- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Of H.P v. Phulla Singh
The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
Deepak Gupta, J.:— This appeal by the State is directed against the judgement of the Special Judge, Hamirpur, in corruption case No. 01 of 2008 whereby he acquitted the accused of having committed offences punishable under Sections 7 and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (herein-after referred to as the Act).
2. Briefly stated the facts of the case are that the accused Phulla Singh at the relevant time was working as Kanungo having jurisdiction over the area of village Tikkar where land of the complainant's father was situated. The case of the complainant is that on 20.6.2007 one Vakil Singh, who is a neighbour of his father, got his land demarcated through accused Phulla Singh. The complainant was present at the time of demarcation and as per the demarcation carried out it was found that the father of the complainant had encroached upon one and half kanals of land belonging to Vakil Singh. According to the complainant the accused only measured the land of his father but did not measure the land of Vakil Singh. When the complainant objected to the demarcation then the accused stated that he would satisfy the complainant later on.
3. After a few days, the complainant met the accused in village Kheri and talked to him about the demarcation. The accused allegedly told the complainant, that he would cancel the demarcation if some arrangements were made for “Chai Pani”. Thereafter on 10.07.2007 the complainant contacted the accused on his mobile No. 94184-18283 for the said purpose and the accused told him that it would cost the complainant Rs. 5000/- to get the work done. The complainant told him that he did not have so much money and at best could arrange Rs. 1000/- and he would give rest of the money after the work was done. Thereafter the accused told the complainant that on the same evening he would visit the residence of the complainant and the complainant should pay him the money there. The complainant who is working as a driver in the office of the Fire Brigade did not want to pay any bribe and therefore, filed a complaint with the Vigilance and Anti Corruption Bureau at Hamirpur and on the basis of this complaint F.I.R Ext. PW-1.A was lodged. When he went to lodge the complaint one Nanak Chand, who is also working in the Fire Brigade Office was accompanying him.
4. On the asking of the Police Official, the complainant handed over 10 currency notes of Rs. 100 each, who noted down the numbers of the currency notes and prepared a memo Ext. PW-1.B in this behalf. Thereafter, the complainant and Nanak Chand were given a demonstration of the use of phenolphthalein powder. They were shown phenolphthalein and sodium carbonate powder. When each of the powder were mixed in a glass of water the liquid remained clear. However, when the contents of the two glasses were mixed the colour turned pink. The liquid which turned pink was kept in a glass bottle vide Ext. P-1 and was sealed vide memo Ext. PW-1.C. Both the memos were signed by the complainant and Nanak Chand. The currency notes were also treated with phenolphthalein powder.
5. Thereafter, on the instruction of the police the complainant alongwith Nanak Chand went to his office which is at a distance of about 25 steps from his residence. The accused reached the office at about 5.00 p.m The complainant wished him and took him to his residence alongwith Nanak Chand. The accused was feeling very hot. He removed his shirt and hung it on a peg on the wall. He sat down on a cot. The complainant served him water and thereafter handed over Rs. 1,000/- to the accused which had been treated with phenolphthalein powder. The accused put the money in the back pocket of his pants and lay down on the cot. In between Nanak Chand went outside and gave the predetermined signal to the police. The Police Officials accompanied by the Tehsildar came inside the residence. The accused was asked as to whether he had taken a bribe and on this he took out the currency notes from the back pocket of his pants. The numbers of the notes were checked and these were tallied with the numbers noted down in the memo Ext. PW-1.B and were found to be the same. The currency notes were put in an envelope and memo Ext. PW-1.D was prepared. The accused was made to wash his hands with plain water which remained colourless. Then another powder i.e sodium carbonate powder was mixed and the water immediately turned pink. This pink water was sealed in a glass bottle vide Ext. P-3 and taken into possession vide memo Ext. PW-1.E. The accused was then made to take off his pants. The back pocket of the pants was also washed in a similar fashion and the colour of the wash of the pants also turned pinkish and this water was then put in a nip vide Ext. P-4 and taken into possession vide memo Ext. PW-1.F.
