Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Madhya Pradesh Power Management Company Limited v. Renew Clean Energy Private Limited And Another

Supreme Court Of India
Apr 5, 2018
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, M.P. Power Management Company Ltd. (MPPMCL), initiated a tariff-based competitive bidding process on 6-5-2015 to procure 300 MW of solar power to meet renewable purchase obligations in Madhya Pradesh. Respondent 1, ReNew Clean Energy Pvt. Ltd., was awarded 51 MW at a tariff of Rs 5.457/kWh and executed a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) on 10-11-2015, backed by a performance bank guarantee of Rs 15.3 crores from Respondent 2 (the bank).

Respondent 1 faced difficulties obtaining encroachment-free land at the original site in Rajgarh District. After repeated resistance, it sought and received permission from the appellant’s board on 29-12-2016 to change the project location. Respondent 1 then purchased 253 acres in Ashok Nagar District and advanced construction, informing the appellant on 10-7-2017 that commissioning was expected on 31-8-2017—before the scheduled date of 7-9-2017.

Under Clause 2.5.1 of the PPA, failure to meet “Conditions Subsequent” within 210 days plus a further 9-month grace period permitted MPPMCL to terminate the contract and encash the guarantee. On 11-8-2017, the appellant terminated the PPA and imposed a penalty of Rs 11,95,54,200. Respondent 1 filed Writ Petition No. 12432 of 2017, where the High Court on 18-8-2017 set aside the termination but upheld invocation of the bank guarantee. The appellant appealed; the Supreme Court granted leave and delivered the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether MPPMCL’s termination of the PPA under Clause 2.5.1 for delay beyond the stipulated period was lawful and justified.
  2. Whether the appellant was entitled to encash the performance bank guarantee notwithstanding the setting aside of termination.
  3. The quantum and enforceability of the contractual penalty for delay in achieving the Conditions Subsequent.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant’s Arguments (MPPMCL)

  • Respondent 1 failed to fulfil Conditions Subsequent within the contractual period of 210 days plus an additional 9 months; therefore, termination under Clause 2.5.1(d) was mandatory.
  • The delay exceeded nine months, so the question of merely imposing penalty did not arise; termination and encashment were both permissible.

Respondent 1’s Arguments (ReNew Clean Energy Pvt. Ltd.)

  • Delays were caused by encroachment and violent resistance at the government-allotted land—circumstances outside its control.
  • Upon receiving permission to relocate, it swiftly purchased new land and was on track to commission the plant ahead of schedule (31-8-2017).
  • Investment of substantial funds (land purchase and Rs 267.37 crore term loan) rendered termination arbitrary and inequitable.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Supreme Court acknowledged the contractual framework allowing termination after a nine-month delay but focused on the factual matrix:

  • Respondent 1 had encountered genuine impediments at the original site and promptly acted once relocation was approved.
  • Construction was in an advanced stage, with commissioning imminent and ahead of the contractual deadline.
  • Although these circumstances did not amount to a force-majeure event under the PPA, they were relevant in evaluating whether termination was fair or arbitrary.
  • The PPA expressly provided for liquidated damages (Clause 2.5.1) as a calibrated response to delay; therefore, levy of penalty, not termination, was the proportionate remedy.

Concluding that MPPMCL’s termination was “not fair” and “arbitrary,” the Court upheld the High Court’s decision setting aside termination while recognising that Respondent 1 remains contractually liable to pay the stipulated penalty.

Holding and Implications

Appeal Dismissed. Respondent 1 must pay Rs 11,95,54,200 as penalty to the appellant within four weeks.

Implications: The contract is revived (termination void), but monetary penalty and invocation of the bank guarantee stand. The decision is confined to the contractual terms of this PPA and does not establish new precedent on force-majeure or termination principles; it primarily affects the parties by allowing project completion subject to payment of liquidated damages.

Show all summary ...

R. Banumathi, J.— Leave granted. This appeal arises out of the judgment 2017 SCC OnLine MP 1654, (2018) 1 MP LJ 481 passed by the High Court of Madhya Pradesh, Principal Seat at Jabalpur in and by which the High Court allowed Writ Petition No. 12432 of 2017 setting aside the order of termination of contract dated 11-8-2017 while maintaining the appellant's action on invocation of bank guarantee in terms of Clause 2.5.1 of the contract.

