Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mohan Lal Vijay v. The State Of Rajasthan & Another

Rajasthan High Court
May 12, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner challenged an order dated 27 July 2005 (Annexure-5) passed by the Deputy Secretary to Government, Personnel Department, which partly allowed and partly rejected his representation seeking expunction of adverse remarks in his confidential report for the year 2003-04. The petitioner was appointed as Assistant Commercial Taxes Officer in 1981, promoted to Commercial Taxes Officer in 1996 and later promoted to Assistant Commissioner on a regular basis by order dated 9 December 2004. He served as Assistant Commissioner (Anti Evasion), Dungarpur from 19 July 2003 to 4 October 2004.

On 4 January 2005 (Annexure-3) the petitioner was informed of adverse remarks in his 2003-04 confidential report and was invited to submit a representation within one month. The petitioner submitted a detailed representation (Annexure-4) with enclosures. The reviewing authority's order of 27 July 2005 set aside the adverse remark relating to the petitioner's "integrity" but maintained other adverse remarks (described as relating to "unsatisfactory work etc.").

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the adverse remarks (other than those relating to "integrity") recorded in the petitioner’s confidential report for 2003-04 were justified, having regard to the reporting officer’s contemporaneous appreciation and the petitioner’s documentary proof of significant revenue performance for the period 19 July 2003 to 31 March 2004.
  2. Whether the respondents, while deciding the petitioner’s representation, applied mind to the petitioner’s submissions and material (including comparative revenue statistics) and provided a reasoned (speaking) order consistent with legal requirements for recording and communicating adverse entries in confidential reports.
  3. Whether the maintained adverse remarks were recorded in a manner inconsistent with recognized principles (including requirement of specific instances, counseling/guidance before adverse consequences and communication rules) and therefore liable to be quashed.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Maloo)

  • The relevant period for the adverse entry is 19 July 2003 to 31 March 2004; the reporting officer had, by a D.O. letter dated 13 April 2004, appreciated the petitioner’s work for that period.
  • The Commissioner of Commercial Taxes sent a letter dated 6 April 2004 congratulating staff for achieving revenue targets for 2003-04; this supported the petitioner’s good performance.
  • The petitioner produced a voluminous (about 100 pages) representation with documents and comparative statistics showing substantial increases in revenue collection (including a 242.97% growth in Dungarpur) that were not considered by the respondents.
  • The impugned order of 27 July 2005 is non-speaking, arbitrary, suffers from malice in law and is based on no material; the maintained adverse remarks were intended to adversely affect the petitioner’s promotion to Deputy Commissioner.
  • The reviewing authority did not indicate when or what guidance/advice was given to the petitioner regarding performance, nor did it explain why the petitioner alone received such adverse remarks despite apparently superior performance relative to others.

State’s Arguments

  • The respondents considered the petitioner’s representation objectively before passing the impugned order.
  • The reviewing authority had already expunged the adverse remarks regarding "integrity", showing some consideration of the representation.
  • No malafide has been attributed to the reporting or reviewing officers; thus the impugned order does not suffer from malice or arbitrariness.
  • The writ petition lacks merit and should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
M.A. Rajasekhar v. State of Karnataka ((1996) 10 SCC 369) Adverse remarks that criticize an officer’s objectivity must be pinpointed with reference to specific instances so the officer has an opportunity to correct himself; where integrity is not doubted and performance is satisfactory, adverse comments must be tied to specific failures and opportunity must be given. The court relied on this principle to hold that adverse remarks must be specific and that the petitioner was not afforded an explanation tied to concrete instances; therefore, the maintained adverse remarks were inconsistent with the legal requirement that an officer be given a chance to know and correct specific criticisms.
State of Rajasthan v. R.B. Parmar (RLR 1999 (1) 125) If an officer did not work objectively or satisfactorily, he should be given an opportunity to correct himself and be guided by authority; absence of such exercise makes downgrading/adverse remarks inconsistent with law. The court cited this decision to reinforce that downgrading or adverse entries require guidance and communication; the court found that such guidance/explanation was not recorded or shown in the respondents' order.
U.P. Jal Nigam's case (as discussed in the opinion) A downgrade in grading (even from a higher positive grade to a lower positive grade) can be adverse if unexplained by comparison; reasons for downgrade should be recorded and communicated. The court used the reasoning to criticize the impugned order for lack of explanation and to emphasize that downgrading without reasons or communication may be unlawful; the court observed that the impugned order was not a speaking order addressing such requirements.
Union of India v. Major Bahadur Singh ((2006) 1 SCC 368) Describes modalities for recording and communication of adverse/advisory entries (stages of counselling, guidance, consequences), and highlights instructions that define when assessments or adverse remarks must be communicated, including that adverse/advisory pen-picture remarks and guidance for improvement should be communicated. The court applied these principles to conclude that adverse/advisory remarks ought to follow stages of counseling and guidance and that communication rules (as reproduced) were not complied with; the court treated the absence of such compliance as material in assessing the validity of the maintained adverse remarks.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded by examining the documentary record produced by the petitioner and the respondents' reply. It reproduced the reporting officer’s adverse remarks and the reviewing authority’s order dated 27 July 2005 which deleted the integrity-related remark but maintained other adverse observations.

