Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Kalyan Banerjee v. Eastern Coal Fields Limited And Ors.

Calcutta High Court
Nov 25, 2005
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an application for review of a Division Bench order dated 30th April, 2003, which held a writ application filed by a dismissed employee challenging his dismissal to be not maintainable due to lack of territorial jurisdiction. The writ petitioner was an employee of Eastern Coal Fields Limited, a Government company with its registered office in Burdwan, within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. The petitioner was dismissed while posted in Dhanbad, which falls under the jurisdiction of a different High Court. The disciplinary proceedings and cause of action arose there. The Single Judge referred the issue of territorial jurisdiction to the Division Bench, which ruled that only the Jharkhand High Court had jurisdiction. The petitioner seeks review of that order, contending that this Court has jurisdiction because the employer’s registered office is within its territorial limits and that earlier Division Bench decisions supporting this view were overlooked.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether this High Court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain a writ petition challenging dismissal of an employee when the cause of action arose outside its territorial limits but the employer’s registered office is within its jurisdiction.
  2. Whether the Division Bench erred in ignoring binding precedents of other Division Benches that held this Court had territorial jurisdiction in similar circumstances.
  3. Whether the order dated 30th April, 2003 should be reviewed on the ground of an apparent error due to non-consideration of relevant precedents.

Arguments of the Parties

Writ Petitioner’s Arguments

  • The High Court has territorial jurisdiction under Article 226(1) of the Constitution of India since the employer, a Government company, has its registered office within the Court’s territorial limit.
  • The Division Bench wrongly disregarded two earlier Division Bench decisions—Ram Brich v. Coal India Limited and Eastern Coal Fields Ltd. v. Khagen Bouri—which supported the Court’s jurisdiction.
  • The Court’s jurisdiction is not defeated merely because the cause of action arose outside the territorial limit if the respondent is situated within it.

Respondent’s Arguments

  • The writ application was not maintainable before this Court because the petitioner was posted and the cause of action arose in Dhanbad, outside this Court’s territorial jurisdiction.
  • The decisions relied upon by the petitioner were not brought to the Division Bench’s notice at the time of hearing, and thus the order did not commit any illegality warranting review.
  • The employer denied that the contested decisions were submitted during the original hearing and alleged that the copies were subsequently inserted in the record.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
N.N Singh v. Coal India Limited (C.O No. 5869 (W) of 1994) High Court’s territorial jurisdiction over writ petitions involving a Government company with registered office within the Court’s limits. The Single Judge initially relied on this decision to assert jurisdiction, but it was later disapproved by the Division Bench.
General Manager, Mugma Area, Eastern Coalfields Limited v. Gopal Chandra Mondal (F.M.A No. 581 of 1999) Disapproval of the jurisdictional principle laid down in N.N Singh; held that territorial jurisdiction lies with the High Court where the cause of action arose. The Division Bench preferred this decision over N.N Singh and held that only the Jharkhand High Court had jurisdiction.
Ram Brich v. Coal India Limited (A.P.O.T No. 343 of 2002) Supports territorial jurisdiction of the High Court where the employer’s registered office is located. The petitioner relied on this decision in the review application to challenge the Division Bench’s order.
Eastern Coal Fields Ltd. v. Khagen Bouri, 2002 (1) C.L.R 884 Similar principle affirming jurisdiction based on the employer’s registered office location. Also relied upon by the petitioner to contend error in the Division Bench’s order.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court acknowledged the undisputed fact that the employer, Eastern Coal Fields Limited, is a Government company with its registered office within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court. It applied Article 226(1) of the Constitution of India, which permits a High Court to entertain writ petitions if the person to be bound by the order is situated within its territorial limits, regardless of where the cause of action arose. The Court noted that the Division Bench had focused solely on the cause of action arising outside its jurisdiction and ignored the employer’s registered office location, which is a critical factor. The Court further emphasized settled law that a Government company’s registered office is deemed its site for litigation purposes under the Companies Act. The Court also highlighted the principle that if a binding Division Bench precedent is overlooked, the later Bench should refer the matter to a larger Bench rather than take a contrary view. Since the Division Bench did not consider two relevant Division Bench decisions supporting jurisdiction, the Court found an error apparent on the face of the record justifying review. The Court declined to engage in disputed factual questions regarding whether the petitioner had placed those decisions before the Division Bench, focusing instead on the legal principle and admitted facts.

