Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Subrata Kr. Rajak v. State Of W.B And Ors.

Calcutta High Court
Mar 23, 2006
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Pratap Kr. Ray, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner (together with other eligible candidates) participated in a selection process to fill a vacancy for the post of clerk at Dakshin Khanda Mahatmaji Vidyapith. The selection followed the recruitment procedure/guidelines issued by the Director of School Education, West Bengal (Memo No. 1736 (21) G.A dated 1st Nov., 1999). A Selection Committee conducted oral interviews and a typing test (the typing test being conducted by an expert body) and prepared a panel of three candidates in order of merit. The panel placed the petitioner first and respondent no. 8 second. The Managing Committee examined and recommended the panel for approval by the District Inspector of Schools (D.I.S).

Before the D.I.S. approved the panel, respondent no. 8 obtained the letter of the Member of Parliament, Shri Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, which led the District Magistrate, Murshidabad, to direct an enquiry (carried out by Additional District Magistrate Smt. Sima Halder). On the basis of that enquiry report the District Inspector of Schools directed the School Authority/Managing Committee to recast the panel, and respondent no. 8 was subsequently appointed and joined the post on 18 December 2001.

The petitioner filed the present writ application seeking mandamus to set aside the approval of the recast panel and to approve the original panel (which placed the petitioner first), and to direct submission of the enquiry report and related records. The writ was contested by the School Authority, the State respondents and private respondent no. 8. After detailed hearing, the High Court delivered judgment quashing the enquiry, the recasting and the appointment of respondent no. 8, and directed the D.I.S. to consider the original panel for approval.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, under the Recruitment Procedure/guidelines issued by the Director of School Education (exercising power under Rule 28 of the Management Rules, 1969 and Section 45 of the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education Act, 1963), the District Magistrate had any scope or jurisdiction to conduct an enquiry into the selection process and whether the District Inspector of Schools could act on such an enquiry initiated by the District Administration at the instance of a Member of Parliament.
  2. Whether the Managing Committee could recast the panel when the Selection Committee had become functus officio after finalizing the selection.
  3. Whether a post-selection dispute alleging imperfect action in allotting marks by Selection Committee members could be entertained so as to disturb a final panel which had been forwarded to the Managing Committee for recommendation and approval.
  4. What reliefs could be granted given the parties' pleadings?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The Selection Committee prepared the panel after conducting an oral interview and a typing test (the petitioner typing 44 words correctly in two minutes, obtaining first position on aggregate marks) and the Managing Committee recommended that panel to the D.I.S. for approval in terms of the Recruitment Rules.
  • There was no scope for the District Magistrate (a "stranger body" under the Recruitment Rules) to hold an enquiry into the selection process or to direct re-evaluation of marks; such interference was de-hors the statutory recruitment procedure and a trespass into the domain of the Selection Committee and Managing Committee.
  • Once the Selection Committee finalized the panel it became functus officio and its decision could not be reassessed by anyone other than the Selection Committee itself (or in narrow, specified circumstances) — the District Magistrate had no legal status under the recruitment rules to interfere.

Private Respondent No. 8's Arguments

  • The District Magistrate's enquiry was valid and lawful; the defect was identified irrespective of the District Inspector of Schools' jurisdiction.
  • The recasting of the panel pursuant to the D.I.S.'s action was valid and legal and an appointment letter had already been issued; respondent no. 8 had joined the post on 18 December 2001.

School Authority's Position

  • The School Authority produced records asserting that the expert body's marks for the typing test were not changed, and the Selection Committee endorsed the expert's decision. However, acting under the direction of the District Inspector of Schools, the School Authority recast the panel when so directed.

