- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
The State Of West Bengal & Ors. v. Krishna Chandra Dey & Ors.
Ashim Kumar Banerjee, J.:β A peculiar situation has arisen because of lackadaisical approach of the State. The respondents claimed that they were degree Engineers and were entitled to be appointed as direct recruit in the post of Assistant Engineer in 60% category that was not being filled up by the State. The respondents approached the High Court by filing a writ petition that was transferred to the Tribunal after its establishment and renumbered as T.A 1178 of 1996. When the original application was filed in 1990, the State gave an undertaking before this Court that in case the petitioners succeeded, three vacant posts would be kept reserved for them and they would be accommodated in such post. The Tribunal disposed of the matter vide judgment and order dated January 28, 1997. The Tribunal, upon looking to the rival pleading, came to the conclusion that the Rule for direct recruitment was performed in breach. The Tribunal deprecated the practice of not filling up the vacancy in direct recruit category. The Tribunal asked the State to accommodate the respondents. Accordingly, they were accommodated in the vacant post. However, there was no proper adjudication on the issue save and except the observation of the Tribunal deprecating the State policy in not filling up the direct recruit category.
The State accepted the decision and gave appointment to the respondents in direct recruit category, although they were Sub-Assistant Engineers. The State, however, did not determine their seniority and asked for opinion of the Public Service Commission. The Public Service Commission shirked of their responsibility on the ground that the petitioners were not recommended by them. End result is, the seniority was not determined. By that time, the respondents became eligible for the post of Executive Engineer. Two respondents along with other private respondents were recommended (in all six) for promotion to the post of Executive Engineer. The Public Service Commission, however, did not recommend the case of the respondents without assigning any reason. The State gave appointment to the others and denied identical treatment to the present private respondents being respondent nos. 1 & 2.
The respondent nos. 1 & 2 again approached the Tribunal. The State filed affidavit by contending that all those candidates were recommended for the post. They could not give appointment to the applicants in absence of recommendation of the Public Service Commission. The Public Service Commission did not file any affidavit. They verbally submitted before the Tribunal that the applicants could not be recommended for the post as they did not clear out the departmental examination which were being held twice a year. The State was, however, not clear on their stand. State wanted to take shelter on the reason assigned by the Public Service Commission. The Tribunal rejected the contention and directed notional benefit to be given to the applicants but by that time they retired.
Being aggrieved by the judgment and order dated March 03, 2006, the State filed the instant application before us, however, did not take any further step for final disposal. The application was dismissed by the Division Bench vide order dated August 17, 2007. An application for restoration was filed. The Division Bench allowed the said application vide order dated December 16, 2010. The matter came up before the Division Bench on March 03, 2011 when direction for filing affidavits were given. Accordingly, affidavits have been filed and the matter has now come up for hearing.
Mrs. Bhattacharyya contends that the statutory rule would provide for passing of the departmental examination to become eligible for the post of Executive Engineer. The respondent nos. 1 & 2 did not clear out such examination. Hence, they were rightly excluded by the Public Service Commission. She is, however, not definite on her stand on the issue of recommendation made by the State. She tries to justify the act of the State by submitting, since they crossed the age of 50 years and their seniority was not determined, taking a lenient view their cases were recommended. However, the Public Service Commission did not agree to such recommendation. Mrs. Bhattacharyya, submits that the respondent nos. 1 & 2 did not opt for the examination and as such they could not be allowed to take part. Hence, they were not given the post. According to her, the Tribunal should not have directed promotion to be given which was not a matter of right.
Opposing the application, Mr. Milan Bhattacharyya, learned counsel, appearing for the respondent nos. 1 & 2, submits that the issue reached finality when the earlier Tribunal Application was disposed of and the respondent nos. 1 & 2 were given appointment in the post of Assistant Engineer. Hence, their seniority should relate back to the date when their colleagues got appointment in such post. Since their seniority was not determined, their cases could not be considered. According to him, passing of the departmental examination was not a must and in any event, the State condoned such lapses by recommending their cases to the Public Service Commission.
We have considered the rival contentions. We are of the view that once the State recommended their case to the Public Service Commission applying the relaxation clause being clause (6), the State was precluded from contending otherwise. The Tribunal observed so, as we find from page 18-19 of the said judgment impugned herein. The Tribunal observed βIt is therefore obvious that they were appointed otherwise than in accordance with the Recruitment Rules, and consequent orders were also issued by the appropriate authority in terms of Rules 6(2) of the west Bengal Services (Appointment, Probation and confirmation) Rules, 1979 (hereinafter referred to as Rules 1979)β
In view of such relaxation it would not be wise for the State to take shelter to the verbal explanation offered by the Public Service Commission before the Tribunal as referred to above.
The Tribunal considered the issue at a stage when both of them had retired. The issue was kept pending for long at the instance of the State. Once the State gave them appointment as direct recruit in the post of Assistant Engineer it was the bounden duty of the State to fix their seniority which they did not during their service tenure. Considering these peculiar facts, we decide not to interfere with the judgment and order of the Tribunal that gave notional benefit to the respondent nos. 1 & 2 that would help them to get appropriate pensionary benefit.
WPST 235 of 2011 thus fails and is hereby dismissed.
There would be no order as to costs.
There would be stay of operation of the judgment and order for a period of one month from date.
Urgent photostat certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to the parties on usual undertaking.
Shukla Kabir (Sinha), J.:β I agree.
Alert