Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shyamal Kumar Sinha And Others Petitioners v. State Of Jharkhand And Another S

Jharkhand High Court
Sep 7, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This writ application challenges the entire criminal proceeding of complaint case C/2 Case No. 2971 of 2007, including the order dated 24.8.2007 by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jamshedpur, which took cognizance of offences under section 92 of the Factories Act for alleged violations of multiple provisions of the Factories Act and Jharkhand Factories Rules, 1950.

The facts reveal that on 28.5.2007, Binay Kumar, Factory Inspector, with Labour Department officers, conducted a surprise inspection at M/s. Timken India Limited. They found 125 contract labourers and 394 permanent labourers employed, but noted several irregularities: absence of contract labour entries in Form 12, workers exceeding working hours, non-display of working hours, lack of leave books and paid annual leave for contract labourers, missing attendance registers and cards, no provision of weekly holidays, inadequate canteen facilities, and absence of rest or shelter rooms.

The inspection report was forwarded on 30.5.2007 to the occupier and manager of the factory (petitioners no. 1 and 2) for compliance. The petitioners replied on 5.6.2007 stating contractors were asked to produce required registers and comply with provisions. Their reply was rejected on 8.6.2007. Subsequent communications included attempts by contractors to produce documents and verification by Deputy Chief Inspector of Factories. Meanwhile, the Inspector of Factories sought and obtained sanction for prosecution against petitioners no. 1, 2, and 3, although petitioner no. 3 was not originally sought to be prosecuted. Prosecution report was submitted on 24.8.2007, and cognizance was taken by the Chief Judicial Magistrate.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the prosecution launched against the petitioners for alleged violations of the Factories Act and Rules was legally sustainable given the compliance and replies submitted by the petitioners.
  2. Whether the sanction for prosecution against petitioner no. 3, who was not originally sought to be prosecuted and was not asked to comply with the Act and Rules, was valid.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The prosecution was initiated on the incorrect premise that the petitioners did not comply with the show cause notice dated 3.5.2007, whereas replies were submitted on 5.6.2007 and 10.7.2007 indicating compliance and production of documents before the Deputy Labour Commissioner.
  • The replies and documents submitted were not considered, rendering the prosecution bad in law.
  • Sanction for prosecution was never sought against petitioner no. 3, yet it was granted, indicating lack of application of mind and illegality in the sanction order.

Respondent's Arguments

  • Although sanction was sought only against petitioners no. 1 and 2, sanction was granted also against petitioner no. 3 because he was Chief of Human Resource Department and authorized to correspond with the Inspector of Factories.
  • Multiple irregularities were found during inspection, and petitioners failed to comply with the notice within the stipulated time, justifying prosecution.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the inspection findings which revealed numerous violations of the Factories Act and Rules at the factory premises occupied and managed by petitioners no. 1 and 2. Despite notices and opportunities to comply, the petitioners failed to produce required documents before the Inspector of Factories within the stipulated time, although they claimed production before the Deputy Labour Commissioner, which was not considered sufficient. The show cause replies were deemed unsatisfactory, and sanction for prosecution was properly granted against petitioners no. 1 and 2. However, petitioner no. 3 was neither asked to comply nor was prosecution originally sought against him. The sanction order including petitioner no. 3 was held to be passed without application of mind. Consequently, the court found no illegality in prosecuting petitioners no. 1 and 2 but quashed the prosecution and order taking cognizance against petitioner no. 3.

Holding and Implications

The writ application is allowed in part.

The prosecution and cognizance of offence under the Factories Act stand upheld against petitioners no. 1 and 2, but are quashed in respect of petitioner no. 3 due to absence of proper sanction and application of mind. The decision directly affects the parties by limiting prosecution to the appropriate petitioners and does not establish any new precedent.

Show all summary ...

This writ application has been filed for quashing the entire criminal proceeding of complaint case bearing C/2 Case No. 2971 of 2007 including the order dated 24.8.2007 passed by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jamshedpur whereby and whereunder cognizance of the offence under section 92 of the Factories Act has been taken for violation of the provisions as contained under sections 61, 62, 79, 52, 54, 56, 59, 46, 47 of the Factories Act read with Rule 80, 79, 87, 88, 67(2), 70 and 71 of the Jharkhand Factories Rules, 1950.

The facts giving rise this application are that one Binay Kumar, Factory Inspector along with officers of the Labour Department made a surprise inspection on 28.5.2007 in the factory premises of M/s. Timken India Limited. In course of inspection, inspecting team found 125 contract labourers employed by different contractors as well as 394 permanent labourers engaged in different process of the production. But entries of contract labourers were not found in requisite Form 12 and that the large number of workmen were found working beyond their working hours and that working hours in respect of workmen had not been displayed and that temporary labourers (contract) though were working continuously for years together but were not provided either the leave book nor they are being provided the salary paid annual leave and that attendance register and attendance card of number of workmen were not found and that workmen were not being provided with weekly holidays and that all the facilities were being not provided at the canteen to the workmen and that no rest room or shelter room was found.