State Respondents' Position

  • The State respondents supported the legality of the District Magistrate's action and the subsequent steps taken in pursuance of the enquiry (as they contended no illegality was committed by the District Magistrate in directing the enquiry).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
C.B. Gautam v. Union of India, (1993) 199 I.T.R. 530 Direction upon a body (SEBI) considered as having mandatory binding effect though not declared a rule per se (approving K.P. Varghese v. I.T.O.). Relied upon to show that guidelines/directions from an authority (Director of School Education) may have binding effect on the recruitment process participants.
K.P. Varghese v. I.T.O., (1981) 131 I.T.R. 597 Principle regarding the binding effect of certain directions (as approved by the five-judge bench in C.B. Gautam). Used (via C.B. Gautam) to support that the recruitment guideline has statutory favour and binding effect on parties involved in recruitment.
Maniruddin Bepari v. The Chairman Of The Municipal Commissioners, Dacca, 40 C.W.N. 17 Authority on statutory bodies acting within statutory limits (cited among cases emphasising limits on administrative interference). Cited to support the proposition that statutory bodies must act within the periphery of statutory limits.
Sri K. Ramdas Shenoy v. Chief Officer, Town Municipal Council, Udipi, (1974) 2 SCC 506 Principle that statutory bodies must act within prescribed statutory parameters. Relied upon to reinforce constraint on non-statutory interference in statutory selection processes.
S.R. Tewari v. The District Board, Agra, AIR 1964 SC 1680 Authority cited for limits on administrative power and requirement to act within statutory ambit. Applied to support the Court's view that the District Magistrate exceeded jurisdiction in conducting the enquiry.
J.N. Ganetra (Morvi Municipality), (1996) 9 SCC 495 Cases on the limited domain of enquiry/interference by bodies other than the constituted selection authority. Relied upon in the context that outside bodies cannot re-evaluate selections made by constituted bodies.
Bhavnagore University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (P) Ltd., (2003) 2 SCC 111 Support for principle that statutory provisions and bodies' powers must be respected and not transgressed by outsiders. Used to buttress that the District Magistrate had no power to enter the selection arena.
Chancellor v. Dr. Bijayendra Kar, (1994) 1 SCC 169 Allegation against an expert/Selection Committee is not entertainable to disturb selections unless malice/bias proved. Applied to hold that complaints against members of the Selection Committee cannot be entertained to upset a final panel.
Air Vice Marshal S.L. Chhabra v. Union of India, 1993 Supp (4) SCC 441 Expert body's view cannot be interfered with unless bias or mala fide is shown. Invoked to hold that the expert conducting the typing test could not be re-evaluated by a third party absent mala fide.
Neelima Mistra v. Harinder Kaur Paintal, (1990) 2 SCC 746 Decision that academic/selection bodies' decisions should not be lightly interfered with. Relied upon to support non-interference with Selection Committee/expert decisions absent bias.
Simms Motor Units Ltd. v. Minister of Labour & National Service, 1946 (2) All E.R. 201 Authority cited in connection with the doctrine of "dictation" — a body should not act on another's decision as if it were its own. Used with other authorities to apply the doctrine of dictation and hold that the D.I.S. acting on another body's findings was unlawful.
R. v. Police Complaints Board, ex parte Madden, (1983) 2 All E.R. 353 Also cited for the doctrine of dictation and improper delegation or adoption of another's findings. Relied upon to characterize the D.I.S.'s action as improper adoption of the enquiry officer's findings.
H. Lavender and Son Ltd. v. Minister of Housing and Local Government, (1970) 3 All E.R. 871 Authority invoked for principles on unlawful adoption of others' decisions (doctrine of dictation). Applied to support quashing of actions taken by the D.I.S. relying on the enquiry report.
Orient Paper Mills Ltd. v. Union of India, (1970) 3 SCC 76 : AIR 1970 SC 1498 Authorities on administrative law and limits on adopting third-party findings. Cited to reinforce that decision-making bodies must not abdicate or adopt another's conclusions improperly.
Anirudhsinhji Karansinghji Jadeja v. State of Gujarat, (1995) 5 SCC 302 Authority touching on administrative decision-making limits (cited among cases on the doctrine of dictation). Invoked to support the conclusion that actions taken on the enquiry report were outside lawful procedure.
Biswanath Das v. State of West Bengal, C.O. 16826 (W) of 1995 (order dated 2 Mar 2001) High Court decision discussed on limits of D.I.S. power to recast or modify panels (only allowed for mathematical mistakes, not subjective re-evaluation). Relied upon as precedent and followed by a Division Bench affirming that D.I.S. can only correct mathematical errors and not reassess subjective marks.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded through a structured analysis grounded in the Recruitment Procedure (Memo No. 1736 (21) G.A dated 1st Nov., 1999), issued under Rule 28 of the Management Rules, 1969 and Section 45 of the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education Act, 1963. The Court observed that:

  1. The Recruitment Rules constituted the governing procedure for filling non-teaching posts. Under those guidelines the Selection Committee (constituted by the Managing Committee) conducts tests (viva/written and typing by an expert), records marks in score sheets, prepares a panel of three candidates in order of merit and submits the panel to the Managing Committee for examination and onward forwarding to the District Inspector of Schools for approval.
  2. Once the Selection Committee finalizes the panel and forwards it, the Selection Committee becomes functus officio. The Court emphasised settled law that decisions of a statutory/selection body must remain within statutory contours and cannot be reassessed by bodies not authorised by the statute.
  3. There was no provision in the Recruitment Rules permitting the District Magistrate (District Administration) to hold an enquiry into the subjective elements of the selection process (including re-marking of a typing test conducted by an expert). The Court held that the District Magistrate was a "stranger" to the selection process and had no statutory status under the Recruitment Rules to interfere.
  4. The expert who conducted the typing test had recorded marks in the score sheet and the Selection Committee endorsed those marks; the School Authority produced original score sheets which did not show any subsequent endorsement or change by the expert. The Court held that an expert's marks (and the Selection Committee's acceptance) could not be re-evaluated by the District Administration or by any other third party unless mala fide or bias was proved.
  5. The enquiry officer (Additional District Magistrate) substituted her own view on the typing test outcome; the Court found that substitution to be legally impermissible and characterised the enquiry report as bad in law.
  6. The District Inspector of Schools' action of directing recasting of the panel on the basis of the enquiry report was held to be outside the scope of his authority under the recruitment guidelines (save for correcting mathematical errors). The Court applied the doctrine of dictation — i.e., a decision-maker cannot simply adopt or act upon another's conclusions in a manner that abdicates its own proper function — to hold the D.I.S.'s action invalid.
  7. Following prior High Court decisions (including Biswanath Das) and a Division Bench affirmation, the Court reiterated that the D.I.S. may only correct mathematical mistakes in totals; subjective reassessment of marks or substitution of the Selection Committee's findings was impermissible.

Holding and Implications

Holding: Writ allowed.

The Court's specific orders (direct consequences for the parties) were:

  • The direction of the District Magistrate to hold an enquiry (appointing an Enquiry Officer) was quashed and set aside as being without jurisdiction and contrary to the recruitment procedure.
  • The enquiry report (prepared by the Additional District Magistrate) was quashed.
  • The District Inspector of Schools' direction dated 22nd November, 2001, to the Managing Committee to recast the panel (and the Managing Committee's recast panel) were set aside and quashed.
  • The approval of the recast panel and the appointment of respondent no. 8 were set aside and quashed; respondent no. 8 was directed to vacate the post forthwith in pursuance of the judgment.
  • The original panel prepared by the Selection Committee (which placed the petitioner first) was to be considered by the District Inspector of Schools for approval, but the D.I.S. was prohibited from making any subjective reassessment or re-evaluation of marks awarded by the expert body or the Selection Committee. The D.I.S. was directed to decide on approval within two weeks of the judgment and communicate the decision to the petitioner and the Managing Committee. If approved, the Managing Committee was to issue an appointment letter and the petitioner would be allowed to assume duties.
  • The writ petition was allowed and costs of Rs. 15,000 were imposed on the State respondents to be paid to the petitioner within one month (the Court quantified costs due to the petitioner having incurred substantial legal expenditure because of the interference by a "stranger" to the recruitment process).
  • Operational directions: return of original documents to the School Authority's counsel (after keeping Xeroxed copies), and refusal of stay sought by respondent no. 8; certified copies to be provided to parties on priority.

