, which fell due by the date 28.05.2012, even after the expiry of the grace period, inspite of sending reminders, therefore, the policy was lapsed due to non- payment of renewal premium and the same went into Auto Render mode in the year 2012. As per clause No.4 of policy terms and conditions clearly shows that the renewal premium was not paid for the past 2 consecutive years. The policy will be lapsed due to non-payment of renewal premium, when the policy was Auto Surrender. The policy holder has option to revive the policy by paying all the dues are he can make a written request to surrender the policy and the insurance company will pay surrender value. The husband of complainant on 15.07.2016, for the first time sent e-mail to the customer care making false allegations. In fact, the husband of complainant was taking care of the insurance policy, he is highly educated and they never raised any objection till 15.07.2016, therefore, they are estopped from questioning the policy terms and conditions. The insurance company time and again issued suitable replies to the e-mails sent by husband of complainant clarifying the terms and conditions of the policy. But the complainant approached Ombudsman, Hyderabad by raising all the pleas, the object of Ombudsman is to act an arbitraries and to pass the awards. The insurance company submitted detailed explanation before Ombudsman. The Ombudsman after perusing all the documents passed award on 09.12.2016, directing the insurance company to pay discontinued fund value to the policy holder with simple interest of 6% from the date of auto foreclosure, after passing award by Ombudsman. The insurance company expressed its readiness to pay the amount of receiving consent letter from complainant. The complainant instead of sending consent letter, she sent e-mail dated 07.02.2017, through her husband. Formerly, accepting for the award and intends to receive the amount by visiting company head office at Hyderabad. She also sent another e-mail on the same day, raising objection that, the policy number was wrongly mentioned and she cannot accept the award. In fact, mistake occurred only one digit in the office of Ombudsman, again the complainant on 08.02.2017, sent another mail raising all objections, for which, the insurance company gave detailed reply on 14.02.2017. The insurance clearly informed regarding Circular No.20 of 2009 of IRDA, which is not applicable in the case of complaint since the policy was issued prior to the circular. The insurance company through their reply dated 14.02.2017, expressed their willingness to comply the award, but the complainant approached this forum unclean hands. As per IRDA (treatment of discontinued linked insurance policies) regulations 2010, the regulation No.1 (2) mentioned that, it will come into force on the date of their publication in the Official Gazit and shall apply to all products of linked life insurance cleared by the authority thereafter, therefore, the circular quoted by complainant is not applicable to the policies, which are issued before 1st July2010. In fact, IRDA Circular No.20 of 2009 dated 22.07.2009 is not at all applicable to the policies issued prior to publication, hence, there is no violation of IRDA circular. The complaint is liable for dismissal. The complainant having participated in the hearing of insurance Ombudsman, she cannot no deny the award passed by Ombudsman and she has no right to file the complaint before this forum. The complaint is not maintainable on the score of lack of jurisdiction to entertain the case.

6. On behalf of complainant her chief affidavit is filed and the same is treated as evidence of P.W.1, and Exs.A1 to A12 are marked. On behalf of opposite parties 1 and 3 chief affidavit of Assistant General Manager was filed and the same is treated as evidence of R.W.1 and Ex.B1 to B12 are marked.

7. Heard the arguments on both sides.

8. Now the point for consideration is: whether there is deficiency of service on the part of opposite parties 1 to 3 as pleaded by the complainant? whether this forum is having jurisdiction to entertain the case? and whether the complainant is entitled for the reliefs as prayed for?

9. Point:- The complainant in her complaint and in her evidence specifically pleaded that, she was misled, misrepresented, and cheated by the staff of branch office of Shreeram Chits, Chirala, i.e., the Branch Manager and Office Assistant, both of them induced her, to take Shri Plus Policy of Shreeram Life Insurance. According to her pleadings, in the month of May2009, when she visited the branch office for encashment of FDs., which were matured, she was made to believe the words and she was misled by the staff and she was told that she has to pay premium at Rs.1,00,000/- per year, for a period of 3 years, and later, after 6 years, the amount will be doubled and she can withdraw the amount in the 7th year with a benefit of insurance coverage also, and, the staff also gave her a pamphlet to that effect. Believing their words, she obtained policy in the month of May2009 and paid 3 premiums i.e., for 3 years up to 2011, later, she has not paid any premium as instructed by the staff, and in 7th year, when she tried to take back money, at that time, she received a phone call from Chennai Office, informing that, the policy was Auto Surrendered in the year 2014, itself, since she failed to pay premiums regularly after 3rd year, and saying so they offered to pay Rs.2,45,000/-. On hearing the message, she was shocked, because, the staff assured her that, she will get Rs.6,00,000/- under the policy, but they are now offering only Rs.2,45,000/-, then, she verified the policy document and came to know that, she was cheated and misled by staffs. She also pleaded that, the policy was sent to her by the insurance company, after the free look period, therefore she could not reject the policy. Further, she pleaded that, she never received Auto Surrender notice from the insurer. These are the allegations that were pleaded by the complainant against the Branch Office of Shreeram Chits, Chirala.