2. Brief facts which led to filing of this appeal are as follows: the appellant M.P. Power Management Company Ltd. initiated the process of procurement of power from Grid Connected Solar Energy through tariff based competitive bidding for meeting its Renewable Purchase obligations in the State of Madhya Pradesh. Accordingly, a request for proposal (RFP) dated 6-5-2015 was issued by the appellant for long term procurement of 300 MW power from Grid Connected Solar Energy Sources through tariff based competitive bidding. Out of 100 bidders who participated in the bidding process, Respondent 1 ReNew Clean Energy Private Ltd. was selected on the basis of cheaper merit order rates.

3. The appellant issued a letter of intent dated 23-10-2015 in favour of Respondent 1 allotting 51 MW capacity at quoted tariff of Rs 5.457/kWh for twenty-five years which was accepted by Respondent 1 by its consent letter dated 26-10-2015. A power purchase agreement (PPA) dated 10-11-2015 was executed between the appellant and Respondent 1 for sale and procurement of 51 MW solar power, for which, Respondent 1 submitted a bank guarantee from Respondent 2 Bank for an amount of Rs 15,30,00,000 valid till January 2018.

4. Since Respondent 1 was unable to obtain the requisite land for establishing the power plant, Respondent 1 requested assistance from the State Government. Accordingly, the Collector, District Rajgarh by order dated 21-4-2016 allotted 96.73 acres of revenue land to MP New and Renewable Energy Department for further allotment on lease to Respondent 1. This was done by the appellant even though the land procurement was the obligation of the bidder.

5. According to Respondent 1, there were difficulties in accessing the land, because when measurement of land was taken on 29-6-2016, it was found encroached and the project team faced heavy resistance, physical attacks, etc. and therefore, Respondent 1 vide its letter dated 29-9-2016 requested the appellant to allow to change the location of the project. The said permission sought for by Respondent 1 was granted by the appellant by its Resolution dated 29-12-2016. The relevant portion of the Resolution reads as under:

“Resolved that condition for not allowing change of location after 210 days from signing of PPA be relaxed and following Solar Power developers be allowed to change the location of their respective project, subject to provision of Clauses 2.5 and 2.6 of the PPA.”

6. After permission was granted to change the location of the project, Respondent 1 purchased lands to an extent of about 253 acres in Villages Bansara and Pipriya Rai in Ashok Nagar District and undertook the development/construction activities. On 10-7-2017, Respondent 1 wrote to appellant that “commissioning process was in final stages and we expect to commission the plant on 31-8-2017 (tentative date), which is ahead of scheduled commissioning date of 7-9-2017.”

7. As per Clause 2.5.1 of the PPA, a maximum period of nine months beyond 7-6-2016 for achieving Conditions Subsequent enables the appellant to terminate the agreement if Respondent 1 failed to satisfy the Conditions Subsequent by this date along with penalty which was to be calculated as per Clause 2.5.1 of the PPA. In the light of the abovesaid provisions of the PPA, the appellant by order dated 11-8-2017 terminated the PPA and imposed a penalty of Rs 11,95,54,200 on Respondent 1.

8. Being aggrieved, Respondent 1 filed Writ Petition No. 12432 of 2017 before the High Court praying that the appellant be directed not to give effect to termination and encashment of performance bank guarantee. The High Court vide impugned judgment dated 18-8-2017 2017 SCC OnLine MP 1654, (2018) 1 MP LJ 481 partly allowed the writ petition setting aside the order of termination of the contract while maintaining the invocation of the bank guarantee.

9. We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the parties and perused the impugned judgment and materials on record.

10. Clause 2.1 of the PPA required Respondent 1 to fulfil all Conditions Subsequent within a period of 210 days from the effective date i.e. 6-6-2017, failing which Article 2.5 of the PPA allowed further extension up to nine months for fulfilment of the Conditions Subsequent subject to payment of liquidated damages in terms of the PPA. Clause 2.5 of the PPA reads as follows:

2.5 Delay in achieving conditions subsequent
2.5.1. In case of delay in achieving any of the Conditions Subsequent under Clause 2.1 (a to h), as may be applicable, Mppmcl shall encash CPG (submitted by seller @ Rs 30 lakhs/MW) as under, subject to force majeure:
(a) Delay from 0-3 months — 1% per week.
(b) Delay from 3-6 months — 2% per week for the period exceeding 3 months, apart from (a) above.
(c) Delay from 6-9 months — 3% per week for the period exceeding 6 months, apart from (a) and (b) above.
(d) In case of delay of more than 9 months, Mppmcl shall terminate PPA and release balance amount of CPG.