Implication summary: The decision restores the Selection Committee's original panel and forbids post-selection subjective re-evaluation by the District Magistrate or the District Inspector of Schools (except correction of mathematical errors). The appointment effected pursuant to the recast panel was annulled, and the D.I.S. must consider the original panel for approval within two weeks. Costs were awarded against the State.

Show all summary ...

The Judgment of the Court was delivered by

Pratap Kr. Ray, J.:— Heard the learned Advocates appearing for the parties.

2. The matter has been heard at length for as many as 12 days or more on allowing all parties proper opportunity of hearing. Today the matter is appearing in the list as ‘For Orders’. The writ petitioner has prayed for the following reliefs in the writ application.

“a) A writ in the nature of mandamus directing the District Inspector of Schools (SE), Murshidabad to forthwith withdraw, recall and set aside the approval of the said illegal recast panel made by the Selection Committee in the instance of the District Magistrate Murshidabad and to approve the panel made by the Selection Committee whe??? the petitioner has been placed at the top.

b) A writ in the nature of mandamus directing the District Inspector of Schools (SE), Murshidabad as well as School Authority to submit a report of the enquiry by the Deputy Magistrate, Murshidabad and also all relevant records relating to this interview.”

The factual matrix of the case as pleaded in a nutsell as follows:

3. The petitioner along vith other eligible candidates appeared in the selection process with reference to the filling up of vacancy of the post of clerk in Dakshin Khanda Mahatmaji Vidyapith. The selection process started in terms of the recruitment procedure issued by the Director of School Education, West Bengal. The Selection Committee as constituted by the Managing Committee duly interviewed the candidates by taking oral interview and the typing test through an Expert Body and a panel was ultimately placed to the Managing Committee for recommendation and onward transmission to the office of the District Inspector of Schools concerned for his necessary approval. The Managing Committee recommended the same and the matter was pending before the office of the District Inspector of Schools concerned for approval. At this juncture on behalf of the private respondent no. 8, Shri Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, Member of Parliament of the concerned area had written a letter to the District Magistrate, Murshidabad alleging, inter alia, that the selection process was not proper and there was manipulation of marks so far as typing test was concerned. The District Magistrate, Murshidabad alleging, inter alia, that the selection process was not proper and there was manipulation of marks so far as typing test was concerned. The District Magistrate, Murshidabad entertained this complaint and directed one of his officers, Smt. Sima Halder, an Additional District Magistrate to enquire into the matter, who in turn scrutinized the papers of the selection process by her visit in the school premises and thereafter made a note directing the District Inspector of Schools concerned to take appropriate steps by pointing out the alleged illegality in the marking of the typing test. In pursuance thereof, the District Inspector of Schools concerned acted and on the basis of the enquiry report whereby the respondent no. 8 was shown as the first empanelled candidate, contrary to the panel as prepared by the Selection Committee as per Recruitment Rules, directed the School Authority to recast the panel and such requested panel was placed before the District Inspector of Schools concerned who accorded approval. From that panel the respondent no. 8 was appointed giving a go-bye to the first empanelled position of the petitioner as was judged by the Selection Committee members and which was accepted by the Managing Committee by its recommendation following the Recruitment Rules.

4. This writ application has been opposed by filing affidavit-in-opposition by the School Authority, the respondent no. 7, by the State respondents and by the private respondent no. 8. It is the stand of the private respondent that nothing illegality was done by the District Magistrate directing to hold an enquiry on the matter and the action as taken in pursuance thereof was legal and valid. It is also the stand of the State Government. The School Authority has taken a stand by placing the relevant documents that at no point of time any correction was made in the original typing test papers by expert, endorsed by Selection Committee. But the School Authority acted in terms of the direction of the District Inspector of Schools concerned whereby the School Authority was directed to recast the panel. The learned Advocate appearing for the petitioner has submitted that in the typing test as the petitioner corrected 44 words within two minutes and taking into account of the oral interview marks, the petitioner secured the first position in the panel whereas the private respondent no. 8 since correctly typed 15 words in two minutes in terms of the dictation test on adding oral interview, he secured second position in the panel and such panel once having been finalized by the Selection Committee and duly recommended by the Managing Committee by referring the same to the District Inspector of Schools concerned seeking approval under the Recruitment Rules issued by the Director of School Education, West Bengal, there was no further scope to enquire into the matter about legality and validity of such selection by a stranger body who has no legal status under the Recruitment Rules, namely, the District Magistrate of the District and that too in pursuance of the letter of member of the Parliament. It is submitted that the entire action of the District Magistrate directing an enquiry through his subordinate staff and thereby direction to the District Inspector of Schools concerned to take steps accordingly in terms of such enquiry report is de-hors of the statutory provision of law, namely, the recruitment procedure as framed and constituted by the Director of School Education, West Bengal. It has been further contended that once a selection process has been finalized there is no scope to disturb such selection process by anybody.