Key factual materials examined by the court included:

  • The Commissioner of Commercial Taxes' letter dated 6 April 2004 congratulating staff for achieving the revenue targets for 2003-04 and noting overall commendable achievement.
  • The reporting officer’s D.O. letter dated 13 April 2004 which conveyed appreciation to the petitioner and staff and thus demonstrated contemporaneous satisfaction with the petitioner’s performance for the relevant year.
  • Comparative revenue statistics placed on record by the petitioner showing a marked increase in revenue collection in his jurisdiction — specifically figures reproduced in the petition showing an increase from Rs. 12.45 lakhs in 2002-03 to Rs. 42.70 lakhs in 2003-04 for Dungarpur (noted as 242.97% growth) and other district-wise comparative figures.

Applying legal principles from the cited precedents, the court found that:

  • The contemporaneous appreciation letters and the revenue statistics were material and should have been considered by the reporting and reviewing authorities when assessing the petitioner’s performance for 2003-04.
  • The reviewing authority's order that maintained the adverse remarks (other than integrity) was non-speaking and did not address or record consideration of the petitioner's submissions and statistics; therefore it was cursory.
  • Given the precedents requiring specific instances to justify adverse remarks, guidance/counseling stages, and communication modalities for adverse/advisory entries, the court found that respondents had not shown compliance with these requirements and had produced no documents to justify the maintained adverse remarks.
  • On the available record the court concluded that the adverse remarks were entered without adequate material or explanation and appeared to have been recorded with an ulterior motive to affect the petitioner’s promotion to Deputy Commissioner.

The court therefore applied the cited authorities to the facts and concluded that the maintained adverse remarks could not stand.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. The court quashed and set aside the adverse remarks communicated to the petitioner vide order dated 4 January 2005 (Annexure-3) in the confidential report for 2003-04 and the reviewing authority's order dated 27 July 2005 (Annexure-5).

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The maintained adverse remarks in the petitioner's 2003-04 confidential report and the reviewing order have been quashed and set aside; parties were directed to bear their own costs.
  • Broader implication: The court applied established principles (as cited) concerning the need for specific instances to justify adverse entries, the requirement of counseling/guidance before adverse consequences, and the need for a speaking order addressing submissions and material. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new legal precedent beyond applying those authorities to the facts of this case.

Note: This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion; no information has been added that was not present in the text.

Show all summary ...

BY THE COURT:

The petitioner has preferred this writ petition challenging the impugned order dated 27th July, 2005 (Annexure-5) passed by the Deputy Secretary to Government, Personnel (Ka-1.Conf. Rep.) Department, whereby his representation to expunge adverse remarks in his confidential report for the year 2003-04 was partly allowed and partly rejected.

The petitioner was initially appointed on the post of Assistant Commercial Taxes Officer in the year 1981 and he was promoted on the post of Commercial Taxes Officer in the year 1996. Thereafter he was promoted on the post of Assistant Commissioner purely on merit on regular basis vide order dated 9 December, 2004. The petitioner was posted as Assistant Commissioner (Anti Evasion), Dungarpur during the period from 19 July, 2003 to 4 October, 2004. Vide letter dated 4 January, 2005 (Annexure-3), the petitioner was informed about his adverse remarks in his confidential report for the year 2003-04 and was asked to submit a representation against it, if he feels so aggrieved within a period of one month.

The petitioner submitted a representation (Annexure-4) in this regard along-with necessary enclosures. The said representation was decided vide order dated 27 July, 2005 (Annexure-5) whereby the adverse remarks relating to “integrity” was set-aside, but other remarks relating to “unsatisfactory work etc.” were maintained.