Holding and Implications

The review application is allowed. The Court held that the writ application challenging the dismissal of the employee is maintainable before this Court because the employer’s registered office is located within the territorial jurisdiction of this Court, invoking Article 226(1) of the Constitution. The Court directed the learned Trial Judge to decide the writ petition on its merits. There will be no order as to costs.

The direct effect is that the petitioner’s writ petition can be heard and decided by this Court despite the cause of action arising outside its territorial limits. The order corrects the previous Division Bench’s error in jurisdictional assessment but does not establish a new precedent beyond reaffirming existing legal principles regarding territorial jurisdiction and the importance of binding precedents.

Show all summary ...

Bhaskar Bhattacharya, J.:— This is an application for review of an order dated 30th April, 2003 passed by a Division Bench of this Court on a reference made by a learned single Judge of this Court by which a writ application filed by a dismissed employee challenging the order of dismissal was found to be not maintainable before this Court for lack of territorial jurisdiction.

2. There is no dispute that the writ petitioner was an employee of the Eastern Coal Fields Limited, the respondent no. 1, a Government Company within the meaning of the Companies Act having its registered office at Sanctoria in the District of Burdwan within the territorial limit of this Court. When such a writ application was moved before a learned Single Judge of this Court, the respondents, the employer, took a preliminary objection as to the maintainability of the said writ application on the allegation that the writ petitioner was at the time of dismissal posted at Dhanbad which is within the territorial jurisdiction of a different High Court and the disciplinary proceedings also having been conducted at that place, no part of cause of action had accrued within the territorial limit of this Court.

3. The writ petitioner relied upon a decision of Mr. Justice N.K Batabyal in C.O No. 5869 (W) of 1994 (N.N Singh v. Coal India Limited) and contended that this High Court had the territorial jurisdiction. The learned Single Judge disagreed with the view taken by Batabyal, J. and accordingly, referred the matter to the Division Bench.

4. The Division Bench by its order dated 30th April, 2003 accepted the view of the learned referring Judge and came to the conclusion that the cause of action of the present writ application had arisen wholly within the territorial jurisdiction of Jharkhand High Court and therefore, the Jharkhand High Court alone could entertained decide the matter an this Court had no territorial jurisdiction. While arriving at such conclusion, the Division Bench observed that the said Division Bench in F.M.A No. 581 of 1999 (General Manager, Mugma Area, Eastern Coalfields Limited v. Gopal Chandra Mondal) decided on 26th March, 2003 disapproved the law laid down by Batabyal, J. and the three decisions referred to in the said judgment and accordingly, preferred to follow its own decision in F.M.A No. 581 of 1999.

5. The writ petitioner has come up with the present application for review alleging that at the time of hearing, the learned advocate for the writ petitioner relied upon two decisions of other Division Benches, one in the case of Ram Brich v. Coal India Limited in A.P.O.T No. 343 of 2002 and the other, of a different Division Bench in the case of Eastern Coal Fields Ltd. v. Khagen Bouri, reported in 2002 (1) C.L.R 884, but the Court did not consider those judgments as it appears from the order sought to be reviewed. The petitioner, therefore, submits that there is an error apparent on the face of the record, first, for ignoring the earlier two Division Bench decisions of this Court and secondly, for overlooking the fact that the Head office of the Company being situated within the territorial limit of this court, it is competent to entertain the writ application.

6. This application for review is seriously opposed by the employer and it has been specifically alleged in the affidavit-in-opposition that those decisions of the Division Bench taking a contrary view were never brought to the notice of the Court and as such, the Division Bench did not commit any illegality justifying review of its order. It appears from record that no affidavit-in-reply has been given to the aforesaid assertion and Mrs. Mitra, the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the petitioner, submitted before us as he is unable to contact her client, no affidavit-in-reply could be filed.

7. It, however, appears that the Xerox copies of those two decisions of different Division Benches are available in the records of the present case. Mr. Banerjee, the learned advocate appearing on behalf of the respondent, complained that those have been subsequently inserted in the records.

