Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

M.R Ratheesh v. Murukesan M.R

Kerala High Court
Apr 3, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners are candidates included in a list (Ext.P3) of 265 dependent sons of arrack workers who committed suicide. The list was prepared by the Chief Welfare Fund Inspector of the Kerala Abakari Workers Welfare Fund Board. The sale of arrack was abolished in the State in 1996, rendering approximately 12,000 abkari (arrack) workers jobless. In 2001 the State entrusted sale of foreign liquor to the Kerala State Beverages Corporation (KSBC), and KSBC appointed workers formerly engaged in private IMFL shops.

In 2002 the Government issued G.O.(Rt) 01/2002.TD dated 20.02.2002 (referred to as Ext.P1), directing that 25% of future daily-wage employment vacancies in KSBC be reserved for abkari workers who lost service due to the arrack ban with effect from 01.04.1996. The petitioners allege that Ext.P1 was not implemented. Subsequently the Government issued a modified order (Ext.P2) restricting the benefit to a small group — namely dependent sons of abkari workers who had committed suicide — and a list of 265 names (Ext.P3) was prepared.

After various appointments by KSBC (including many appointments of outsiders, deputation staff, temporary and daily-wage employees), trade unions challenged certain regularisation steps in W.P.(C) No. 21026/2006 and connected cases. A Division Bench judgment in those petitions (Ext.P5) issued directions, including that casual employees required in future be appointed only through the employment exchange and that such casual employees would not acquire a right to regularisation.

The present writ petition challenges the non-implementation of Ext.P1, the narrowing effected by Ext.P2, and the Government order Ext.P6 that limited eligibility under Ext.P3 to the first 51 persons. The Court considered the facts, the prior Division Bench directions (Ext.P5), government orders (Ext.P1, Ext.P2, Ext.P6, Exts.P8–P10) and various appointments made by KSBC and issued the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Government order Ext.P1 (reserving 25% of future daily-wage vacancies in KSBC for abkari workers affected by the arrack ban) ought to be implemented and given effect.
  2. Whether the subsequent modification by Ext.P2 — limiting the benefit to dependent sons of abkari workers who committed suicide and reducing the beneficiary class to the names in Ext.P3 — was justified.
  3. Whether Ext.P6 (a Government order limiting eligibility from Ext.P3 to the first 51 persons) is sustainable in law in view of the facts and prior orders.
  4. How the Division Bench judgment in W.P.(C) 21026/2006 (Ext.P5) and its directions affect the entitlement and implementation of the 25% quota under Ext.P1/Ext.P2.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners are included in Ext.P3 (265 dependent sons) and are entitled to be appointed under the 25% quota contemplated by Ext.P1.
  • Ext.P1 was passed in February 2002 but was not implemented; the failure to implement contributed to unemployment and suicides among abkari workers.
  • Ext.P2 improperly narrowed the beneficiary class and no reasons were recorded for restricting the benefit to the 265 persons in Ext.P3.
  • KSBC continued to appoint outsiders, deputation staff and temporary workers (including more than 800 after Ext.P2) instead of employing those on Ext.P3; documentary material shows KSBC permitted temporary appointments from employment exchange or deputation up to the end of 2008.
  • There remain regular vacancies in KSBC, and if Ext.P2 had been followed, almost all persons in Ext.P3 would have been employed.

Respondents' (KSBC / Government) Arguments

  • The Government and KSBC defended the modification (Ext.P2) on the basis that an alternative absorption scheme was formulated to place a major portion of abkari workers in toddy shops run by private individuals; the 25% quota was therefore restricted to dependent sons of suicided workers.
  • The respondents pointed out that the Supreme Court (referred to as the Apex Court) did not approve the scheme for absorbing abkari workers in private toddy shops, and consequently that scheme was not implemented, frustrating the intended placements.
  • The Division Bench judgment in W.P.(C) 21026/2006 (Ext.P5) issued directions (including Direction No.6) limiting appointments of casual employees to recruitment through employment exchange and restricting regularisation claims; Ext.P6 was issued in view of that Division Bench judgment to limit eligibility to the first 51 persons in Ext.P3.
  • KSBC stated that it had already appointed many persons (reporting 676 vacancies to PSC, recruited by PSC), and that it had employed persons on deputation (submitted that more than 500 are on deputation). The Government also placed reliance on recruitment orders Ext.P8 and Ext.P9 (appointments via employment exchange) and Ext.P10 (inviting deputation hands) as steps taken to fill vacancies through the prescribed processes.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P.(C) No. 21026/2006 and connected cases (Division Bench judgment) — marked Ext.P5 Held that posts manned by temporary employees continuously for one year shall be treated as regular posts; directed that casual or other employees necessary in future be appointed only through employment exchange and that such employees will not acquire a right to regularisation (Direction No.6). The Court observed that Ext.P5 dealt with temporary vacancies generally and that beneficiaries of Ext.P1 and Ext.P2 were not parties to that case; therefore Ext.P5 principles apply to temporary vacancies other than the specific 25% quota contemplated by Ext.P1/Ext.P2. The court declined to treat Ext.P5 as barring implementation of Ext.P1/Ext.P2 in their specific terms.
Judgment of the Apex Court (unnamed in the record) Reportedly did not approve a Government scheme to absorb abkari workers in privately run toddy shops. The Court noted that because the Apex Court did not approve the toddy-shop absorption scheme, that scheme was not implemented and the intended large-scale absorption of abkari workers did not materialize; this fact influenced the Court's assessment of the justification for restricting the Ext.P1 benefit.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis proceeded on the following lines, based on the material before it:

  1. The original government direction (Ext.P1) reserved 25% of future daily-wage vacancies in KSBC for abkari workers displaced by the arrack ban. The Court found no justifiable reasons recorded for the Government's subsequent failure to implement Ext.P1 in a manner benefitting the larger class of abkari workers.
  2. Ext.P2 narrowed the beneficiary class to dependent sons of abkari workers who committed suicide and thereby limited the benefit to those listed in Ext.P3 (265 persons). The Court found no adequate justification in the record for denying the broader class the benefits originally conferred by Ext.P1.
  3. The Division Bench judgment in W.P.(C) 21026/2006 (Ext.P5) and its Direction No.6 related to general rules for appointment of casual employees (appointment through employment exchange; limitation on regularisation rights). The Court emphasized that beneficiaries under Ext.P1 and Ext.P2 were not parties to Ext.P5; consequently Ext.P5's principles govern temporary vacancies generally but do not directly determine the validity or implementation of the specific 25% quota created by Ext.P1/Ext.P2.
  4. The Government's Ext.P6 order limiting eligibility under Ext.P3 to the first 51 persons was issued in view of the Division Bench judgment. The Court held that since the Division Bench had not considered Ext.P1/Ext.P2, Ext.P6's reliance on Ext.P5 to curtail the specially earmarked quota was unjustified.
  5. The factual material showed that KSBC made multiple appointments of outsiders, deputation staff and other temporary employees after Ext.P2, and that a large number of vacancies and new outlets existed. The Court treated those facts as militating against the Government's and KSBC's contention that there was no scope to implement the 25% reservation for the persons on Ext.P3.
  6. On this basis, the Court concluded that Ext.P6 (to the extent of limiting eligibility to the first 51 persons) is unsustainable and that respondents should employ the remaining dependent sons on Ext.P3 within the 25% quota. Where appointments made via employment exchange (Exts.P8 and P9) occupied the quota, the Court permitted termination of an equal number of such appointees if necessary to implement the quota.
  7. Finally, the Court directed the Government to reconsider Ext.P2 insofar as it denied benefits that Ext.P1 had conferred on a broader class, and allowed the Government the option of modifying Ext.P2 to effect rehabilitation of abkari workers who had lost employment due to the ban.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • Ext.P6 is quashed to the extent it limited eligibility under Ext.P3 to the first 51 persons.
  • The Court directed respondents 1 and 2 to pass orders employing the remaining dependent sons named in Ext.P3 within the 25% quota available to them; if necessary, an equal number of employment-exchange appointees engaged under Exts.P8 and P9 may be terminated to accommodate those entitled under the quota. Such appointments must be made within six weeks of the judgment.
  • The Government is directed to reconsider Ext.P2 to the extent it denies benefits conferred by Ext.P1 on a larger group of abkari workers; the Government may modify Ext.P2 so that the 25% of future vacancies are filled by the beneficiaries under Ext.P1 (the abkari workers). A decision on re-consideration is to be taken within three months from receipt of the judgment.
  • The writ petition is disposed of in accordance with these directions.

Implications

The direct consequences of this judgment are orders to implement the 25% reservation in favour of the persons listed in Ext.P3 beyond the first 51, the quashing of the Government's restrictive Ext.P6 order, and a mandate to the Government to revisit and, if appropriate, modify Ext.P2 so as to restore the broader intent of Ext.P1. The Court authorized remedial steps (including termination of an equal number of employment-exchange appointees, if necessary) to give effect to the quota within a specified timeframe.

