- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Paschim Gujarat Vij Company Limited. & 1 Petitioner(S) v. Ishwarlal Mohanlal Thakkar (S)
Summary of the Opinion — P.P. Bhatt, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petition was filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India by the Gujarat Electricity Board, Vadodara (substituted as Paschim Gujarat Vij Company Limited), seeking quashing of the judgment and award dated 31.7.2001 passed by the Labour Court, Bhavnagar in Reference (LCB) No. 225 of 1998.
The respondent was an employee of the erstwhile Bhavnagar Electricity Company which was taken over by the petitioner Board in 1978; the petitioner obtained and retained the service records on takeover. A dispute arose concerning the respondent's date of birth: the service records and other employment documents recorded 27.6.1937, while a birth certificate issued by Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation (registered 22.5.1987) recorded 27.6.1940 (the municipal certificate was issued following a brief order by a Magistrate). The Labour Court, Bhavnagar allowed the Reference on 31.7.2001, directing the petitioner to give effect to the award within 30 days and to extend all retiral benefits, with Rs. 1500 as costs.
The petitioner challenged that award in this writ petition. After preliminary hearing a Rule was issued, the matter was listed for final hearing and the parties agreed that during pendency the workman would not attempt execution of the award.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Labour Court erred in accepting the municipal birth certificate (issued on the basis of a brief magisterial order) over the long-standing service records and other employment documents showing the respondent's date of birth as 27.6.1937.
- Whether the principle of estoppel bars the respondent from obtaining alteration of the date of birth entry after having signed and accepted service records showing 27.6.1937 and after a long delay in challenging that record.
- Whether the Labour Court's judgment and award dated 31.7.2001 in Reference (LCB) No. 225 of 1998 should be quashed and set aside on the facts and authorities relied upon by the petitioner.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's (Gujarat Electricity Board / Paschim Gujarat Vij Co. Ltd.) Arguments
- On takeover in 1978 the petitioner received the service records from the erstwhile company; those records recorded the respondent's birth date as 27.6.1937 and the respondent signed the transfer/confirmation papers in 1978 "with open eyes".
- The respondent could and should have challenged the recorded date of birth in 1978; his later attempt (in or after 1987/1997 as per the record) came after a considerable delay and therefore estoppel applies.
- The Labour Court improperly relied on a birth certificate issued by Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation pursuant to a four-line magisterial order which contained no discussion of evidence; such magisterial orders are to be deprecated (relying on Bhavin Natvarlal Patel (1998 (1) GLR 770)).
- Documentary evidence in the service book, CPF application, confidential reports and other records consistently show the birth date as 27.6.1937 and thus the Labour Court’s reliance on the municipal certificate (issued because of the magisterial order) was misplaced and rested upon hearsay/conjecture.
- Authorities (including Union of India v. C. Rama Swamy and Punjab & Haryana HC v. Megh Raj Garg) support the proposition that alteration of a date of birth after appointment is not permissible where the incumbent represented a different date to his advantage and estoppel applies.
- The impugned Labour Court order is ex facie illegal and deserves to be quashed.
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent only became aware of the wrongly recorded birth date in 1987 and promptly represented to the employer; when the petitioner did not act he filed civil proceedings and ultimately raised the industrial dispute before the Labour Court (with the civil proceedings having been withdrawn).
- The Labour Court properly examined the evidence and relied upon the municipal birth certificate issued by the competent municipal authority pursuant to the magisterial direction; membership documents such as the petitioner’s identity card and an LIC policy (Exh.42) also record the birth date as 27.6.1940 and premiums were deducted by the petitioner in accordance with that date.
- The Head Office circular of 28.5.1989 limited reliance on affidavits but did not render the municipal certificate invalid; the Labour Court correctly treated the certificate issued by the competent municipal authority as conclusive (relying on Govindbhai M. Karshala (2007 (2) GLH 341)).
