Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

POORNIMA D/O KUPPA MOGER v. STATE OF KARNATAKA

Karnataka High Court
Mar 1, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners claim membership of the Moger caste, which they assert is classified as a Scheduled Caste in the relevant List. To support this, they produced transfer certificates (including one issued by Canara College Society (Regd.) showing petitioner No.2's caste as Moger) and an earlier order of this Court in W P No.43169/2002 dated 30.11.2004. Despite these materials, the Tahsildar, Bhatkal issued show cause notices (Annexure-G and H) directing the petitioners to appear for enquiry on 19.2.2009. The petitioners challenged the notices as arbitrary and issued without application of mind, seeking quashing. The respondent argued that writ petitions are not maintainable against a show cause notice and that the petitioners should appear before the Tahsildar to place their defense. The court heard both sides and proceeded to decide whether the challenge to the notice was maintainable and what directions to issue.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether writ petitions are maintainable challenging a show cause notice that is not a final order affecting the petitioners' rights.
  2. Whether the particular show cause notices issued by the Tahsildar (directing the petitioners to appear for enquiry into their caste status) are arbitrary or issued without application of mind and therefore liable to be quashed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners asserted they belong to the Moger caste, classified as a Scheduled Caste in the List, and produced transfer certificates and a prior court order (W P No.43169/2002 dated 30.11.2004) in support.
  • They contended the show cause notices issued by the Tahsildar were arbitrary and without application of mind and therefore liable to be quashed.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent's counsel submitted that writ petitions cannot be maintained against a show cause notice that is not a final order; the petitioners' caste status had not been declared contrary to their claim, and they should be required to appear before the Tahsildar and put forth their defense.
  • The respondent also contended that the Moger designation appears in different classifications (noting a Category I mogera classification not as a Scheduled Caste and that Moger appears in lists for both Scheduled Caste and Backward Class), and that preventing persons belonging to Backward Class from illegally obtaining status as Scheduled Caste was necessary to protect genuine beneficiaries of reservation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
State of Orissa vs. Dr. (Miss) Binapari Dei & others, AIR 1967 SC 1269 That a show cause notice may be challenged where it amounts to a final order affecting rights; a mere notice that is not a final order is generally not amenable to challenge by way of writ petition. The court relied on this authority to hold that the show cause notice in the present case is not a final order and therefore is not susceptible to being quashed at this stage; only final orders that affect rights may be challenged.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began from the principle that a show cause notice is not ordinarily amenable to challenge by way of writ petition unless it is in the form of a final order affecting the petitioners' rights. The court noted the Supreme Court's holding in State of Orissa v. Binapari Dei that a show cause notice could only be challenged in circumstances where it amounted to a final order.

Applying that principle, the court observed that the Tahsildar's communication was a notice directing the petitioners to appear with materials so that an enquiry could be conducted to examine whether they belong to the Moger caste. It was not a final adjudicative order depriving the petitioners of any right. The court further recognised the respondent's position that the Moger designation appears in different classifications (including reference to a Category I mogera not classified as Scheduled Caste) and that persons belonging to a Backward Class might improperly claim Scheduled Caste status; preventing such misuse is material to protect genuine beneficiaries of reservation.

On that basis the court concluded that the challenge to the notice was premature. The proper forum for the petitioners to contest their classification was the enquiry before the Tahsildar, where they could present their materials and defenses.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

Direct effect on the parties: The petition was disposed of with directions that the petitioners appear before the Tahsildar, Bhatkal without awaiting further notice on 28.3.2017, and that the Tahsildar dispose of the matter expeditiously but not later than three months thereafter. The court therefore declined to quash the show cause notices at this stage.

Broader implications: The opinion does not set out any new precedent; it applies the existing principle that a show cause notice that is not a final order is not ordinarily amenable to a writ challenge and confines the dispute to the statutory/administrative enquiry process.

Show all summary ...

The petitioners claim that they belong to Moger Caste which is classified as a Scheduled Caste in the List. In support of their claim, they have produced transfer certificates. One more transfer certificate issued by Canara College Societys (Regd.) where one of the petitioners has completed B A degree and submitted in both the certificates, caste of the petitioner No.2 has been referred as Moger and in the list at Sl.No.70 it has 3been referred as Moger. The petitioners have also produced order of this Court in W P No.43169/2002 dated 30.11.2004 and claimed that petitioners are persons belonging to particular caste and notwithstanding the same and without application of mind, the Tahsildar, Bhatkal issued a show cause notice Annexure-G and H directing them to appear before him for enquiry on 19.2.2009. The petitioners submit that the show cause notice issued is arbitrary one and without application of mind and the same is liable to be quashed.

2. The learned counsel for the respondent submits that the writ petitions cannot lie as against a show cause notice. It is not yet declared that the petitioners do not belong to a particular caste. It is required that the petitioners to appear before the Tahsildar and they can put-forth their defence.

3. Heard both.

44. Show cause notice cannot be decided before this Court unless it is in the form of a final order and affects the rights of the petitioners. In the circumstance where notice is issued proposing a penal action without affording an opportunity, then only that could be challenged. In the instant case what has been issued is a notice by the Tahsildar only directing them to appear with all materials in order to examine whether they belong to Moger caste.

5. The Honble Supreme Court in State of Orissa vs., Dr.(Miss) Binapari Dei & others, (AIR 1967 SC 1269 held, show cause notice could be challenged in the circumstance wherein it is a final order. In the present case, notice is not a final order. It is the case of the respondent that the petitioners Moger Caste which is classified under Category I mogera which is not classified as a scheduled caste. Moger which is found a place both in List of Scheduled Caste and Backward 5class, persons belonging to Backward Class illegally obtained as if they are Scheduled Caste. That has to be prevented in order to provide reservation to genuine persons.

6. Hence this petition is disposed of directing the petitioners to appear before the Tahsildar without awaiting notice on 28.3.2017 and the Tahsildar, Bhatkal is directed to dispose of the case expeditiously but not later than three months thereafter. Sd/- JUDGE akd*