8. There is serious dispute as to whether those two decisions were really placed before the Division Bench and as one of us, who was a member of that Bench, after such a long time is unable to recollect whether those decisions were really submitted at the time of hearing, we are not going into those disputed questions of fact. Mrs. Mitra, the learned advocate herself argued the matter and according to her, she produced those decisions but such fact is denied by Mr. Banerjee who also appeared at the time of hearing. In such a state of affairs, we refrain from entering into such disputed questions as well find that the application for review can be disposed of without entering in to such controversy.

9. Mr. Banerjee appearing on behalf of the employer, however, did not dispute the fact that the writ petitioner before dismissal from service was an employee of the Eastern Coal Fields Limited, the respondent no. 1 herein, a Government company within the meaning of Companies Act, 1956 and that the registered office of the said Company is situated in the district of Burdwan within the territorial limit of this Court. In view of the aforesaid admitted fact, we are of the view that Article 226(1) of the Constitution of India is clearly attracted and this Court had territorial jurisdiction to entertain the writ application.

10. As provided in the Companies Act, Company is a body corporate and its registered office should be deemed to be its site for the purpose of all litigations. The law is equally settled that an employee challenging an order of dismissal cannot get an effective order unless the employer is made party to the litigation and as such, in this case, the Eastern Coal Fields Limited having its registered office in the district of Burdwan is a necessary party and if the Court proposes to give relief to the writ petitioner, specific direction of reinstatement must be given to the employer to be carried out through its appropriate officers. As provided in Article 226(1) of the Constitution of India, even if the cause of action arises outside the territorial limit of a High Court, such High Court can entertain a writ application if the person sought to be bound by the order of the Court is stationed within the territorial limit. Article 226(2) is an additional provision subsequently incorporated by way of amendment enabling a High Court to issue writ even in cases where the respondents are functioning beyond its tertitoral limit if the cause of action has arisen fully or in part within its territorial limit.

11. Once it is held that Article 226(1) is clearly applicable, there is no necessity of invoking Article 226(2) of the Constitution of India. From the order sought to be reviewed, we find that Division Bench confined its attention to the cause of action of the present writ application but totally ignored the fact that the employer, the Government company, has its registered office within the district of Burdwan and consequently, the question whether cause of action had really arisen within the territorial limit of this Court was immaterial.

12. We, therefore, find that the respondent no. 1, the employer being statutorily located within the territorial limit of this Court having its registered office therein and such employer being a necessary party, this court has territorial jurisdiction to entertain the writ application.

13. Apart from the aforesaid fact, one we find that two other Division Benches of this Court had taken a contrary view to the one taken by the Division Bench which passed the order sought to be reviewed, even if those decisions were not placed at the time of hearing, in our view, such order should be recalled the moment it is brought to the notice of the court that the order was passed in ignorance of a valid precedent. It is now settled law that if there is already a Division Bench decision dealing with a specific question and another Division Bench proposes to take a contrary view, the later should refer the matter to a larger Bench; but it cannot take a contrary view, unless the earlier decision is found to be per incuriam or there is any subsequent decision of a superior court or a Larger Bench of the same court taking a contrary view.

14. The Division Bench in the order sought to be reviewed took no notice of the other two decisions which had already taken a contrary view. We are quite conscious that mere fact that a relevant decision was not cited or a point was not argued by the learned Advocate at the time of hearing is not a ground for review, but if a binding precedent was not cited and the court took a contrary decision in ignorance of such binding precedent, such fact is sufficient to review an order.

15. We, therefore, review the order dated 30th April, 2003 passed by the Division Bench and hold that the employer, the respondent no. 1, having its registered office in the district of Burdwan within the territorial limit of this Court, this writ application is quite maintainable before this Court, even if, the cause of action for filing the writ application had arisen entirely outside the territorial limit of the Court. We, therefore, direct the learned Trial Judge to dispose of the writ application on merit. The review application is, thus, allowed. In the facts and circumstances, there will be, however, no order as to costs.

Jayanta Kumar Biswas, J.:— I agree.

16. Order accordingly.