5. The private respondent no. 8 has sub???ted that as from the records the defect was identified irrespective of the fact of jurisdiction of the District Inspector of Schools concerned, the recasting of the panel as was done as per direction of the District Inspector of Schools concerned was valid and legal. It is further submitted that in pursuance of such decision of recasting of the panel an appointment letter has already been issued and the respondent no. 8 has already joined in the post as clerk on 18th December, 2001. The learned advocate appearing for the School Authority has submitted by producing the original records that the expert body's views never was changed and/or modified by any other person and selection process was rightly completed. But as the District Inspector of Schools concerned directed recasting of the panel, the School Authority had no other alternative but to recast the same. Having regard to the rival contentions of the parties, the following points emerged for adjudication in this writ application.

1. Whether in terms of the recruitment procedure framed and constituted by the Director of School Education, West Bengal on exercise of power under Rule 28 of Rules of Management of Recognized Non-Government Institution (Aided and Unaided) Rules, 1969, being the guideline for recruitment of non-teaching staff issued under Memo No. 1736 (21) G.A dated 1st November, 1999, there is any scope for an enquiry by the District Magistrate, Murshidabad through his officer and as to whether the District Inspector of Schools concerned as per recruitment procedure acted properly by taking notice of such enquiry submitted by the District Administration on the basis of the complaint of a Member of the Parliament.

2. Whether under the Recruitment Rules there was any scope of recasting of the panel by the Managing Committee when the Selection Committee already became functus officio after the selection was over.

3. Whether a post-selection dispute could be entertained alleging imperfect action of the members of the Selection Committee of allotting marks when already that Selection Committee finalizing the panel referred the same to the Managing Committee who in turn recommended the panel for approval by the District Inspector of Schools concerned.

4. What relief could be granted on the basis of the pleadings of the respective parties?

6. To adjudicate the first point as to whether the District Magistrate, Murshidabad had any jurisdiction to direct an enquiry to identify the legality and validity of the selection process and allotment of the marks in the typing test by the expert body, this Court needs not to detain itself any more as it is a settled law that every statutory body must act within the periphery of the statutory limits and contours in terms of the statute. Further it is a settled law that a statutory body must act in terms of a statute and it cannot act beyond the scope of jurisdiction and parameter prescribed by the statute. To identify the issue involved herein the relevant statutory provision namely the recruitment procedure is now required to be dealt with. Since the interview letter was served on 6th August, 2001, the Recruitment Rules as existing as on that date would be the guiding principle to identify the procedure of recruitment.

7. Having regard to such, the Recruitment Rules of the year 1999 as issued under Memo No. 1726 (21) G.A dated 1st February, 1999 being the latest Recruitment Rules in the field for recruitment of the non-teaching staff in the secondary school is the guiding rules. This Recruitment Rule was issued by the Director of School Education, West Bengal in terms of the power exercised under Rule 28 of the Rules of Management of Recognized Non-Government Institution (Aided and Unaided) Rules, 1969, for brevity hereinafter referred to as Management Rule. Rule 28 also got its statutory source in terms of Section 45 Sub-section (1) and Sub-section 2(d) of the West Bengal Board of Secondary Education Act, 1963 in terms whereof the Management Rules was framed and constituted. Though the recruitment procedure aforesaid was a direction/guideline issued by the Director of School Education, West Bengal but such recruitment procedure has absolute binding effect upon all the members related to such recruitment process though this guideline in the nature of direction in the stricto sensu cannot be deemed as a Recruitment Rules in terms of a statute but it has statutory favour in the nature of a direction, which is binding to all the parties concerned involved in such process. Reliance may be placed to the judgment passed in the case C.B Gautam v. Union of India, reported in (1993) 199 I.T.R 530, a judgment of five Judges Bench, which approved K.P Varghese v. I.T.O, reported in (1981) 131 I.T.R 597, arose out of Income Tax proceeding whereby the direction upon SEBI was considered by the Apex Court as having a mandatory binding effect upon the Income Tax Authorities even the direction was not declared as a rule per se.

8. Now the Recruitment Rules aforesaid to be scanned to identify the ???oint as emerges herein for decision in this writ.

9. The relevant provision of the said Recruitment Procedure reads to this effect:

“GOVERNMENT OF WEST BENGAL

Director of School Education

Memo No. 1736 (21) G.A Dated, Calcutta, the 1st Nov., 1999.

Guidelines for Recruitment of Non-Teaching Staff (Librarian, Clerk, Group ‘D’ Staff) of Non-Govt. Aided Secondary Schools, Higher Secondary Schools, Govt. sponsored Schools, D.A getting school and all types of Aided Madrasahs including Senior Madrasahs and newly set up Educational institution at Secondary Level in West Bengal:

DIRECTIONS

1(A) All appointment of non-teaching staff (Librarian, Clerk, Group ‘D’ Staff) shall be made with the prior permission of the District Inspector of Schools (S.E) of the respective District against sanctioned post.

(b) Prior permission ???hall not be necessary for appointment in vacancies of 4 months or less.

…………………

3.(a) When any vacancy occurs against any sanctioned post in any recognized and aided Schools, Madrasahs or in any set up School/madrasah.

The management of these Institution shall approach the D.I.S (S.E) for prior permission for taking steps for appointment with relevant papers.

…………….

4.(a) On receipt of the prior permission from the School stage from the D.I of Schools (S.E), the School Authorities shall approach the Local Employment Exchange for sponsoring the names of the Employment Exchange candidates.

…………………

MODE OF SELECTION & SELECTION

COMMITTEE:

FOR NEWLY SET-UP EDUCATIONAL

INSTITUTION AT SECONDARY LEVEL.