Thereupon the inspection report was forwarded, vide letter dated 30.5.2007 to the petitioners no. 1 and 2 being the occupier and manager of the factory respectively for its compliance. On getting the notice, it was replied by the petitioners, vide its letter dated 5.6.2007 intimating therein that the contractors, who had employed contract labourers, have already been asked to present themselves before the authority and to produce register for annual leave with wages, weekly working hours, weekly off and daily wages register, over time register etc. and even the contractor who has been running canteen has been asked to do needful in terms of provision of the Acts and Rules. However, the reply on being found unsatisfactory was rejected on 8.6.2007 Upon it, the petitioners again intimated that adult workmen register had already been produced by the contractors before the Deputy Labour Commissioner and that working hours had already been displayed with and that contractor has already been asked to produce register for annual leave with wages. When no reply was made, one of the contractors visited the office of the Inspector of Factories on 14.7.2007 for verification of the documents but he was not entertained and, therefore, all the documents were sent through registered post on 17.7.2007 As per the case of the petitioners, the contractor even approached the Deputy Chief Inspector of Factories on 27.7.2007 and got the different registers verified but before that Inspector of Factories, vide its letter dated 8.6.2007 moved before the competent authority for according sanction for prosecution against the petitioners no. 1 and 2 for contravention of the provision of the Act and Rules which was accorded, vide letter dated 25.7.2007 (Annexure 11/1) not only against the petitioners no. 1 and 2 but even against the petitioner no. 3, who had never been sought to be prosecuted. On getting the sanction order, the prosecution report was submitted on 24.8.2007 whereupon cognizance of the offence under the Factories Act was taken by the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Jamshedpur against the petitioners.

Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners submits that the prosecution has been launched on the premise that the petitioners did not comply the direction given under the show cause notice dated 3.5.2007 but that was not correct as reply had already been made on 5.6.2007 and subsequently, on 10.7.2007 it had been intimated that the documents sought to be produced had already been furnished before the Deputy Labour Commissioner but the reply submitted by the petitioners were never taken into consideration and as such, entire prosecution is bad.

It was also submitted that sanction for prosecution had never been sought against the petitioner no. 3, still sanction for prosecution has been accorded against him besides petitioners no. 1 and 2 and as such, the order of sanction can be said to have been passed without application of mind and, therefore, the prosecution based on the said sanction is quite illegal.

A counter affidavit has been filed wherein it has been stated that it is true that Inspector of Factories had sought sanction for launching prosecution against the petitioners no. 1 and 2 but sanction has been accorded against the petitioners no. 1 and 2 and also against the petitioner no. 3 as he is the Chief of Human Resource Department and was authorized to interact and make correspondence to the office of Inspector of Factories and that when the inspecting team found so many irregularities contravening the provision of the Act and Rules, petitioners were asked to comply with the provision of the Act and Rules but that was never complied with within the time stipulated under the notice and as such, the petitioners have rightly been prosecuted.

Having heard learned counsel appearing for the parties and on perusal of the record, it appears that on inspection being made in the premises of the factories to which petitioner no. 1 is the occupier and petitioner no. 2 is the manager several deficiencies contravening several provisions of the Act and Rules were found and as such, petitioners no. 1 and 2 were asked, vide notice dated 3.5.2007 to submit show cause, upon which cause was shown whereby it has been intimated that the contractor, who had employed temporary workers has already been asked to present attendance register for annual leave with wages, weekly working hours, weekly off and daily wages etc. which never seems to have been produced within the time before the Inspector of Factories, though it has been claimed by the petitioners that certain documents had been produced before the Deputy Labour Commission but, not before the Inspector of Factories. Show cause submitted was never found to be satisfactory and, hence, prosecution was launched on getting sanction by the competent authority.

Under this situation, I do not find any illegality in launching prosecution and even taking cognizance of the offences so far petitioners no. 1 and 2 are concerned. However, so far petitioner no. 3 is concerned, admittedly he had never been asked to comply the provision of the Act and Rule nor any prosecution was sought to be launched against him, still sanction for prosecution was accorded against the petitioner no. 3 and, therefore, the order granting sanction can be said to have been passed without application of mind so far petitioner no. 3 is concerned and hence, the entire prosecution as well as order taking cognizance of the offence is quashed so far the petitioner no. 3 is concerned.

Accordingly, this application is allowed in-part.