Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

CHANDRASHEKHAR v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA,

Karnataka High Court
Nov 21, 2016

COURT MADE THE FOLLOWING: 2ORDER The sole accused in CC.518/2016, which is said to be committed to sessions and pending consideration in District and Sessions Court, Bagalkot, has come up in this petition seeking enlargement under Section 439 of Cr.P.C.

2. Brief facts leading to this petition are as under: Petitioner is the sole accused in Crime No.108/2016 registered for the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC. The complaint would disclose that petitioner herein has committed homicide of his younger sister Bharti, aged about 32 years on the premise that she had illicit relationship with several people in their village, thereby reducing the dignity of their family in the society. The records would also disclose that the complaint is filed by the younger brother of the accused on 25.6.2016 at about 5.00 pm., with reference to a crime which has taken place on the intervening night of 24th and 25th of June 2016.

3. The place of occurrence of crime is the residence of deceased, which is situated adjacent to the house of 3accused. The crime is said to have taken place when the victim opened the door of house in response to the knock by the accused and the crime is said to have committed by throttling the neck of the victim in the presence of her minor son, aged about 11 years who was sleeping in the same room at the relevant point of time and also in the presence of another witness Vishnu, aged about 14 years. It is stated by the complainant that the incident was narrated to him by the accused himself at about 10 am., on 25.6.2016 when he came to his village having come to know about the death of his sister Bharti. The delay in filing complaint at 5.00 pm., on next day is due to time taken for discussion with the other members of the family and after getting consent of others complaint is said to have filed.

4. On the basis of complaint, charge sheet is prepared accusing the petitioner herein of the offence punishable under Section 302 of IPC. After the investigation, police have filed charge sheet mainly relying upon the so called confession statement of the accused 4before his younger brother, who is complainant in Crime No.108/2016.

5. In the present petition filed seeking his enlargement on bail, the counsel for the petitioner would try to plead before this court that the very fact that accused never ran away from the place of incident though it had taken place in the middle of the night he was available at the place of crime even at the time of filing of complaint on next day evening at 5 pm. It is also stated that act of crime is not said to be for gain and not said to be for personal enmity. And even assuming that the accusations against him are true, it could be in the nature of an incident having taken place in the fit of rage or in an altercation between himself and his sister. He would state that aforesaid inference can be drawn without taking the petitioner in conceding to the crime. He would also state that the petitioner is a physically handicapped person having the responsibility of taking care of his wife and children and the entire family is depending on the income generated from his Pigmy collection job and if petitioner is 5not enlarged on bail, the whole family would suffer. He further submits that the petitioner undertakes that he will not move out of the jurisdiction of the Court and he will abide himself to any stringent condition that may be imposed on him.

6. On appreciation of the material available on record and noticing that there was no attempt on the part of the petitioner either in preventing the complaint being filed by his younger brother or in running away from the place of incident when admittedly said incident had taken place in the intervening night of 24th and 25th of June, 2016 he was available at the place of incident till such time when the complaint was filed on the next day at 5 pm. Thereafter, when he was taken into custody by police, it is clearly seen that there is no attempt by him either to dodge the arrest or doing any kind of act which would either obstruct the investigation or to remove the evidence, if any to be collected by the police. When statements of all the other witnesses are looked into, it is seen that there is no attempt on the part of petitioner to 6influence any of the witnesses. In that view of the matter, even assuming that he had role in commission of the offence alleged, considering the manner in which he has behaved throughout, this court feel that it is not necessary that he should be condemned to prison at this stage as if the crime against him is proved. Therefore, in the facts and circumstances, this Court feel that he may be enlarged on bail subject to stringent conditions.

7. Accordingly, this petition is allowed and the petitioner is enlarged on bail subject to the following conditions:

1. The petitioner shall execute personal bond for a sum of Rs.1,00,000/- and shall also furnish one surety for the like sum to the satisfaction of the concerned Court. 2.The petitioner shall not tamper with any of the prosecution evidence directly or indirectly and shall not try to influence the witnesses and interfere with the trial.

3. The petitioner shall not leave the boundaries of Bagalkot district without prior 7permission of the Sessions Court where the trial is to be carried on . Sd/- JUDGE nd/-