6. This is also the version of the complainant while appearing as PW-1. He has been cross-examined at length. He admitted that in the demarcation it was found that his father had encroached upon one and half kanals of land but he again stated that the land of Vakil Singh was not demarcated. He has also stated that his residence consists of one room and a kitchen. In cross-examination he stated that he telephoned the accused from the house of the Pradhan on the first occasion and on the day when the demand of bribe was made he had telephoned the accused from the STD booth near the Fire Brigade Office. The presence of the accused in the residence of the complainant is admitted because a suggestion has been put to the complainant that since it was summer season and hot the accused took off his shirt and pants and had hung them on a peg on the wall. He also denied the suggestion that he (complainant) had put the currency notes into the back pocket of the accused. His version is that the police had asked Nanak Chand to come out of his residence after the accused had accepted the amount and put his hand on his head as a signal. He clearly states that he did not know the accused earlier.
7. PW-2 Nanak Chand is the shadow witness. According to him the complainant told him that the accused was demanding bribe from him. Then they went to report the matter to the police. Demonstration of the use of phenolphthalein powder was given in his presence and 10 currency notes of 100 each, which were produced by the complainant and handed over to the police, were treated with the said powder. The police instructed this witness to give a signal by placing his hand on his head after payment was received by the accused. According to him the accused came at about 4.45 p.m at the office. He proceeded to the residence of the complainant and the witness and the complainant also went there. The complainant informed the witness that he had handed over the money to the accused and then this witness came out and placed his hand on the head and then the vigilance staff alongwith 10-15 persons entered the room. He does not know anything else except that he saw the Tehsildar counting the currency notes. He further states that these currency notes were handed over by the accused to the vigilance staff who in turn handed over the notes to the Tehsildar for counting but the witness could not state as to from where the accused had taken out the currency notes. The witness turned hostile and did not support the prosecution case thereafter. He denied the suggestion that the accused had taken out the currency notes from his pants pocket and handed over the same to the police. Though according to this witness hand-wash was not taken in his presence but the same was put in a bottle in his presence. This witness admitted the suggestion put to him by the defence that the complainant and the accused had no conversation about demarcation and demand of bribe in his presence.
8. PW-3 is the Tehsildar, who accompanied the police party. According to him the raid was conducted in the residence near the Fire Brigade Office at about 5 p.m The accused was lying on a cot. On seeing the police party he got up. The police party caught hold of the hands of the accused and asked him to hand over the currency notes which he took out from the back pocket of his pants. These currency notes were of the denomination of Rs. 100 each and were 10 in number. The witness tallied the number of these currency notes and found them to be the same. Thereafter the currency notes were sealed. In the presence of this witness hand wash of the accused was taken and the same was treated with sodium carbonate powder. Its colour turned pink and was sealed in a nip Ext. P-3 vide memo Ext. PW-2.A. Similarly, the pocket wash of the pants was also taken and kept in possession. In cross-examination the witness states that the pocket of the pants of the accused had not turned pink. He denied the suggestion that the pants of the accused was not hanging on the peg of the wall.
9. Most of the other witnesses are formal witnesses. PW-8 has proved the sanction order. PW-9 has stated that the complainant alongwith Nanak Chand had come to the Police Station to lodge the F.I.R PW-12 is the Investigating Officer and he has also supported the prosecution case in full.
10. The case of the accused is that he had carried out the demarcation and since the demarcation was against the father of the complainant a false case was lodged against him. After trial the learned trial Court acquitted the accused mainly on the ground that the accused had not demanded a bribe but had only asked the complainant to arrange for “Chai Pani”. Secondly, according to the learned trial Court the independent witness PW-2 had not supported the prosecution version regarding the acceptance of the money from the accused and of the recovery of the same from the accused. The learned trial Court went on to hold that mere recovery of the currency notes is not sufficient to convict the accused.
11. I have heard Shri Rajesh Mandhotra, learned Deputy Advocate General on behalf of the State and Shri Adarsh Kumar Vashisth counsel for the respondent. According to Shri Rajesh Mandhotra, learned Dy. A.G the learned trail Court totally misread the evidence. He submits that the demand of bribe is proved, the delivery of the money and the acceptance thereof by the accused also stand proved beyond reasonable doubt. He, therefore, submits that the judgement of the learned trial Court be set-aside and the accused be convicted of having committed the offences aforesaid.
12. On the other hand Shri Adarsh Kumar Vashisth, learned counsel for the respondent, has supported the judgement of the learned trial Court. He submits that neither any demand of bribe has been proved nor it has been proved that the accused has accepted any bribe. A number of authorities have been cited by the learned counsel for the parties.
