- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of Karantaka v. Basappa
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
K. Govindarajulu, J.:—State is in appeal challenging the acquittal recorded by the JMFC-I, Court at Hubli in C.C No. 707/2004 dated 25.05.2005 The case of the State is that on 11.02.2004 at 2.30 p.m at Deshpande Nagar, near Vivekananda Hospital the accused was driving tractor and trailer bearing registration Nos. KA-25.T-1102 and KA-25.T-1103. While so driving the tractor and trailer from Bembalagi Cross towards Desai Cross, he has driven the tractor rashly, negligently and dashed against the Scooty bearing registration No. KA-25.Q-4837. A child aged about two years by name Apoorva, died, rider PW-5 Sridhar is injured. On account of rash and negligent driving of the tractor it hit to the backside of the Scooty, as a result of it the child aged about two years namely Apoorva fell down and the tyre of the tractor passed on the head of the child-Apoorva. Immediately thereafter Apoorva was shifted to the hospital and she has succumbed to the injuries. Charge sheet is filed for the offences under Section 279, 304(A) of IPC read with Section 187 and 196 of M.V Act.
2. The learned trial Judge has secured the presence of accused, accused has pleaded for trial. PW-1 to PW-11 are examined and Ex. P-1 to Ex. P-7(a) are marked. The learned trial Judge has disbelieved the version of the three eyewitnesses, i.e, PW-5, PW-6 and PW-9 who have narrated the case.
3. Learned State Public Prosecutor contend that no worth evidence is brought in cross-examination of eyewitnesses, i.e, PW-5, PW-6 and PW-9. There is no evidence brought out in the cross examination of the witnesses to disbelieve the version of the complaint. In this proved material evidence the approach of the learned trial Judge at paragraph 22 of the judgment is not proper appreciation of the material evidence has resulted in injustice. So, pray for an order of conviction.
4. Learned advocate for the accused vehemently contend that the evidence would show the vehicle number do not tally. The same is brought to the notice of the Motor Vehicle Inspector who is examined as PW-8. The Motor Vehicle Inspector explains, contending that it is an oversight This type of fragile evidence is adduced by the prosecution to bring home the guilt of the accused. In such circumstances the accused had total denial. He further adds that the evidence placed before the Court from PW-9 prove accused was available near the hospital and they had scolded the accused. So the case of the prosecution Is doubtful. So, approach of the trial Judge is proper. So, pray for an order of dismissal of the appeal.
5. The scope of the appellate Court while appreciating the material evidence in a case of acquittal is limited. It can go into if there is prima facie material error committed by the learned trial Judge. In the light of the above that the point that arise for consideration by this Court is as under:—
• Whether the State has made out a case to interfere with the acquittal order recorded by the J.M.F.C?
6. PW-1 is the complainant. He states in the complaint that on 11.02.2004 he along with his brother were moving in a two wheeler at a place near Vivekananda Hospital. Accident occurred between the tractor and a Scooty. In the Scooty a child was found and on account of the dashing the tractor, the child fell down. Thereafter the tractor has moved on the child. So, the child was injured and shifted to Vivekananda Hospital, which was nearby place of accident. The accident had occurred at 2.30 p.m He identifies the complaint is as per Ex. P-1. In the cross examination the witness is questioned the place for parking at hospital, movement of different kinds of vehicle is questioned, questioned about as to why the rider of the scooter has not given the complaint. He states further that near Vivekananda Hospital gate the accident has occurred. It is suggested that the road is the busy locality. It is also suggested he is pillion rider of the vehicle and could not see the accident deposing falsely.
7. PW-2 Nagaraj has signed the inquest mahazar as per Ex. P.3 prepared by the police. In the cross-examination he states that he has signed the inquest mahazar but not Spot Mahazar. PW-3 is the another witness to the inquest mahazar. PW-4- Neelakantha, he states that the accident occurred at Vivekananda circle, it occurred in between 2.15 p.m to 2.20 p.m When the accident occurred the vehicle was moving from Desai Cross and the Scooty driver riding the scooty along with child. Positively states that left wheel of the tractor has ran over the child.
8. PW-5 is the rider of the scooter. He not only states about riding of Scoty but also states that the child was in his scooter. The driver of the tractor being negligent is cause for the accident. He identifies the driver of the tractor. The cross-examination is in regard to the busyness of the said circle. PW-6 is the witness to the Spot mahazar as per Ex. P-2. Witness is illiterate witness, he denies the contention police have not read the contents. PW-7 is the another panch witness to the inquest to Ex. P-3. PW-8 is the Motor Vehicle Inspector. He admits that there is oversight in recording the registration number of vehicle. PW-9 narrates not only the accident but also states that the driver of the tractor was scolded near the hospital.
9. The first contention of the leaned advocate is that the accused was present but his name was not found in the first material statement. Thereafter his name is added. The version of the witness narrated supra would probablise that the presence of the accused near the hospital is recognized and he is also scolded. Scolding of the accused is almost admitted. In the light of this admission, presence of the accused at the hospital is probablised. Under Section 6 of the Evidence Act, facts though not issue if they are so connected with a fact in issue as to form part of the same transaction, they are relevant. In this case on the accident pleaded by State. There is a denial of the case by the accused it is in total denial, there is an admission of he being scolded by the people is found in the evidence of PW-9 This would probablise the presence of the accused and he having been scolded by the public, absolutely there is no reply by the accused in the entire version of the 313 statement also. Further the charge is found fault contending he was present but police have stated he has run away and it is false. So, the identification of the accused though denied by the accused in the defence, there is evidence to rebut the denial. The above discussion proves the presence of the accused. The allegation on the accused of he being negligent. So the ingredients for the offences complained by the state are proved.
10. The prosecution has failed to prove the offences under Section 187, 197 of MV Act. But proves offences under Section 279, 304-A. So, Court holds that the learned JMFC is not justified in recording acquittal. Acquittal order recorded is set aside.
11. Appeal is allowed. Accused is sentenced to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a period of six months and also pay a fine of Rs. 2,000/- failing which to undergo Simple Imprisonment for a further period of three months. For the offence under Section 279 the accused shall pay Rs. 500/- and failing to pay he is liable to under go Simple Imprisonment for 60 days. Sentences shall run concurrently. The trial Judge is directed to secure the accused for serving the sentence.
Alert