- Apparent mistakes in the school record were rectified by the school on the basis of the magisterial order and municipal certificate; the Labour Court’s factual conclusion in favor of the respondent was justified.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bhavin Natvarlal Patel v. Regional Passport Officer, 1998 (1) GLR 770 | Criticism of magisterial orders which direct municipal entries without discussing or recording documentary/oral evidence; such casual/cryptic orders are to be deprecated. | The Court relied on this decision to criticise the four-line magisterial order that led to the municipal birth certificate in this case and to justify doubting the municipal certificate issued on that basis. |
| Union of India v. C. Rama Swamy, (1997) 4 SCC 647 | Principle of estoppel: a person who secured appointment or advantage by representing a date of birth cannot later seek to change it to his benefit; authorities may legitimately decline alteration. | The Court applied the estoppel principle from this authority to conclude that the respondent, having signed and accepted the 1937 date in service records and after long delay, could not legitimately succeed in altering the date of birth. |
| Punjab & Haryana High Court at Chandigarh v. Megh Raj Garg, 2010 (6) Scale 61 | Support for the application of estoppel in disputes concerning change of date of birth after entry into service. | Cited by petitioner to reinforce the estoppel argument; the Court considered it supportive of the petitioner’s case on the application of estoppel. |
| Govindbhai M. Karshala v. Gujarat Electricity Transmission Corp. Ltd., 2007 (2) GLH 341 | Where there is a discrepancy between school/SSC records and a certificate issued by the Competent Authority under the Act (entry in the municipal register), the municipal certificate may be treated as final and conclusive. | The Court noted this precedent relied upon by the respondent but distinguished it: in Karshala the municipal register entry dated from 1940 (an original register entry), whereas in the present case the municipal entry was made in 1987 based on a magisterial order without evidentiary discussion, and thus Karshala was found not applicable. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the documentary record and the sequence of events relied upon by both sides. Its reasoning proceeded along these primary lines:
- Examination of the municipal certificate and its provenance: the Court observed that the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation certificate was issued pursuant to a brief magisterial order which contained no analysis or discussion of oral or documentary evidence; the Court described the four-line order as cryptic and deprecated such practice, citing Bhavin Natvarlal Patel.
- Assessment of the service record and employee conduct at takeover: the Court gave weight to the fact that when the petitioner Board took over the erstwhile company in 1978 the service records were transferred and the respondent signed documents confirming the service particulars that included the birth date 27.6.1937. The Court found it implausible that the respondent had no knowledge of the recorded date when he signed in 1978.
- Application of estoppel and tardy challenge: the Court emphasised that the respondent raised the dispute about his date of birth only after about ten years from the date of transfer/signature and on the verge of retirement; relying on the principle of estoppel as articulated in Union of India v. C. Rama Swamy (and related authorities), the Court held that this delay and prior representation disentitled the respondent to have the date altered.
- Distinguishing contrary authority relied upon by the respondent: the Court considered Govindbhai M. Karshala (which supports the conclusiveness of municipal entries) but distinguished it on facts — in Karshala the municipal register entry pre-dated the dispute and originated in 1940, whereas in the present case the municipal entry was made in 1987 pursuant to a magisterial order and not as an original contemporaneous register entry; hence Karshala was inapplicable here.
- Final evaluative conclusion: weighing the defective provenance of the municipal certificate (magisterial order lacking evidentiary discussion), the consistent employment records showing 1937, the respondent’s signature at the time of takeover, and the doctrine of estoppel, the Court concluded that the Labour Court had erred in relying on the municipal certificate and that the impugned award was unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court allowed the petition and quashed the Labour Court's judgment and award dated 31.7.2001 in Reference (LCB) No. 225 of 1998.
IMPUGNED JUDGMENT AND AWARD QUASHED AND SET ASIDE
Direct effects on the parties:
- The Labour Court, Bhavnagar's order directing the petitioner to give effect to the award and to extend retiral benefits to the respondent is set aside.
- Rule in the writ petition was made absolute and the petition was allowed; there was no order as to costs.
Broader implications: The Court relied on established principles (notably estoppel relating to alteration of date of birth after entry into service, and judicial caution against accepting municipal entries founded upon cryptic magisterial directions). The opinion did not purport to announce any novel legal principle; it resolved the dispute on the facts and existing authorities and explicitly distinguished a precedent relied upon by the respondent (Govindbhai M. Karshala) on factual grounds.
P.P Bhatt, J.:— The present petition is filed under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India by the Gujarat Electricity Board, Vadodara which is subsequently substituted as Paschim Gujarat Vij Company Limited, inter alia, praying for issuance of appropriate writ or direction for quashing and setting aside the judgment and award dated 31.7.2001 passed by learned Labour Court, Bhavnagar in Reference (LCB) No. 225 of 1998.
2. After preliminary hearing of this petition, Rule was issued making it returnable on 17.7.2002 and the office was directed to place this matter on final hearing Board separately on the aforesaid day. It was agreed by counsel for both the sides that they will cooperate for final disposal of the matter and Mr. Lakhani fairly conceded that during the pendency of the petition, the concerned workman will not take any steps for the purpose of executing the Award in question.