11. Since Respondent 1 was unable to obtain the requisite land, on request by Respondent 1, the State Government allotted 96.73 acres of land at district Rajgarh to the appellant for being allotted to Respondent 1 on lease. According to Respondent 1, upon initiation of measurement and demarcation exercise by the revenue officials, the land was found to be heavily encroached and there was stiff resistance which continued every time Respondent 1 tried to approach the said land and therefore, Respondent 1 could not access the project site and commence any construction activities. On request by Respondent 1 by its letter dated 29-9-2016, Respondent 1 sought for change of location of the project. The Board of Directors considered the request of Respondent 1 and by Resolution dated 29-12-2016 allowed change of location of the project. Thereafter, Respondent 1 purchased the land to an extent of 253 acres in Village Bansara and Pipriya Rai in Ashok Nagar District within a period of about eighty-three days from the date of the appellant's approval. After acquiring the land, Respondent 1 undertook the construction activities and the project in an advanced stage of synchronisation as early as on 10-7-2017. The same was notified to the appellant by communication dated 10-7-2017 stating that the commissioning of the project is in final stage and that the expected date of commissioning of the project is 31-8-2017 which according to Respondent 1 is ahead of the scheduled commissioning date i.e. 7-9-2017 in terms of the PPA.

12. Even when Respondent 1 has undertaken the construction activities in the changed location and informed the appellant that the expected date of commissioning of the project is 31-8-2017, the appellant terminated the contract by its order dated 11-8-2017. As pointed out by Respondent 1 in its counter-affidavit, on 6-6-2016, Respondent 1 has got sanction of the term debt facility of Rs 267.37 crores from PTC India Financial Services Ltd. and has spent huge amount in purchasing the land to an extent of 253 acres in Ashok Nagar District. Respondent 1 has also spent substantial amount in development of the project in the changed location and reached an advanced stage of commissioning the project by 31-8-2017. The delay in commissioning the project appears to be due to unavoidable circumstances like resistance faced at the allotted site in Rajgarh District and subsequent change of location of the project. These circumstances, though not a force majeure event, time taken by Respondent 1 in change of location and construction of the plant have to be kept in view for counting the delay. Having invested huge amount in purchasing the land and development of the project at Ashok Nagar District and when the project is in the final stage of commissioning, the termination of the contract is not fair.

13. The High Court observed that the delay in completing the project was only for sixteen days. But according to the appellant, Respondent 1 was granted time period of 210 days to complete the Conditions Subsequent after which the penalty was leviable for the delay and if the delay exceeded more than nine months, the appellant could terminate the contract. According to appellant, the delay was not of sixteen days; but the said delay of sixteen days is beyond the period of nine months permissible under the PPA. In the light of our observations above, we are not inclined to go into the merits of this contention. Suffice to note that in cases of delay, Articles 2.5 and 2.6 provide for levy of penalty. As observed by the High Court, since the contract permits imposition of penalty, Respondent 1 is liable to pay penalty in terms of Clause 2.5.1 of the PPA for the delay. But the action of the appellant in terminating the contract is arbitrary and was rightly set aside by the High Court.

14. While setting aside the termination of the contract, the High Court maintained the action of invocation of bank guarantee in terms of Clause 2.5.1 of the PPA. By order dated 22-9-2017 SLP (C) No. 23848 of 2017, 2017 SCC OnLine MP 1654, this Court has stayed the order of the High Court subject to restitution by the appellant of the amount covered by the bank guarantee which has been invoked which is said to have been complied with by the appellant. In our view, interest of justice would be met by directing Respondent 1 to pay penalty amount of Rs 11,95,54,200 imposed upon Respondent 1 by the appellant.

15. In the result, the appeal is dismissed. Respondent 1 shall pay the penalty of Rs 11,95,54,200 to the appellant within a period of four weeks from the date of this judgment. No costs.