The learned counsel for the petitioner Mr. Maloo contended that the petitioner was posted at Dungarpur on 19 July, 2003. The adverse remarks relates to the year 2003-04, meaning thereby relevant period is from 19 July, 2003 to 31st March, 2004. As per D.O letter dated 13 April, 2004 (Annexure-6), the reporting officer i.e Deputy Commissioner (Administration), Commercial Taxes, Udaipur, appreciated the work of the petitioner in respect of his work during the year 2003-04. A copy of the letter dated 6 April, 2004 written by Commissioner, Commercial Taxes Department regarding satisfactory achievement of revenue target was also annexed along-with the above letter. He contended that when the work of the petitioner of the year 2003-04 was appreciated by the reporting authority soon after closer of financial year, then where was the occasion to make an adverse entry against the petitioner in respect of his work for the year 2003-04. He further contended that he submitted a representation running in about 100 pages along-with all necessary documents showing that revenue targets were satisfactorily achieved in the relevant year by the petitioner, but the same were not considered and only by a non speaking order, the rest part of adverse remarks relating to unsatisfactory work was maintained, which is liable to be set-aside by this Court. He further submits that the impugned order suffers from malice in law as it is arbitrary and it is based on no material to support it. He also referred the relevant annexures to show that in comparison to previous or earlier years, the revenue targets achieved by the petitioner in the year 2003-2004 were more better. He further contended that the adverse remarks regarding work and performance have been retained out of prejudice without any consideration and application of mind to the relevant facts including the detailed representation of the petitioner. While the facts reveal that the performance of the petitioner was the best in the entire State, but he has been chosen for adverse remarks, whereas none other officer has been given such remarks during the relevant period or in the preceding years. He also contended that impugned order does not show as to when and what advise was given to the petitioner regarding his work and performance during the year. He also referred the statistics and contended that the same clearly reveal that performance of petitioner was the best and revenue collection in his jurisdiction increased by 242% in comparison to the previous year, therefore, it clearly shows that the adverse remarks have been entered solely with the ulterior motive of adversely affecting his promotion to the post of Deputy Commissioner and to the benefit of someone else. The timing of giving adverse remarks is deliberate. He, therefore, contended that the impugned order be quashed and set-aside.

The learned counsel for the State defended the impugned order and contended that the representation submitted by the petitioner was considered by the respondents objectively and only thereafter the impugned order was passed. The reviewing officer has already set-aside or expunged the remarks relating to “integrity”. He further contended that no malafide has been attributed against any person or the reporting or reviewing officer so as to hold that the impugned order suffers from malafide or it is arbitrary. He, therefore, contended that there is no merit in this writ petition and the same is liable to be dismissed.

I have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the parties and examined the documents annexed with the writ petition and also the contents of reply filed on behalf of the respondents. The adverse remarks which were communicated to the petitioner in respect of year 2003-04 along-with letter dated 4 January, 2005 are reproduced as under:

The petitioner filed his representation along-with number of documents which have been placed on record as Annexure-4. The respondents vide their letter/order dated 27 July, 2005 restored the integrity of the petitioner but so far as other adverse remarks are concerned, the same were maintained. The order dated 27 July, 2005 is reproduced as under:

From the above, it is clear that so far as adverse remarks regarding ‘integrity’ of the petitioner is concerned, the same was set-aside or the same was not found to be correct by the State Government and the same were ordered to be deleted and integrity of the petitioner was restored. In these circumstances, the other part of adverse remarks are concerned, the same relate to the revenue collection/target etc. In this connection, it is relevant to mention that period in dispute is from 19 July, 2003 to 31 March, 2004 and soon after closer of financial year as on 31 March, 2004, the Commissioner, Commercial Taxes wrote a letter dated 6 April, 2004 to the Deputy Commissioner (Administration), Commercial Taxes Department, Udaipur, who was reporting officer of the petitioner wherein he conveyed his feelings to each and every member of the staff and congratulated on their superlative performance. The letter of Commissioner reads as under:

“Deepak Upreti I.A.S

Commissioner,

Commercial Taxes Department

Government of Rajasthan,

Kar Bhawan, Ambedkar Circle,

Jaipur, Rajasthan-302 005

Dt. 06/04/2004

Dear Shri Sharma,

The Commercial Taxes Department has achieved the revenue targets of sales tax set for it in respect of the BE of 2003-04. This is a commendable achievement in light of the fact that the revenue growth was below 6% in the month of August. The overall growth thereafter has been nearly 22%.