10. To prove all these allegations, she relied on her chief affidavit and relied on Ex.A1, Ex.A3 and Ex.A10 documents. Ex.A1 is the pamphlet alleged to have published by the Shreeram Chits Private Limited, Branch Office, Chirala. The perusal of the contents, goes to show that, Shreeram Chits announced limited period offer, for the benefit of chit subscribers, giving coverage of insurance policy under Shri Plus Insurance Scheme, and on payment of Rs.3,00,000/- for 3 years, it will give them Rs.6,00,000/- after completion of 6 years, including coverage of life insurance. Basing on this pamphlet, the complainant is contending that, the chit fund company and the staff of the branch misled her and cheated her to obtain policy under Shri Plus Life Insurance and made her to pay Rs.3,00,000/- i.e., every year Rs.1,00,000/- for 3 years, and thereby, made her to wait till 6 years and after 6th year when she went to the branch to collect the insurance amount of Rs.6,00,000/-, then she was informed that her policy was Auto Surrendered in the year 2014, itself. But she pleads that she has paid the premiums regularly for 3 years as stated by staff. The complainant also relied on the premium receipts paid by her from 2009 to 2011, she also produced the policy bond issued by the insurance company under Shri Plus Scheme. Being on the same, she pleads that she is entitle for Rs.6,00,000/- with interest.

11. She relied on Ex.A3, the e-mail copy giving complaint to customer care, Shriram Life Insurance, dated 15.07.2016, wherein, she alleged that the staff of Shriram Chits, cheated her and misrepresented her, thereby, she paid only 3 premiums and that, she was assured the final maturity amount of Rs.6,00,000/-, but without any notice, the bond was Auto Surrendered, in the year 2014, and therefore, she was cheated. In reply to this contention, the opposite party No.3 and 1, in their written version, they pleaded that, the complainant averred all false allegations in the complaint and that, she is working as teacher in Z.P. High School, Kodavalivaripalem, Prakasam District. She, herself, proposed insurance policy and submitted a proposal form dated 20.05.2009 by paying deposit of Rs.1,00,000/- proposing to take a unit linked insurance policy, named as Shri Plus, and the policy as 15 years, with annual premium of Rs.1,00,000/- payable for a term of 15 years at yearly mode for a some proposed amount of Rs.7,50,000/-, the complainant signed the proposal form and submitted the same to the company. The insurance company issued policy mentioning all the details,

i.e., policy schedule first premium receipt, terms and conditions and copy of signed proposal form with a covering letter to the complainant. Further, as per regulation 6(2) of TPI regulation 2002, the policy holder, who receive the policy document has an option to raise objection within 15 days or to cancel the policy under free look period. But, the complainant never requested for cancellation of the policy and never raised any objection. The company also sent reminders to the complainant saying premium fell due in the year 2012 and the complainant even after receiving reminders and even after expiry of grace period, she has not paid the 4th year premium, thereby, the policy was lapsed and went in to Auto Surrender mode. The policy holder not even availed the two options i.e., to revive the policy by paying all the dues or never requested to surrender the policy to receive the surrender value, therefore, the allegations mentioned by complainant or baseless and false.

12. In support of their contention, the opposite parties relied on the copy of policy bond, policy covering letter, another letter of insurance company acknowledging the receipt of proposal and the 1st premium from the proposer and policy schedule and 1st premium receipt, the policy conditions and privileges endorsement for accident, shield endorsement for family income benefit writer, which are marked as Exs.B1 and B2. Relying on all these documents, the insurance company is contending that, staff of the branch office never cheated and never misled the complainant and never Lured her to take the policy under Shri Plus Scheme and they never assured her saying that, if she pays only 3 years premium, she will get Rs.6,00,000/- after 6 years.

