Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

SIDDU S/O KALLAPPA SAVADI, v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,

Karnataka High Court
Jul 27, 2017

Though the matter is listed for admission, but with the consent of both sides, it is taken up for final disposal. : 3 :

2. This is the petition filed by petitioners/ accused Nos.1 to 3 under Section 482 of the Cr.P.C., praying the Court to quash the charge sheet and consequently entire proceedings in C.C.No.159/2016 on the file of learned Civil Judge and J.M.F.C., Banahatti for the offence punishable under Sections 171C, 171F r/w 34 of I.P.C.

3. Brief facts of the case as per the complaint it is alleged that complainant has been appointed as Election Officer to Sasalatti Village Panchayat Election. Accordingly, he was on duty and when he was near Sasalatti school on 29.05.2015, the members of Sasalatti village namely (1) Kamal s/o Saidusab Pathan, (2) Devaraj s/o Shivappa Baligar, (3) Susalawwa w/o Bhimappa Ullagaddi gave complaint against him alleging that on 26.09.2015 at about 5.00 p.m. one Siddu Kallappa Savadi i.e. petitioner No.1 openly canvassing by pada yatra march near Shivalingeshwar : 4 : Hospital. Further he requested to investigate the matter under section 171c and 171f of i.p.c. The complaint is produced as per Document No.1 in the case and on the basis of the said complaint, case came to be registered in Terdal Police Station Crime No.55/2015. The FIR came to be registered against the petitioner No.1 only alleging that he had committed the offence under section 171c and 171f of i.p.c. Subsequently after completing investigation charge sheet came to be filed against all the petitioners herein for the said offences. Hence, being aggrieved by the registration of the criminal case, the petitioners herein are before this Court in this petition challenging the legality and correctness of the same on the grounds as mentioned in the petition at Para Nos.1 to 8.

4. Heard the arguments of the learned counsel appearing for the petitioners-accused Nos.1 to 3 and also the learned HCGP appearing for the respondent : 5 : No.1-State. The respondent No.2 though served with the petition notice remained absent and there is no representation. Learned counsel the respondent No.3 absent.

5. Learned counsel for the petitioners made the submission that both the alleged offences are non- cognizable offences, there is no compliance of Section

155 of Cr.P.C. before the Police Officer proceeding to investigate the matter. Hence, he submitted that on this count itself the criminal proceedings are liable for quashing. He also made the submission though it is the case of the prosecution that they made the requisition before the concerned Magistrate Court at Banahatti and the learned Magistrate permitted the police to proceed with the investigation. Counsel made the submission that simply mentioning as permitted on the requisition by the police is not sufficient, there could have been reasoned order on the application of mind by the : 6 : learned Magistrate, which is not done in this case. Hence, he submitted that even on that ground also it can be said that there is no compliance of the mandatory requirements of Section 155(1) as well as (2) of the said provision. Counsel made the submission that the trial court without considering these legal aspects in the case wrongly proceeded by registering the criminal case and issuing the process to the petitioners/accused Nos.1 to 3. Hence, he submitted to allow the petition and to quash the proceedings.

6. Per contra, learned HCGP for respondent No.1/State made the submission that there is a compliance of the said provision and he relied upon the requisition submitted by the police before the learned Magistrate Court and he submitted that the learned Magistrate permitted the police officer to proceed with the investigation in the matter. Hence, it is his contention that in view of this permission by the : 7 : J.M.F.C. Court, there is a compliance of the said provision. Hence, he submitted that there is no merit in the petition. The petitioners have to face the criminal case. Hence, the petition be rejected.

7. I have perused the grounds urged in the petition, so also considered the documents produced by the petitioners along with the petition like FIR, complaint and the entire charge sheet material. I have also perused the order sheet of the trial court and the requisition said to have been filed by the concerned police before the J.M.F.C. Court at Banahatti dated 01.06.2015.

8. Looking to the materials, the offences alleged against the present petitioner herein are under Section 171C and 171F r/w 34 of the I.P.C. so both the offences are admittedly non-cognizable offences. Therefore, in such a case the relevant provision made applicable regarding the procedural aspect is concerned is Section : 8 :

155 of the Cr.P.C. Looking to the said provision as per clause (1) of the section 155 it mandates that whenever such information is given by the complainant, the Police Officer has to reduce the information in the Station House Diary and immediately he has to refer the informant to the Magistrate. Therefore, it is the contention of the petitioners herein no such steps have been taken, the procedure has not been followed and it is not the case of the prosecution that the informant was referred to Magistrate. It is also the requirement under Section 155(2) that the Police Officer before proceeding with the investigation in the matter he has to obtain the necessary permission from the concerned Magistrate Court. It is no doubt true prosecution relied upon the requisition moved and also the endorsement by the learned Magistrate on the said requisition dated 01.06.2015. I have perused the same. The learned Magistrate mentioned as permitted below that he has put his signature and the date. But now the question is : 9 : whether this endorsement as permitted on the police requisition amounts to sufficient compliance of mandatory requirements of Section 155(2) of the Cr.P.C. The object of the said section is that whenever such request is made by the Investigation Officer, the learned Magistrate has to apply his judicial mind to the requisition and also the supporting material to the said requisition and he has to take a decision in the matter whether he satisfied about the said material that there is a case to giving such permission to the Police Officer to proceed with the investigation in the matter or it is not a case for give such permission. But looking to the requisition dated 01.06.2015, there is no mention by the learned Magistrate what are the materials perused. So this goes to show that only the requisition was placed before the learned Magistrate. Because there is no mention about the other documents annexed along with this requisition. When that is so only because of mentioning the word permitted it cannot be said that it : 10 : is in compliance of the mandatory requirements of Section 155(2) of the Cr.P.C. Therefore, in reality it is no permission at all. Under such circumstances, the prosecution has not satisfied the Court that mandatory requirements are complied with before proceeding with the investigation in the matter. Therefore, these legal aspects have been completely overlooked by the trial court while ordering for registering the criminal case and to proceed with the matter by issuing process to the petitioners herein. Looking to these materials, it goes to show that it is the abuse of process of the Court to continue other proceedings not only that it is a waste of the valuable time and energy of the Court. Even if the trial is proceeded with, it is a futile exercise in the matter. Accordingly, petition is allowed. Criminal proceedings initiated so also the charge sheet in the case are hereby quashed. Sd/- JUDGE