Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Arya S. Kumar v. Assistant Education Officer

Kerala High Court
Jan 2, 2012

JUDGMENT

The petitioner competed in Mohiniyattam in the Cherthala Sub District School Kalolsavam for the year 2011-12. The petitioner did not get the first place as expected by her. She was placed 2nd with ‘A’ grade. The petitioner complains that one out of the three judges had made corrections in the tabulation sheet, which was not attested by the judge concerned, which is contrary to the provisions of the Kerala Youth Festival Manual, 2008. The petitioner therefore seeks the following reliefs:

(i) issue a writ in the nature of mandamus directing the respondents to allow the petitioner to participate in Revenue District School Youth Festival, Alappuzha-2012, to be held at Chengannur for Mohiniyattam Competition.

(ii) issue a writ in the nature of certiorari quashing Exhibit P1 order allowing the appeal.”

The only ground on which the petitioner now challenges the results is that one of the judges made corrections in the tabulation sheets without attesting the same. In view of the said allegation, even if I accept the same, the only relief that can be given to the petitioner is to direct the respondents to exclude the marks given by the 3rd judge to all the candidates. But the counsel for the petitioner admits that, that will not in any way benefit the petitioner in so far as taking the marks of the other two judges also the petitioner would not succeed. In any event this Court does not have the expertise to decide the question as to who performed better in the competition sitting miles away from the actual scene of competitions. The experts in the field have judged the performance of the competing candidates and has rendered a decision. I do not think that this Court will be justified in upsetting that decision on the basis of allegations raised by the petitioner which cannot be proved with any amount of certainty on the basis of affidavits. In the above said circumstances, there is no merit in this writ petition and accordingly the same is dismissed.