3. Brief facts giving rise to the present petition are as under.
3.1 The respondent was the employee of erstwhile Bhavnagar Electricity Company (hereinafter referred as “the company” for short). The said company was taken over by the petitioner Board in the year 1978 and thereafter, the respondent was appointed afresh as per the agreement. The respondent gave an application in the year 1978 to change his birth date from 27.6.1937 to 27.6.1940 but he was orally informed about rejection of his request. Thereafter, in the year 1997, the respondent filed the Civil Suit for declaration and prayed for interim relief. The injunction application was rejected by the Civil Court and thereafter he preferred Civil Misc. Appeal No. 124 of 1997 before the learned District Court, Bhavnagar. The said appeal was also rejected. On reaching the age of superannuation on the basis of the respondent's birth date i.e 27.6.1937, he was relieved from the petitioner Board's service. Thereupon, the respondent raised the industrial dispute on the same facts and the said dispute was referred for adjudication before the Labour Court, Bhavnagar being Reference (LCB) No. 225 of 1998. The said Reference was tried by Labour Court, Bhavnagar. Meanwhile, the respondent withdrew the suit by giving withdrawal purshis. The Labour Court, Bhavnagar allowed the Reference by its order dated 31.7.2001 and directed the petitioner Board to give effect of an award within 30 days from the date of its publication and to extend all retiral benefits payable to the respondent. Rs. 1500/- were also ordered as costs.
3.2 Being aggrieved and dissatisfied by the said judgment and award passed by the Labour Court, Bhavnagar, the petitioners have filed this petition mainly on the grounds stated in paragraph 3 of the petition.
4. It is mainly contended by learned advocate Mr. Hasurkar for the petitioners that when the petitioner Board had taken over the erstwhile Bhavnagar Electricity Company in the year 1978, whatever service record was available with erstwhile company, was transferred to the petitioner Board and as per the said record, birth date of the respondent was 27.6.1937
4.1 It is submitted that the Labour Court failed to appreciate that the respondent signed necessary papers of his service particulars at the time of taking over the erstwhile Bhavnagar Electricity Company by the petitioner Board and in the said record, birth date of the respondent was 27.6.1937 It is submitted that the respondent signed the documents with all open eyes and it was open for the respondent to raise the dispute about his birth date in the year 1978, but the respondent did not take any steps for change of his birth date in the year 1978 and subsequently in the year 1987, he raised the dispute about his birth date by way of filing the Civil Suit.
4.2 It is submitted that the Civil Court rejected the injunction application filed by the respondent. Being aggrieved by the said order, the respondent preferred the Civil Misc. Appeal before the learned District Court, but the same was also rejected. Thereafter, the respondent raised the industrial dispute before the Labour Court and there, he produced a certificate issued by the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation indicating his date of birth as 27.6.1940 Learned advocate for the petitioners has invited attention of the Court to page 216 - order passed by the Judicial Magistrate, First Class, Bhavnagar in Criminal Misc. Application No. 227 of 1987 filed by the brother of the respondent and submitted that learned Magistrate without assigning any detailed justification or reasons directed the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation to issue birth certificate having birth date as 27.6.1940 in respect of Ishwarlal Mohandas Thakkar - respondent herein and on the basis of the said order, birth certificate was issued by the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation in respect of Ishwarlal Mohandas Thakkar. The said certificate was registered and issued on 22.5.1987
4.3 Learned advocate for the petitioners has also invited attention of the Court to pages 148, 150 and 152 and submitted that the respondent has made correction in his birth date and the same is visible on perusal of the said document. It is further submitted that confidential reports were signed by the respondent every year and there also, his birth date was indicated as 27.6.1937 The service book of the respondent reflects the birth date as 27.6.1937 Even, in the application form for CPF reflects the birth date as 27.6.1937 It is submitted that all these evidence clearly estopped the respondent from contending any other birth date than that of 27.6.1937 However, the Labour Court merely on the basis of the birth certificate issued by the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation on the basis of an order passed by learned Magistrate ought not to have believed the birth date as 27.6.1937 as in the School Leaving Certificate and other service records, birth date of the respondent was reflected as 27.6.1937
4.4 It is submitted that the Labour Court merely on the basis of the conjectures and surmises relied upon the contrary document and evidence which itself are based on hearsay evidence.
4.5 It is further submitted that the Labour Court failed to appreciate that the respondent approached the Labour Court after he failed to obtain any relief from the Civil Court. While passing the orders on an application for interim relief, the Civil Court as well as the first Appellate Court did not grant any relief to the respondent. It is submitted that the respondent approached the Civil Court when he was on the verge of retirement.