The opinion does not assert that it establishes a new general legal precedent beyond its application to the facts and orders under consideration; it focuses on giving effect to the specific government orders (Ext.P1/Ext.P2/Ext.P6) and correcting the administrative implementation in the circumstances of this case.

Show all summary ...

JUDGMENT

Petitioners are the candidates included in the list of 265 dependent sons of arrack workers who have committed suicide. The said list is prepared by the Chief Welfare Fund Inspector of Kerala Abakari workers Welfare Fund Board. Ext.P3 is the said list. The sale of arrack in the State was abolished in the year 1996. Consequently, approximately 12,000/- workers engaged in the arrack shops were said to be rendered jobless Subsequently in the year 2001 the sale of foreign liquors through private licencees were also stopped by the Government and entrusted the same to the Kerala State Beverages Corporation (For short KSBC) and Consumer Fed. Consequently the KSBC appointed more than 1200 workers who were working under various IMFL shops owned by private individuals in the year 2001. During 2001, the various unions of the abkari workers launched strike demanding rehabilitation, as a result an agreement was arrived wherein it was agreed among other things that the abkari workers will also be employed in the retail outlets of I.M.F.L of the KSBC to be opened in future

2. The Government passed G.O(Rt) 01/2002.TD dated 20.2.2002 and ordered that 25% of all daily wage employment vacancies arising in the KSBC in future will stand reserved to be filled up by the abkari workers registered with the abkari workers welfare fund board who have been terminated from service due to arrack ban with effect from 1.4.1996 The petitioners alleging that though Ext P1 order was passed in February 2002, no action was taken by the Government to implement the said Government Order. Due to the ban of arrack, consequent unemployment, financial problems etc, poverty stricken workers committed suicide. Therefore the Government is compelled to pass Ext.P1 order. But the same was not given effect to for no good reasons.

3. Though the arrack ban was imposed on 1.4.1996 the decision (Ext.P1 order) to accommodate 25% dependents was not implemented by the Government for reasons known to them only. The Government did not care to implement the same order even at the belated stage. The inaction of the Government lead to many suicides. If Ext.P1 order was implemented at the right time many lives of poor abkari workers could have been saved. In the circumstances the Government was compelled to take a second decision in the meeting held on 22.10.2003 Ext.P2 modified order was passed on 7.8.1994

4. Ext.P1 order was passed earmarking 25% of the total daily workers earmarked for employees who lost employment due to ban. But by Ext. P2 Order the employment opportunities was limited to a small group i.e dependent sons of suicided workers. It is strange to note that the entire arrack workers approximately 12,000 in number are rendered jobless due to the arrack ban. Ext.P2 order only protects a small group who are the dependent sons of arrack workers who had committed suicide consequent on the loss of employment due to the ban of arrack in the State. It is not known why the benefits should not be conferred to a large number of thrown out abkari workers also and why it was limited to a small group of dependent sons containing in Ext.P3 list who are only 265 in number and no reasons are stated in Ext.P2 order for taking away the benefit conferred on such workers under Ext.P1 order.

5. It is the case of the petitioners that they have been included in Ext.P3 list and are entitled to be appointed. Subsequently the K.S.B.C has appointed 1082 employees who were working in the Foreign liquor shops run by private individuals and again the KSBC appointed more than 676 persons as daily wage employees in various warehouses as well as foreign liquor outlets. When steps were initiated by the Government to regularise the said 676 employees, some trade unions alleging back door appointments approached this Court and filed writ petition No. 21026/2006 and connected cases. A Division bench of this Court considered the question of regularisation of the said 676 employees. This Court issued six directions in the said writ petitions.

Direction No. 6 is relevant for consideration in this case. It reads as follows:

If any casual or other employees are necessary hereafter, they can be appointed only through employment exchange and such employees will not get any right for regularisation on any account as they shall not be allowed to work for more than six months. We further make it clear that regular vacancies should be notified and regular appointments should be made as expeditiously as possible.

6. The judgment passed by this Court In W.P (C) 21026/2006 is marked as Ext.P5 As per Ext.P5 judgment all posts manned by temporary employees continuously for a period of one year shall be treated as regular posts and if any temporary vacancies is to be filled up that can be done only through employment exchange. The beneficiaries of Ext.P1 and P2 orders were not parties in that writ petitions. The issue regarding the 25% quota for appointment of dependent sons of suicided abkari workers or appointment of erstwhile abkari workers was not brought for consideration in that cases. Therefore the principle in Ext.P5 judgment can apply only in respect of temporary vacancies other than 25% quota earmarked as said above. Exts. P1 and P2 orders were not under consideration in the Ext.P5 case.