………………

For the Post of Clerk and Group D Staff:

1. Headmaster/Headmistress/Teacher-in-Charge in recognized High/H.S/High Madrasahs in the Sub-division.

2. Secondary of the Managing Committee/Ad-hoc Committee/Administrator. If the Headmaster and the Secretary of the School are one and the same person, the President of the Committee shall be included as a member.

3. One approved Headmaster/Headmistress of other High/Higher Secondary/High Madrasah in the same Sub-division to be selected by the Managing Committee.

4. One nominee of the Panchayat Samity for School situated in rural areas to be nominated by the Sabhapati, Panchayat Samiti. For other areas one member of the Managing Committee to be selected by the Managing Committee. The nominee of the Panchayat Samity, however, shall not be a member of the Staff of the School.

…………………….

ALLOTMENT OF MARKS

No marks shall be awarded to the candidate for any academic qualification above the qualification mentioned by the D.I of School (S.E) in the prior permission. No claim or evidence regarding qualification/age of any candidate shall be accepted after the interview.

……………….

For appointment to the post of Clerk, marks for

(i) Academic qualification shall be awarded for MP/SF/Or its equivalent (full marks)-10

(ii) Viva Voce/Written test (full marks)-5

(iii) Type writing to be tested on the date of interview with stress one accuracy (full marks) — 5

………………

Marks awarded to each candidate in each individual items shall be recorded separately in the score sheet. Copies of such score sheet in respect of all the Candidates appearing in the interview along with the Tabulation sheet shall be sent to the D.I of School (S.E) along with the panel.

The total marks awarded to each of the candidates on the terms mentioned before shall be computed and panel consisting of 3 candidates in order of merit shall be prepared for submission to the Managing Committee. Panel of less than 3 candidates can be prepared only for the post reserved for S.C & S.T/O.B.C candidates provided the names of three or more candidates are not available inspite of all possible efforts.

………………

Panel should be prepared with average of marks awarded by each of the members of the Selection Committee. If any of the members want to keep his opinion reserved average marks shall be calculated on the marks awarded by other members.

……………….

The Selection Committee after preparing the panel on the date of interview shall submit the same to the Organizing/Managing Committee/Ad-hoc Committee/Administrator. On being examined by the Managing Committee/Ad-hoc Committee/Administrator the panel shall be forwarded to the District Inspector of School (S.E), for approval with all relevant papers within 15 days from the date of interview. Dist. Inspector of Schools (S.E) shall convey his decision within one month from the date of receipt of the panel.

On getting approval of the panel the Organizing/Managing Committee/Ad-hoc Committee/Administrator of the School shall issue appointment letter to the 1st empanelled Candidate within 15 days through Registered Post Card/Registered Inland letter. The panel shall remain valid for one year from the date of approval of the panel by the D.I of Schools (S.E).

…………….

The School Authority shall submit papers to the District Inspector of Schools (S.E) ???or approval of the appointment within 15 days of the joining of the employee and the District Inspector of Schools (S.E) shall convey his decision with one month. In the approval letter District Inspector of Schools (S.E) shall specifically mention the name, qualification, Scale of pay, period of approval and the nature of vacancy against which the appointment has been made and approved.

…………….

Sd/- A.K Roy

Director of School Education, West Bengal.”

10. On reading of the Recruitment Rules, it appears that as soon as a vacancies cropped up in a school, it requires prior permission to fill up by the District Inspector of Schools concerned and in terms thereof under Clause 4(a) once prior permission is accorded, the Employment Exchange is invited to sponsor the names of the eligible candidates from their life register. The Selection Committee is framed and constituted following the steps under heading “mode of selection and Selection Committee”, which empowers the Committee to prepare the final panel holding viva voce/written test and type writing test. The panel for the selected candidates on merit as is finalized in terms of said procedure is submitted to the office of the Managing Committee for their examination. The Managing Committee then refers the matter for approval by the District Inspector of Schools concerned and when the approval decision is reached to the office of the School Authority, appointment letter is issued in terms of the panel having the validity of the life of the panel for one year.

11. In the instant case, a panel consisting of three names was prepared by the Selection Committee on 29th August, 2001 following the said procedure. Typing test was conducted by an expert and decision of expert was duly endorsed by the Selection Committee members. The panel thereafter was finalized where the petitioner stood first securing 9.25 marks whereas the respondent no. 8 stood second securing 8.88 marks. This panel thereafter was referred to the Managing Committee by the Selection Committee. The Managing Committee held a meeting and on examining, recommended the panel for approval to the office of the District Inspector of Schools concerned. Hence, from the procedure of the Recruitment Rules as already referred to, it appears before this Court that the panel prepared by the Selection Committee was duly accepted and recommended by the members of the Managing Committee wherein the petitioner stood first. But this panel while awaiting for the approval of the District Inspector of Schools concerned, the Managing Committee, Murshidabad directed one Additional District Magistrate to hold an enquiry by entertaining the letter of one Shri Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, a Member of the Parliament. The letter of Shri Adhir Ranjan Chowdhury, M.P reads to this effect:

“…………Kindly find herewith a copy of representation of Shri Bablu Kumar Das of Vill. Kamdevbati, P.O Satitara, Dist. Murshidabad addressed to me and a copy to you in connection with unjustified procedure adopted in the interview in the post of clerk at Dakshinkhanda Mahatmaji Vidyapith to deprive his case.

The matter may kindly be investigated from his own accord so that the suitable person is not deprived from his legitimate position……………”

12. A direction was given by the District Magistrate to hold an enquiry authorizing one of his subordinate staff, Additional District Magistrate. The said officer submitted an enquiry report and invited the District Inspector of Schools concerned to act as per such enquiry report.

