- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
U.P Avas Evam Vikas Parishad And Another v. Lajja Ram .
R.H Zaidi, J.:— The above noted two second appeals are defendants' second appeals in which questions of law and fact involved were common. They were, therefore, connected on the request made by the learned counsel for the appellants, heard together and are being decided by this common judgment. The second appeal No. 1444 of 2000 shall be the leading case.
2. The relevant facts of the case giving rise to the present second appeal, in brief, are that the plaintiff-respondent Lajja Ram filed Original Suit No. 418 of 1997 with respect to plot Nos. 387, 388, 389, 390, 391 and 392 of village Makanpur, district Ghaziabad, for short, ‘the land in dispute’ for permanent injunction restraining the defendant-appellants from interfering in his possession and use of the land in dispute and not to demolish the construction existing in the said land. Prayer for a direction to the defendant-appellants for grant of permission to construct a multi-storied building in the land in dispute was also made. In brief, it was pleaded by the plaintiff-respondent that he was the owner in possession of the land in dispute. Firstly his father Raghunath Sahai, son of Anand Swarup, was the owner of the said land for more than 50 years. His name continued to be recorded in the revenue papers upto 1366 Fasli but thereafter by mistake of the Lekhpal it was not recorded. Defendants had no concern whatsoever with the land in dispute but they were extending threats to take illegal possession over the land in dispute and to demolish the construction existing thereon. Therefore, the plaintiff had to file the said suit for the above mentioned reliefs.
3. On behalf of the defendant-appellants a written statement was filed controverting the facts stated in the plaint. It was pleaded that the name of the plaintiff's father was never recorded in the revenue papers over the land in dispute. The land in dispute was acquired by the Special Land Acquisition Officer, Meerut regarding which case No. 3/87 was filed on. 15.8.1989 and the defendants had succeeded in taking possession over the said land. The plaintiff had no right or possession over the land in dispute. It was pleaded that in the suit State of Uttar Pradesh was not impleaded as a party. The suit was under valued and was also barred by sections 34 and 41 of the Specific Relief Act. It was also barred by sections 16 and 30 of the Land Acquisition Act. Therefore, the suit was liable to be dismissed.
4. On the basis of the pleadings, the Trial Court framed as many as eight issues. The parties produced evidence, oral and documentary, in support of their cases. The Trial Court after perusing the material on record and after hearing the parties answered all issues in favour of the plaintiff and decreed the suit by its judgment and decree dated 2.5.1997 for the reliefs noted above.
5. Aggrieved by the judgment and the decree passed by the Trial Court the defendants filed an appeal before the Court below, which was registered as civil appeal No. 105 of 1997. The Appellate Court framed as many as eleven additional issues and referred them to the Trial Court for recording and returning findings on them. On receipt of the said issues, the Trial Court once again afforded the parties an opportunity to produce additional evidence, oral and documentary, if any. After the parties again produced evidence with respect to the additional issues, the Trial Court thereafter recorded findings on them in favour of the plaintiff. With respect to issue No. 19, it was, however, observed that the same was not pressed by the counsel for the defendant appellants. It will not be out of place to state that in the said appeal, the plaintiff-respondent also filed a contempt petition under Order XXXIX, Rule 2-A of the Code of Civil Procedure, which was registered as Misc. Contempt Petition No. 8 of 1999, Lajja Ram v. N.C Pradhan. The Appellate Court after hearing the counsel for the parties and after perusing the material on the record also affirmed the findings recorded by the Trial Court on all the issues, which were based on the relevant evidence on the record and dismissed the appeal with costs and affirmed the decree passed by the Trial Court with slight modification. The contempt petition was also allowed. It was held that the defendant-appellants have committed breach of the injunction order issued by the Court. Having recorded the said findings, the consequential orders for compliance of the order passed by the Court were passed, which are mentioned in the end of the judgment of the Appellate Court dated 13.9.2000, hence the present second appeal.
6. The above noted appeals were filed by Mr. Pankaj Mittal, Advocate with Sri Murlidhar as Senior Advocate with him. Sri Murlidhar appeared before the Court and submitted that the judgment and decree passed by the Courts below were wholly illegal as the same were based on misreading and misconstruction of the relevant evidence on the record but he failed to show from the material on the record any misreading or misconstruction of evidence, as the same was not before the Court. He, therefore, prayed for summoning the records of the Courts below (suits and appeals) through special messenger at his own cost. The records were, accordingly, summoned. Thereafter appeals were listed several times but the learned counsel appearing for the appellants evaded to appear before the Court even when the appeals were listed peremptorily, they sent their illness slips, which was contrary to the Rules, however, the appeals were not dismissed for default. Ultimately, learned counsel for the appellants argued the appeal. It was vehemently urged that the plaintiff-respondent was not the owner in possession of the land in dispute. The land in dispute was acquired in accordance with law as the same was banjar. The suit was, thus, barred by the provisions of sections 16 and 30 of the Land Acquisition Act as well as the U.P Avas Evam Vikas Parishad Adhiniyam, 1965. The claim of the plaintiff-respondent, according to him, was totally false and the appeal was liable to be allowed.
7. I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for the appellants and also perused the record.
8. The two Courts below have recorded concurrent findings on all questions involved in the appeal. Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as amended by the C.P.C (Amendment) Act No. 104 of 1976, m sub-sections (1) and (3) of section 100, provides as under:—
“100. Second Appeal.—(1) Save as otherwise expressly provided in the body of this Code or by any other law for the time being in force, an appeal shall lie to the High Court from every decree passed in appeal by any Court subordinate to the High Court, if the High Court is satisfied that the case involves a substantial question of lax.
(2) ………………
(3) In an appeal under this section, the memorandum of appeal shall precisely state the substantial question of law in volved in the appeal.”
9. According to the above noted provisions, satisfaction of the High Court that the case involves a substantial question of law and framing of substantial questions of law in the memo of appeal is necessary for entertainment/admission of a second appeal. Substantial question of law, in view of the decisions of the Apex Court and this Court, is a question which is not dependent upon examination of evidence and requires no fresh investigation of facts, which directly and substantially affects the rights of the parties as well as the decision of the Court below if it is decided against. The above noted appeal is concluded by concurrent findings on all issues framed by the Trial Court as well as on additional issues framed by the first Appellate Court. The findings recorded by them are based on relevant evidence on record. Learned counsel for the appellants has also failed to frame any substantial question of law in the memo of appeal. The questions framed by them require examination of evidence and fresh investigation of facts, which is legally not permissible and none of the questions framed by them can be said to be a substantial question of law within the meaning of section 100, C.P.C The judgment and orders passed by the Courts below are very well considered and are based on cogent reasons. It has specifically been held that the plaintiff was the owner in possession of the land in dispute which was never acquired as there was no documentary evidence of the acquisition of the land, therefore, there was no question of bar of sections 16 and 30 of the Land Acquisition Act or of any provisions of the U.P Avas Evam Vikas Adhiniyam. Learned counsel for the appellants has also utterly failed to demonstrate to this Court that any substantial question of law is involved in the present appeal. The appeal therefore, merits dismissal.
10. In view of the facts and reasons stated above, this appeal fails and is hereby dismissed under Order 41, Rule 11 C.P.C
11. This judgment shall also govern the connected second appeal No. 1445 of 2000. A copy of this judgment may also be placed on the record of connection second appeal No. 1445 of 2000.
12. Appeal Dismissed.
Alert