13. The Apex Court in R.C Mehta v. State Of Punjab, AIR 1971 SC 1420 held that the burden of proving his innocence can never be shifted on the accused. In Ram Prakash Arora v. State Of Punjab, AIR 1973 SC 498 the Apex Court held that evidence of interested and partisan witnesses who are concerned in the success of the trap must be tested in the same way as that of any other interested witness. Therefore, there should be independent corroboration before a person can be convicted.
14. In Panalal Damodar Rathi v. State Of Maharashtra (1979) 4 SCC 526 the Apex Court held that the statement of the complainant cannot be placed on a better footing than that of an accomplice and corroboration in material particulars connecting the accused with the crime must be insisted upon. In my view this authority is not applicable since in the case before the Apex Court the recovery of the treated currency note was made, not from the possession of the appellant before the Court but, from the other accused Dalvi to whom payment was made. It was in this context that the observations of the Apex Court have to be read. In that case according to the complainant, the accused had told the complainant to hand over the money to constable Dalvi. Here the case is entirely different because according to the complainant he paid the money directly to the accused.
15. Shri Adarsh K. Vashisth, learned counsel has relied upon a judgement of the learned Single Judge of the Delhi High Court in Anand Sarup v. The State, 1988 Cri. L.J 756, in which it was held that mere recovery of money divorced from the circumstances under which it was paid is not sufficient to convict the accused when the other substantive evidence in the case is not reliable. Reliance placed by Shri Adarsh Vashisth, Advocate, on the judgement of the Apex Court in Meena (Smt) W/O Balwant Hemke v. State Of Maharashtra, (2000) 5 SCC 21 is totally misplaced. That was also a trap case but the recovery of the currency notes was made not from the possession of the accused but from the table. The Apex Court held that there was not sufficient evidence before it to satisfy the judicial conscience of the Court that the accused was guilty. The case of the accused was that she had refused to accept the bribe and had pushed the currency notes away. The facts of the present case are totally different.
16. Reliance has also been placed on the judgement of this Court in State Of Himachal Pradesh v. Inder Mohan 2005 (2) Shim. L.C 336. The facts of that case are entirely different. In that case the version of the accused was that the complainant had handed over the money for delivery to some other person and the accused told the complainant to directly give the money to that person. This authority has no applicability to the facts of the present case.
17. The last judgement cited before me is State of Kerala v. C.P Rao, (2011) 6 SCC 450 wherein the Apex Court again reiterated that the testimony of the complainant regarding demand of bribe by the accused must be corroborated and only the statement of the complainant cannot be relied upon. The Apex Court held as follows:—
“12. Those observations quoted above are clearly applicable in this case. In the context of those observations, this Court in SCC para 28 of A. Subair made it clear that the prosecution has to prove the charge beyond reasonable doubt like any other criminal offence and the accused should be considered innocent till it is proved to the contrary by proper proof of demand and acceptance of illegal gratification, which is the vital ingredient to secure the conviction in a bribery case. In view of the aforesaid settled principles of law, we find it difficult to take a view different from the one taken by the High Court.”
18. Applying these principles to the present case, it is apparent that even in corruption cases the burden to prove the case does not shift upon the accused. When a public servant demands or accepts or agrees to accept gratification other than the legal remuneration due to him for work which he has to do it is a demand for bribe. It is necessary for the prosecution to prove that there has been a demand and further that pursuant to such demand accused has been paid something which was not legally due to him. If the prosecution proves that the accused person accepted or obtained or agreed to accept any gratification other than legal remuneration a presumption would arise under Section 20 of the Prevention of Corruption Act that this gratification was such as is mentioned in Section 7. It is thus obvious that the burden is on the prosecution to prove that a demand of bribe was made and subsequently the bribe was paid. If such exchange of money takes place then it is for the accused to explain why he was in possession of the amount and why it should not be presumed to be a bribe or illegal gratification.