I wish to place on record the appreciation received from the Principal Secretary Finance who has termed it as ‘Outstanding’.

I remember, ‘Late Shri Shiv Dutt Joshi’ and Late Shri Uma Shankar Rana who laid down their lives for the tasks set before the department during the course of anti evasion activities. I am also aware of the difficulties of our field staff. A job which does not have challenges is no job at all. Having completed our task this year we should look for new challenges now.

Please convey my feelings to each and every member of the staff and congratulations on your superlative performance.

Yours sincerely,

Sd/-

(Deepak Upreti)

Shri B.L Sharma,

Dy. Commissioner (Admn.)

Commercial Taxes Department Udaipur.”

On the basis of above letter, the Deputy Commissioner, who was reporting officer of the petitioner, wrote a DO letter to the petitioner on 13 April, 2004, the contents of which are very material for the purpose of deciding the present writ petition. Hence, the same are reproduced as under:-

The above letter makes it very clear that reporting officer was fully satisfied with the work of the petitioner and soon after closer of financial year as on 31 March, 2004, he congratulated the petitioner and issued this appreciation certificate in the shape of letter.

Apart-from above, it is also relevant to mention that the petitioner annexed the comparative chart and document showing the revenue collection at his instance or in his division or by his subordinates and comparative chart showing revenue from anti evasion circle through out the state district-wise and a bare perusal of the same clearly shows that in comparison to previous/earlier years, the revenue collection in this year was much higher. The statement annexed by the petitioner along-with his representation in respect of his office at Dungarpur is reproduced as under:-

The above statement makes it clear that in the previous year i.e 2002-03, the total revenue collection was only for Rs. 12,45,000/-, whereas in the year 2003-04, it was increased to Rs. 42,82,000/-. Further, the adverse remarks also relates to the check-post Ratanpur and petitioner enclosed a statement of check-post Ratanpur along-with his representation and a bare perusal of it also shows that in the year 2002-03, the total revenue collection was only Rs. 23,28,000/-, whereas it was increased to Rs. 34,42,000/- in the year 2003-04. Similarly, the petitioner also annexed the comparative monthly revenue statement from anti evasion circle for the year 2003-04 along-with his representation in respect of each district including Dungarpur, where the petitioner was posted and a bare perusal of it makes it clear that the revenue collection in District Dungarpur was 42.70 lakhs i.e 242.97% growth, which was the highest growth in the State of Rajasthan. The comparative monthly revenue statement in this regard is also reproduced as under:

S. No. Name of A.E Progressive upto March 04

02-03

03-04

Growth

1

2

30

31

32

1

A.E Ajmer

128.14

153.39 19.71

A.E Bikaner

109.48

175.6

60.39

A.E Jhunjhunu

42.32

48.26

14.04

A.E Bhilwara

80.2

65.08

-18.85

A.E Chittorgarh

21.23

7.19

-66.13

A.E Ganganagar

111.52

113.61

1.87

A.E Hanumangarh

23.54

21.95-6.75

A.E Jaipur-I

122.45

243.76 99.07

A.E Jaipur-II

240.72

201.07-16.47

A.E I Kota

79.51

124.2

56.21

A.E II Kota

122.5

57.06

-53.42

A.E Udaipur

76.58 117.78 63.8

A.E Dungarpur

12.45

42.7

242.97

A.E Pali

43.05

70.21

63.24

A.E Aburoad

14.33

25.22

68.92

A.E Jodhpur

92.77

103.24

11.29

A.E Alwar

122.33

141.64

15.31

A.E Bharatpur

29.19

97.69

234.67

A.E I

244.4

225.59

-7.7

A.E II

239.58

157.72

-34.17

A.E III

183.46

153.8

-16.17

Grand Total

2140.91

2346.76

9.62

The above statement makes it clear that revenue collection in the jurisdiction of the petitioner in the year 2003-04 was increased by 242% in comparison to previous year. All the figures discussed and reproduced above show that they were material to the present case and they all were placed by the petitioner along-with his representation, but a bare perusal of the impugned order passed by the respondents dated 27 July, 2005 will show that not a single submission of petitioner or statistics placed by him were taken into consideration. The impugned order is neither well reasoned nor it can be said to be a speaking order. If the respondents would have considered the contents of the representation of the petitioner objectively, then the adverse remarks of the reporting officer communicated to him, would have been set-aside while accepting the representation, but it appears that the respondents did not consider the same objectively and decided the representation in a cursory manner.

