- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Adiveppa v. Bhimappa
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs filed O.S No. 85/2001 seeking declaration of title over “B” and “C” schedule properties, partition and separate possession of a 4/9th share in “D” schedule properties, and consequential injunction against alienation of these properties. The suit arose from familial property disputes involving the descendants of Adiveppa, the original propositus who died 30-35 years prior to the suit. The plaintiffs claimed “B” and “C” schedule properties were self-acquired by their father Hanamappa through his own income from rearing sheep and agricultural activities, while “D” schedule properties were joint family properties inherited from Adiveppa. The defendants denied exclusive ownership of the “B” schedule properties by Hanamappa, claimed prior partition, and asserted entitlement to shares in the properties.
The defendants resisted the suit, and the trial court clubbed a related suit (O.S No. 1/04) filed by Defendant No. 2 for partition. Evidence was recorded from both parties, including oral testimonies and documentary exhibits. The trial court framed nine issues relating to ownership, partition, expenditure on properties, and entitlement to reliefs. Ultimately, the trial court dismissed the plaintiffs’ suit with costs by answering most issues negatively in favor of the defendants.
The plaintiffs appealed against the dismissal of their suit, challenging the trial court’s findings on the nature of the properties and entitlement to shares.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the plaintiffs proved that deceased Hanamappa acquired “B” and “C” schedule properties by his own earnings?
- Whether the plaintiffs proved entitlement to a 4/9th share in “D” schedule properties?
- Whether the defendant No. 1 proved that there was a prior partition on 28/10/1993 and they were enjoying separate shares?
- Whether defendant No. 1 proved entitlement to half share in the flour mill and VPC No. 134?
- Whether defendant No. 1 proved expenditure of Rs. 45,000/- on construction and alterations?
- Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to declaration, partition, and separate possession as sought?
- Whether defendant No. 1 is entitled to partition as prayed in his written statement?
- What reliefs are the parties entitled to?
- What decree or order should be passed?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Hanamappa had independent income from rearing sheep and agriculture.
- “B” and “C” schedule properties were self-acquired by Hanamappa and thus exclusively owned by plaintiffs.
- “D” schedule properties are joint family properties, entitling plaintiffs to a 4/9th share.
- The trial court failed to properly appreciate oral and documentary evidence.
- The dismissal of the suit was erroneous and liable to be set aside.
Respondents' Arguments
- Plaintiffs failed to prove Hanamappa’s independent income and exclusive ownership of “B” and “C” schedule properties.
- Evidence showed prior partition of properties among brothers, with respective shares enjoyed by parties.
- The defendants were in possession of their allotted shares as per partition.
- The trial court rightly dismissed the suit based on evidence and partition.
- The appeal should be dismissed.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court carefully examined the pleadings, evidence, and trial court judgment. It found no dispute as to familial relationships but focused on whether “B” and “C” schedule properties were self-acquired by Hanamappa and whether plaintiffs were entitled to shares in “D” schedule properties. The court noted that the plaintiffs failed to prove Hanamappa’s exclusive ownership or independent income sufficient to acquire the disputed properties. The evidence of plaintiffs’ witnesses lacked personal knowledge regarding acquisition and partition, and some witnesses were not blood relatives. Conversely, evidence from defendants’ witnesses who were present at the time of partition supported the existence of a prior partition dividing the properties among brothers. The court found the trial court’s negative findings on plaintiffs’ claims to be justified and upheld the dismissal of the suit. The defendants’ assertion of prior partition was unchallenged by counterclaim or court fee, further supporting the trial court’s decision.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is dismissed. The judgment and decree of the Principal Civil Judge (Senior Division), Bagalkot, dismissing the plaintiffs’ suit in O.S No. 85/2001, is confirmed.
Each party is to bear their own costs in the appeal. The decision resolves the dispute between the parties on the basis of evidence of prior partition and failure of plaintiffs to prove exclusive ownership claims. No new legal precedent was established; the ruling affirms the trial court’s factual and legal findings.
1. This appeal is filed by the plaintiffs in O.S No. 85/2001 on the file of the Principal Civil Judge(Senior Division), Bagalkot, being aggrieved by the judgment and decree dated 15/07/2006 wherein the suit filed by the plaintiffs-appellants herein seeking for declaration of title in respect of “B” and “C” schedule properties and for partition and separate possession of 4/9th share in “D” schedule properties and for consequential injunction in respect of schedule “B” and “D” properties, has been dismissed.
