Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of West Bengal & Ors. v. Raja Ram Nayek

Calcutta High Court
Jan 3, 2012

The respondent was working as ‘Night Guard’ in the Office of Mass Education Extension Department in the undivided district of Medinipur, since 1986. After bifurcation of Purba Medinipur and Paschim Medinipur, he continued working in Paschim Medinipur on casual basis. A post was created for Purba Medinipur, however, the existing post of ‘Night Guard’ remained vacant in Paschim Medinipur and the respondent was serving as a contingent staff. He approached the Tribunal for his regularization in 2007. The State asked a regular employee from Bankura to join the said post and by that process the respondent lost his job. The Tribunal passed an interim order on July 27, 2008 asking the State to allow him to continue until his service was terminated in accordance with law. The Tribunal, at the time of final disposal of the matter asked the State to create a post for him.

Being aggrieved, the State has now come up before us by filing the instant application.

We have heard Mr. Tapan Kumar Mukherjee, learned Additional Government Pleader appearing for the State and Mr. Mohan Kumar Putatunda, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent.

We have carefully perused the judgment and order impugned. We find from the said order that the State made submission before the Tribunal to the following extent:-

“The state respondents have taken the stand that since the post occupied by the petitioner has not yet been sanctioned, request has been made to the appropriate authority for creation of a sanctioned post to accommodate the petitioner.”

Relying on the said submission of the State, the Tribunal asked the State to create a post for him.

Upon hearing the rival contentions, we are of the view that the State is entitled to create a post according to their necessity. The Tribunal should not have directed creation of post. Moreover, the post could not be created only for the purpose of regularization of the service of the petitioner, as the concept of regularization does not have any support of law. In our view, once the petitioner was serving the State for so long and we are told, that he has only one and half years left to be served as he would be very soon reaching the age of superannuation, his present arrangement with the State should not be disturbed until he reaches the age of superannuation or his service is lawfully terminated, whichever is earlier. In the meantime, if the State wants to fill up the post of ‘Night Guard’ either by creation of any post or in the existing post, the respondent would also be considered along with all other eligible candidates.

With these modifications, the order of the Tribunal is affirmed.

There would, however, be no order as to costs.

Urgent xerox certified copy of this order, if applied for, be given to the parties, on priority basis.