Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Mahesh Dahiya v. Himachal Pradesh State Electricity Board

Himachal Pradesh High Court
Apr 9, 2012
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Judicial Opinion (Rajiv Sharma, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, an employee of the respondent Board, was appointed Assistant Engineer in 1983, promoted to Assistant Executive Engineer on 11.04.1989 and to Senior XEN in September 2002. He was admitted to I.G.M.C. on 04.06.2005 and discharged on 16.06.2005; a fitness certificate was issued on 23.07.2005 and he rejoined duties on 25.07.2005. The petitioner submitted a leave application that was sanctioned and had medical claims reimbursed. He developed chest pain on 30.07.2005 and was again treated; the Board directed him to appear before a medical board on multiple dates (25.08.2005, 07.09.2005, 26.10.2005 and 02.12.2005), but he did not appear. He was placed under suspension on 21.01.2006. Medical certificates from several institutions (I.G.M.C., PGIMS Rohtak, Manchanda Chest Care Clinic) were produced by the petitioner, some certifying that his absence was necessary for health restoration for specified periods.

Disciplinary proceedings were initiated by memorandum dated 21.09.2006 under Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965, alleging willful absence and disobedience of superior's directions and breach of Rule 3(1)(i)(ii)(iii) of the CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964. An inquiry was held; the inquiry officer submitted a report on 29.12.2007. A copy of the inquiry report and a memorandum were supplied to the petitioner on 02.04.2008. The Whole Time Members (WTM) of the Board had, however, in a meeting on 25.02.2008 recorded acceptance of the inquiry report and decision to award removal from service subject to formalities. An order of removal was issued on 06.07.2009 and converted into compulsory retirement on 25.08.2009. The petitioner appealed on 09.09.2009; the appeal was dismissed on 10.12.2009. The petitioner filed the writ petition which resulted in the present judgment.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the departmental inquiry and the subsequent disciplinary process were conducted in accordance with the mandatory provisions of Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 and applicable principles of natural justice.
  2. Whether the inquiry officer considered and recorded reasons after evaluating the documentary medical evidence produced by the petitioner (medical certificates, discharge slips and prescriptions), and whether the inquiry report was a reasoned document addressing the petitioner’s defence.
  3. Whether the disciplinary authority (Whole Time Members) supplied the inquiry report to the petitioner before making up its mind to impose penalty, and whether a pre-decisional stance by the WTM (25.02.2008) prejudiced the petitioner.
  4. Whether the disciplinary and appellate orders were reasoned, self-speaking and showed application of mind as required by law.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Hamender Chandel)

  • The inquiry was not conducted in conformity with mandatory provisions of Rule 14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965.
  • The inquiry report is neither speaking nor detailed and failed to discuss the petitioner's documentary medical evidence.
  • The disciplinary authority did not supply the inquiry report to the petitioner before deciding to impose penalty.
  • The petitioner’s representation to the show cause notice was not properly considered.
  • The disciplinary and appellate orders are laconic, non-speaking and show no application of mind.
  • No disciplinary proceedings were warranted because the petitioner was genuinely ill, his leave had been sanctioned and medical claims reimbursed; medical certificates supported his absence.

Respondent-Board's Arguments (as advanced by Ms. Anjula Khajuria)

