- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
G. Daniel v. Govt. Of A.P & Ors.
1. The petitioner is seeking a writ of Mandamus declaring the order of the 1st respondent dated 19.5.2003 appointing a Special Public Prosecutor as arbitrary and illegal.
2. The petitioner is an accused in S.C No. 90 of 1999 on the file of the Court of the Metropolitan Sessions Judge, Hyderabad. He along with four others is charged under Section 302 read with 120-B of IPC. At the instance of the de facto complainant, who is the 3rd respondent herein, the 1st respondent - Government, issued the impugned G.O.Rt No. 942 dated 19.5.2003 appointing Sri J. Krishna, Advocate as Special Public Prosecutor to conduct the prosecution in S.C No. 90 of 1999, subject to the condition that the fees to the Special Public Prosecutor shall be borne by the 3rd respondent. The said order has been assailed by the petitioner on various grounds. The learned counsel for the petitioner Sri A. Ravinder Reddy contended that the order impugned is violative of Section 24(8) of the Criminal Procedure Code. The learned counsel contends that the Public Prosecutor is not part of the investigating agency but he is an independent statutory authority and he has to act impartially and since in the instant case the appointment of the Special Public Prosecutor was made on a request made by the de facto complainant who agreed to pay the fees to the said Special Public Prosecutor, it cannot be expected that he would work disinterestingly to the prosecution as well as the accused. He further contended that even an Advocate appointed to assist the Public Prosecutor in prosecuting the case cannot conduct prosecution but he can only assist the Public Prosecutor and at the most can file written arguments with the permission of the Court. Therefore, according to the learned counsel the appointment of the 3rd respondent as Special Public Prosecutor as per the choice of the de facto complainant is nothing but engaging an Advocate to plead the case of the de facto complainant. The learned counsel in support of his contention placed reliance upon Public Prosecutor v. Ch. Satyanarayana, 1986 (1) ALT 141.
3. On the other hand, the learned Government Pleader appearing for respondents 1 and 2 submitted that the Special Public Prosecutor would conduct the case of the prosecution as per the instructions of the Government authorities and the apprehensions of the petitioner are without any basis. It is also submitted that taking into consideration the importance of the case and for early disposal of the case the Special Public Prosecutor has been appointed under the impugned order which is in accordance with Section 24(8) of the Criminal Procedure Code and does not warrant any interference by this Court.
4. It is relevant to note that in the counter-affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents 1 and 2, it is stated that on the representation made by the 3rd respondent - de facto complainant, the Government having examined the matter issued the order impugned, appointing the Special Public Prosecutor for conducting the trial in S.C No. 90 of 2000 keeping in view the importance of the case and for its early disposal. It is also stated that Section 24(8) does not specify the existence of any special circumstances for appointment of a Special Public Prosecutor, and that the Government is competent and empowered to appoint a Special Public Prosecutor under Section 24(8) of Cr. P.C
5. As can be seen from the material on record the writ petitioner is the Accused No. 1 in S.C No. 90 of 1999 on the file of the court of the Metropolitan Sessions Judge, Hyderabad. He was charged along with four others for an offence under Section 302 read with 120B of IPC. A perusal of the charge sheet dated 18.11.1997 shows that on 25.7.1997 the brother of the 3rd respondent-de facto complainant, was murdered at about 8.30 p.m while proceeding on his scooter at Madhuranagar. The 3rd respondent lodged a complaint on the same day. The police having conducted the investigation filed the charge sheet stating that Accused No. 1 by name Rajendra Reddy, who is no other than the cousin brother of the deceased, had serious disputes with the deceased in connection with their respective claims in respect of certain properties and since the deceased was proceeding with the constructions on the disputed property, Accused No. 1 decided to liquidate the deceased by hiring killers. Accused Nos. 2 to 5, who had criminal background were hired by the 1st accused to kill the deceased. On 25.7.1997 all the accused together waylaid the deceased and stabbed him with daggers, due to which the deceased died on the spot. All the accused absconded from the scene of offence and were arrested on 21.8.1997 together at their hideout in the house of Accused No. 2. They were identified in the identification parade and the material objects were recovered at the instance of the accused. Ultimately charge sheet was filed stating that Accused No. 1 hired Accused Nos. 2 to 5 and in furtherance of their conspiracy, Accused Nos. 1 to 5 committed murder of the deceased.