4.6 In support of his submissions, learned advocate for the petitioners has referred to and relied upon the judgment in the case of Bhavin Natvarlal Patel v. Regional Passport Officer, reported in 1998 (1) GLR 770 wherein the order passed by the magisterial Court based on the oral evidence and photostate copy of the school leaving certificate was deprecated by this Court. It is submitted that in the instant case also, the respondent approached the magisterial Court for insertion of birth entry in the municipal record and learned Magistrate has passed very casual and cryptic order without assigning any justification or reasons and directed the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation to issue birth certificate.
4.7 Learned advocate for the petitioners has also referred to and relied upon the judgment in the case of Union of India v. C. Rama Swamy, reported in (1997) 4 SCC 647. It is submitted that alteration of entry in official records regarding date of birth, it has been held by the Honourable the Apex Court that appointment secured on the basis of a particular date of birth, not permissible to get it changed afterwards. Learned advocate for the petitioners has pointed out from paragraph 26 of the said judgment that “the principle of estopple would apply and the authorities concerned would be justified in declining to alter the date of birth and if such a decision is challenged, the Court also ought not to grant any relief even if it is shown that the date of birth, as originally recorded, was incorrect because the candidate concerned represented a different date of birth to be taken into consideration obviously with a view that that would be to his advantage. Once having secured entry into the service, possibly in preference to other candidates, then the principle of estopple would clearly be applicable and relief of change of date of birth can be legitimately denied”.
4.8 Learned advocate for the petitioners has also referred to and relied upon the judgment in the case of Punjab & Haryana High Court at Chandigarh v. Megh Raj Garg, reported in 2010 (6) Scale 61 and submitted that the said judgment is also based on the principle of estopple.
4.9 Lastly, it is submitted that the order passed by the Labour Court is ex-facie illegal and the same deserves to be quashed and set aside.
5. As against that, learned advocate Mr. Murli Devnani for the respondent filed the reply at page 137 and resisted the petition. The respondent has also produced certain documents along with his reply from pages 148 to 257.
5.1 Learned advocate for the respondent has vehemently submitted that the respondent came to know about wrongly mentioning of his birth date in the year 1987 only. Prior to that, the respondent had no knowledge about incorrect record with the petitioner Board about his date of birth and, therefore, immediately he raised the dispute about his date of birth by way of submitting the representation before the petitioner Board, but as the petitioner Board did not consider the representation made by the respondent, he filed the Civil Suit before the Civil Court, Bhavnagar. The injunction application filed by the respondent was rejected by the Civil Court and being aggrieved by the said order, he preferred the appeal before the District Court, but the said appeal was also rejected. It is submitted that the petitioner Board appeared in the said proceedings and raised the objection about maintainability of the suit and that is why, the respondent raised the industrial dispute before the Labour Court, Bhavnagar by way of filing Reference (LCB) No. 225 of 1998 and withdrew the suit.
5.2 It is submitted that the Civil Suit was filed by the respondent upon receipt of the notice given by the petitioner Board regarding his superannuation, but the Civil Court did not grant any relief in favour of the respondent. As the respondent failed before the Civil Court as well as the Appellate Court, he approached the Labour Court at the fag end of his service career. It is submitted that the respondent produced the birth certificate issued by the competent authority i.e Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation before the Labour Court and relying upon the said document, the Labour Court passed an order to give all retiral benefits to the respondent. It is submitted that the Labour Court has not committed any error in passing the said order.
5.3 Learned advocate for the respondent has invited attention of the Court to the finding given by the Labour Court at page 62 and pointed out that there was no delay on the part of the respondent as the respondent had approached the Labour Court within reasonable time as directed by the circular issued by the Gujarat Electricity Board and prior to completion of 50 years.
5.4 Learned advocate for the respondent has also invited attention of the Court that the Head Office of the Electricity Board vide its circular dated 28.5.1989 informed all the employees that certain corrections and entries were made regarding birth date on the basis of the affidavits, but the said affidavits are not reliable and, therefore, for the purpose of deciding birth date, only School Leaving Certificate, SSC or HSC certificates may be taken into account. It is submitted that the Labour Court, Bhavnagar has also considered the evidence produced by the respondent at length and discussed in its judgment and award in detail.
5.5 It is submitted that the petitioner Board has considered the cases of other employees for rectification of birth dates merely on the basis of affidavits and the Labour Court has taken note of this fact in its judgment and award, whereas the case of the respondent was based on documentary evidence which was issued by the competent authority i.e Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation. It is submitted that the identity card issued by the petitioner Board also indicates the birth date of the respondent as 27.6.1940 and the said fact is also believed by the learned Judge that there is no scope of any mistake in issuance of the identity card.