13. As already discussed, under the recruitment procedure, the panel reached its finality upto the stage of recommendation of the Managing Committee. Under the recruitment procedure the Selection Committee after preparing the panel was bound to submit it to the Managing Committee for their examination, who in turn on examining the same was required to forward the matter for approval of the District Inspector of Schools concerned. Under the four corners of the aforesaid recruitment procedure of 1999 there is no provision that the District Administration, namely, the District Magistrate would be entitled to reassess the selection process further on holding an enquiry. Under the guidelines of recruitment of non-teaching staff the District Magistrate of the District Administration has no hand to interfere with the selection process. The entire selection process is absolutely within the domain of the Managing Committee of the school, through the members of the Selection Committee and the District Inspector of Schools concerned. The Managing Committee created under the statute, namely, the Management Rules, 1969 was only vested with power to constitute the Selection Committee. The Managing Committee also has no right of interference in the matter of selection process as completed by the Selection Committee itself, save and except examination of the papers as submitted by the Selection Committee after finalization of the selection process. Hence, the District Magistrate, Murshidabad got no hand even if any complaint made to him by anybody to interfere with such selection process by scrutinizing the papers of typing test as was finalized by the Expert Body. The allotment of the marks by an Expert Body in respect of the typing test cannot be the subject matter of scrutiny by the District Magistrate, Murshidabad. It is a settled law that the statutory body must perform their statutory responsibility within the framework of the statute. It is a settled law further that an individual can do whatever he likes save and except as are not prohibited by law whereas a statutory body is bound to perform only those acts as are prescribed under a statute. Reliance may be placed to the judgments passed in the cases. Maniruddin Bepari v. The Chairman Of The Municipal Commissioners, Dacca*, Dacca, reported in 40 C.W.N 17, Sri K. Ramdas Shenoy v. Chief Officer, Town Municipal Council, Udipi, reported in (1974) 2 SCC 506, S.R Tewari v. The District Board, Agra reported in AIR 1964 SC 1680, J.N Ganetra, Morvi Municipality, reported in (1996) 9 SCC 495 : [1996 (4) SLR 598 (SC)] Bhavnagore University v. Palitana Sugar Mills (P) Ltd., reported in (2003) 2 SCC 111. In this context a passage from the Books of Statutory Construction by Earl. T. Crawford is quoted, wherein at page 34 under the heading “Express Mention and Implied Exclusion” the following has been emphasized:

“As a general rule, in the interpretation of statutes, the mention of one thing implies the exclusion of another thing. If therefore, logically follows that if a statute enumerates the things upon which it is to operate, everything else must necessarily, and by implication, be excluded from its operation and effect. If the statute directs that certain acts shall be done in a specified manner, or by certain person, their performance in any other manner than that specified, or by any other person than one of those names, is impliedly prohibited.”

14. Having regard to the said legal position, accordingly, this Court is of the view that the action of the District Magistrate, Murshidabad was de-hors of the said recruitment procedure and no where under any statute he got any right to interfere with the selection process by holding an enquiry to identify the legality and validity of the subjective test of the selection process as culminated to a panel.

15. In that view, the action of the District Magistrate directing to hold en enquiry was of without jurisdiction and was nothing but illegal trespass in the selection process. Law never has authorized that gentleman to enter into the arena of the selection process. Even the Managing Committee of the school also got no right to interfere with the selection process. The selection process and finalization of the panel is entirely with in the domain and field being duly contoured in the Recruitment Rules and the guideline and is vested solely to the Selection Committee members. Hence, the action of the District Magistrate directing to hold an enquiry has vitiated the decision to change the panel, which goes to the root of the matter and the same cannot stand lawfully.

16. Besides those settled principles of law about limitation of exercise of power by the statutory body, the issue could be looked into in another angle. As already discussed that the selection and empanelment thereof is within the absolute domain of the members of the Selection Committee, which cannot be interfered with, modified and or corrected by anybody save and except the members of the Selection Committee itself. Furthermore, it is a settled law that once the Selection Committee finally decides the matter by empanelling the names of the candidates and forwards the papers to the appropriate body for their decision as per empanelment, it becomes functus officio. Once the Selection Committee becomes functus officio, the decision of such Selection Committee on the basis of relevant data of their respective tests either objective or subjective cannot be reassessed, recalculated, re-varied and re-evaluated by anybody and no complaint about illegality or impropriety of such selection process alleging any bias action of any members of the Selection Committee could be entertained far to say could be the basis of turning round the entire selection process and its result. Reliance may be placed to the judgment passed in the case Chancellor v. Dr. Bijayendra Kar, reported in (1994) 1 SCC 169 : [1994 (1) SLR 17 (SC)] wherein an allegation was made about the selection of the university teacher made by the Expert Body and the Apex Court answered that no complaint was entertainable alleging against the members of the Selection Committee. The point no. 1 is accordingly answered in favour of the petitioner and against the respondent by holding that the District Magistrate had no jurisdiction and power to enquire into the legality and validity of the selection process, which culminated to a panel of selected candidates on allotting marks by an Expert Body in terms of the, statutory provision, namely, the guidelines framed by the Director of School Education, West Bengal, a guideline for recruitment of the non-teaching staff.