2. The material facts of the case leading up to this appeal with reference to the rank of the parties before the trial Court are as follows;
The appellants herein filed O.S No. 85/2001 on 28/03/2001 averring that parties are related to each other as per schedule “A” to the plaint, Adiveppa who was the propositus died about 30-35 years back (suit filed on 28/03/2001). Thereafter, his wife Yamanavva died about 10 years back. Adiveppa and Yamanavva had two sons and one daughter, Hanamappa @ Hanamant, Bheemappa and Gundavva. Hanamappa died after the death of his mother and father (six years next before filing of the suit), Defendant No. 1-Bheemappa is the second of Adiveppa and Yamanavva and Gundavva is the daughter of Adiveppa and Yamanavva, Plaintiff No. 3 is the wife of Hanamappa and plaintiffs 1 and 2 are the children of plaintiff No. 3 and Hanamappa-deceased. It is further averred in the plaint that “B” and “C” schedule properties are the exclusive properties owned and possessed by Hanamappa-father of plaintiffs 1 and 2 and husband of plaintiff No. 3 and the said property is purchased by their father Hanamappa out of his own income as he was rearing sheep and doing business in the same and they also owned agricultural lands which was being cultivated by him. However, “D” schedule properties ate the properties of Adiveppa which were inherited by Hanamappa through whom plaintiffs claim the schedule property and by Bheemappa and Gundavva-defendants 1 and 2. It is further averred that after the death of Hanamappa, defendant No. 1 with an illegal motive to dispose of the properties in favour of his wife's brother and his children, has given his daughters to his wife's brother sons who were living with him as he has no sons. He has manipulated the panchayat and revenue records by colluding with the panchayat Secretary and revenue inspector in creating a false mutation and panchayat records as if there has been a partition and it is only after Hanamappa died, there has been a division which is absolutely false. There is no partition as such at any time. Since “D” schedule properties are the joint family properties, the plaintiffs are entitled to 4/9 share in the suit schedule properties and wherefore the suit was filed seeking declaration that plaintiffs are the owners in possession of the properties described in plaint schedule “B” and “C” and for preliminary decree for partition and separate possession of 4/9 share in “D” schedule properties. Plaintiffs also sought for consequential injunction to be granted to get demarcated strips in any of the properties described in Schedule “B and “D” through a surveyor and perpetual injunction to be granted against defendant No. 1 not to alienate any parts of the property described in Schedule “B” and “D” till final partition and separate possession.
The suit was resisted by the defendants. Defendant No. 1 filed written statement which was adopted by-defendant No. 2 by filing a memo to that effect on 08/06/2001.
It is averred in the written statement filed by defendant No. 1. that the averment made in the plaint that Hanamappa was the exclusive owner of “B” schedule is false. The said property was the property of Hanamappa and defendant No. 1 and was not exclusive property of Hanamappa and defendant No. 1 who are the sons of Adiveppa and there was a prior partition wherein “D” schedule property has been allotted to the share of defendant No. 1. It is also averred that in the alternative that defendant No. 1 claims half share in the flour mill and in VPC No. 134 and averred that he has spent Rs. 45,000/- for construction and alteration work during the life time of Hanamappa, Defendant No. 1 is ready to pay the Court fee regarding this case and the plaintiffs have left out their rights in the hcuse Nos. 133/1, 133/2 and 221/2 which is a open space according to partition. There is no cause of action and the suit is liable to be dismissed.
Gundavva-Defendant No. 2 alone also filed O.S No. 1/04 for partition and separate possession and that was also made over to the trial Court and both the suit were clubbed and common evidence was recorded.
On behalf of the plaintiffs in O.S No. 85/2001, plaintiff No. 1 was examined as PW-1 and also examined PWs. 2 and 3 and got marked Ex.P-1 to P-47. On behalf of the defendants, defendant No. 1 is examined as DW-1 and also examined DWs. 2 to 5 who are the persons present at the time of oral partition and got marked Exs. D-1 to D-25. No evidence was lead in O.S No. 1/04. Plaintiff was not examined in O.S No. 1/04.