  • The inquiry was conducted in accordance with law.
  • The penalty of compulsory retirement (converted from removal) imposed on the petitioner was justified and warrantable.
  • The petitioner had willfully absented himself from duties and the charges were duly proved.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Managing Director, ECIL, Hyderabad v. B. Karunakar (1993) 4 SCC 727 Requirement to supply a copy of the Inquiry Officer's report to the delinquent before the disciplinary authority makes up its mind; it's essential to give a fair opportunity to reply to the inquiry findings. The court relied on this authority to hold that the WTM had made up its mind on 25.02.2008 before the inquiry report was supplied (02.04.2008), thereby prejudicing the petitioner.
G. Vallikumari v. Andhra Education Society, 2010 (2) SCC 497 Disciplinary authority must record reasons when removing an employee; absence of reasons vitiates the order because of violation of statutory rules and natural justice. The court invoked this principle to find that the disciplinary and appellate orders were laconic and non-speaking and therefore vitiated for lack of reasons and application of mind.
Union of India v. Prakash Kumar Tandon (2009) 2 SCC 541 If disciplinary proceedings are not conducted fairly, a presumption of prejudice to the charged employee can be drawn; enquiry officer must act fairly and reasonably. The court used this precedent to support the conclusion that unfair conduct of the inquiry could be presumed to have prejudiced the petitioner where procedural defects were shown.
S.L. Kapoor v. Jagmohan Non-compliance with principles of natural justice itself causes prejudice. Cited as authority for the proposition that failure to follow natural justice leads to prejudice; relied upon to assess effect of procedural breaches.
Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank (2009) 2 SCC 570 Departmental enquiry is quasi-judicial; inquiry officer must consider materials and give reasoned findings; findings based on conjectures/surmises cannot be sustained; disciplinary and appellate authorities must pass reasoned orders. The court applied these principles in concluding that the inquiry report failed to discuss crucial documentary medical evidence and that findings based on incomplete consideration could not be sustained.
Union of India v. Gyan Chand Chattar (2009) 12 SCC 78 Enquiry must adhere strictly to statutory provisions and natural justice; charges must be specific and definite; enquiry cannot be sustained on vague charges; findings should not be perverse or based on conjecture. Relied upon to emphasize that the departmental process must be fair, charges definite and findings based on proper evidence — standards applied to assess the present inquiry.
Mohd. Yunus Khan v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2010) 10 SCC 539 Inquiry must be conducted fairly; inquiry report must contain reasons for the conclusions reached; it cannot be the ipse dixit of the inquiry officer; principles of natural justice must be observed. The court used this precedent to require that the inquiry report should have recorded reasons for finding the charge proved and to criticize the inquiry report for lack of such reasoning.
Krushnakant B. Parmar v. Union of India, JT 2012 (2) SC 352 Inquiry must decide whether absence was willful and whether it amounted to misconduct; the inquiry officer must not base findings on surmises and irrelevant facts but must address the defence evidence. Applied to underline that absence alone does not establish misconduct and that the inquiry must examine defence evidence and reach reasoned conclusions — a standard applied to this case.
Bachhittar Singh v. State of Punjab; Union of India v. H.C. Goel; Anil Kumar v. Presiding Officer; Moni Shankar v. Union of India Grouped references cited to support the general principle that disciplinary proceedings are quasi-judicial and must be fairly conducted in accordance with natural justice. Cited within the judgment (in the context of Mohd. Yunus Khan) to support the proposition that the enquiry must be fair and reasoned; used to bolster the court's assessment of defects in the inquiry.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a sequential analysis based strictly on the materials and arguments on record:

  1. Fact-finding on medical history and leave: The court noted that the petitioner had documented serious medical ailments (including pleural effusion / pulmonary tuberculosis and bronchial asthma) and had produced multiple medical documents from I.G.M.C., PGIMS Rohtak and Manchanda Chest Care Clinic which, according to Annexure P-5 and other certificates, justified absence from duty for specified periods. The petitioner’s leave had been sanctioned and medical claims reimbursed.
  2. Inquiry proceedings and evidentiary lacunae: The inquiry officer examined departmental witnesses (PW-1 and PW-2) and the petitioner produced a defence witness; however, the court found that the inquiry officer did not discuss or assess crucial documentary evidence — discharge slips, prescriptions and multiple medical certificates — nor did the report address the veracity and implications of those documents, which the department had not challenged.
  3. Failure to apply mind and to give reasoned findings: The court stressed that an inquiry report must be reasoned and must discuss both oral and documentary evidence. The inquiry officer’s report, as characterized by the court, primarily reflected the departmental version and overlooked the petitioner’s defence and written brief; thus it lacked the requisite application of mind and reasoning.
  4. Delay, suspension review and procedural breaches: The court observed procedural irregularities including extension of suspension review dates contrary to Rule 10(7) of CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 and inordinate delay in issuance of the charge-sheet and initiation of proceedings. These procedural lapses were treated as material to assess fairness of the process.
  5. Predetermination by disciplinary authority: The court found that the Whole Time Members had recorded acceptance of the inquiry report and a decision to remove the petitioner on 25.02.2008 — this decision preceded supply of the inquiry report to the petitioner on 02.04.2008. Relying on Managing Director, ECIL v. B. Karunakar, the court held that the right to receive the inquiry report before the disciplinary authority forms its conclusion is an essential component of reasonable opportunity and natural justice. Because the WTM had "made up its mind" earlier, the petitioner was prejudiced.
  6. Failure to consider representations and laconic orders: The court noted that the disciplinary authority did not adequately consider the petitioner’s representations against the proposed penalty, and both disciplinary and appellate orders were laconic and non-speaking. Citing authorities that require reasoned orders, the court held that the absence of reasons and discussion is legally significant and vitiates such orders.
  7. Application of precedents: The court applied a line of Supreme Court decisions to conclude that departmental enquiries are quasi-judicial, must be fair, must consider defence evidence, must provide reasoned findings, and that failure in these respects gives rise to prejudice warranting interference.
  8. Conclusion drawn from facts and law: Given the procedural defects (predetermination, delayed supply of inquiry report, failure to discuss medical evidence and lack of reasoned orders) and the authorities cited, the court concluded the disciplinary process was vitiated and that the punitive orders could not stand.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed. Annexure P-25 (dated 25.08.2009) and Annexure P-1 (dated 10.12.2009) are quashed and set aside. The respondent-Board is directed to reinstate the petitioner forthwith with all consequential benefits. The respondent-Board is also directed to open the sealed cover and promote the petitioner to the post of Superintending Engineer, if he is found suitable by the Departmental Promotion Committee, within four weeks from the date of production of a certified copy of this judgment by the petitioner. Pending application(s), if any, stand disposed of. No costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner is to be reinstated immediately and is entitled to consequential service benefits. If departmental promotion procedures deem him suitable, he is to be promoted to the post of Superintending Engineer within the specified time frame. The disciplinary order of compulsory retirement/removal and the dismissal of his appeal have been annulled.
  • Procedural message: The judgment reaffirms established principles — that departmental enquiries must be conducted fairly, that inquiry reports must be supplied to the charged employee before the disciplinary authority forms a conclusion, and that disciplinary/appellate orders must be reasoned and demonstrate application of mind. The court applied binding Supreme Court authorities to overturn the departmental outcome on grounds of procedural unfairness and lack of reasoned findings.
  • Scope of precedent: The opinion applies existing precedents to the facts and does not purport to lay down any novel legal principle beyond enforcing established rules of natural justice and statutory requirements for departmental enquiries.

No costs were awarded.

Show all summary ...

Rajiv Sharma, Judge:

Petitioner was appointed as Assistant Engineer in the respondent-Board in the year 1983. He was promoted as Assistant Executive Engineer on 11.04.1989 Thereafter, he was promoted as Sr. XEN in the month of September, 2002. He was admitted in I.G.M.C on 04.06.2005 He was discharged on 16.06.2005 The fitness certificate was issued to him on 23.07.2005 He joined his duties on 25.07.2005 He submitted an application for sanctioning the leave to the Controlling Officer, which was duly sanctioned. He was also reimbursed the medical claim. He developed pain in the chest on 30.07.2005 and was rushed to I.G.M.C on 30.07.2005 He submitted leave application alongwith station leave to the Director (Commercial). He was directed by the Chief Engineer (Commercial), HPSEB, Shimla to appear before the medical Board to be constituted by the C.M.O, Shimla on 25.08.2005 and 07.09.2005 He was also sent telegrams on 30.09.2005, 20.10.2005 and 02.12.2005 He also took treatment from Pt. B.D Sharma PGIMS, Rohtak. He was placed under suspension on 21.01.2006 vide Annexure P-4. He obtained Annexure P-5, dated 18.02.2006 from I.G.M.C, Shimla. It was certified vide Annexure P-5 that petitioner's absence from duty w.e.f 01.08.2005 to 11.11.2005 was absolutely necessary for restoration of his health. Petitioner has also submitted a certificate issued by Pt. B.D Sharma PGIMS, Rohtak on 04.01.2006 alongwith Annexure P-5, dated 18.02.2006, certifying therein that he was examined vide MOD No. 102360 on 12.11.2005 and it was reviewed on 30.11.2005, 14.12.2005 and 31.12.2005 He was advised rest from 12.11.2005 onwards. Thereafter, he submitted his joining report on 20.02.2006 vide Annexure P-6. He filed a representation seeking revocation of suspension on 27.02.2006 He was served with a memorandum on 21.09.2006 vide Annexure P-8, whereby the disciplinary proceedings were initiated against him under Rule-14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965. The Article of Charge reads thus:

“That the said Er. Mahesh Dahiya while functioning as Sr. Executive Engineer (Elect.) in the office of the Chief Engineer (Comm.), HPSEB, Shimla-4 during the period from 2005-06 proceeded on leave on 30.7.05 on medical ground. Er. Dahiya was repeatedly directed vide Chief Engineer (Comm.), HPSEB, Shimla-4 letter dated 25.8.05, 7.9.05, 26.10.05 and 2.12.05 to appear before the Medical Board but he failed to do so. Thus, Dr. Dahiya has willfully absented himself from official duties and has disobeyed the directions of his superiors. He has therefore acted in a manner which is unbecoming of an officer of his status. The said Er. Mahesh Dahiya, Sr. Executive Engineer (Elect.) has thus violated the provisions of Rule-3(1)(i)(ii)(iii) of CCS Conduct Rules, 1964 and which made him liable for disciplinary action under Rule-14 of CCS(CCA) Rules-1965.

2. Petitioner filed reply to the same on 15.10.2006 The suspension period of the petitioner was extended on 06.12.2007 The Presenting Officer submitted the brief to the Inquiry Officer vide Annexure P-17. Petitioner submitted the written brief of defence vide Annexure P-18. The Inquiry Officer concluded the inquiry and submitted the report to the disciplinary authority on 29.12.2007 Thereafter, the petitioner was served with a memorandum dated 02.04.2008 alongwith the copy of inquiry report and the decision of WTM, dated 25.02.2008 Petitioner has made a representation against the same on 15.04.2008 He was removed from service on 06.07.2009 He made a representation on 21.07.2009 The punishment dated 06.07.2009, whereby the petitioner was removed from service, was converted into compulsory retirement on 25.08.2009 vide Annexure P-25. Thereafter, the petitioner filed an appeal on 09.09.2009 before the appellate authority. The same was dismissed by the appellate authority on 10.12.2009

3. Mr. Hamender Chandel, learned counsel for the petitioner has strenuously argued that the inquiry has not been held as per the mandatory provisions of Rule-14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965. He further argued that the inquiry report is neither speaking nor detailed. He then argued that the disciplinary authority ought to have supplied the copy of inquiry report to the petitioner before coming to the conclusion that the penalty of removal was to be imposed upon the petitioner. He then argued that the representation made by the petitioner to the show cause notice has not been considered in right perspective. He also contended that the orders passed by the disciplinary authority and appellate authority are laconic and non-speaking. He lastly contended that there was no occasion to initiate disciplinary proceedings against his client, since he was sick and has obtained medical certificates. His leave was duly sanctioned and his medical claims have been reimbursed.

4. Ms. Anjula Khajuria, learned counsel for the respondent-Board has strenuously argued that the inquiry has been conducted in accordance with law. She has justified the imposition of penalty of compulsory retirement upon the petitioner, dated 25.08.2009 She has finally contended that the petitioner has remained willfully absent from duties and the charges were duly proved against him.

5. I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and gone through the pleadings carefully.

6. Petitioner has been charged for not obeying the orders of Chief Engineer (Commercial), HPSEB, Shimla dated 25.08.2005, 07.09.2005, 26.10.2005 and 02.12.2005, whereby he was directed to appear before the medical Board. Thus, according to the charge sheet, the petitioner has willfully absented himself from duties and has disobeyed the directions of his superiors.

7. Petitioner was admitted in I.G.M.C on 04.06.2005 His disease was diagnosed as “Loculated Fluied Collections (Rt) Pleural cavity echo Tubural (Pleural Effusion (T.B)). He remained in the hospital up to 16.06.2005 He was issued fitness certificate on 23.07.2005, pursuant to which he joined his duties on 25.07.2005 He submitted leave application to the Controlling Officer, which was duly sanctioned. His medical claims have also been reimbursed. He developed pain in the chest on 30.07.2005 and was further taken to I.G.M.C, Shimla on 30.07.2005 He has also submitted leave application to the Director (Commercial) alongwith station leave. The Board was well aware about the health of petitioner and, despite this, he was forced to appear before the medical Board on 25.08.2005, 07.09.2005, 26.10.2005 and 02.12.2005 Petitioner was suffering from serious ailment. It is not discernable from the records why the Board was insisting that the petitioner should appear before the Medical Board once the leave has been duly sanctioned and his medical claims were also reimbursed. As noticed above, the petitioner has also submitted application for leave and station leave on 30th July, 2005. He was put under suspension on 21.01.2006 The review has to take place as per CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 after 90 days, but, in the present case, arbitrarily the date of suspension was extended. This act of the respondent-Board was in contravention of Rule-10(7) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. Petitioner has filed a detailed reply to the memorandum dated 21.09.2006 on 15.10.2006 The inquiry report is at page No. 93 of the paper-book. The Inquiry Officer has examined one Shri S.D Rattan, Director (Commercial) as PW-1. Shri Brij Lal Kiashta as PW-2. Petitioner has produced Engineer P.C Sardana as D.W