17. The empanelment is the result, which is based on consideration of the marks as allotted by the members of the Selection Committee with reference to the different tests, which either may be objective or subjective. The marks allotted by such Expert Body and/or members of the Selection Committee also cannot be the subject matter of an enquiry by any other Body not authorized to do so under relevant statute on the issue that a member of the Selection Committee ought to have granted higher marks to a candidate or ought to have granted lower marks to another candidate. As soon as anybody other than Selection Committee decides the issue in that manner, it steps into the shoes of the Selection Committee itself, which is not permissible under the law. Even the Court of Law has no jurisdiction to interfere with the marks as allotted by the members of the Selection Committee as it is within the domain of the Selection Committee itself to allot marks and that too on the basis of the subjective satisfaction on the result of interview. As already discussed, this Court also will not venture to assess the merit of candidates on re-evaluating and reappraising the basis of marks allotment. Reliance may be placed to the judgment passed in the case Air Vice Marshal S.L Chhabra, V.S.M v. Union of India reported in 1993 Supp (4) SCC 441 : [1993 (2) SLR 805 (SC)]. It is a settled law that the Expert Body's view could not be interfered with unless there is a bias or mala fide alleged and that too by the Court of law. Reliance may be placed to the judgment passed in the case Neelima Mistra v. Harinder Kaur Paintal, reported in (1990) 2 SCC 746 : [1990 (2) SLR 435 (SC)]. It is also a settled law that the decision of the academic body should not be interfered with. Reliance may be placed to the judgment passed in the case Chancellor (supra).

18. In the instant case, so far as the marks allotted for academic qualification and the oral interview there is no dispute raised by the alleged Enquiring Officer appointed by the District Magistrate, Murshidabad, save and except the marking of typing test. It has been alleged in the enquiry report that the expert, who conducted such test failed to allot marks properly on the basis of typing test. In the report it has been identified that the petitioner ought not to have been allotted marks on the basis that he correctly typed 22 words per minute as from the result sheet it was revealed that the figure was not correct. Allotment of the marks by the expert in a typing test where there is a necessity of assessment of the speed also, not only depends upon the typing of the correct words without any mistake but it also depends upon the speed of a candidate who followed dictation of such test. The School Authority has produced the original typing test sheet wherefrom it appears that the expert who had taken the test did not change his mind as is alleged in the opposition field by the respondent no. 8 by contending that the expert subsequently admitted that there was mistake. From the original score sheet as placed by the School Authority it appears that there is no such endorsement of the expert and the expert never changed his views. Furthermore, the expert even had no scope to change it as marks allotted by expert became the marks allotted by the Selection Committee who by acceptance of such, prepared the panel. The Selection Committee did not change score sheet and there was no scope to do such under the law. Furthermore, once the expert decided any issue, he became functus officio and he had no jurisdiction to re-evaluate it until it is directed to do such by the Selection Committee or Managing Committee who appointed him and authorized to act.

19. Having regard to such state of affairs and having regard to the legal position that once the expert allotted the marks on the basis of the speed of the candidate in typing a matter as well as typing of the correct words in a particular time, this Court is of the view that nobody can reassess or reevaluate such to substitute the finding of the expert.

20. In that view of the matter, the report of the Enquiry Officer is also bad in law as the said Enquiring Officer substituted his own views, which is de-hors of law.

21. Having regard to such, the observations and findings of the Enquiring Officer is also contrary to the settled position of law as discussed, namely, that expert body's decision cannot be reevaluated or reassessed by any other body and District Inspector of Schools under said recruitment rule had no jurisdiction and authority to act as per said report.

22. Hence, the action of the District Inspector of Schools concerned on the basis of the alleged enquiry report of the Additional District Magistrate was de-hors of the statutory provisions. District Inspector of Schools concerned under the aforesaid guidelines had no scope to entertain any enquiry report and that too, a report prepared by a 3rd party stranger who under the law cannot have any access in the selection process. The District Inspector of Schools concerned accordingly acted outside the scope of his jurisdiction as identified in the guidelines. His action to recast the panel on the basis of the said enquiry report accordingly was without jurisdiction on considering the alleged enquiry report submitted by a body, who acted without jurisdiction. Furthermore, his action is illegal and bad applying the doctrine of dictation, which speaks that a body under the law when is duty bound to act as per his own decision, if decides the issue or report of other person, the action is totally bad in law. Reliance may be placed to the judgment passed in the case Simms Motor Units, Ltd. v. Minister of Labour & National Service, reported in 1946 (2) All. E.R 201, R. v. Police Complaints Board, ex parte Madden, reported in (1983) 2 All. E.R 353, H. Lavender and Son Ltd. v. Minister of Housing and Local Government, reported in (1970) 3 All. E.R 871, Orient Paper Mills Ltd. v. Union Of India, reported in (1970) 3 SCC 76 : AIR 1970 SC 1498 and Anirudhsinhji Karansinghji Jadeja v. State of Gujarat, reported in (1995) 5 SCC 302.

