- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The Union Of India T... v. Ajay Kumar Singh
1. Heard learned counsel for the South Eastern Railway.
2. The railway is aggrieved by the order dated 20.9.2016 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Patna Bench, Circuit Court, Ranchi, in OA/051/00231/2015, whereby, the application filed by the private respondent, who was working as Senior Assistant Loco Pilot and due to some ailments in his ear, he was advised for surgery by the Medical Board, but had refused to undergo surgery, and had prayed for alternative job, was disposed of by the Central Administrative Tribunal in the following terms:
“In view of the above, we are of the opinion that since the applicant is not eager to go for surgical correction, the respondents cannot force him to do the same. However, they have every right to re-assess him medically and decategorize him as per his fitness by putting him in a lower post wherever he is found fit as per the extant rules.
Accordingly, the OA is disposed of with direction to the respondent no. 4 to re-consider the case of the applicant in the light of the above observation within a period of four months of date of receipt of this order. No order as to costs.”
3. The petitioner South Eastern Railway is aggrieved by this order, and it is submitted by learned counsel that since the private respondent had refused to undergo surgery for his ailment, he is not entitled for a decision regarding certification for alternative employment on medical grounds, as he is entitled for the same, only after having exhausted of all the methods of treatment, as per Para 561(B) of the Indian Railways Medical Manual, 2000.
4. We do not see any reason as to why the railway is aggrieved by the impugned order passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal. Even according to the learned counsel for the petitioner railway, the private respondent is entitled for a decision regarding certification for alternative employment on medical grounds, but only after exhausting all methods of treatment. Thus, even if the respondent refuses to undergo surgical treatment, it can be taken as if the ailment remains even after exhausting all the methods of treatment, and his case can be considered.
5. Even in paragraph 561(B) of the Indian Railways Medical Manual, 2000, as placed by the learned counsel for the railway, there appears to be no bar for any decision regarding alternative employment on medical grounds, without exhausting all methods of treatment, as even if the respondent refuses for the treatment prescribed by the Medical Board, it can very well be treated that his ailment remains even after exhausting all the methods of treatment, and if with that ailment, he is fit for any alternative job, he may be considered for it.
6. Thus, we do not find any ground to the petitioner South Eastern Railway, for being aggrieved by the impugned order. Accordingly, we do not find any reason for even issuing notice to the private respondent.
7. This writ application is accordingly, disposed of in the admission stage itself, with the observations as above.
Alert