13. The opposite parties are disowning the circulation of pamphlet to the public

i.e., Ex.A1 and they are also denying the allegation that, the manager and another staff misled her to take the policy. Their main defence is that, the complainant is an educated person, working in Z.P. High School, as Teacher, and she received the policy schedule along with 1st premium receipt and other documents, but she never raised objection or expressed her un willingness within free look period. Further, their contention is that, they informed her about Auto Surrender through a letter dt: 29.05.2014, which is, through ordinary post, it was sent to the address given by her in the policy. In fact, for the allegations pleaded by the complainant, with regard to the aspects of cheating, misleading, misrepresentation and Luring, this forum cannot go deep into the mater, it requires full pledged trial on both sides and the Civil Court above can decide the alleged points, but this forum being adopting summary procedure, based on affidavits and copies of documents available on record, the allegation that, the complainant was misled by the staff and she simply believed the words of manager and staff such allegation cannot be believed, because, she is well educated person and working as teacher in a Government High School. It is highly doubtful to believe that she simply believed and signed on the proposal forms. The contents of policy schedule, clearly disclosing the insurance plan term of 15 years, commencement date 28.05.2009, due date of last premium 28.05.2023, sum assured is Rs.7,50,000/-, mode of payment yearly, installment premium Rs.1,00,000/-, date of maturity shown as 28.05.2024. This document speaks volumes and it is difficult to believe the version of complainant as she has not gone through the document till 2016. With regard to her contention that, she received the documents after expiry of free look period also cannot be believed, because even if, she received the documents with delay even then, she will have

15 days time to exercise her option from the date of receipt of policy. Admittedly she has not raised any objection within 15 days after receipt of policy. Therefore, her contention that, she was misled and lured by the staff or by the pamphlet cannot be believed.

14. Apart from that, as per Ex.B1, the copy of proposal form, which clear discloses about the particulars of the policy i.e., policy term, annual premium, mode of premium, paying term, maturity date etc. Apart from that, she signed in the proposal form with a certificate that all the statements and information were fully explained to her and she fully understood the significance of the proposed contract and signed the proposal form. Therefore, now, she cant go back and say that, she was misled, cheated or lured by the staff of insurer. Ex.B2 document the policy covering letter disclosing to the complainant that she has option for cancellation within 15 days after receipt of policy. The 1st premium receipt also discloses all the details of policy terms and conditions. Therefore, it is highly improbable to believe that, she has not gone through the documents and she was under the impression that, she will get Rs.6,00,000/- after 6 years and she need to pay only 3 yearly installment premiums. Such contention of complainant is highly doubtful and cannot be believed.

15. Further, the document Ex.A10, which is C.D.(Compact Disk) filed to prove that, she has recorded the alleged conversation with staff at the time of signing the proposal form and other documents. In fact, the complainant has not taken steps to play the C.D in open court and never insisted to hear the conversation, nor it was not sent to any expert to prove the alleged conversation. Therefore, no credence can be given to the C.D.Ex.A10. Being a literate woman, she cannot plead that, she was trapped and she blindly believed the words of staff and signed in the documents. Such plea will not stand to scrutiny, therefore, the alleged plea of cheating and misleading cannot be believed. The next aspect is with regard to Auto Surrender. Admittedly, the complainant paid only 3 premiums under receipts filed and marked as Ex.A2. In view of the above discussion, the complainant failed to prove that, she was misled by the staff as, she needs to pay only 3 yearly installments and after that, she need not pay any amount till 6th year. Such plea cannot be believed. Infact as per policy terms and conditions, she has right to renew the policy within 2 years after the expiry of date of 1st unpaid premium, but she has not exercised the option and not paid the premiums, due.