The trial Court after considering the contentions of the learned counsel for the parties framed the following issues:
“1. Whether the plaintiffs prove that deceased Hanamapp has acquired B and C schedule properties by his own earnings?
2. Whether the plaintiffs prove that they have got 4/9 share in ‘D’ schedule properties?
3. Whether the defendant NO. 1 proves that there was aiready partition on 28/10/1993 and they were enjoying their separate half share in the suit schedule properties?
4. Whether the defendant No. 1 proves that he is entitled to half share in the flour mill and in VPC No. 134?
5. Whether defendant No. 1 proves that he has spent Rs. 45,000/- for construction of both buildings and. alteration works?
6. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for declaration, partition and separate possession as sought for?
7. Whether defendant NO. 1 is entitled for partition as prayed by him in para 6 of his W.S?
8. To what relief the parties are entitled to?
9. What decree or order?
and answered the above issues as follows:
Issue No. 1: in the negative Issue No. 2: in the negative. Issue No. 3: in the affirmative. Issue No. 4. in the negative. Issue No. 5: in the negative. Issue No. 6: in the negative. Issue No,7: in the negative., Issue No. 8: as per the final order. Issue No. 9: as per the final order.
and accordingly dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs with costs.
3. Being aggrieved by the said judgment and decree dated 15/07/2006, this appeal is filed by the unsuccessful plaintiffs in O.S No. 85/2001.
4. We have heard the learned counsel appearing for the appellant and the learned counsel appearing for the respondents.
5. Learned counsel appearing for the appellant has taken us ‘hrough the evidence of PWs. 1 to 3, contents of the document produced by the plaintiff as also the evidence of DWs. 1 to 5 and contended that Hanamappa had income of his own as he was rearing sheep and was also cultivating agricultural land and the properties at “B and “C” schedule are the self acquired properties of Hanamappa and the defendants have no share whatever in the suit properties and “D” schedule property is the joint family property and the plaintiffs are entitled to half of Hanamappa and wherefore the trial Court ought to have properly appreciated the oral and documentary evidence on record and decreed the suit of the plaintiffs as prayed for and the impugned judgment and decree dismissing the suit is liable to be set aside.
6. Learned counsel appearing for the respondents submitted that the plaintiffs have failed to prove that Hanamappa had his own income and the evidence of PWs. 1 and 2 would clearly show that they have miserably failed to show that “B and “C” schedule properties were purchased out of awn earnings of Hanamappa without reference to the income received from the joint family property and admittedly there was prior partition as per the evidence of PWs. 1 and 2 and as averred in the plaint and wherefore the Trial Court has rightly held that there was partilion of the property and defendant No. 3 is in possession of the property that was allotted to his share and the plaintiffs are in possession of the property that was allotted to them which has been clearly proved by the evidence of DWs. 1 to 5 and therefore the trial court has rightly dismissed the suit of the plaintiffs and the appeal be dismissed.
7. Having regard to the contentions urged, the points that arise for determination in this appeal are:
1. Whether the finding of the trial Court that the plaintiffs have failed to prove that “B” and “C” schedule property are the self acquired properties of Hanamappa and consequently rejecting the prayer of declaration and injunction, is justified or calls for interference in this appeal?
2. Whether the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court is justified or calls for interference in this appeal?
3. What order?
and we answer the above points as follows;
1. the finding of the trial Court is justified and does not call for interference in this appeal.
2. judgment and decree passed by the trial Court is justified.
3. As per the final order for the following reasons:
8. We have given careful consideration to the contentions of the learned counsel appearing for the parties and scrutinized the material on record, including the pleadings and the evidence of PWs. 1 to 3, DW-1 and contents of Exs.P-1 to P-47 and D-1 to D-25 and perused the judgment passed by the trial Court.