8. According to PW-1, Er. S.D Rattan, petitioner has disobeyed the orders of his superior by not appearing before the medical Board. According to him, the medical certificate of the petitioner was not available on 30 July, 2005.

9. Now, as far as PW-2 Sh. Brij Lal Kiashta is concerned, he has categorically stated that the petitioner has joined his duties in the Circle office on 20.02.2006

10. DW Engineer P.C Sardana has testified that petitioner was suffering from Tuberculosis during June/July, 2005. He has shown the medical certificate and discharge slip to him. He has also admitted that 30.07.2005 was his last day in the office before superannuation. According to him, the petitioner has shown his inability to attend the party as he was rushed to the hospital. The inquiry officer, while concluding his inquiry, has not at all discussed the prescription slip dated 16.06.2005, issued by the I.G.M.C, discharge slip dated 23.07.2005 issued by the I.G.M.C, medical certificate dated 25.07.2005, prescription slip dated 30.07.2005, issued by the I.G.M.C, medical certificate dated 18.02.2006, certificate dated 04.01.2006, issued by Pt. B.D Sharma PGIMS, Rohtak and medical certificate issued by Manchanada Chest Care Clinic, dated 16.02.2006 It was incumbent upon the inquiry officer to look into these documents, veracity of which has never been denied even by the department. The inquiry officer has only concluded that the petitioner has disobeyed the orders dated 25.08.2005, 07.09.2005, 26.10.2005 and 02.12.2005 by not presenting himself before the Medical Board. The explanation given by the petitioner ought to have been taken into consideration by the inquiry officer. The inquiry should be reasoned and must show due application of mind. The inquiry officer has to discuss the entire evidence, oral as well as documentary.

11. In the instant case, the inquiry officer has only discussed the version of department and has over looked the defence of petitioner. The prescription slips and medical certificates have been issued to the petitioner by the I.G.M.C, Shimla, Pt. B.D Sharma PGIMS, Rohtak and Manchanda Chest Care Clinic. According to Annexure P-5, petitioner's absence was absolutely necessary for restoration of his health w.e.f 01.08.2005 to 11.11.2005 As per the certificate issued by the Professor & Head, Department of Medicine, PGIMS, Rohtak, dated 04.01.2006, the petitioner has been examined on 12.11.2005 and reviewed on 30.11.2005, 14.12.2005 and 31.12.2005 According to the medical certificate dated 04.01.2006, petitioner was suffering from Bronchial Asthma (Acute exacerbation), Resolving Pleural effusion, Restless leg syndrome & drug dependence. He was advised rest from 12.11.2005 onwards. The Manchanda Chest Care Clinic has also issued a certificate on 16.02.2006 covering the period w.e.f 11.01.2006 to 16.02.2006 Petitioner has submitted his joining on 20.02.2006 He has submitted the certificate to the concerned authority.

12. It will also be apt at this stage to mention that the petitioner has filed written brief vide Annexure P-18, dated 30.10.2007 before the inquiry officer. The written brief is very detailed. He has given the circumstances under which he could not join his duties. The pleas raised by the petitioner in his brief have not been discussed at all by the inquiry officer. In his written brief, the petitioner has highlighted that the Director (Commercial) was biased. According to him, his suspension was also unjustified and there was inordinate delay in issuance of charge sheet.

