- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Tauseef And Others Revisionists v. State Of U.P Opp. Party.
K.N Sinha, J.:— Heard the learned counsel for the revisionists, the learned A.G.A and perused the impugned order.
2. The present revision has been filed against the order dated 29.1.2003 passed by Sri K.K Sharma, Addl. Sessions Judge Court No. VIII, Bijnor in Sessions Trial No. 581 of 1999, State v. Tauseef under section 302/307 I.P.C
3. The brief facts of the case are that during the trial the statements of Raisuddin P.W 1 and Naseemuddin P.W 2 were recorded. After recording the statements an affidavit was filed before the Trial Court wherein they stated that they have given false evidence in the trial at the instance of the police and now they want to make statement according to their conscience. The application was moved by the accused for recalling of the witnesses on the above ground. The learned Trial Judge rejected the said application.
4. The learned counsel for the revisionists has relied upon the case of Amar Pal v. State of U.P,1 wherein it was held that if the witnesses filed affidavits they can be summoned afresh as the said affidavits were clearly in contradiction with the earlier statements.
5. The learned counsel for the revisionists further relied upon the case of State (Delhi Administration) v. Ramesh Kumar,2 in which similar view was taken.
6. The learned counsel for the revisionists further relied upon the case of Mohd. Hussain Umar Kochra etc. v. K.S Dalipsinghji,3 in Which the examination of one witness Ali was made and the cross-examination was also concluded on September 4, 1961. The defence applied for recalling of the said witness as the Witness Ali was repentant and wanted to give otherwise evidence but the same was rejected because there was no affidavit or any other material upon which the Court could be satisfied. On the strength of this authority the learned counsel for the revisionists submitted that the Apex Court rejected the application only because there was no affidavit or any other material on record. This Supreme Court authority and the case of Amar Pal (supra) were discussed by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Tahir v. State of U.P . 2000 40 ACC 311 All. and the Division Bench held as follows:
“The witnesses should not be recalled for further cross-examination under section 311 Cr. P.C On the facts stated by them in the affidavits filed subsequent to their statements recorded in the Court at the request of the accused.”
7. The case of Mohd. Hussain Umar Kachra (supra) was considered in paras 6 and 7 of the judgment of this authority and it was held that it does not follow as a necessary corollary that if an affidavit had been filed by the witness, that would have made out a case for recalling the witness for further cross-examination.
8. The Division Bench further observed that:
“The Court may exercise that power in their behalf when there is some ambiguity in the testimony of witness or there is some strong justifiable cause to recall him. It is not possible to enumerate the variety of circumstances in which the Court may exercise such a power. It is pertinent to mention here that provision of section 145 of the Evidence Act was not the subject-matter of consideration before the Apex Court in the case of Mohd. Hussain Umar Kochra v. Dalipsinghji.5
If the witnesses are recalled subsequent to the conclusion of their evidence in Court at the behest of the accused on the basis of affidavits subsequently filed by them contradicting their previous statements made in Court, it would be in violation of the provisions contained in section 145 Evidence Act.”
9. Thus in view of the above, I have given my anxious consideration to the matter and find that there is no justification for recalling those witnesses and the learned Trial Court has rightly rejected the application under section 311 Cr. P.C
10. The revision is therefore, devoid of any force and is hereby dismissed.
Revision Dismissed.
Alert