9. The material on record would clearly show that there is no dispute regarding relationship among the plaintiffs and defendants. Original propositus Adiveppa died about 30-35 years prior to filing of the suit on 28/03/2001 leaving behind his; wife Yamanavva, two sons and daughter-Hanamappa, Bhimappa and Gundavva. Yallavva died 10 years next before filing of the suit and Hanamppa died thereafter about 6 years prior to filing of the suit on 28/03/2001. Plaintiffs 1 and 2 are the sons of plaintiff No. 3 and plaintiff No. 3 is the wife of Hanamappa The contention of the plaintiffs that “B” and “C” schedule properties are the self acquired properties of Hanamappa and the defendants are not entitled to any share in the suit properties and the plaintiffs are entitled to 4/9 share has to be considered by re-appreciating the evidence adduced by the parties before the trial Court.
10. PW-1-the plaintiff has reiterated the averments made in the plaint in the affidavit filed, in lieu of examination-in-chief and has also got marked the documents Exs.P-1 to P-47. It is elicited in the cross-examination of PW-1 that he was born alter the death of his grand father Adiveppa. His grand father owned 5 acres of dry land arid 15 acres of masari land having 10 acres of dry land and 10 acres of irrigated land and total extent was about 40 acres. His grand father was growing about 50 bags of crops. His father has purchased 10 acres of land. At that time, he was aged 15 years. He was not present when the sale took, place and when the amount was paid. He does not know what is the consideration amount paid to the vendor to purchase the said land. His father gave consideration amount out of the business of selling sheep. His father had not kept the amount in the bank. His father and his brothers are living separately since 30 years (witness examined on 22/03/2005). It is not true to suggest that “B and “C” schedule properties are the joint family properties. His father was looking after the property after the death of Adiveppa. They were faking two crops in the in the land is correct. He has denied suggestion that he is deposing falsely as share has to be given in “B” and “C” schedule properties. It is false to suggest that the propeities are purchased out of the joint income of the family.
11. PW-2 Shivappa Mallappa Gatti has deposed in his examination-in-chief that he knows the plaintiffs and the defendants. He knew Hanamappa. Adiveppa had 3 children. There was partition among Hanamappa and defendants about 30 years ago (Witness has filed affidavit on 07/06/2005) and the properties shown in “D” schedule are joint family properties. It is true that the parties are sepaiately cultivating the land and they are staying separately. Hanamappa was doing agricultural work apart form rearing sheep. He was running flour mill in the house. It is elicited in his cross-examination that plaintiffs are his distant relatives but not blood relatives. He does not know as to whether there was any document evidencing partition. Partition was not done in his presence. However, he has further stated that he was present as an elderly person to the partition so effected. He does not know as to whether Hanamappa had kept any amount in the bank. He has signed the sale deed. However, he does not know what is the consideration amount for the same. He does not. know when the document was registered. He has denied suggestion that he has not signed the sale deed ana that, he is deposing falsely at the instance of the plaintiffs.
12. PW-3 has deposed in his examination-in-chief by way of affidavit filed in lieu of examination-in-chief that he is the resident of Nagaral (S.P village). He knows the plaintiffs and defendants in the suit. Hanamappa died about 7 to 8 years ago (affidavit filed on 07/06/2005). He has stated about the relationship of the parties and has further stated that the properties described in “D” schedule are the joint family properties and was being cultivated separately by the parties. father of the plaintiffs Hanamappa was cultivating the land and also doing rearing of sheep and he had reared about 200 sheep. It elicited in his cross-examination that he is not related to the plaintiffs. He was present at the time of partition. PW-2 was also present at that time. The document, was handed over to the defendant. Document eontained only description of the joint famlly properties, He does not. know as to whether Hanamappa was having cash in the bank. He has denied suggestion that he was not at all present; at the time of partition and that he is deposing falsely to help the plaintiffs.
13. The documents produced on behalf of the plaintiffs comprises of the revenue records, extract of VPC as per Ex.P-1. to P-31, mutation entry extract as per Exs.P-32 to P-33, Extract of Tharav passed by VPC Negaral S.P dated 12/10/1995 as per Ex.P-34, report of Village Accountant, Pattadkal, as per Ex.P-35, Extract of R.S No. 68 of Nagaral S.P for 94-95 to 95-96 as per Exs. P-36 to 41, sale deed dated 1/5/87 in respect of R.S No. 94/1 Aand 94/2+3A of Nagaral as per Ex.P-42, sale deed dated 8.5.92 in respect of R.S No. 123/7 of Nagaral S.P as per Ex. P-43, sale deed dated 13/7/1992 in respect of R.S No. 120/2 as per Ex.P-44, sale deed dated 30/12/1991 in respect of R.S No. 100/1 as per Ex.P-45, sale deed dated 1/5/87 in respect of VPC NO. 134 as per Ex.P-46 and sale deed dated 2/5/87 in respect of purchase of flour mill for Rs. 15,000/- as per Ex. P-47. On behalf of the defendant, the first defendant has filed an affidavit in lieu of examination-in-chief and reiterated the averments made in the written statement and got marked the documents as per Exs.D1 to D-25.