23. From the materials on record it further appears that though a writ proceeding was initiated by the Respondent No. 8, being no. 14551 (W) of 2001, whereby and whereunder District Inspector of Schools concerned by the order dated 18th October, 2001, was directed to consider the matter upon hearing the parties, but it appears that on the basis of the said order no hearing was concluded by the District Inspector of Schools concerned upon giving notices to all the parties, though in affidavit-in-opposition it has been alleged that District Inspector of Schools concerned in terms of the order of the High Court heard the matter and decided the issue directing to recast the panel. However, it appears from the records that the recasting order was passed by the District Inspector of Schools concerned On the basis of the alleged enquiry report submitted by the Additional District Magistrate concerned. Under the recruitment process even the District Inspector of Schools concerned had no power to change marks except the condition, namely, when marks not properly added on mathematical calculation only, but not on scrutinizing the issue by subjective revaluation of the matter on marking. The District Inspector of Schools concerned also had no jurisdiction to direct the Managing Committee to recast the panel as the panel was never prepared by the Managing Committee. The concerned panel was prepared by the concerned Selection Committee and that panel only was examined by the Managing Committee under the guidelines. Examination of the panel is not synonymous to the preparation of the panel. The body who has prepared the panel is only entitled to vary and/or modify the panel on detecting any mistake in allotting any marks and that too, on the basis of mathematical calculation only but not on further subjective revaluation of the matter of marking. In that view of the matter direction of the District Inspector of Schools concerned dated 22nd November, 2001, directing the Managing Committee to recast the panel also was dehors of the guidelines as Managing Committee got no power to recast the panel. In the instant case the Selection Committee became functus offico and as such, there was no scope of reconstituting that Selection Committee. Hence, on a reading of the guidelines, this Court in the earlier judgment passed in the case Biswanath Das v. State of West Bengal, being No. C.O 16826 (W) of 1995 dated 2nd March 2001, had already held that the District Inspector of Schools concerned got the right to recast or modify the panel in the event any mistake, which relates to mathematical calculation is detected by not agreeing with due respect with the views expressed by Hon'ble Justice G.R Bhattacharjee, J. (as His Lordship then was), in an identical case, where His Lordship held that the District Inspector of Schools concerned had no power to recast the panel as the power was vested to the Director of School Education, West Bengal in terms of sub-clause (2) of Rule 28 of the Management Rules. This Court on interpreting the said sub-clause (2) of Rule 28 of the Management Rules, 1969, identified the point that sub-clause (2) Rule 28 of the Management Rules has applicability when a permanent employee's prayer for extension is returned or refused by the District Inspector of Schools concerned and at this juncture the matter is required to be placed before the Director of School Education, West Bengal. This Court accordingly held in the judgment that under the selection process when the panel is in the preparatory stage on way of approval of the District Inspector of Schools concerned, there was no appointment of any teacher and/or staff and accordingly, extension of service of any appointee in terms of the said sub-clause (2) of Rule 28 of the Management Rules had no applicability under the recruitment process.

24. On considering such and identifying such humble disagreement with His Lordship G.R Bhattacherjee, J. this Court referred the matter to the Larger Bench following the judicial discipline to settle the law. Division Bench (Coram: A.K Mathur, C.J & Jayanta Kr. Biswas, J.) by the order dated 8th October, 2002, decided the issue affirming the views expressed by this Court. Hence, law at the present moment is settled law that with reference to the recruitment process and the recruitment rules till the appointment is being given by the Managing Committee, the District Inspector of Schools concerned only has a right to recast, vary or modify the panel in the event the District Inspector of Schools concerned considers on mathematical calculation that there was a mistake. But District Inspector of Schools concerned is not empowered even to reassess or reevaluate the subjective methods of selection so far as the allotment of the marks as was done by the Selection Committee as it was absolutely within the domain of the members of the Selection Committee, which cannot be touched by anybody, save and except the Court of Law that to in the event any malice is alleged and proved against any member of Selection Committee in the matter of allotment of the marks or any bias is alleged and proved by anybody in favour of any candidate of such selection. Having, regard to all such state of affairs, accordingly, this Court is of the view that decision of the District Magistrate to make an enquiry appointing one Smt. Sima Halder, Deputy Magistrate, as an Enquiry Officer, was de hors of the statutory recruitment guideline and without jurisdiction and accordingly the same is set aside and quashed. The decision of the said Enquiry Officer is, also quashed. The decision of the District Inspector of Schools concerned directing the Managing Committee to recast the panel on the basis of the alleged enquiry report is also accordingly set aside and quashed. The recasting of the panel as done by the Managing Committee, is also set aside and quashed accordingly. As a result, the effect of approval of recasted panel and appointment thereof in favour of the Respondent no. 8, is also set aside and quashed.

25. In a summary accordingly now the result appears that the panel as was already prepared by the Selection Committee wherein the petitioner no. 1 stood first and Respondent no. 8 stood second, now be considered by the District Inspector of Schools concerned for necessary approval only on examination of papers submitted by Managing Committee but not on any subjective reassessment or reevaluation of the allotment of the marks as was allotted by the expert body on typing tests and by the Selection Committee in the oral interview. Such consideration of the decision of the approval with reference to the said panel, to be done by the District Inspector of Schools concerned within two weeks from this date and the decision to be communicated to the petitioner and the Managing Committee to that effect and in the event, there is approval of the panel, the Managing Committee will issue an appointment letter forthwith as soon as the panel would reach from the office of the District Inspector of Schools in favour of the petitioner and petitioner shall be allowed to perform his duties. Respondent No. 8 is directed to vacate the post forthwith in pursuance of the judgment of this Court.

26. The writ application is, accordingly, allowed.

27. Having regard to the facts of the case since a stranger in the recruitment process and the recruitment rules as well as with reference to the guidelines framed by Director of School Education, West Bengal, namely, the District Magistrate, Murshidabad entered into the arena of the selection process by appointing one of his officers, as an Enquiry Officer, to identify the defect and thereby trespassed the jurisdiction in utter disregard and violation of the recruitment rules as framed by the Director of School Education, West Bengal and thereby caused disturbance to the entire selection process by stepping into the shoes of Selection Committee, this Court is of the view that such arbitrary action invites cost as to be imposed upon the State as costs of this proceedings as the petitioner has been compelled to spent huge money for legal proceedings in the High Court at Calcutta. It that view, a cost identifying to the extent of Rs. 15,000/- is quantified, which to be paid by the State respondent to the petitioner within a month from this date.

28. Upon keeping the Xerox copy of the original records of the papers of typing test attested by learned Advocate of the School Authority, all the true copies of the original records and the original documents as produced by the School Authority be returned to the learned Advocate who produced the same.

29. Operation of stay of the order as prayed for by the learned Advocate for the respondent no. 8, is refused. Xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for, be delivered to the parties on priority basis.

30. Petition allowed.