13. According to Rule-32(2)(d) of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972, the petitioner was also entitled to extraordinary leave up to eighteen months since he was suffering from Pulmonary Tuberculosis. This aspect has also been overlooked by the Board. Petitioner has not been dealt with in a just and fair manner. It was not the case of the respondent-Board that the petitioner was not suffering from this serious ailment of Pulmonary Tuberculosis. The certificates issued by the I.G.M.C, Shimla, Pt. B.D Sharma PGIMS, Rohtak and Manchanda Chest Care Clinic cannot be doubted till something contrary was brought on record. In fact this Court has examined the doctor, who has issued Annexure P-5. According to him, this certificate has been issued to the petitioner strictly in accordance with law and after taking into consideration his ailments. He has satisfactorily explained the circumstances before this Court on 03.11.2011 Petitioner has never been apprised that his leave application has been rejected. It is settled law that every willful absence will not constitute misconduct.

14. In the instant case, the petitioner has given reasons for not joining duties, which has been overlooked by the disciplinary authority and appellate authority.

15. The matter is required to be considered from another angle. The inquiry officer has submitted the report to the disciplinary authority on 29.12.2007 The inquiry report ought to have been supplied by the disciplinary authority to the petitioner to enable him to make a representation by pointing out the shortcomings, deficiencies and violation of Rule-14 of the CCS(CCA) Rules, 1965 before the disciplinary authority makes up its mind to impose the penalty. The purpose of supplying the copy of inquiry report to a delinquent is to enable him to make a representation by pointing out the shortcomings, deficiencies and violation of the mandatory provisions of rules, under which the inquiry is conducted.

16. In this case, the Whole Time Members of the Board in its meeting held on 25.02.2008, which is at page No. 101 of the paper-book had already made up its mind to award major penalty of removal from service. The findings of the Whole Time Members of the Board in 354 meeting are as follows:

“The findings of the Enquiry report were accepted by the WTM and it was decided to award major penalty of removal from service after following proper codal formalities.”

17. Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Managing Director, ECIL, Hyderabad v. B. Karunakar(1993) 4 SCC 727 have held that the copy of inquiry report has to be supplied to an employee before the disciplinary authority makes up his mind to impose penalty. The purpose of supplying the copy of inquiry report is to enable an individual to represent against the short-comings, deficiencies and violation of mandatory rules during the course of departmental inquiry. Their Lordships have held as under:

“The reason why the right to receive the report of the Inquiry Officer is considered an essential part of the reasonable opportunity at the first stage and also a principle of natural justice is that the findings recorded by the Inquiry Officer form an important material before the disciplinary authority which along with the evidence is taken into consideration by it to come to its conclusions. It is difficult to say in advance, to what extent the said findings including the punishment, if any, recommended in the report would influence the disciplinary authority while drawing its conclusions. The findings further might have been recorded without considering the relevant evidence on record, or by misconstruing it or unsupported by it. If such a finding is to be one of the documents to be considered by the disciplinary authority, the principles of natural justice require that the employee should have a fair opportunity to meet, explain and controvert it before he is condemned. It is the negation of the tenets of justice and a denial of fair opportunity to the employee to consider the findings recorded by a third party like the Inquiry Officer without giving the employee an opportunity to reply to it. Although it is true that the disciplinary authority is supposed to arrive at its own findings on the basis of the evidence recorded in the inquiry, it is also equally true that the disciplinary authority takes into consideration the findings recorded by the Inquiry Officer along with the evidence on record. In the circumstances, the findings of the Inquiry Officer do constitu te an important material bef ore the disciplinary authority which is likely to influence its conclusions. If the Inquiry Officer were only to record the evidence and forward the same to the disciplinary authority, that would not constitute any additional material before the disciplinary authority of which the delinquent employee has no knowledge. However, when the Inquiry Officer goes further and records his findings, as stated above, which may or may not be based on the evidence on record or are contrary to the same or in ignorance of it, such findings are an additional material unknown to the employee but are taken into consideration by the disciplinary, authority while arriving at its conclusion. Both the dictates of the reasonable opportunity as well as the principles of natural justice, therefore, require that before the disciplinary, authority comes to its own conclusions, the delinquent employee should have an opportunity to reply to the Inquiry Officer's findings. The disciplinary authority is then required to consider the evidence, the report of the Inquiry Officer and the representation of the employee against it.”