14. It is elicited in the cross-examination of DW-1 that it is not true to suggest that parties are in possession of the property that have fallen to their share in the partition. It is true that the flour mill was purchased in the name of Hanamappa and himself. However, sale deed was in the name of Hanamppa. Plaintiffs have given him two houses and one vacant site. It is not true to suggest that Hanamappa had purchased “B” and “C” schedule properties out of his own income and “D” schedule properties is the joint family property. He does not know when they have jointly cultivated the property. He has denied the suggestion that he has not at all given any amount to Hanamappa to purchase the property. Since 25 years, himself and Hanamappa are separated and as per the prior partition, they are cultivating the land that have fallen to their share.
15. DWs. 2 to 5 are the elderly persons present at. the time of partition of the properties and they have spoken to about the said partition of the properties between the brothers and nothing has been elicited in their cross-examination to aisbelieve their evidence about the partition and all the witnesses have denied suggestion that the properties described in “B” and “C” schedule are self acquired properties of Hanamappa and “D” schedule property is the joint family property.
16. It is clear from re-appreciation of the above said material on record that though the plaintiffs have taken a specific contention in the plaint that “B” and “C” schedule properties are the self acquired properties of Hanamappa and “D” schedule property is the joint family in which they are entitled to 4/9 share, they have failed to prove the averments made in the plaint. The facts elicited in the cross-examination of PW-1 would show that he has no personal knowledge as he was born after the date of his grander father and was aged 15 years when the purchase was made by Hanamappa. It is also admitted in the cross-examination, apart from rearing sheep, his father was not doing any other avocation. The evidence of PWs. 2 and 3 is also not helpful to show that “B” and “C” schedule properties are the self acquired properties of Hanamappa and that the plaintiffs are entitled to declaration and consequential injunction in that behalf, as the facts elicited in their cross-examination would clearly show that they have no personal knowledge about the acquisition made by Hanamappa as averred in the plaint and it is elicited in the cross-examination of both the witnesses that they are not related to the plaintiffs. It is elicited in the cross-examination of PW-2 that he does not know whether there was any document evidencing the partition and he has denied that he was not present at the time of partition. However, he has further volunteered that he was present at the time of partition. Similarly the evidence of PW-3 also show that he was present at the time of partition. However, according to him, in the document that was handed over to the first defendant, only the description of the joint family properties were written and wherefore it is clear that the plaintiffs have miserably failed to prove that “B and “C” schedule properties are the self acquired properties of Hanamappa. So far as “D” schedule properties are concerned, in view of the fact of the evidence that PWs.2 and 3 have volunteered that they were present at the time of partition and evidence of DWs.2 to 5 who are elderly person, present at the time of partition, would clearly show that there was partition of the properties among the brothers and they were cultivating the land which had fallen to their share in the said partition and wherefore the finding of the trial Court that the plaintiffs have failed to prove that they are entitled to declaration that “B” and “C” schedule properties are the self acquired properties of their father Hanamappa to which they succeed and they are entitled to 4/9 share, is justified. The trial Court has rightly appreciated the evidence on record in the proper perspective and on re-appreciation, we hold that the finding of the trial Court is justified. Though the defendants have averred in the written statement that they are entitled to share in “B” and “C” schedule properties, no counter claim was made by paying court fee and even otherwise, defence of the defendants is there is already partition among the brothers and wherefore, we hold that the judgment and decree passed by the trial Court is justified, Accordingly, we answer the points for determination and pass the following order:
17. The appeal is dismissed. The judgment and decree passed by the Court of Principal Civil Judge (Senior Division), Bagalkot in O.S No. 85/2001 dismissing the suit of the plaintiffs is confirmed. Parties to pay and bear their own costs in this appeal.
Alert