19. Coming to the case in hand, I find that the approach of the learned trial court that the demand for Chai Pani cannot be treated to be a demand for bribe is totally erroneous. Any Government servant asking for gratification which is not legally due to him will not say give me a bribe or “Mujhe Rishwat Do”. The illegal gratification will never be demanded directly but indirectly. Therefore, the demand for Chai Pani has to be read in the context in which it was made. The complainant while appearing as PW-1 has clearly stated that when he asked the accused what was the meaning of Chai Pani he was told that a sum of Rs. 5000/- was to be paid. Thereafter, the complainant told the accused that he would pay him Rs. 1000/- and the balance would be paid after the work was done. Whether the complainant is telling the truth or not is a separate question but if his statement is accepted it is a clear demand for illegal gratification of an amount not due to the accused as his legal remuneration.
20. The learned trial Court has also relied heavily upon the fact that the shadow witness turned hostile. He, however, did not take into consideration the fact that the shadow witness turned hostile only with regard to the certain facts and not to the entire story. PW-2 Nanak Chand the shadow witness supported the prosecution fully as far as the first part of the case is concerned. According to him the complainant had informed him that the accused was demanding a bribe. Thereafter both of them went to lodge the complaint. He also supported the prosecution when he states that the complainant handed over 10 currency notes of Rs. 100/- each to the police which was treated with chemical powder and their numbers were noted down. In his presence demonstration of phenolphthalein powder was also given. He also supported the prosecution case in so far as the presence of the accused in the residence of the complainant is concerned. He also states that complainant served water to the accused and then informed the witness that he had handed over the money to the accused. Thereafter he came out and gave a signal to the police party. No doubt, he does not support the prosecution in as much as he states that no demand of bribe was made in his presence but he admits that the accused had handed over the notes to the vigilance staff who in turn handed over the notes to Tehsildar who counted the currency notes and the same were sealed. The testimony of the hostile witness is not to be discarded totally. This witness has not supported the prosecution in certain parts but he has supported the prosecution to a fairly large extent.
21. PW-3 Balwan Chand was the Tehsildar. He is not a member of the police force. True it may be that he was a member of the raiding party but he had nothing to gain directly from the conviction of the accused and he is also to be treated as an independent witness. In his presence also no bribe was demanded by the accused but according to him when he entered alongwith the police party the accused was laying on a cot wearing pants and an undershirt. When asked by the police as to where he had kept the bribe the accused took out the currency notes from the back pocket of his pants and handed over the same to the police and who in turn handed over the same to the witness, who counted the same and tallied the numbers with the memo.
22. Thus the following factors emerges:—
(i) That other than the complainant there is no direct evidence with regard to the demand of bribe at the relevant time;
(ii) That the 10 currency notes of the denomination of Rs. 100 each were recovered from the accused;
(iii) That the accused produced these currency notes from the back pocket of his pants.
23. The case of the accused is of denial simpliciter and of entrapment. A suggestion was put to the witnesses that the pants of the accused had also been hung by him on the peg of the wall. This has been denied by all the witnesses. The accused was wearing the pants and therefore, nobody could have surreptitiously put the money in his back pocket. Another important factor is why the accused went to the residence of the complainant. Admittedly, they were not known to each other earlier. It is also an admitted case that the accused had carried out demarcation of the land of the father of the complainant. He, therefore, had no business to go to the house of the accused. In such circumstances, where the recovery of the treated currency notes is proved beyond reasonable doubt and the story of the complainant is corroborated on other material aspects by the independent witnesses, the mere fact that the shadow witness did not hear the demand for bribe, is not sufficient to acquit the accused especially when there is no explanation on behalf of the accused as to what he was doing in the residence of the complainant.
24. It also stands established that the hands of the accused were got washed and the hand-wash turned pink when treated with sodium carbonate powder. Similarly, the wash of the pants also turned pinkish. All these factors clearly indicate that the money was lying in the pocket of the accused in the residence of the complainant and in such circumstances in my considered view the presumption under Section 20 of the Act is fully applied.
25. Corruption is an evil, which is threatening the very existence of our country. It is to be dealt with sternly. No doubt, the prosecution must prove its case but at the same time when a case has been proved beyond doubt the Courts should not pick holes where none exists only to give a benefit to the accused.
26. Therefore, I am constrained to set-aside the judgement of the learned trial Court and the accused is convicted of having committed offences punishable under Sections 7 and 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act. His bail bonds are accordingly cancelled. The matter may now be listed on 7th September, 2011 for hearing the accused on the quantum of sentence.
Alert