16. According to opposite parties, they sent letter dated 29.05.2014, informing about Auto Surrender, the complainant pleads that, she has not received any letter and that, she only received phone call in 6th year, when she went to office to collect the maturity amount. Such contention cannot be believed. There is no hard and fast rule on the insurer to send letter by R.P. Therefore, the contention of complainant in this regard, cannot be accepted. Further, according to insurer they have sent another letter on 26.08.2016, requesting to submit necessary documents to pay the amount of Rs.2,47,855-53 ps. The complainant is denying all the letters alleged to have sent by the insured. The complainant relied on Ex.A3, which is copy of complaint sent through e-mail to customer service of the insurance company dated 15.07.2016. Ex.A4 is the complaint to IRDA., in the remarks column of Ex.A4, the insurance company pleaded that, they have sent letter at the time of Auto Surrender dated 29.05.2014, but there was no response from complainant. The complainant relied on Ex.A11, award passed by Ombudsman dated 09.12.2016.

17. Admittedly, the Ombudsman after going through, the documents filed by both parties and after hearing both parties, he gave a finding and directed the insurer to settle the discontinued fund value with simple interest @ 6% p.a., from the date of Auto Foreclosure of the policy. Accordingly, he allowed the case partly. Now, the complainant not satisfied with the award passed by Ombudsman, she filed the present complaint seeking direction to the opposite parties to pay Rs.6,00,000/- with interest @ 18% p.a., and Rs.1,00,000/- as compensation and Rs.10,000/- towards costs of the litigation. In fact, the complainant, sent Ex.B8 e-mail correspondence dated 07.02.2017 to the insurer, and expressed her consent stating that, I am agreeing to the award passed by insurance Ombudsman and ready to take payment of Rs.2,88,000/- from the insurance company. She also expressed that, she need money for her cancer treatment and she is sending her husband to the head office with consent letter and other records and requested to give cheque on the same day to her husband. This e-mail was sent by husband of complainant in response to the letter addressed by insurance company i.e., Ex.B7 dated 27.12.2016, through which letter, the insurance company expressed its willingness to comply the direction given under the award passed by Ombudsman dated 09.12.2016.

18. Further, the husband of complainant sent another e-mail under Ex.B8 expressing gratitude for extending time and requesting another 3 days time to submit consent letter, due to her treatment in the hospital. Having given consent and having accepted the award passed by the Ombudsman, the complainant again going back and stating that, there is mistake in the award passed by Ombudsman regarding the proof insurance policy, therefore, insisted to correct the mistake in the award and send the copy to her, so that, she will give consent letter. This e-mail was sent by the complainant through Ex.B9 e-mail letter. The contention of complainant at this juncture is that, she is not accepting the calculation made by insurance company regarding under amount payable as per document Ex.B5, she pleads that, under IRDA regulations, she is entitled for minimum guaranty interest as applicable to Savings Bank Accounts of State Bank of India. For this proposition, she relied on Ex.A5 document i.e., regulation No.6 (2) passed by IRDA. In reply to this, insurance company relied on Ex.A7 document, filed by complainant, the perusal of the circular goes to show that, the charges for the Ulips regulated under guidelines accrued by IRDA, the circular comes into effect from 1st October 2009. Therefore, all the policies payable on or after 01.10.2009, will be governed by the provisions of the circular. Therefore, based on this circular, the insurance company is contending that, the IRDA regulations regarding payment of interest as per bank rate will only applicable to the policies issued after 01.10.2009. The present policy, which is subject matter was issued on 28.05.2009, therefore, this IRDA circular has no application for the present policy.

19. Apart from that, as per Ex.A8, IRDA circular regarding the discontinued policies i.e., the fund value will be paid only after lock-in period, which is minimum 5 years from the start of the policy, and the money earns 3.5% of the interim, and the insurance company can deduct maximum of Rs.6,000/- as charges for such surrender. Therefore, in accordance with this circular, the insurance company sent a letter through Ex.A9 offering to pay Rs.2,47,855-53ps. as on 23.09.2016. Aggrieved by this, the complainant now, filed the complaint seeking payment of Rs.6,00,000/- with interest, which is not at all justified, because, as per the policy terms and conditions, the insured over the discontinued premium amount i.e., fund value, the insurer is entitled for the income earned over that amount after deduction of the fund management charges as provided in the regulations of IRDA. Therefore, the complainant now cannot insist for payment of more than surrender value with earned income management charges.