In M.A Rajasekhar v. State of Karnataka ((1996) 10 Supreme Court Cases 369), the Hon'ble Apex Court held that when the integrity of the appellant was not doubted and his work also in all respects was found satisfactory, then the remark that he “does not act dispassionately when faced with dilemma” must be pointed out with reference to specific instances in which he did not perform that duty satisfactorily so that he would have an opportunity to correct himself of the mistake. Para 5 of the judgment is reproduced as under:

“5. It was found that his integrity was not doubted and his work also in all those respects was found to be satisfactory. Under those circumstances, the remark that he “does not act dispassionately when faced with dilemma” must be pointed out with reference to specific instances in which he did not perform that duty satisfactorily so that he would have an opportunity to correct himself of the mistake. He should be given an opportunity in the cases where he did not work objectively or satisfactorily. Admittedly, no such opportunity was given. Even when he acted in a dilemma and lacked objectively, in such circumstances, he must be guided by the authority as to the manner in which he acted upon. Since this exercise has not been done by the respondents, it would be obvious that the above adverse remark was not consistent with law.”

This Court in State of Rajasthan v. R.B Parmar (RLR 1999 (1) 125) observed that if the person did not work objectively or satisfactorily, he should be given opportunity to correct himself of the mistake. He must be guided by the authority as to the manner in which he ought to have acted upon. If such exercise is not done, the adverse remarks can not be said to be consistent with law. This Court considered the various judgments of the Apex Court and held as under:

“7. If the officer did not work objectively or satisfactorily he should be given opportunity to correct himself of the mistake. He must be guided by the authority as to the manner in which he ought to have acted upon. If such exercise is not done the adverse remarks can not be said to be consistent with law.

8. In M.A Rajasekhar's case (supra) their Lordships of the Supreme Court propounded that-

“It is not settled law that the object of making adverse remarks is to assess the competence of an officer on merits and performance of an officer concerned so as to grade him in various categories as outstanding, very good, good, satisfactory and average etc. The competent authority and the reviewing authority have to act fairly or objectively in assessing the character integrity and performance of the incumbent.”

9. In U.P Jal Nigam's case (supra) it was held that-

“As we view it the extreme illustration given by the High Court may reflect an adverse element compulsorily communicable, but if the graded entry is of going a step down, like falling from ‘very good’ to ‘good’ that may not ordinarily be an adverse entry since both are a positive grading. All that is required by the authority recording confidentials in the situation is to record reasons for such downgrading on the personal file of the officer concerned, and inform him of the change in the form of an advises.”

10. Their Lordships of the Supreme Court in U.P Jal Nigam's case incorporated the view of the High Court thus-

“The High Court to justify its view has given an illustration that if an employee legitimately had earned an ‘outstanding’ report in a particular year which, in a succeeding one and without his knowledge is reduced to the level of ‘satisfactory’ without any communication to him, it would certainly be adverse and affect him at one or the other state of his career.”

Their Lordships accepted the view of the High court and observed thus-“It may be emphasised that even a positive confidential entry in a given case can previously be adverse and to say that an adverse entry should always be qualitively damaging may not be true. In the instant case we have seen the service record of the first respondent. No reason for the change is mentioned. The downgrading is reflected by comparison. This cannot sustain. Having explained in this manner the case of the first respondent and the system that should prevail in the Jal Nigam, we do not find any difficulty in accepting the ultimate result arrived at by the High Court.”

11. As APARs of the respondent R.B Parmar were downgraded from ‘outstanding’ to ‘satisfactory’ in 1991-92 and from ‘outstanding’ to ‘good’ in 1994-95 and 1995-96, he ought to have been guided by the authority concerned as to the manner in which he ought to have acted upon. In the absence of this exercise the down grading of APAR cannot be said to be consistent with law. In this view of the matter, I do not find any difficulty in accepting the ultimate result arrived at by the Tribunal.”