5.6 It is submitted that learned Judge has also referred to and relied upon Exh. 42 i.e LIC Policy wherein birth date of the respondent is mentioned as 27.6.1940 Learned advocate for the respondent has invited attention of this Court that premiums of this policy were also deducted from the salary of the respondent and paid by the petitioner Board to the insurance company and learned Judge has rightly appreciated this evidence while passing the judgment and award in favour of the respondent.
5.7 Learned advocate for the respondent has also invited attention of this Court that in the school record, there was apparent mistake and, therefore, the respondent approached the school authorities for rectification of the same and on the basis of the order passed by the magisterial Court and the certificate issued by the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation, the school authorities also rectified the birth date of the respondent.
5.8 In support of his submissions, learned advocate for the respondent has referred to and relied upon the judgment in the case of Govindbhai M. Karshala v. Gujarat Electricity Transmission Corp. Ltd., reported in 2007 (2) GLH 341 and submitted that whenever there is a discrepancy in the date of birth in the school leaving certificate and/or SSC examination certificate and the certificate issued by the Competent Authority under the Act, the date of birth mentioned in the certificate issued by the Competent Authority under the provisions of the Act on the basis of the entry in the relevant Register should be considered as final and conclusive.
6. Now, having regard to the facts and circumstances involved in the matter and on perusal of the judgment and award rendered by the Labour Court, Bhavnagar, it appears that learned Judge has taken into account the fact of issuance of certificate by the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation which was issued on the basis of an order passed by the magisterial Court on the representation made by the respondent herein. On perusal of the order passed by learned Magistrate, it appears that the said order is passed without any discussion about documentary evidence or oral evidence led before him. Four lines order passed by the magisterial Court straightaway issuance of direction to the Bhavnagar Municipal Corporation for issuance of birth certificate indicating particular date as mentioned by the applicant before it is deprecated by this Court in its judgment referred to and relied upon by learned advocate for the petitioner in the case of Bhavin Natvarlal Patel (supra). It appears that the Labour Court has also failed to appreciate the entire service record of the respondent speak about his birth date i.e 27.6.1937 The most important factor which learned Judge has failed to consider that the respondent was working with the erstwhile company and the said company was taken over by the petitioner Board in the year 1978 and while transferring the service record, the petitioner Board has obtained the signatures of the employees for confirmation of the service record and at that time, the present respondent has signed those documents with open eyes. In the said service record, the birth date of the respondent was mentioned as 27.6.1937, so, it was open for the respondent to challenge or raise the dispute about his date of birth when he signed those documents and particulars about service record with the petitioner Board, but apparently the respondent did not do so and subsequently in the year 1987, that is almost after 10 years, he raised the the dispute. It is the say of the respondent that, he came to know about his birth date in the service record only in the year 1987, but that fact cannot be believed because the respondent has signed the documents in the year 1978 when the service record was transferred from erstwhile company to the present petitioner Board and while confirmation of the record, the employee - the respondent has signed those documents wherein the date of birth was mentioned as 27.6.1937
7. It is an admitted fact that the respondent had approached the Civil Court in the year 1997 by way of filing the Civil Suit when he received the notice of superannuation, but the Civil Court refused to interfere and rejected the application Exh. 5 on merits. Being aggrieved by the said decision, the respondent approached the Appellate Court by way of filing Civil Misc. Appeal, but the Appellate Court has also confirmed the order passed by the Civil Court and did not grant any relief in favour of the respondent and, thereafter the respondent approached the Labour Court by way of filing the Reference. As discussed hereinabove, the principle of estopple will come in the way of the respondent as the respondent filed these proceedings almost after 10 years from the date of his knowledge about the date of birth in the service record. As per the principle laid down in the judgment cited by learned advocate for the petitioners in the case of Union of India (supra), the respondent has no case on merits and the impugned order passed by the Labour Court, Bhavnagar deserves to be set aside.
8. It is also to be noted that the judgment cited by learned advocate for the respondent in the case of Govindbhai M. Karshala (supra) is not applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case as in that case, necessary entry in the register of the Nagarpalika was made on 16.2.1940, whereas in the present case the entry was made in the year 1987 and that too based on the order passed by the magisterial Court upon making a representation by the respondent and this practice of passing such order has been deprecated by this Court in its judgment in the case of Bhavin Natvarlal Patel (supra).
9. In view of the aforesaid discussion, the present petition deserves to be allowed. Accordingly, this petition is allowed. The impugned judgment and award passed by the Labour Court, Bhavnagar in Reference (LCB) No. 225 of 1998 dated 31.7.2001 is quashed and set aside. Rule is made absolute. There shall be no order as to costs.
Alert