20. Considering all these aspects and considering the documents filed by both parties and considering the arguments of both sides, since the complainant already expressed her willingness and consent to take payment of Rs.2,88,000/- as offered by the insurance company after passing of award by the Ombudsman under Ex.A11, the insured is not justified in demanding Rs.6,00,000/-, which is illegal and not justified. The complainant is now, estoped to claim more amount according to her will and pleasure. Since, she already gave consent for the award passed by the Ombudsman, she cannot go back for the simple reason that, the policy number is not correctly mentioned in the award and she cannot say that, the award passed by Ombudsman is in a casual manner. The Ombudsman after careful consideration of all the aspects, he rightly passed award and therefore, we are not inclined to accept the argument setup by the complainant. With the aforesaid discussion, and taking into consideration of the IRDA guidelines, we are of the view that, the complainant is entitled to the discontinued fund value of Rs.2,47,885/- with interest @ 6% p.a., from the date of Auto Foreclosure of the policy till the date of payment, which relief, according to us is justified.

21 Further, we are of the view that, we can be grant an amount of Rs.10,000/- as compensation for mental agony and trauma under gone by complainant for all these days. Further, she is entitled for Rs.5,000/- towards costs of litigation. Accordingly, the point is answered.

22. In the result, the complaint is partly allowed, directing the 3rd opposite party/the insurer to pay the discontinued fund value i.e., 2,47,885/- with interest @ 6% p.a., from the date of Auto Foreclosure of the policy till the date of payment. Further, the complainant is entitled for Rs.10,000/- towards compensation and Rs.5,000/- towards costs of the litigation. Dictated to the Stenographer, transcribed by her and corrected and pronounced by us in the open forum this the 22th day of January, 2018. sd/-xxx sd/-xxx MEMBER PRESIDENT APPENDIX OF EVIDENCE WITNESS EXAMINED FOR COMPLAINANT: P.W.1 03-07-2017 Dasari Nirmala Devi, Aged 54 years, 9-5-9, Opp. A.R.M. High School, Perala-Chirala-523157, Prakasam District (A.P.) WITNESS EXAMINED FOR OPPOSITE PARTIES NO.1 TO 3: R.W.1 03.08.2017 E.Sridhar, S/o. E.J. Lingam, age 53 years, Assistant General Manager in M/s. Shriram Life Insurance Company Ltd. Having its registered office Plot No.31&32, 5th Floor, Ramky Selenium, Beside Andhra Bank Training Centre Financial District, Gachibowli, Hyderabad-500032. EXHIBITS MARKED FOR COMPLAINANT: Ex.A1 - Original pamphlet issued by Insurer. Ex.A2 - Original receipts(3 in no.) for Rs.3,00,000/- and policy bond. Ex.A3 - Complaint made to insurer by e-mail. Ex.A4 - Reply of insurer in IGMS. Ex.A5 - IRDA Circular regarding interest. Ex.A6 - Insurers discharge summary without interest. Ex.A7 - IRDA circular no.20 which was violated by insurer. Ex.A8 - IRDA circular regarding charges deductable. Ex.A9 - Insurers discharge summary showing high deductable charges. Ex.A10 - Voice recording CD of Smt. Sarala. Ex.A11 - Insurance Ombudsman award copy. Ex.A12 - Oncologist Certificate regarding my cancer disease affidavit signed by complainant and was notarized. EXHIBITS MARKED FOR OPPOISTE PARTIES: Ex.B1 20.05.2009 Copy of the signed proposal form of complainant. Ex.B2 20.05.2009 Copy of the policy document (containing covering letter, policy schedule, first premium receipt, terms & conditions) Ex.B3 24.04.2002 Copy of IRDA Regulation 2002. Ex.B4 - copy of e-mails (in different dates 15.07.2016, 21.07.2016, 22.07.2016 & 25.07.2016). Ex.B5 28.09.2016 Copy of the Surrender Quotation. Ex.B6 09.12.2016 Copy of the Insurance Ombudsman Award. Ex.B7 27.12.2016 Copy of Letter sent by company. Ex.B8 07.02.2017 Copy of e-mail of complainant. Ex.B9 07.02.2017 Copy of e-mail of complainant. Ex.B10 08.02.2017 Copy of notice sent by complainant. Ex.B11 14.02.2017 Copy of companys reply notice. Ex.B12 01.07.2010 Copy of IRDA Regulation 2010. sd/-xxx PRESIDENT Copies to:

1) Complainant.

2) Opposite parties 1 & 3.

3) Opposite party No.2. Free copy was issued in dis.no. /date: //free copy//