18. The copy of the inquiry report alongwith its memorandum has been supplied to the petitioner on 02.04.2008 Since the WTM has already made up its mind to impose a major penalty upon the petitioner, even without supplying the copy of the inquiry report to him, he has definitely been prejudiced by the WTM order on 25.02.2008 Thereafter, the petitioner was served with office order dated 6 July, 2009, whereby he was offered an opportunity to make a representation on the quantum of penalty, i.e, removal from service. The whole Time Members have given an undue importance to a very trivial fact as reflected in order dated 06.07.2009 According to WTM, the petitioner has applied for station leave on 30.07.2005, but the medical certificate issued by the I.G.M.C could not cover the period w.e.f 01.08.2005 to 11.11.2005 Petitioner has filed a representation against the order dated 06.07.2009 vide Annexure P-24 on 21.07.2009 Thereafter, the petitioner has been imposed the penalty of compulsory retirement on 25.08.2009 vide Annexure P-25. The disciplinary authority has not taken into consideration the representation made by the petitioner against the order dated 06.07.2009 in right perspective. The grounds raised in the representation were required to be taken into consideration in-depth by the disciplinary authority. The appeal preferred by the petitioner has also been rejected vide Annexure P-1, dated 10.12.2009 Petitioner has raised as many as 17 grounds in his memorandum of appeal. However, the same have also not been considered in accordance with law by the appellate authority. The issues raised in the appeal were required to be discussed at length.

19. Mr. Hamender Chandel, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted at the Bar that the case of petitioner was also considered for the post of SE, but the same has been kept in a sealed cover.

20. In the instant case, neither the disciplinary authority nor the appellate authority have applied their minds while passing the orders. The orders passed by them are laconic. They ought to have passed reasoned, detailed and self speaking orders.

21. Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in G. Vallikumari v. Andhra Education Society, 2010 (2) SCC 497 have held that the disciplinary authority must record reasons while removing an employee, if reasons are not recorded, the order is vitiated due to violation of the statutory rules and the principles of natural justice.

22. Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India v. Prakash Kumar Tandon(2009) 2 Supreme Court Cases 541 have held that if the disciplinary proceedings have not been conducted fairly, presumption can be drawn that this caused prejudice to the charged employee. Their Lordships have held as under:

“13. From the evidence of another Assistant Engineer who had taken part in the raid, it is evident that the alleged loss caused to the Railways was negligible and mere marginal allowances are permitted for measurement of “scantlings and planks”.

14. In the aforementioned situation, we are of the opinion that the Tiribunal as also the High Court cannot be said to have erred in holding that the Said Mr. Walia should have been examined as a witness.

15. The principles of natural justice demand that an application for summoning a witness by the delinquent officer should be considered by the enquiry officer. It was obligatory on the part of the enquiry officer to pass an order in the said application. He could not refuse to consider the same. It is not for the Railway Administration to contend that it is for them to consider as to whether any witness should be examined by it or not. It was for the enquiry officer to take a decision thereupon. A disciplinary proceeding must be fairly conducted. An enquiry officer is a quasi-judicial authority. He, therefore, must perform his functions fairly and reasonable which is even otherwise the requirement of the principles of natural justice.

17. If the disciplinary proceedings have not been fairly conducted, an inference can be drawn that the delinquent officer was prejudiced thereby.

18. In S.L Kapoor v. Jagmohan this Court has held that non-compliance with the principles of natural justice itself causes prejudice. We are not oblivious of the fact that the said principle has since been watered down but in a situation of this nature, we are of the opinion that the concurrent findings of the Tribunal, as also the High Court cannot be said to be unreasonable or suffering from any legal infirmity warranting interference.”

23. Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Roop Singh Negi v. Punjab National Bank(2009) 2 Supreme Court Cases 570 have held that a departmental proceeding is a quasi-judicial proceeding. The enquiry officer performs a quasi-judicial function. The charges levelled against the delinquent officer must be found to have been proved. The enquiry officer has a duty to arrive at a finding upon taking into consideration the materials brought on record by the parties. Their Lordships have further held that the disciplinary authority and appellate authority must pass reasoned orders. Their Lordships have further held that the enquiry report based on conjectures and surmises, cannot be sustained. Their Lordships have also held that that suspicion howsoever high cannot be a substitute for legal proof and though the Evidence Act, 1872 is not applicable, the inquiry has to be conducted according to principles of natural justice.

24. Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India v. Gyan Chand Chattar(2009) 12 Supreme Court Cases 78 have held that an enquiry has to be conducted against any person giving strict adherence to the statutory provisions and principles of natural justice. The charges should be specific, definite and giving details of the incident which formed the basis of charges. No enquiry can be sustained on vague charges. Enquiry has to be conducted fairly, objectively and not subjectively. The finding should not be perverse or unreasonable, nor the same should be based on conjectures and surmises. Evidence adduced should not be perfunctory even if the delinquent does not take the defence or make a protest against that the charges are vague, that does not save the enquiry from being vitiated for the reason that there must be fair play in action, particularly, in respect of an order involving adverse or penal consequences.

25. Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Mohd. Yunus Khan v. State of Uttar Pradesh(2010) 10 Supreme Court Cases 539 have held that the enquiry is to be conducted fairly and reasonably and enquiry report must contain reasons for reaching the conclusion that charge framed against delinquent stood proved against him. It cannot be ipse dixit of enquiry officer. Their Lordships have held as under:

“16. We have to proceed keeping in mind the trite law that holding disciplinary proceedings against a government employee and imposing a punishment on his being found guilty of misconduct under the statutory rules is in the nature of quasi-judicial proceedings. Though the technical rules of procedure contained in the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 and the provisions of the Evidence Act, 1872 do not apply in a domestic enquiry, however, the principles of natural justice require to be observed strictly. Therefore, the enquiry is to be conducted fairly and reasonably and the enquiry repost must contain reasons for reaching the conclusion that the charge framed against the delinquent stood proved against him. It cannot be an ipse dixit of the enquiry officer. Punishment for misconduct can be imposed in consonance with the statutory rules and principles of natural justice. (See Bachhittar Singh v. State of Punjab, Union of India v. H.C Goel, Anil Kumar v. Presiding Officer, Moni Shankar v. Union of India and Union of India v. Prakash Kumar Tandon.)”

26. Their Lordships of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Krushnakant B. Parmar v. Union of India, JT 2012 (2) SC 352 have held as under:

“13. The Inquiry Officer noticed the aforesaid facts and held the appellant was unauthorisedly absent between 3rd October, 1995 and 7 November, 1995; 9 November, 1995 and 10 December, 1995; 10 December, 1995 and 2nd August, 1995. However, while coming to such contention, the authority failed to decide whether such absence amounted to misconduct. The evidence led by the appellant in support of his claim that he was prevented to sign the attendance register and to perform duty though noticed the Inquiry Officer on presumption and surmises, held the charge proved.

14. Rule 3(1)(ii) and Rule 3(1)(ii) of Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964, relates to all time maintaining integrity, devotion to duty and to do nothing which is unbecoming of a Government servant and reads as follows:

“Rule 3-General. (1) Every Government servant shall at all times-

(i) maintain absolute integrity;

(ii) maintain devotion to duty; and

(iii) do nothing which is unbecoming of a Government servant.”

15. In the case of appellant referring to unauthorized absence the disciplinary authority alleged that he failed to maintain devotion of duty and his behaviour was unbecoming of a Government servant.

22. In the present case, the disciplinary authority failed to prove that the absence from duty was willful, no such finding has been given by the Inquiry Officer or the Appellate Authority. Though the appellant had taken a specific defence that he was prevented from attending duty by Shri P. Venkateswarlu, DCIO, Palampur who prevented him to sign the attendance register and also brought on record 11 defence exhibits in support of his defence that he was prevented to sign the attendance register, this includes his letter dated 3 October, 1995 addressed to Shri K.P Jain, J.D, SIB, Ahmedabad, receipts from STD/PCO office of Telephone calls dated 29 September, 1995, etc. but such defence and evidence were ignored and on the basos of irrelevant fact and surmises the Inquiry Officer held the appellant guilty.”

27. Accordingly, in view of the observations and discussions made hereinabove, the writ petition is allowed. Annexure P-25, dated 25.08.2009 and Annexure P-1, dated 10.12.2009 are quashed and set aside. The respondent-Board is directed to reinstate the petitioner forthwith with all consequential benefits. Respondent-Board is also directed to open the sealed cover and promote the petitioner to the post of Superintending Engineer, if he is found suitable by the Departmental Promotion Committee, within a period of four weeks from the date of production of a certified copy of this judgment by the petitioner. The pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of. No costs.