The Hon'ble Apex Court in Union of India v. Major Bahadur Singh ((2006) 1 Supreme Court Cases 368) observed that the modalities provided for recording and communication of adverse entries clearly indicate as to in which cases the communication of adverse or advisory remarks are to be made. The relevant instructions in that particular cases dated 3rd February, 1989 was also considered and it was observed that reading of the instructions clearly indicate that there are different stages: first is the counselling, second is the guidance and third is the consequences of the officer failing to show the desired improvement. Para 19 of the judgment is reproduced as under:

“19. A reference is also necessary to the instructions issued on 3 February, 1989. Paragraph 103 is of considerable importance and reads as follows:

“103. Assessment contained in a CR will not to be communicated to the officer except in the following contingencies:-

(a) When figurative assessment any where in the CR is Low or Below Average (i.e 3 marks). In such cases extract of figurative assessment (i.e 3 or less) will be communicated to the officer.

(b) When the brief comments (pen picture) contains adverse or advisory remarks. In such cases completes pen pictures (excluding the box grading) together with comments on Guidance for Improvements will be communicated to the officer. Further, the box grading will also need communication to the officer when assessment is low or Below Average (3 or less).”

The modalities provided for recording and communication of adverse entries clearly indicate as to in which cases the communication of adverse or advisory remarks are to be made. The word “Advisory” is not necessarily adverse. Great emphasis was laid on the instructions dated 21.8.1989 titled “Reflection and Communication of adverse and advisory remarks in the Confidential Reports”. The same reads as follows:

“The actual pen picture comprises the brief comments given at Paragraphs 13(e)/19(a) of the ACR forms for Majors to Colonels or Paragraphs 13/15 of the ACR Form for Captains and below. Therefore adverse/advisory remarks, if any, should be endorsed in these paragraphs/sub paragraphs only. The information to be given under the Column “Verbal or Written Guidance for Improvement” (i.e Para 18(b)/19(b) or Para 15/16) is only to support the adverse/advisory remarks reflected in the pen picture. If there are no adverse/advisory remarks reflected in the pen picture, there is no requirement of including details of verbal or written guidance for improvement given to the ratees during the reporting period. It is reiterated that “Performance Counselling is a continuous process and, therefore, the ratee must be given appropriate “Guidance for improvement” as and when noticed.”

A reading of the instructions clearly indicate that there are different stages: first is the counseling, second is the guidance and third is the consequences of the officer failing to show desired improvement. Only when an officer fails to show the desired improvement the adverse/advisory remarks are included in his Confidential Report so that cognizance is taken for his weakness while planning his future placements. The High Court has clearly overlooked these aspects and on that ground alone the judgment is vulnerable. Additionally, it is noticed that the writ-petitioner had merely made a grievance of non-communication but the High Court quashed the entry for 1989-90 which is clearly indefensible. In the fitness of things, therefore, the High Court should re-hear the matter and consider the grievances of the writ-petitioner in the background of the parameters which clearly exist. We make it clear that we have not expressed any opinion on the merits of the case as the matter is being remitted to the High Court for fresh consideration.”

The above facts referred and discussed clearly show that when the petitioner remained posted at Dungarpur, during the relevant year, the revenue collection in his jurisdiction was progressively increased by 242% in comparison to previous year. The matter relates to the year 2003-04. The year ended on 31 March, 2004 and soon thereafter the work of the petitioner was appreciated by his reporting officer, who has made the adverse remarks, vide his letter dated 13 April, 2004 as reproduced above. In fact, the contents of the letter dated 13 April, 2004 should have been mentioned in confidential report of the petitioner for the relevant year i.e 2003-04, but for the reasons known to the reporting officer, the remarks communicated to the petitioner were mentioned. The reviewing authority although was satisfied so far as the integrity of the petitioner is concerned and the same was restored, but did not consider the other figures relating to revenue targets achieved in the jurisdiction of the petitioner, which have been reproduced above and which were placed on record before it along-with the representation of the petitioner and by a non-speaking order upheld the remaining adverse remarks, which cannot be said to be proper or justified in the facts and circumstances of the present case. The respondents have not placed on record any document whatsoever along-with their reply to justify the adverse remarks maintained by reviewing authority against the petitioner. In these circumstances, it is clearly established that the adverse remarks have been entered solely with the ulterior motive of adversely affecting the promotion of the petitioner on the post of Deputy Commissioner and to give the benefit to some one else.

In view of above discussions, the writ petition is allowed. The adverse remarks communicated to petitioner vide order dated 4 January, 2005 (Annexure-3) in the confidential report of the year 2003-04 as well as the order dated 27 July, 2005 (Annexure-5), both, are quashed and set-aside. However, parties are directed to bear their own costs.