7. I find no justifiable reasons for not implementing Ext.P1 order which confers benefits to a large group of abkari workers rendered jobless from 1996. I also find no justification for limiting the benefit to a small group whose names are mentioned in Ext.P3 list.

8. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the KSBC and the learned Government Pleader that another scheme was formulated by which the major portion of the abkari workers are directed to be absorbed in the toddy shops run by the private individuals and according to them that is the reason why this 25% quota is restricted to dependent sons of suicided abkari workers. It is submitted at the Bar that the Apex Court did not approve the scheme for absorbing the abkari workers in toddy shops run by the private individuals. Therefore the said scheme was not implemented, as a result the abkari workers who lost employment, remained unemployed. The purpose of modification of Ext.P1 order was defeated by the Judgment of Apex Court. Thereafter no modification was made to Ext.P2 order.

9. Besides giving employment to 676 persons who are from outside, as daily wage employees the KSBC employed several employees on deputation basis. It is submitted by the counsel for the KSBC that more than 500 employees are working on deputation basis. It is also submitted that subsequent to the appointment of 51 persons from Ext.P3 list more than 35 foreign liquor shops and two warehouses were opened by the Corporation, that for each shop at least 8 persons are required and for each warehouses 16 persons were required. If the 25% quota available to the abkari workers was implemented in time a sizable number of 12,000 abkari workers could have been accommodated and could have been regularized in the temporary vacancies.

10. The counsel for the petitioners also produced documents which will go to show that till the end of 2008, the KSBC granted permission to appoint temporary workers either from employment exchange or on deputation basis. Going by the contentions raised by the parties I find that there is no justification for not absorbing the entire 265 abkari workers from Ext.P3 list which is prepared by the Chief Welfare Fund Inspector. Now 214 workers are awaiting employment as per Ext.P2 order. It is brought to the notice of this Court that on a rough estimate the KSBC has appointed approximately 800 workers after Ext.P2 order. If Ext.P2 order was followed, almost all the persons in Ext.P3 list would have been employed In this context, it is brought to the notice of this Court, Ext.P6 order passed by the Government stating that only first 51 persons will be eligible for appointment in KSBC in view of the judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in W.P (C) 21026/2006 and connected cases and that the temporary/casual appointments in KSBC have to be made through Employment Exchange. As I said in the preceding paragraphs, the Division bench dealt only with other issues not connected with the issues in question. There was no occasion for the Division Bench to consider the implementation of Ext.P2 So the stand of the Government in Ext.P6 to the effect that 51 persons in Ext.P3 list alone will be eligible for appointment in the KSBC, is not justifiable.

11. The learned counsel for the KSBC submitted that the Corporation has already reported 676 vacancies to P.S.C for recruitment and that the P.S.C has notified the same. It is also submitted that the Government vide Ext.P8 order dated 13.08.2007 recruited 129 abkari workers and 176 abkari workers vide Ext.P9 order dated 03.03.2008 through Employment Exchange. Ext.P10 is the order dated 27.5.2008 by which the KSBC invited deputation hands from all public sector undertakings and other Government Departments, to fill up the regular vacancies. The petitioners submitted that there are large number of regular vacancies still existing in the K.S.B.C and in order to show the said fact they appended Ext.P10 order.

12. On a consideration of all the facts and materials, the relevant Government Orders Ext.P6 order passed by the Government to the extent of limiting the number to 51 is unsustainable. Therefore a direction is issued to respondents 1 and 2 to pass orders employing the remaining dependent sons in Ext.P3 list in the 25% quota available to them. By Exhibits P8 and P9 orders 129 and 176 workers are employed through Employment Exchange on daily wages without employing abkari workers from the 25% quota. If it is necessary equal number of employment exchange hands appointed under Ext.P8 and P9 orders shall be terminated, for employing candidates under the 25% quota. The appointments shall be made within a period of six weeks from today.

13. As I have stated earlier the modification of Ext.P1 order by Ext.P2 order denying employment to unemployed abkari workers cannot be justified. Government shall reconsider Ext.P2 order to the extent of denying the benefits conferred on a larger group of beneficiaries by Ext.P1 order. Government may consider that the 25% of the future vacancies shall be filled up by the beneficiaries under Ext.P1 order who are none other than the abkari workers. For the said purpose it is open to the government to modify Ext.P2 Government order so that the abkari workers who lost employment consequent to the ban of arrack can be rehabilitated. A decision shall be taken within a period of 3 months from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. Ext.p6 order is quashed.

This writ petition is disposed of as above.