6. Now, the present writ petition is filed by the Accused No. 2 alone alleging that he cannot place trust and confidence in the Special Public Prosecutor who was chosen by the de facto complainant, who is also an Advocate practicing in the same Court.
7. It is true that in Public Prosecutor v. Ch. Satyanarayana (2 supra), this Court has not accepted the argument that the accused has no locus standi to raise an objection as to the appointment of a particular person as a Special Public Prosecutor under Section 24(8) of Cr. P.C on the ground of reasonable apprehension of bias. There can be also no dispute about the ratio laid down that the prosecuting counsel does not represent either the de facto complainant or the police and that his function is to assist the court in arriving at the truth but not to obtain a conviction at any cost.
8. However, the interference of this Court is warranted only where the facts and circumstances give rise to a reasonable apprehension that the Special Public Prosecutor would not act impartially and where a case is made out that fair and dispassionate presentation of facts of case is doubtful. Where the accused merely pleads that he has no confidence in the Special Public Prosecutor and such a plea is not supported by any material, this Court would normally decline to interfere with the decision of the Government made in exercise of powers under Section 24(8) of Cr. P.C It is relevant to note that in Ch. Satyanarayana's case a specific allegation has been made by the accused that the Special Public Prosecutor who was appointed at the instance of de facto complainant, was an Advocate for the de facto complainant and he had also appeared for her and he prevailed over the Inspector of Police and got a charge sheet filed against the accused even before the investigation was complete by the crime branch. That apart specific allegations were made against the Special Public Prosecutor that he was known for his capacity for bringing and suppressing and also for foisting criminal cases and that he was in the good looks of the police and that the PRC earlier registered against him was the outcome of the latter's manipulation and in one of the adjournment petitions he clearly alleged that the accused has committed the alleged offences. In the circumstances, it has been held that since he has identified himself as the counsel for the de facto complainant, he had clearly disqualified himself from being placed in a position of trust and confidence so far as the accused is concerned. Thus, it was held that a reasonable apprehension has arisen in the minds of the accused that the Special Public Prosecutor would not act with impartially, which is expected of him, in the light of the particular facts and circumstances of the case it was held that the Government acted illegally in appointing the 2nd respondent therein as Special Public Prosecutor.
9. In the case on hand, the facts are entirely different. Except a vague statement made in the affidavit that the petitioner cannot placed trust and confidence in the Special Public Prosecutor, who was chosen and paid by the de facto complainant, no other allegation was made either against the Special Public Prosecutor or any motive has been attributed against the de facto complainant in choosing the Special Public Prosecutor.
10. Admittedly, the offence alleged is based on the alleged conspiracy among the accused and a request has been made by the 3rd respondent-de facto complainant, to appoint Mr. J. Krishna, who is the former Addl. Public Prosecutor and well experienced in conducting such type of cases. The 1st respondent-Government having considered the request made by the 3rd respondent appointed the Special Public Prosecutor in exercise of powers under Section 24(8) of Cr. P.C There is neither a plea nor any material to show that the 1st respondent issued the impugned order mechanically nor was any allegation that it was for any extraneous considerations. Under Section 24(8) of Cr. P.C it is open to the 1st respondent-Government to appoint a Special Public Prosecutor on being satisfied that the case deserves the appointment of a Special Public Prosecutor. I am unable to hold that the decision of the 1st respondent-Government, is vitiated merely on the ground that it was done at the instance of the 3rd respondent or on the ground that the fees is borne by him. For the aforesaid reasons, I am unable to hold that the decision taken by the 1st respondent suffers from any serious illegality or infirmity warranting interference by this Court. It cannot be said that the order impugned has been passed without application of mind to the facts of the case nor any case is made out to show that it causes any prejudice to the case of the petitioner. Accordingly, I do not find any merit in the contention raised by the petitioner.
11. The writ petition is accordingly dismissed.
12. No costs.
Alert